aglasem.com
Home Schools Admission Career Mock Test PDF Docs Playground
ClassChoose class
StateSelect state

CA Final May 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme)

Download the CA Final May 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) PDF from AglaSem. These are the official suggested answers released by ICAI. Use them to check your answers and learn how to present them in the exam.
CA Final May 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) - Page 1 of 33

About CA Final May 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme)

CA Final May 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) is available here for free download. Published by ICAI for ICAI CA, this solution can be viewed online or downloaded as a PDF (33 pages). Candidates preparing for ICAI CA can use CA Final May 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) to understand the exam pattern, the type of questions asked, and the overall difficulty level.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I download CA Final May 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme)?

Open this page and click the Download button to save CA Final May 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) as a PDF. It is completely free on AglaSem Docs.

Is CA Final May 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) free to download?

Yes. CA Final May 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) can be viewed online and downloaded as a PDF free of cost on AglaSem Docs.

How many pages does CA Final May 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) have?

CA Final May 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) contains 33 pages, which you can read online or download together as a single PDF.

Where can I find more ICAI CA study material?

You can find more ICAI CA question papers, sample papers, syllabus, and answer keys on AglaSem Docs.

CA Final May 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) – Text

Read the full text of this solution below — useful to quickly search, copy and reference the content online without downloading the PDF.

📄 View text version (33 pages)

Page 1

FOR CA FINAL EXAM PREPARATION

CA Final 2022
Suggested Answers ·
Paper 6A Risk
Management (Old
Scheme)
EXAM YEAR TYPE

CA Final 2022 Suggested Answers
SUBJECT DATE

Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) May 2022

Notes · Sample Papers · Previous Year Papers · Mock Tests

Page 2

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g

DISCLAIMER
This Suggested Answer hosted on the website do not constitute the basis for evaluation of the

m
m c. o
co
student’s answers in the examination. The answers are prepared by the Faculty of the Board of

. e m
em
Studies with a view to assist the students in their education. Alternate Answers have been

la s
l a s a g
aerrorg or omission is noticed, the same may be brought to the attention of the Director of Board
incorporated, wherever necessary. While due care is taken in preparation of the answers, if any

of Studies. The Council of the Institute is not in anyway responsible for the correctness or

otherwise of the answers published herein.

Further, in the Elective Papers which are Case Study based, the solutions have been worked

o m
out on the basis of certain assumptions/views derived from the facts g iven in the question or

c
. to work out the solution to the case studies
m
e made or views taken.
language used in the question. It may be possible

la s
g
in a different manner based on the assumptions

a

m
m .co
c. o se
m
s em g la
gla a
a

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 1 of 32

Page 3

2 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022

PAPER – 6A – RISK MANAGEMENT

The Question Paper comprises five case study questions. The candidates are required
to answer any four case study questions out of five.
Answers in respect of Multiple-Choice Questions (MCQs) are to be marked on the OMR
Answer Sheet as given on the Cover Page of the answer book.
Answer to MCQs, if written inside the descriptive answer book, will not be evaluated.
Candidates should answer the Case Study Questions as selected by them in totality i.e. MCQ
as well as descriptive Question of the same Case Study Question.
Candidates are not permitted to answer MCQs of one Case Study Question and the
descriptive questions of another Case Study Question and vice-versa.
Candidates may use calculator.
CASE STUDY: 1

INTRODUCTION
Organic farming is a method of agricultural cultivation mainly using bio fertilisers and organic
pest control materials. This concept has been developed mainly due to the realisation of
environmental and health issues caused by the sustained use of chemical pesticides and
fertilisers. Though this type of farming is ecologically supportive, the outputs from these farms
are lower when compared to other regular farms, thereby pushing-up the prices of the products
sold.
FACTS OF THE CASE
Fresh Farms Limited (FPL) converted to organic method of farming ten years ago and has
earned a good name in the local market. It produces sugarcane, cotton, pulses, medicinal plants
and herbs, fruits, vegetables, and millets.
FPL is aware that (i) the cost of production is more by 25%, than compared to that of regular
farming and (ii) they cannot increase the prices of the farm outputs beyond a certain level. The
revenue for last year ended 31.03.2021 stood at ` 30 Crores. The cost cutting measures were
employed but did not produce desired results. In some instances, the customers expressed
dissatisfaction that the fruits they ordered for the festive season did not arrive in time .
An initial analysis of the operations revealed that various processes could be streamlined; better
efficiency could be achieved by following the standards and procedures followed globally in this
type of farming.
The Managing Director (MD) explained to all the board members that FFL would strive to
innovate by exploring into newer methods of cultivation and thereby increasing the profitability.

