Page 1
FOR CS PROFESSIONAL EXAM PREPARATION
CS Professional 2024
Question Paper ·
Insolvency and
Bankruptcy - Law and
Practice
EXAM YEAR TYPE
CS Professional 2024 Question Paper
SUBJECT DATE
Insolvency and Bankruptcy - Law and Practice June 2024
Notes · Sample Papers · Previous Year Papers · Mock Tests
Page 2
co m .
. s e
em l a
as a g
NEW SYLLABUS
555
Roll No. ..................................... : 1 : OPEN BOOK EXAMINATION
m
om . co
c m
Time allowed : 3 hours Maximum marks : 100
m . s e
s e g a
l : 19
l a a
ag
Total number of questions : 4 Total number of printed pages
NOTE : Answer ALL Questions.
1. Alok is a dealer in Eyewear, Spectacles and other eye accessories in India for the last
m
c. o
10 years based in Gurgaon. His vision was to transform the way people see and experience
e m of South Africa. Alok has a very good relations
the world. He is a frequent traveller and visited many countries to expand his business. Gulshan
l a s
is one of the cousins of Alok and a resident
agto South Africa in 2015 he started a showroom in partnership
with his cousin and during his visit
with his cousin in South Africa.
Alok has a very big showroom in India also. He used to import spectacles and other accessories
from South Africa. With the increasing demand of more and more spectacles, goggles etc.,
m
c. o
business is reaching greater heights and he made a huge profit. His business was a growing
m
c. o got multiplied in 3 to 4 years. In the year 2019 some differencessdeveloped
m between both
business going very well. Since there was huge demand, the business went well and profits
e
s em g l a
gla a
a
the cousins and Alok decided to quit from the partnership.
He was also a director of Padmavat Solutions Private Limited and its associate company.
Shekhawat Solutions Private Limited where he used to get the sitting fee for attending the
Board Meetings.
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE P.T.O.
m . c
c. o s e m
m a
se
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit
g l
Page 1 of 19
Page 3
555
: 2 :
In India also due to entry of online selling platform and other sales promotion strategies
of the competitors, there were lots of changes in the market situation in India and his business
started running into losses. He raised loans worth ` 10 Crore in the year 2019 to finance
the working capital requirement of the business. He managed for another one year (year
2020) to run the business out of the retained earnings of the business. However due to
the impact of COVlD 19 and other reasons the demand declined rapidly and later on he
started making defaults. He defaulted in making payment to his creditors and Insolvency
proceedings commenced and a repayment plan was approved. Alok failed to follow the
repayment plan and filed for bankruptcy on 1st April, 2022 which was admitted on 10th
April, 2022. A Bankruptcy order was passed and Gopal Gupta, an Insolvency Professional
was appointed as a Bankruptcy Trustee.
Gopal Gupta started investigation of the affairs of the Bankrupt. He observed that on
7th April, 2022, Alok Gupta sold his shop to Kapil Kalra for ` 50 Lakh and gifted this
amount to his major son. As per Bankruptcy Trustee, he has some doubt that this transaction
is not allowed as per Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016.
The Bankruptcy Trustee further asked Alok to prepare the list of the assets and hand over
to the bankruptcy trustee. As per the list of the assets, Alok informed as below :
• Alok stated that he has been entrusted by his friend Arun to look after his property
in Delhi currently valued at ` 1 Crore as Arun is staying in UK.
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE Contd. ........
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 2 of 19
Page 4
co m .
. s e
em l a
as a g
555
: 3 :
m
• Alok has ` 50 Lakh in provident fund, pension fund and the gratuity fund of the
om . co
m
employees.
.c se
em l a
s
• Alok has a residential flat worth ` 2 Crore in his name.
a a items
l has an antique paintings and silver household utensils and other valuable g
g
a worth ` 50 Lakh which have not been encumbered.
• He
• He has also unencumbered insurance policy worth of ` 50 Lakh.
• He has also the father's inherited property now in his name worth ` 5 Crore.
