Page 1
FOR CS PROFESSIONAL EXAM PREPARATION
CS Professional 2024
Question Paper ·
Drafting, Pleadings and
Appearances
EXAM YEAR TYPE
CS Professional 2024 Question Paper
SUBJECT DATE
Drafting, Pleadings and Appearances June 2024
Notes · Sample Papers · Previous Year Papers · Mock Tests
Page 2
co m .
. s e
em l a
as a g
NEW SYLLABUS
532
: 1 :
Roll No. .....................................
m
m . co
c. o s em
em la
Time allowed : 3 hours Maximum marks : 100
la s a g
g
a of questions : 6
Total number Total number of printed pages : 7
NOTE : Answer ALL Questions.
m
PART–I
c. o
regarding a strategic partnership proposalmwith a promising tech start-up. With 12 directors
1. XYZ Ltd., a multinational conglomerate operating across various sectors, faces a critical decision
s e coupled with the diverse locations of its board
a
gl an in-person meeting. Consequently, the company
members, poses a challenge inaconvening
on the board, the urgency of the matter,
seeks an alternative method to pass the resolution.
W acted as a director on the Board of Directors of XYZ Ltd. between 2016 and 2018.
He is also a shareholder in the said company, owning approximately 25.66% equity shares,
and drew a salary of ` 2.50 lakh per month. The Commissioner of Central Goods and
Service Taxes, based on the information received indicating that XYZ Ltd. was availing Input
m
c. o
Tax Credit (ITC) against fake/ineligible invoices, commenced an investigation under section
m
c. o commissioner’s statement, admitted to the fact that he had acted as saedirector
m of the company
67 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, against XYZ Ltd. W, as per the
s em between 2016 and 2018, and since then, he has been working inlthe
g a company in the capacity
gla of a mentor/advisor. Furthermore, W also stated to the CGSTaDepartment that, in his capacity
a as the mentor/advisor to the company, he received ` 30 Lakh in the concerned FY i.e.,
2019-2020, from the company. According to W, this money was given as he had been
providing “strategic guidance” to the Company. The bank accounts of W have also been
attached to the CGST Department.
1/2024/DPA/NS P.T.O.
m . c
c. o s e m
m a
se
g l
Page 1 of 7
Page 3
532
: 2 :
XYZ Ltd. enters into a contract with B, a logistics provides, to deliver a shipment of newly
manufactured electronic gadgets to various retail stores across the country. The contract specifies
a delivery deadline crucial for the upcoming Deepawali season sales. However, due to B’s
negligence, the delivery is delayed by two weeks, causing significant financial losses to XYZ
Ltd. As a result of the delay, XYZ Ltd. misses the peak sales window, leading to decreased
revenue and tarnished brand reputation. The company is contemplating seeking legal remedy
for the loss caused.
The Ministry of Road Transport and Highways of India has announced a significant infrastructure
project for the construction of Megha Highway. This highway project aims to connect various
cities and towns, boosting transportation and economic development in the region. To execute
this project, the ministry has initiated a tendering process inviting bids from qualified construction
firms. XYZ Ltd., which is also engaged in construction activity, is contemplating participating
in the tendering process for construction of the Megha Highway. As a major player in the
construction industry, XYZ Ltd. sees this project as lucrative opportunity to showcase its
expertise, expand its portfolio, and contribute to the nation’s infrastructure development.
XYZ Ltd. wants to enter into e-contracts across the country for the sale of their various
products. The company’s counsel is considering the fact that conventional contract law may
not be sufficient to address all the issues arising in electronic contracts. The Information
Technology Act (IT Act) addresses some of the peculiar issues arises in the formation and
authentication of electronic contracts. The Indian Evidence Act, 1872, deals with the presumption
as to e-records, providing electronic records as evidence in disputed matters (Sections : 85A,
85B, 88A, 85C).
Based on the facts of above case study, answer following questions :
(a) You are required to guide XYZ Ltd. on the alternative method under the Companies
Act, 2013, to pass the resolution for the strategic partnership with the tech
start-up. What requirements will the company have to fulfil ?
1/2024/DPA/NS Contd. ........
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 2 of 7
Page 4
co m .
. s e
em l a
as a g
532
: 3 :
m
(b) W has approached you to seek your opinion on the matter of attaching his bank
m . c o
co Ltd. on the remedies available to them under the Indian Contract Act, m
accounts. Write an opinion.
Advise .XYZ e
(c)
emfor the loss caused. l a s
la s
1872
a g
(d) g What considerations XYZ Ltd. should take into account, while preparing a tender
a
document for the Megha Highway project ?
(e) What prohibitions must specifically be included in e-contracts ? Furthermore, how shall
the limitation of liability of XYZ Ltd. be addressed under e-contracts ?
(5 marks each)
m
c. o
2. (a) Bharathi, by a deed of gift made over certain property to her daughter, Narmadha,
emsaid property. On the same day, Narmadha executed
and directing her to pay an annuity to the donor’s brother, Ram, as she had promised
her brother Ram before gifting sthe
g l a
a of the donor’s brother (Uncle) agreeing to pay the annuity.
a deed, in writing, in favour
Afterwards, Narmadha declined to fulfil her promise to pay her uncle saying that no
consideration had moved from him. Is the contention of Narmadha tenable ?
(b) In a simple mortgage, the security for the debt is two-fold. Elucidate and cite case
m
m c. o (5 marks)
law, if any.
c. o s e m
em la
as ag
(c) Amalgamation is basically a merger of two or more companies into one another company
l
ag
and the shareholders of each merging company becomes the shareholders in that another
company. It may be either by :
(i) the transfer of two or more companies into one another new company, or
(ii) the transfer of one or more companies into one existing company
1/2024/DPA/NS P.T.O.
m . c
c. o se m
m a
se
g l
Page 3 of 7
Page 5
532
: 4 :
In light of the above, when a transferor company stands dissolved due to amalgamation,
explain the status of legal proceedings pending before the court, in which the transferor company
was a party.