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 2 of 32

Page 4

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 3

He wanted the General Manager (GM) to prepare a report on the measures, risk factors and
control measures to achieve the above objectives. ·

m
c. o
FFL has small offices in five neighbouring countries. Exports of products are made to these

m
co m
countries and receivables included amounts due from some foreign buyers. It was noticed that

.
two export consignments valued at ` 25 lakhs were returned by the customs officials of the
m s e
s e la
respective countries as relevant rules applicable to such exports were not strictly followed and

l amanagement has made a proposal to sell its accounts receivable at a discount to Mode rna
issued notices to FFL that if such practice continued in future, they would blacklist FFL.
g
g
aFinance Limited (MFL), a financing company. Negotiations with MFL are going on.
FFL's

As on last year ended on 31.03.2021, FFL has 225 employees on its salary roll. Most of the staff
lacked motivation and there was not much of co-ordination among them. FFL's manager Mr.
Shyam stressed the need to adopt a systematic study of the various aspects of risk
management. He wanted their executives to be aware of the potential risks and make them act
proactively to achieve greater levels of efficiency.

m
For fulfilling the statutory compliance requirements of a limited company, the Statutory Auditor,

. co
M/s X and Y Associates, were doing an audit of Internal Controls over Financial Reporting. They

em
made an exception to the conduct of one of the directors who withdrew ` 50 lakhs towards his

s
personal drawings, without the specific approval of the board.

g l a
Mr. Rohan, the Farms Manager, is generating scenarios for making an analysis, based on the
a
stressful situations and events happened in the history of FFL.
The risk management consultant, Ms. Bose emphasised the importance of adopting an
integrated risk management approach and further suggested to conduct a comprehensive risk
evaluation exercise. This task was given to Mr. Abdul, the Risk Manager of the company.
Ms. Bose cautioned FFL to exercise more control over its cyber activities in relation to its direct
online selling of farm produce to the customers as organisations are becoming more susceptible
to cyber-attacks. After performing various calculations, she observed that probability cyber -

o m
attack occurring to the online trading portal of FFL is 7% and if it occurs, then the estimated loss

m .c
would be ` 2 Crores and she recommended strengthening the cyber security.

c. o In the background of these facts, you are requested to answer the followingsquestions:
e m
em l a
s g
Multiple Choice Questions

l a a
ag
Choose the most appropriate answer from the given options.
(1.1) In pursuance to Mr. Shyam’s suggestion, if potential risks are communicated to the
executive management, the same would most likely be considered under:
(A) Risk Identification.

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s ag
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 3 of 32

Page 5

4 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022

(B) Risk Analysis.
(C) Risk Assessment.
(D) Risk Mitigation.
(1.2) In the task given to Mr. Abdul, he would not consider:
(A) The importance of various activities to the business.
(B) The amount of control that FFL have over the cyber risks.
(C) Potential profits to the business of FFL.
(D) Benefits or opportunities presented by the cyber risks to FFL.
(1.3) Which among the following would be the most important responsibility of M /s X and Y
Associates, the statutory auditors while doing audit of Internal Controls over Financial
Reporting?
(A) Ascertaining segregation of duties in processes.
(B) Review of the Risk and Control Self-Assessment (RCSA) results.
(C) Recommend to the board and adoption of risk assessment and rating procedures.
(D) Disclosure of risk factors.
(1.4) FFL's proposal to MFL would be known as:
(A) Structural Method.
(B) Private Insurance.
(C) CDS contracts.
(D) Factoring.
(1.5) In Mr. Rohan's task, he will generate the scenarios based on the:
(A) Evaluation of the portfolio risk vulnerability.
(B) Events that will cause movements in the relative risk factors.
(C) Adverse risk factor movements.
(D) Development of events which start from one set of assumptions. (2 x 5 = 10 Marks)
Descriptive Questions
(1.6) The General Manager (GM) needs your inputs for the report requested by the MD. You are
required to prepare a report and submit it to the GM. (5 Marks)
(1.7) What is an integrated risk management? Write a note on Key Quantitative Information
pertaining to the year ended on 31.03 .2021 to the management. (3 Marks)
(1.8) Briefly explain how other risks of FFL would contribute to reputational risks by drawing
examples from the Case Study. (3 Marks)