While bankruptcy proceedings were going on, Alok further decided to start a new business
o m
c
and engage himself in the formation and .management of Kids Paradise Pvt Ltd. (Under
of kids garments by forming a new company in the name of ‘‘Kids Paradise Pvt. Ltd.’’
e m
l a s
ag the following questions :
Incorporation).
Based on the above facts, answer
(a) Whether the doubt of the Bankruptcy Trustee about the sale of his shop to Kapil
Kalra for ` 50 Lakh and gift to his son has any relevance as per the Insolvency
and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. Describe with reference to the provisions of Insolvency
m
c. o (5 marks)
and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 ?
m
c. o s e m
em la
as ag
(b) Is act of Alok for continuing as a director in the Padmavat Solutions Pvt. Ltd. and
l
ag
Shekhawat Solutions Private Limited and participating in the formation and management
of a new company is valid ? Explain with the help of the provisions of Insolvency
and Bankruptcy Code, 2016.
(5 marks)
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE P.T.O.
m . c
c. o s e m
m a
se
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit
g l Page 3 of 19
Page 5
555
: 4 :
(c) Explain the relevant provisions for the distribution of the estate of the Alok in accordance
with the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code.
(5 marks)
(d) Based on the above facts, ascertain the assets, which will form part of the estate
of the Alok.
(5 marks)
(e) What is fresh start process and conditions to be fulfilled for applying for fresh start
process ?
(5 marks)
2. (a) Vinayaka Car Company Ltd (VCC) is a manufacturer of passenger cars and commercial
vehicles in India. It sells the cars through single brand dealerships across different
cities. The dealerships are separate for passenger cars and commercial vehicles. VCC
is lagging behind the competitors in the passenger car segment due to its cost structure
and is losing market share for the last 3 years. With no revival in sight, the company
has decided to exit the passenger car segment and notified its dealers about shutdown
of passenger car manufacturing and sales in India. Further added that the service
centres for passenger cars will continue its operations for the next 3 years.
Karthik Cars Pvt Ltd. (KCL) is a passenger car dealer for VCC in Bangalore with
an office cum showroom and no service centre. KCL has bank loans from Bank
B1 and Bank B2 for ` 10 crore and ` 7 crore respectively. Both the banks have
pari-passu charge on the office premise cum showroom.
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE Contd. ........
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 4 of 19
Page 6
co m .
. s e
em l a
as a g
555
: 5 :
m
KCL has expressed its inability to repay its financial obligations to the bankers. One
om . co
c m
of the bankers, Bank B1 has filed an application for Insolvency Resolution Process
m . se
e l a
(IRP) which is admitted by the adjudicating authority, while the other bank is still
l a s a g
g
contemplating to proceed against the borrower under SARFAESI.
a • VCC has an interest free dealership security deposit of ` 1.50 crore since
2010 from KCL with a right to set-off against any receivables pending from
KCL towards VCC.
• The nephew of the promoter of KCL had given a loan of ` 0.50 crore
m
c. o
to KCL in the last 3 months to pay the utility bills, pressing commitments
m
and office expenses.
VCC in its claims hasse
•
g l a demanded ` 3.50 crore from KCL against pending
receivables. a
• KCL has not paid wages to the tune of ` 0.50 crore to its workmen and
statutory employer contributions to the tune of ` 0.20 crore.
• As per valuer, Rama Mani’s report, approximate realizable value of office cum
m
c. o
showroom is ` 12 crores. Items which are not readily relishable having not
m
c. o e m
touch value has not been reckoned and hence has been ignored by the Valuer.
em la s
s
Value of furniture and equipment is to the tune of ` 0.05 crore.
gla ag
a
• The current receivables on books are ` 1.50 crore, out of which 50% is
doubtful.
• KCL has a general-purpose current account with B1 having current balance
of ` 0.15 crore.
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE P.T.O.
m . c
c. o s e m
m a
se
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit
g l Page 5 of 19
Page 7
555
: 6 :
On the basis of the below mentioned fact answer the questions :
(i) How much is VCC’s net claim against KCL ?
(ii) What will be the status of VCC as a claimant for its claims against KCL ?
(iii) Who all will be in the committee of creditors ?
(iv) Who among the creditors/groups of creditors, cannot reject a proposed resolution
plan ?