3. (a) A competent jurisdictional authority has issued a show cause notice to Abdul Rehman.
He has sought your advice for replaying the same. What are the points that he must
consider while replying to the show cause notice ?
(b) X, with the intention of disposing of his old stock of outdated machines, requested
Y to place them in his shop for sale. Y handed over a blank cheque to X to
be used only upon his instructions, after sold out of all those machines. However,
since the machines were outdated and faulty, they could not be sold. Despite this,
X lodged the cheque in the bank, which was subsequently dishnonoured. Y received
a notice under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, from X’s advocate,
demanding payment. You are required to draft a reply to the above notice, assuming
the necessary facts.
(c) Draft a resolution for approval and adoption of CSR policy.
Attempt all parts of either Q. No. 4 or Q. No. 4A
4. (a) Explain the conditions which are required to be fulfilled under section 70 of the Indian
Contract Act, 1872 for a court to allow compensation under the principle of Quantum
meruit.
1/2024/DPA/NS Contd. ........
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 4 of 7
Page 6
co m .
. s e
em l a
as a g
532
: 5 :
m
(b) What do you understand by Alternate Dispute Resolution (ADR) Mechanisms ? Elucidate
om
its different types.
. co
.c e m
m
eper The Company Secretaries Auditing Standard (CSAS-3), how the auditor should l a s
l a s a g
g
a deal, if, after accepting the audit engagement, the appointing authority imposes a limitation
(c) As
on the scope of the audit.
OR (Alternative question to Q. No. 4)
m
. co
4.A. (i) Whether the licence as defined under The Indian Easements Act, 1882, is
s em
transferable ?
g l a
a
(ii) While forming an opinion, comment on “reliance put by opinion giver on the certificates
of public official” while understanding the facts of a case.
(iii) Explain E-stamping. Enumerate its benefits.
m
m c. o (5 marks)
c. o s e m
s em l a
PART–II
la 5. Sharma, a resident of Delhi, filed a revision petition before the g
a Delhi High Court challenging
ag
an order passed by the subordinate court in a property dispute case. The order had gone
against him, as instead of filing appeal before appellate court, he sought relief under section
115 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC).
1/2024/DPA/NS P.T.O.
m . c
c. o s e m
m a
se
g l Page 5 of 7
Page 7
532
: 6 :
Sharma has been embroiled in a property dispute for several years. Frustrated by the delays
and complexities of the traditional court system, he seeks a more efficient resolution to his
case. Upon hearing about the e-Courts Project, Mr. Sharma decides to explore its services.
The e-Courts Project was conceptualized on the basis of the “National Policy and Action
Plan for Implementation of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) in the Indian
Judiciary—2005” submitted by e-Committee, Supreme Court of India with a vision to transform
the Indian Judiciary by ICT enablement of Courts. The e-Courts Mission Mode Project,
is a Pan-India Project, monitored and funded by Depatment of Justice, Ministry of Law
and Justice, Government of India for the District Courts across the country.
Furthermore, Sharma had advanced a sum of ` 5 Lakh to Mr. T on 1st November 2023,
with an agreed rate of interest @12 percent per annum and repayment within three months.
He recovered ` 5 Lakh with in time from T but could not recover the agreed interest
even after repeated reminders. He wants to file suit against T for recovery of interest.
Based on the facts of the above case study, answer the following questions :
(a) The e-Courts Project, initiated and based on the National Policy and Action Plan
for Implementation of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) in the judiciary,
aims to transform the Indian judiciary through ICT enablement of courts. State the
objective of the e-Courts mission project. What services are available to litigants through
the e-Courts Project ?
(b) What are the grounds upon which the High Court can intervene in revision
proceedings ? Whether it can interfere, if it differs from the conclusions of the subordinate
court on questions of fact or law ?
(c) Sharma approaches you seeking guidance on filing a suit against T. Advise him on
the necessary facts to include in the suit for the recovery of interest from T.
(5 marks each)
1/2024/DPA/NS Contd. ........
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 6 of 7
Page 8
co m .
. s e
em l a
as a g
532
: 7 :
m
Attempt all parts of either Q. No. 6 or Q No. 6A
m . c o
.co approaches the National Company Law Tribunal in some matter and submits
s e m
em in Tamil. The Registry of the NCLT refuses to accept the document a
6. (a) Sudharshini
s g l
laas it is in Tamil. Is the refusal of the Registry tenable ? Explain. a
a document
a g
(b) The registered office of Poornabodha Limited is located in the city of Udupi in Karnataka.
In a matter pertaining to the removal of a director, a notice was despatched by
the company from a post office in Hassan in Karnataka. A shareholder has contended
that the notice is not valid. Explain if the contention of the shareholder is correct.
o m
c
. can be compounded under the Companies Act,
(c)
m
e compounding such offences.
Explain the nature of offences, which
2013. Specify the jurisdiction sfor
g l a
a (5 marks)
OR (Alternative question to Q. No. 6)
6.A (i) Examine the role of Adjudicating Officers under the SEBI Act, 1992 to determine
the quantum of fine when any provisions specified in the SEBI Act or SCRA, 1956
are not been complied with.
o m (5 marks)
m . c of Company
c. o (ii) s em
Explain the objectives of the ICSI (Guidelines for Attire and Conduct
s em g la
la
Secretaries), 2020.
g a
a
(iii) Explain Appellate Authorities under the Competition Act, 2002.
————— o —————
1/2024/DPA/NS P.T.O.
m . c
c. o s e m
m a
se
g l
Page 7 of 7