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 4 of 32

Page 6

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 5

(1.9) Discuss whether cyber-attacks on online platform of FFL be considered as single factor to
determine its risk appetite and also explain the reasons for risk appetite to be integrated

m
with the control culture of FFL. (4 Marks)
Answer
o m c. o
.c e m
s
1.1 (A)
1.2 (C) m
1.3 (A)s
a
e g la
l
1.4g (D)
a
a1.5 (B)
1.6 Report to GM
Strategic Strategic Measure Risk Factor Control Measure
Objective
Innovate by Selection of new Failure of the new Close monitoring of the
exploring into ideas and methods ideas and measures. same and finding out

m
co
newer and removing the

.
methods of May not yield pitfalls.

em
cultivation expected results. Following meticulously

l a s Failure of the same Implementing and
the industry standards.

a g
Increasing the Cost cutting.
profitability meticulously following
Increasing effective Internal
productivity and Controls.
sales.

Improved marketing
Or

o m
To

m .c
c. o
General Manager

e m
em s
Fresh Farm Ltd

s
Subject: - Report on Measures, Risk Factors and Control Measures
g a
lillustrated below:
gla a
This report covers some of the key risks affecting the Company as
a (a) Economic Risk: The company is facing economic risk due to:
(i) the cost of production is more by 25%, than compared to that of regular farming
and,

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 5 of 32

Page 7

6 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022

(ii) they cannot increase the prices of the farm outputs beyond a certain level.
To control this risk the company should look for comparatively cheaper sources of
raw material without compromising on quality aspect. Especially meeting commitment
during the festive reason.
Further efficiency could be improved upon by following the standards and procedures
which are followed globally.
(b) Foreign Exchange Risk: Since Company has offices in five neighboring countries
and also export its products, hence the company is exposed to risk in fluctuation in
foreign exchange rates.
The company should take steps to hedge its position e.g. taking position in derivatives
market.
(c) Compliance Risk: Company is also facing Compliance Risk because two exports
consignment valued at ` 25 lakhs were returned by the custom official of the
respective countries as relevant rules applicable to such exports were not strictly
followed and issued notice to Company if such practice in continued in future, they
would blacklist the company.
Company should appoint some expert or forwarding, agent to get smoothen
consignments of exports after complying with the required regulatory requirement.
(d) Liquidity Risk: Since, Company is in process of availing factoring services for its
receivables, which clearly indicated company can face liquidity risk. Accordingly,
company should accelerate collection of its receivables.
Further, to avoid risk. of Bad Debts it should go for Non-Recourse Factoring
arrangements.
(e) Operational Risk: Conduct of one director of withdrawing ` 50 Lakhs towards his
personal drawings without specific approval of Board is an indicator of operational
risk.
Company should establish a proper internal Control system to control such type of
risks.
(f) Cyber Risk: The probability of exposure of the company to cyber risk is quite higher.
Not only that the loss due to such risk is also quite higher.
Accordingly, the company should take steps to strengthen the cyber security.
1.7 Integrated risk management is managing all the risks that relate to all activities carried out
throughout FFL.
It is a structured form to assist organization in preparing for the worst case scenario while
aspiring to be better faster and cheaper.

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 6 of 32

Page 8

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 7

Key Quantitative Information (KQI) of earlier year:
(1) There were 225 employees

m
m c. o
(2) The revenue stood at ` 30 crore.

c o m
(4) FFL .has decided to innovate by exploring into newer methods of cultivation. e
(3) FFL operates in five countries.

e m l a s
l a s a g
ag For
1.8 Normally, reputational risks are the result emanating from other risks.
example:
❖ Compliance Risk: Two export consignments valued at ` 25 lakhs were returned by
the customs officials of the respective countries as relevant rules applicable to such
export were not strictly followed and issued notices to FFL that if such practice
continued in future, they would blacklist FFL.
❖ Governance Risk: Misconduct of senior management: One of the directors who
withdrew ` 50 lakhs towards his personal drawings, without the specific approval of
the board.
m
. co
❖ Contractual Risk: Not meeting customers’ expectations and contractual

em
requirements: In some instances, the customers expressed dissatisfaction that the

s
fruits they ordered for the festive season did not arrive in time.

g l a
All these risks would result in causing reputational risks to FFL.
1.9 a
❖ There is a 7% the probability that the cyber risk will occur
❖ If cyber-attack occurs the loss would be ` 2 crores
❖ The online trading portal is susceptible to cyber - attack and therefore the cyber
security is to be strengthened.
Risk appetite is not a single, fixed concept. There will be a range of appetites or ranges for

m
co
different risks which need to be aligned and these appetites may vary over time. Like in

m .
c. o
sourcing decisions, the Board may set vendor business share limits as they would be make

m
se
the entity dependent on few vendor companies that could eventually impact business

em la
continuity or range of quality defects.