(v) Assume that IRP has failed in the resolution of the case. After deducting the
insolvency costs, sum available from proceeds of liquidation of assets is
` 10.99 crore. Based on priority of claims, how much will Bank Bl receive ?
(vi) How much will Bank B2 receive, in case the proceeds on liquidation of assets
are ` 8.34 crores.
(6 marks)
(b) Ankur Constructions Limited, is a Public Limited Company incorporated under the
provisions of Companies Act, 2013 on 30th June, 2017. The Company had a 100%
subsidiary in the name of ABC International Private Limited. It was engaged in the
business of Projects relating to the cleaning of the Ganga River and the surrounding
areas under the ‘‘Namami Gange Programme’’, a flagship programme approved by
the Union Government of India to achieve the objective of effective abatement of
pollution, conservation and rejuvenation of National River Ganga. The ABC International
Private Limited could procure some orders under the "Namami Gange Programme"
and commenced its commercial operations and continued working for four years and
completed all its projects. After 4 years of its existence, the Board of Directors waited
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE Contd. ........
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 6 of 19
Page 8
co m .
. s e
em l a
as a g
555
: 7 :
m
for 2 more years and could not expand its operations and thought of merging the
om . co
.c e m
company with the other operational company(s). The proposal of merger could not
em l a s
s g
hold good and later on the management decided to wind up the company under
g a a 2016.
l voluntary winding up provisions of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code,
a The Ministry of Urban Housing and Urban affairs also accorded its approval to close
the
the company. The Board of Directors on their next Board Meeting filed a declaration
of solvency stating that the company is solvent and no litigation is pending under
any court and need to be closed under the voluntary winding up process of the
m
c. o
company. The company is not having any employee on the rolls of the company.
The Board of Directors receivedem
a s
Liquidator of the Companyglwho is an insolvency Professional and cleared the necessary
a proposal of appointment of Geeta as a proposed
a
examination and training. After obtaining her consent and valid Authorisation for
Assignment, the management recommended her name to the shareholders of the
Company. The Management also appointed Registered Valuers to value the assets
m
of the company ven though there were not any major assets in the company.
m c. o
c. o e m
The management decided to take the agenda of initiation of Voluntary Liquidation
em la s
s ag
and appointment of Voluntary Liquidator in the Extraordinary General Meeting of the
gla
a
company. In the Extraordinary General Meeting held on 20th June, 2023, the liquidator
was appointed and she intimated to various authorities concerned including the Comptroller
& Auditor General of India about the initiation of voluntary winding up of the company
and filing of necessary claims.
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE P.T.O.
m . c
c. o s e m
m a
se
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit
g l Page 7 of 19
Page 9
555
: 8 :
The Liquidator received the claims from various creditors and after verification found
that the both the operational creditors and financial creditors have filed their claims
by post only. The Liquidator took necessary steps to realise the assets of the company
as per the laid down procedures, payoff all the liabilities and distributed the proceeds
among the various stakeholders of the Company after deducting the cost of Liquidation.
In view of the above facts, answer the following with reasons :
(i) Whether the mode of submission of proof of claims to the liquidator by the
financial creditors are in line with the provisions of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy
Code, 2016. Also, what are the various type of forms prescribed for submission
of proof of claim to the liquidator by all the stakeholders ?
(5 marks)
(ii) What is the role of the liquidator if she finds that the corporate person will
not be able to pay its debts in full from the proceeds of assets to be sold
in the liquidation ?
(4 marks)
(c) Panapathi G. Seeds Pvt. Ltd. a closely held private company was engaged in the
business of processing oilseeds for edible oils. It was established in 1988 under the
leadership of Panapathi G. Prasad. Within a decade, Panapathi G. Seeds Pvt. Ltd
positioned itself as a leader in production of groundnut oil in the Western region
of India with two premium brands.
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE Contd. ........
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 8 of 19
Page 10
co m .
. s e
em l a
as a g
555
: 9 :
m
In 2016 Panapathi G. Prasad had a severe heart attack and died without any succession
om . co
c m
plan in place. Ram and Sham, the two sons of Panapathi G. Prasad were also directors
m . s e
a
e brothers had strained relations over the management control which adverselygaffected
l
in the company with equal shareholding. After the death of Panapathi G. Prasad,
a s
l the business of the company. With declining profit and turnover both theabrothers
g
both
a
were worried and decided to reach a family settlement whereby the control of the
company was handed over to the elder brother Ram. Sham resigned as the director
of the company and in lieu of the same he was entrusted with the management and
control of another family firm Saraswathi Edibles, wherein both brothers were partners.
m
c. o
Praveen, son of Ram was inducted as director in the Company.
e m unsecured loan given by him to the company
l a s
In 2018 Sham wanted to withdraw
ag paying him interest on the loan. Despite follow up
because the company stopped
Sham was not paid either the principal or interest, which forced him to file an application
under section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016.
The Adjudicating Authority (i) admitted the application, (ii) declared moratorium and
(iii) appointed Nagarajan, as an Interim Resolution Professional (IRP). Ram refused
o m
m c
. IRP not to make
to hand over the management control to the IRP on the plea that it was a family
c. o dispute, and they will settle soon on their own. He also askedmthe
s e
s em l a
la ag of the Corporate Debtor
the public announcement. IRP tried to persuade Ram citing the provisions of the Code
ag and warned him that if he does not hand over control
IRP will be forced to approach the Adjudicating Authority for appropriate orders.
Thereafter Ram allowed the IRP to take inventory of the assets and stocks after
15 days from the insolvency commencement date.
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE P.T.O.
m . c
c. o s e m
m a
se
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit
g l
Page 9 of 19
Page 11
555
: 10 :
With reference to the above facts and other details provided, answer the following
questions with particular reference to the provisions contained in the Code, Regulations
and rules of IBC and others :
(i) Sophie Bank, the only Bank with whom the Company is banking, filed an
appeal before the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) to
set aside the order of Adjudicating Authority regarding admission of CIRP
on the ground that its cash credit account with the company is regular and
there is no default. Will the application of Sophie Bank survive ?
(ii) Sham filed a claim for unsecured loan of ` 1,75,00,000 along with interest
@ 18 per cent per annum. IRP reviewed the accounts and found that there
is neither an agreement to that effect on interest rate, northern is any resolution
of the Board of Director in this regard. IRP admitted the claim only for the
principal amount. Is the IRP right in his decision ?
(iii) Sophie Bank charged interest @ 9 per cent on the cash credit limit availed
by the company, as per the terms of sanction, even after the insolvency
commencement date and justified it on the ground that if the interest is not
charged the account has to be classified as NPA. Is the bank’s claim legally
justified ?
(iv) On review of the bank accounts, IRP observed that sixteen months before
the insolvency commencement date, a payment of ` 1 Crore has been made
to a creditor viz., Saraswathi Edibles in which Ram is a partner. What is
the status of this transaction under the code ?
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE Contd. ........
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 10 of 19
Page 12
co m .
. s e
em l a
as a g
555
: 11 :
m
(v) IRP sent the notice of the CoC meeting to Ram but not to Sham. Sham
om . co
c m
protested this and represented that Ram is also a related party and an unsecured
m . s e
e the CoC meeting. What is your opinion on the representation by gSham a
l ?
financial creditor like him therefore, he is also entitled to receive notice of
l a s a
ag (5 marks)
(d) Whether the legislative scheme that is contained in section 7 and section 9 of IBC,
differentiating between financial creditors and operational creditors respectively as regards
the Code’s objectives and notice on default, are discriminatory and arbitrary ? Substantiate
m
co
your answer with the relevant case law.