las a g
Risk appetite must be integrated with the control culture of the organization. The Risk

g
Management framework explores this by looking at both the propensity to take risk and the
a propensity to exercise control. The framework promotes the idea that the strategic level is
proportionately more about risk taking than exercising control, while at the operational level
the proportions are broadly reversed. Clearly the relative proportions will depend on the

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s ag
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 7 of 32

Page 9

8 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022

organization itself, the nature of the risks it faces and the regulatory environment within
which it operates.
CASE STUDY: 2
FACTS OF THE CASE
Innovative. Agri Limited (IAL), based in NOIDA, is manufacturing and selling various agricultural
tools, such as, sickle, axe, plough and various types of weeders for the past ten years. The
revenue for the past three years is almost stagnant.
Mainly during October and November of every year, the farmers, especially in the northern part
of the country bum their crop wastes. This is known as stubble burning and it causes a variety
of problems - health problems to the public, environmental pollution, soil quality deterioration
etc.
NEW PROPOSALS
IAL wants to explore the possibility of commencing manufacturing Stubble Removing Machine
(SMR), which will greatly reduce the ill-effects of stubble burning. Currently SMRs are being
sold for anywhere between ` 7 lakhs to 20 lakhs in the market. IAL came across a technology,
which would substantially reduce the selling price to ` 4.5 lakhs including a trailer that would be
attached to SMR. The technology can be bought for a one-time payment of ` 50 lakhs.
IAL intends to manufacture SMR under 'Make in India' scheme. Towards meeting the cost of
SMR manufacturing project, IAL has decided to approach a bank for a term loan for fifteen
years. On being satisfied, after the detailed workings and explanations of the project manager,
the bank agreed in-principle to sanction the loan. The loan officer of the bank, Mr. Arun
analysed the internal factors affecting the credit risk of the bank while considering the loan
proposal of IAL. To meet a portion of the cost of the project, IAL wants to sell some ass ets held
in the form of market securities before their stated maturities and has entrusted this job to the
Chief Financial Officer, Mr. Ravi.
IAL is also having a proposal to manufacture and sell Plant Cutting Scissors. The estimated cost
of the project is expected to be funded by the directors. The details of the project are as under:
Sr. No. Particulars Figures
1 Initial Capital Cost ` 5 Cr.
2 Annual unit sales (nos.) 0.2 Cr.
3 Selling price per unit ` 120
4 Variable cost per unit ` 60
5 Fixed costs per year ` 1 Cr.
6 Discount Rate 7%

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 8 of 32

Page 10

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 9

OTHER OBSERVATIONS
It was decided to improve the risk management system of IAL. Mr. Raj, the Internal Auditor was

m
c. o
assigned the task of finding out the risk maturity level of IAL. He suggested to the management

m
co
to consider forming a Risk Committee and an Audit Committee of the Board. He opined that (i)

. e m
s
risk management of IAL would surely minimise the impact of risk on the business with the help

e m
of the Risk Committee and (ii) the Audit Committee would act on the terms of reference as
la
l a s
specified by the Board and would primarily include evaluation of risk management systems
a g
aTheg Managing Director (MD) requested Mr. Raj to explain to him the concepts of (i) Magnitude
including internal control system and internal audit.

of the Risk, (ii) Risk Perception, (iii) Cognitive Psychology and (iv) Emotional Intelligence. It was
also decided to hold periodic meetings with the management and the departmental heads to
capture learning and develop related recommendations at the end of a major activity or
engagement.
Based on the facts given above, you are requested to answer the following questions:
Multiple Choice Questions

o m
c
. while conducting his assigned task?
Choose the most appropriate answer from the given options.

e m
(2.1) Mr. Raj would NOT refer to which of the following

s
la immediate, tangible results.
(A) Risk appetite is defined and communicated across the organisation.

g
a including the tone from the top.
(B) Implement key practices to achieve
(C) Control environment is strong
(D) Business objectives are defined and communicated.
(2.2) Which of the following would be considered by Mr. Arun in his analysis?
(A) Fluctuation in interest rates.
(B) Uncertainty associated with future level.
(C) Ignoring the purpose for which loan was sought by IAL.

o m
m (2.3) While discharging the job entrusted to Mr. Ravi, which of the following risk m c
. arise?
(D) Fluctuation in Exchange Rates.

c. o e
would

em (A) Price Risk.
l a s
l as (B) Yield Curve Risk.
a g
ag
(C) Embedded Option Risk.
(D) Reinvestment Risk.
(2.4) Which of the following is not a common sound practice that is followed in respect of
formation of Audit Committee as suggested by Mr. Raj?

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 9 of 32

Page 11

10 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022

(A) It has a chair who is an independent director.
(B) It includes members who are independent.
(C) Is required to review and approve IAL's risk policies.
(D) Is required to be a stand-alone committee.
(2.5) The periodic meeting to be held with the management and the various departmental heads
would be called:
(A) Problem resolution.
(B) Clean wash.
(C) Meet wash.
(D) Hot wash. (2 x 5 = 10 Marks)
Descriptive Questions
(2.6) In the case of proposal for manufacturing of the Plant Cutting Scissors project, you are
required to:
(1) Calculate NPV of the Project and
(2) Compute the impact on the project's NPV considering a 3 per cent adverse variance
in each variable. Which variable is having maximum effect, consider the life of the
project as three years?
Note:
Year 0 1 2 3
PV Factor for 7% 1.000 0.935 0.873 0.816
Show your workings. (6 Marks)
(2.7) Explain the risks you foresee and suggest remedial measures towards the same, in the
proposal to manufacture SMR. (5 Marks)
(2.8) What would be the explanations of Mr. Raj to MD on various concepts which he requested
him to explain? (4 Marks)
Answer
2.1 (B)
2.2 (C)
2.3 (A)
2.4 (C)
2.5 (D)

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 10 of 32

Page 12

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 11

2.6 Working Notes:
Calculation of Net Cash Inflow per year

m
m c. o
Particulars Amount (`)

.co e m
A Selling price per unit 120

m
e Contribution per unit (A - B)
B Variable cost per unit 60
la s
s
la Number of units sold per year
C 60
a g
ag E Total Contribution (C × D)
D 0.20 Cr.
` 12 Cr.
F Fixed cost per year ` 1.00 Cr.
G Net cash inflow per year (E - F) ` 11.00 Cr.
1. Calculation of Net Present Value (NPV) of the Project
Year Year Cash Flow PV factor @ 7% Present Value (PV)
(` in Cr.) (` in Cr.)
0 (5.00)
m
o 0.935
1.000 (5.00)

. c
em
1 11.00 10.285

s
2 11.00 0.873 9.603
3 11.00
g l a 0.816 8.976
Net Present Value
a 23.864
2. Sensitivity Analysis considering 3 % Adverse Variance in each variable
Particulars Base Initial Selling Variable Fixed Units
capital Price per Cost Per Cost Per sold per
cost Unit Unit Unit year
increased Reduced increased increased reduced
to ` 5.15 to to ` 61.80 to ` 1.03 to 0.194

m
crore ` 116.40 crore

m
(`) (`) (`) (`)
120.
(`)
c o(`)

c. o m
se 60 60
A Selling price 120 120 116.40 120 120

em la
per unit

las B Variable cost 60 60 60 61.80
a g
g
per unit

a C Contribution
per unit
60 60 56.40 58.20 60 60

(A - B)
(` in Cr.) (` in Cr.) (` in Cr.) (` in Cr.) (` in Cr.) (` in Cr.)

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 11 of 32

Page 13

12 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022

D Number of 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.194
units sold per
year
(units in
Crores)
E Total 12.00 12.00 11.28 11.64 12.00 11.64
Contribution
(C × D)
F Fixed cost 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.03 1.00
per year
G Net Cash 11.00 11.00 10.28 10.64 10.97 10.64
Inflow per
year
(E - F)
H PV of Net 28.864 28.864 26.975 27.919 28.785 27.919
cash Inflow
per year
(G × 2.624)
I Initial capital 5.00 5.15 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00
cost
J NPV (H - I) 23.864 23.714 21.975 22.919 23.785 22.919
K Percentage - -0.629% -7.916% -3.96% -0.331% -3.96%
Change in
NPV
The above table shows that by changing one variable at a time by 3% (adverse) while
keeping the others constant, the impact in percentage terms on the NPV of the project can
be calculated. Thus, it can be seen that the change in selling price has the maxim um effect
on the NPV by 7.916%.
2.7 The following risks can be faced in the proposal to manufacture SMR:
(1) Demand Forecasting: It is always not possible to exactly determine the demand of
the product. The demand Forecast of IAL may be low or high depending on the
forecasting model chosen.
Remedial measures: Ensuring that correct predictive model is used for forecasting
and the data used for estimating the demand is accurate.
(2) Competition: Competitors may offer the same product at a lower price or may resort
to aggressive selling.