.
s em
(5 marks)
g l a
a
3. (a) Suhani and Dhwani are childhood friends and were very fond of designing Indian
traditional dresses. After completing their schooling, Suhani joined a fashion designing
course to pursue her interest and Dhwani decided to be a fashion Model. She participated
in various fashion show programs conducted by Non-Government Organisation(s) engaged
in the creating awareness for cervical cancer which is spreading rapidly among Ladies
o m
in India.
m c
After some years, in one of the fashion programmes, they met .again and planned
c. o em
to form a private Limited Company in the name of SuhanisFashions Private Limited
s em g la
gla a Entrepreneurs.
a
having a paid-up share capital of 5 Crore and became
Suhani Fashions Pvt. Ltd. is engaged in the business of Manufacturing and Selling
Ladies Suits and Sarees in Kolkata, West Bengal which is a very big market for
Indian traditional dresses. They also offered their products on online e-commerce
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE P.T.O.
m . c
c. o s e m
m a
se
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit
g l
Page 11 of 19
Page 13
555
: 12 :
platforms. They employed more than 100 Ladies and other staff in their workshop
who were engaged in designing, cutting, tailoring and other allied works. Suhani also
used to design products being sold by the company.
Both Suhani and Dhwani were Promoter Directors of the company as per the Article
of Association of the company and also the subscribers to the Memorandum of
Association of the company by subscribing 50% shares each in the company. Dhwani,
being a fashion model, did modelling for her products in order to improve the sales
of the company. The company started growing very fast and sales touched a figure
of ` 20 crores in the very first year and in order to meet the working capital and
other requirements, the company approached the bankers Beta bank and Gama Bank
for a facility of ` 3 crores and ` 5 crores respectively. The Company already had
taken the credit facilities with Alpha Bank and outstanding amount is ` 6 crores.
After the change in demand of the products and growing need of Formal dresses
from the Indian traditional dresses, sales started declining and the company started
facing cash crunch and made a default in paying the instalments for ` 2 crores which
were outstanding in the name of the Alpha bank.
The Alpha bank decided to file an Insolvency Petition under Section 7 of the Insolvency
and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 as a financial Creditor on 3rd January, 2024. The Corporate
Insolvency Resolution Process application was admitted by the Adjudicating Authority
on 25th January, 2024. Moratorium was declared and Ishann was appointed as an
Interim Resolution Professional. Ishaan, Interim Resolution Professional made a public
announcement and prepared a list of creditors based on the claims received. The
CoC is yet to be formed.
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE Contd. ........
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 12 of 19
Page 14
co m .
. s e
em l a
as a g
555
: 13 :
m
Consider the above facts and answer the following questions :
om . co
.c e m
(i) What is the date of initiation of Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process as
e m l a s
s g
per the provisions of Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 ?
l a a
ag
(3 marks)
(ii) Describe in detail the meaning of Interim finance. How the interim finance and
cost incurred in raising such finance is treated in case the corporate debtor
goes into liquidation ?
(5 marks)
m
c. o
mafter the withdrawal of an application for Corporate
(iii) State, whether any other creditor can initiate proceeding under the Insolvency
s e
l a
and Bankruptcy Code, 2016,
ag Process by an applicant ? Discuss with the help of the
Insolvency Resolution
case laws.
(5 marks)
(iv) State the provisions of Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code for withdrawal of
m
application admitted under section 7, 9 and 10 by the applicant. Can it be
m c. o
c. o
withdrawn after its admission but before the constitution of CoC. Explain with
e m
em la s
the help of the case laws.
las ag
g
(7 marks)
a (b) XYZ Limited had undertaken financial debts of ` 500 crores. It was unable to service
the debts to Financial Creditors. The Financial Creditors restructured the debt under
a Restructuring Agreement with XYZ Limited. However, it continued to remain in
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE P.T.O.
m . c
c. o s e m
m a
se
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit
g l
Page 13 of 19
Page 15
555
: 14 :
default with the Financial Creditors. Application was filed against XYZ Limited under
section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 to initiate Corporate Insolvency
Resolution Proceedings. To this effect XYZ Limited took shelter under a Special Provision
Act of State of Tamil Nadu (State Act). XYZ Limited was declared as a relief
undertaking by the Government of Tamil Nadu under a State law through which XYZ
Limited’s liabilities were suspended by way of Moratorium. National Company Law
Tribunal admitted the application filed by the Financial Creditor initiating Corporate
Insolvency Resolution Process against XYZ Limited. Directors of XYZ Limited
immediately filed an appeal before National Company Law Appellate Tribunal against
the National Company Law Tribunal’s order for admission of the company to Corporate
Insolvency Resolution Process as the company is already subject to moratorium under
the Tamil Nadu State Act.