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 12 of 32

Page 14

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 13

Remedial Measures: By strengthening the marketing, providing a quality product and
services, offering discounts are some of the aspects that IAL may follow to effectively

m
c. o
face the competition.

m
c. o m
(3) Collection from customers: The customer may not pay amounts within the due

m measures: Offering incentives for prompt payments, closely following the las
dates. It is always a risk to IAL.
e
s eRemedial g
l a a
ag (4) Customer
credit period allowed are some of the remedial measures.
Support: There is always a risk that IAL may not provide a quality and
timely after-sales service and the likelihood that the customers might be dissatisfied,
and IAL may face reputational risk are some of the remedial measures.
Remedial Measures: Setting-up service standards, understanding customers’
expectations and needs, intimation of due dates of service, ensuring the availability
of the spare-parts, providing timely service, getting feedback, and removing the
glitches in the service aspects.

o m
(5) Product Quality: A defect in the product always poses a significant risk. The product

. c
may fill or may not perform according to the specifications.
Remedial Measures: Ensuring the m
e control mechanism is in place for the raw
defect free products. Likewise,squality
quality control is working to ensure the sales of

g la and checking at various stages of production.
2.8 The explanations on various a
materials used in the production
concepts which MD has requested Mr. Raj to explain are as
follows:
(i) Magnitude of Risk: The degree of uncertainty or likelihood of occurrence and impact
of the risk outcome combined together.
(ii) Risk Perception: Belief (whether rational or irrational) held by an individual, group, or
society about the chance of occurrence of a risk or about the extent, magnitude, and

m
timing of its effect(s).

m .co
c. o
(iii) Cognitive Psychology: Cognitive Psychology is a science which deals with mental

m
se
skills of memory, perception, reasoning, creativity, understanding and problem

em la
solving.

las (iv)
a g
Emotional Intelligence: When people are anxious or in a state of emotion, they pay

ag close attention to potential threats in the environment and are highly vigilant so as to
preserve themselves and their resources.

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 13 of 32

Page 15

14 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022

CASE STUDY: 3
FACTS OF THE CASE
XYZ Auto Limited (XYZ) is a reputed car manufacturing company having its manufacturing
operations in South India. It's manufacturing units are located near the east coast and well
connected by different modes of transport. It has its presence in the small car - petrol & diesel
segments. The present capacity of XYZ is 60,000 units per annum. It also markets all the related
spares and has established its own service centres.
CHALLENGES FACED BY THE COMPANY
With the opening up of Indian economy and "Make in India" initiatives, global companies started
establishing their operations in India and which is resulting in stiff competition in the domestic
markets for the Company. These new companies have brought in the state of the art technology,
with enhanced features for their cars. The Central & State governments have also provided
various tax benefits to such entities for setting up their plants in India, which had a significant
cost advantage to the new entities.
Other challenges faced by the Company in its operations include:
(i) Non-availability of the Labour as more than 50% of this temporary labour force which
moved to their home towns due to COVID-19 pandemic is yet to come back,
(ii) change in the State government due to elections and likely change in government policies.
(iii) shortage of semi-conductor chips is forcing the company to reduce the production levels.
(iv) significant increase in the raw material prices, especially metals are impacting margins and
(v) increase in cost of petroleum products is forcing customers to buy Electric cars instead of
petrol & diesel cars.
FUTURE PLANS OF THE COMPANY
XYZ is looking at modifying the design of the car and provide better features to meet the
changing preferences of customers. An operational improvement team was set up to identify
cost control measures and improve efficiencies in the production & supply chain activities.
There is a plan to increase its annual capacity from 60,000 to 1,20,000 Units over the next three
years. The additional capacity will be in electric car segment. This requires XYZ to set up a new
production line. XYZ is planning to diversify into exports specifically in the electric car segment.
The cash outflow for setting up the new production line is estimated at ` 150 Crores; ` 80 Crores
and ` 20 Crores in the year 1, year 2 and year 3 respectively. The incremental cash flows and
probability for various scenarios are given below:

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 14 of 32

Page 16

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 15

Year 3 Year 4 Years 5
Cash flows Probability Cash flows Probability Cash flows Probability

m
c. o
` Crores ` Crores ` Crores
m
c. o 0.30 m
60.00 0.50 75.00 0.40 105.00 0.55

m s e
e la
70.00 85.00 0.25 120.00 0.25

l a s
80.00 0.15 95.00 0.20 130.00 0.15
a g
g
aThe CFO is planning to avail a separate term loan for this project from the financial institutions.
90.00 0.05 105.00 0.15 145.00 0.05

OTHER REGULATORY MATTERS
XYZ being a listed entity in India and is required to comply with all the listing agreement norms.
XYZ has junior team members responsible for internal audit and risk management activities and
they report to the CFO of the Company. The CFO makes quarterly presentation to the Audit
Committee and Risk Management Committee and shares internal audit and risk updates to the

m
respective committees set up by the Board of Directors. During the recently held Board Meeting,

. co
the Board of Directors advised the management to establish, a robust Risk Management

em
Process with enhanced focus on risk mitigation procedures and risk reporting requirements,

s
considering the heightened business risks and the planned expansion activities.

l a
Based on these directives from thegBoard of Directors, the Management team has taken the
ACTION TAKEN

following actions: a
A new Chief Risk Officer (CRO) has been appointed by the Company. All the risk management
team members were transferred to a newly created Risk Management Department an d were
asked to report to the CRO.
The newly appointed CRO has engaged an external firm to advise the Company, to establish a
comprehensive Enterprise Risk Management Framework. After a detailed evaluation, the
external firm has provided a comprehensive report to set up the Risk Management framework

o m
including the roles and responsibilities of the Risk Management team members and the Risk

m .c
c. o Based on the facts given above, you are requested to answer the following questions:
Management Committee. The report made few suggestions including categorisation of identified

em
risks as per COSO Framework and ERM implementation, as covered in ISO 31000.

em l a s
l as Multiple Choice Questions
a g
ag Choose the most appropriate answer from the given options.
(3.1) The report by external firm suggested various categories of risks under the COSO
framework. Which category of risks is not coming within the purview of COSO Framework?
(A) Inefficiency and non-effectiveness of Operations

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 15 of 32

Page 17

16 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022

(B) Absence of key financial controls causing material errors in financial statements
(C) Human factors as strikes and lock-outs by trade unions and negligence of employees
(D) Non-compliance with laws and regulations
(3.2) The company has identified challenges faced by it. Amongst them external risks arise from
events taking place outside the business functions. Which amongst the following is not
considered as external risk?
(A) Factors leading to increase in raw material prices and changes in consumer
preference.
(B) Technological factors, unforeseen changes in the techniques of production or
distribution resulting into technological obsolescence, etc.
(C) Natural calamities such as floods, cyclone etc.
(D) Change in Government resulting in changes in policies, impacting the sale of product
in a particular state.
(3.3) Which risk management technique involving a financial analytic tool shall be used by the
CFO to evaluate the incremental future cash flows and for computing the benefits from risk
management actions against the costs of the risk consequences are:
(A) Value at Risk.
(B) Capital Budgeting.
(C) Risk Score Cards.
(D) Risk Heat Maps.
(3.4) A report on the management of significant risks of the organisation and assurance on these
risks being managed within the acceptable limits as laid down by the Board of Directors is:
(A) Risk report issued by the Chief Risk Officer.
(B) Compliance report issued by the Compliance Officer.
(C) Internal audit report issued by the Management Auditor
(D) Statutory audit report issued by the Statutory Auditor.
(3.5) Risk management steps included in the report submitted by external firm covers the
following activities (1) Identify the Risk (2) Monitoring and review the Risk (3) Evaluation
the Risk (4) Analyse the Risk and (5) Treating the Risk. The sequence of step-by-step
process to deliver a simple and effective risk management process is:
(A) 1-4-3-5-2.
(B) 1-2-3-5-4.
(C) 1-3-2-4-5.
(D) 1-4-5-3-2. (2 x 5 = 10 Marks)

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 16 of 32

Page 18

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 17

Descriptive questions
(3.6) What are the aspects covered in the report on the Risk Management Framework issued by

m
c. o
the external firm, which are key for the successful implementation and effective functioning

o m
of Enterprise Risk Management, taking into account the current risks faced by XYZ Auto

c
(3.7) The CFO .and CRO had a discussion with respect to the risks relating to financial reporting e m
Limited? (5 Marks)

e min the report during a meeting between Finance team and Risk management team las
l a s
covered
(5 Marks) g
a
g
members. Elucidate the risks under discussions.
a outflows and incremental cash inflows during the first five years of the project. You are
(3.8) Compute the Net Cash flows, from the expansion activities, taking into account the cash

required to evaluate the expected Net Present values for the incremental inflows while
computed the net cash flows from the project. State the maximum cash flow required for
the expansion project, upon summarising the cash flows at the end of each year.
Consider the following PV factors for computing the present value of cash inflows:
PV Factors

m
co
Year 3 0.7722
Year 4 0.7084
.
Year 5 0.6497
s em
g la (5 Marks)
Answer a
3.1 (C)
3.2 (B)
3.3 (B)
3.4 (C)
3.5 (A)

m
c. o
3.6 Various aspects to be covered in the report on the Risk Management Framework issued

m
c. o
by the external firm, which are key for the successful implementation and effective