Whether the non-obstante Clause contained under Insolvency and Bankruptcy
Code, 2016 will prevail over the non-obstante Clause under a State Act ?
(5 marks)
4. (a) Vikky Construction Company Pvt. Ltd. (Corporate Debtor & Respondent) entered
into a sub-Contract Agreement with one Nusheerabad Constructions Pvt. Ltd. (NCPL)
on 01.02.2008, to undertake work of Construction and widening of roads for and
on behalf of NCPL.
Apart from this Agreement, a separate agreement of the same date was entered into
between the said NCPL and one KDM Projects Private Limited, Kolkata, as a result
of which, a tripartite Memorandum of Understanding was entered into on 09.05.2008
between NCPL, KDM Projects Pvt. Ltd. and the Respondent.
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE Contd. ........
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 14 of 19
Page 16
co m .
. s e
em l a
as a g
555
: 15 :
m
During the course of the project, disputes and differences arose between the parties
om . co
c m
and the same were referred to an Arbitral Tribunal, which delivered its Award on
m . s e
ofsethe respondent for a sum of ` 1,71,98,302/- which arose out of certain ginterim
l a
21.01.2017. One of the claims that was allowed by the said Award was in favour
g a
l payment certificates. Another claim that was allowed related to higher rates ofapayment
a
in which a sum of ` 13,56,98,624 was awarded. Three cross claims that were made
by the Respondent were rejected.
A notice dated 06.02.2017 was sent by the Respondent to NCPL to pay an amount
m
of ` 1,79,00,166. This notice was stated to be a notice under Section 8 of the
c. o
that was referred to in the saidem
Code. Within 10 days, by a letter dated 16.02.2017, NCPL disputed the invoice
la s notice, stating that the said amount was, in fact,
the subject-matter of an garbitration
a proceeding, and as per NCPL’s accounts, the
Respondent was liable to pay larger amounts to them.
After the notice and reply, on 20.04.2017, a Section 34 petition was filed by NCPL
under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 challenging the aforesaid Award. This
petition was filed within the period of limitation set down in Section 34(3) of the
m
m c. o
Act. It is only thereafter that a petition was filed under Section 9 of the Code,
c. o s e m
em
on 14.07.2017.
s g la
gla a
The Adjudicating Authority (AA), by its order dated 29.08.2017, referred to the afore
a stated facts and also referred to the fact that the Award which was challenged under
Section 34 specifically stated that learned counsel for the first Respondent (i.e., the
corporate debtor) was fair enough to admit that the claimant is entitled to the said
sum of ` 1,71,98,302/- According to the AA, the fact that a Section 34 petition
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE P.T.O.
m . c
c. o s e m
m a
se
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit
g l
Page 15 of 19
Page 17
555
: 16 :
was pending was irrelevant for the reason that the claim stood admitted, and there
was no stay of the Award. For these reasons, therefore, the Section 9 petition was
admitted.
An appeal filed to the Appellate Tribunal met with the same fate, as according to
the Appellate Tribunal, the non-obstante clause contained in Section 238 of the Code
would override the Arbitration Act. Also, according to the Appellate Tribunal, since
Form(s) required to be filed in terms of the Insolvency & Bankruptcy (Application
to Adjudicating Authority) Rules, 2016 requires particulars of an order of an arbitral
panel adjudicating on the default, this would have to be treated as ‘‘a record of
an operational debt", as a result of which the petition would have to be admitted,
as was correctly done by the Adjudicating Authority. The appeal was, accordingly,
dismissed.
Being aggrieved by the decision of the Appellate Tribunal, the Appellant has appealed
to the apex court. In the light of decided cases, examine whether the code can be
invoked in respect of an operational debt where an Arbitral Award has been passed
against the operational debtor, which has not yet been finally adjudicated upon ? Would
the Appellants’ plea against the judgment of the Authorities be accepted ?
(6 marks)
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE Contd. ........
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 16 of 19
Page 18
co m .
. s e
em l a
as a g
555
: 17 :
m
(b) Match the following dictum/issue involved with the Case Law(s) based on ratios/decisions
om . co
.c m
pronounced under IBC :
Sr. m se
s e No. g l a
la (i) There is no scope for elaborate
Dictum/issue involved Case Law(s)
g a
a Sanjay Kumar Ruia Vs. Catholic
pleadings. An application to the Syrian Bank Ltd. & Anr,
Adjudicating Authority under Section
7 of the Code in the prescribed
m
c. o
form, cannot therefore, be compared
m
with the plaint insae suit
g la
(ii) a is shown as ‘fees’ State Bank of India Vs. Jet
Once the amount
and 'resolution cost' the same to be Airways (India) Ltd., (NCLT.
paid in terms of Section 53 of the Mumbai)
m
Code.
m c. o
c. o e m
(iii) Can an Insolvency Resolution Dena Bank (now Bank of Baroda
em Vs. a
l s
las g
aAnr
professional who had been in C. Shivakumar Reddy and
ag employment of a financial creditor
be appointed as Resolution
professional ?
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE P.T.O.
m . c
c. o s e m
m a
se
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit
g l
Page 17 of 19
Page 19
555
: 18 :
(iv) Can the Appellate Tribuanl set aside Liberty House Group Pte. Ltd.
the order of liquidation of a corporate Vs. State Bank of India & Others
debtor using the powers under Rule (NCLAT, New Delhi)
11 of NCLAT Rules, 2016 ?
(v) Without initiating CIRP against the State Bank of India Vs. Metenere
principal borrower, it is open to Limited (Supreme Court)
the FC to initiate CIRP under
section 7 against corporate guarantors
as the creditor is also the FC qua
corporate guarantor.
(vi) Admitting of corporate insolvency Rai Bahadur Shree Ram and
resolution process of the corporate Company Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Rural
debtor in India in the light of order Electrification Corporation Ltd.
passed by a foreign Court ? and Ors.
(9 marks)
(c) Sanjay Garg is a practising Company Secretary and an Insolvency Professional. He
is acting as an Interim Resolution Professional in Saturn Toys Limited. (STL) vide
the order of Hon’ble National Company Law Tribunal, Principal Bench, Delhi dated
8th October, 2018. Sanjay Garg was subsequently confirmed as the Resolution
Professional of the Corporate Debtor, Saturn Toys Limited (STL) by the Committee
of Creditors (CoC) in its first CoC meeting held on 1st November, 2018.
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE Contd. ........
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 18 of 19
Page 20
co m .
. s e
em l a
as a g
555
: 19 :
m
Prior to the commencement of CIRP, MIRDI Bank (one of the financial creditors)
om . co
c m
conducted a bidding process for selecting an Interim Resolution Professional for the
m . s e
e as proposed, H & M was selected to provide Infrastructure, Personnel a
l and
corporate insolvency resolution process of STL. Along with the selection of Sanjay
a s g
l Back-office support services to assist Sanjay Garg for the purpose of corporate ainsolvency
g
Garg
a
resolution process of STL.
The payment agreed to be paid to H & M is 19 times of the fee payable to Resolution
professional. Sanjay Garg, Resolution Professional appointed professionals during the
m
corporate insolvency resolution process and could not disclose the payment made to
c. o
mamount approved by the appropriate authorities.
himself, H & M and the other professionals separately. He raised the invoices for
an amount which is more than ethe
l a s
agagainst the Resolution Professional and the matter travelled
The Complaint was made
to the Disciplinary Committee of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India.
The Disciplinary Committee is of the view that it is inconceivable that the cost of
providing infrastructure, personnel and back-office support services is 19 times of the
m
fee payable to Resolution Professional which is not a reasonable reflection of the
m c. o
c. o m
work done and the insolvency professional was not straight forward and forthright
s e
em la
in his conduct.
las ag
ag
In the light of the provisions of the Code and decided case laws, discuss whether
Sanjay Garg as a resolution professional is liable on the basis of above facts ?
(10 marks)
————— o —————
1/2024/IBLP/NS/OBE P.T.O.
m . c
c. o s e m
m a
se
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit
g l
Page 19 of 19