(1) Winning support and sponsorship from the Top management e
functioning of Enterprise Risk Management are as follows:
m
em s
a by providing
The Board of directors should sponsor the ERM function andlactivities
is a pre-cursor:

las g
a truly enterprise wide,
g
the right focus, resources and attention for ERM. ERM must be
a and understood and embraced by all personnel, and driven from the top through clear
and consistent communication and messaging from the company’s board to senior
management and to the organization as a whole.

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 17 of 32

Page 19

18 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022

The Board needs to put in place an effective ERM leader who is widely respected
across the organization and who has accepted responsibility for overall ERM
leadership, resources and support to accomplish the effort.
(2) Building ERM using small but solid steps: Organisation can start with a simple
process and build from there using incremental steps rather than trying to make a
quantum leap to fully implement a complete ERM process.
By doing so, they are able to:
• Identify and implement key practices to achieve immediate, tangible results.
• Provide an opportunity to change and further tailor ERM processes.
(3) Focus on a simple Risk model with Small Number of Top Risks: The ERM team
should identify small number of critical and strategic risks that can be managed, and
then evolve from this start.
Focusing initially on a smaller, manageable number of key risks would also be
beneficial in developing related processes such as monitoring and reporting for those
specific risks. This focused approach also keeps the developing ERM processes
simple and lends itself to subsequent incremental steps to expand the risk universe
and ERM processes.
(4) Leverage Existing Resources: Organizations often discover that they can rely on
their existing staffs, with the knowledge and capabilities relating to risks and risk
management that can be effectively used to start the ERM process. For example,
some organizations have used their Chief Audit Executive or their Chief Financial
Officer as the catalyst to begin an ERM initiative. In other instances, organizations
have appointed a management committee, sometimes headed by their Chief Finance
Officer (CFO), to bring together a wide array of personnel from across the entity that
collectively have sufficient knowledge of the organization’s core business model and
related risks and risk management practices to get ERM moving.
In addition, most organizations start their ERM effort without any specific enabling
technology or automated tools other than basic spreadsheets and word-processing
capabilities.
(5) Build on Existing Risk Management Activities: Existing functions such as internal
audit, compliance, ethics and other support function could be leveraged to build on
the ERM blocks and activities.
(6) Embed ERM into the Business Fabric of the Organization: ERM is a management
process, ultimately owned by the board of directors and involves people at every level
of the organization.
The comprehensive nature of the ERM process and its pervasiveness across the
organization and its people provides the basis for its effectiveness.

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 18 of 32

Page 20

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 19

ERM cannot be viewed or implemented as a stand-alone staff function or unit outside
of the organization’s core business processes. In some companies and industries,

m
such as large banks, it is common to see a dedicated enterprise risk management

m c. o
unit to support the overall ERM effort including establishing ERM policies and

co m
practices for their business units.

m . s e
e la
(7) Provide On-going ERM Updates and Continuing Education for Directors and

s g
Senior Management: ERM practices, processes and information continue to evolve.

l a a
ag
Thus, it is important for directors and senior executives to ensure that they are
receiving appropriate updates, new releases and continuing education on ERM,
including information about regulatory requirements and best practices.
This information provides the opportunity for directors and senior management to
update their risk management processes as they become aware of new or developing
practices. This ongoing improvement process is particularly important with the
increased focus on ERM by regulators, rating agencies, and the capital market
authorities.
3.7 The various risks relating to financial reporting that can be covered in the report during a

m
meeting between Finance team and Risk management team members are as under:

. co
(a) Changes in operating environment: Changes in the regulatory or operating

em
environment can result in changes in competitive pressures and significantly different
risks.

l a s
a g
(b) New personnel: New personnel may have a different focus on or understanding of
internal control.
(c) New or revamped information system: Significant and rapid changes in information
systems can change the risk relating to internal control.
(d) Rapid growth: Significant and rapid expansion of operations can strain controls and
increase the risk of a breakdown in controls.
(e) New technology: Incorporating new technologies into production processes or
information systems may change the risk associated with internal control.

m
c. o
(f) New business models, products, or activities: Entering into business areas or

m
c. o
transactions with which an entity has little experience may introduce new risks

emreductions and
associated with internal control.

em s
la the risk associated
(g) Corporate restructurings: Restructurings may be accompanied by staff

las a g
changes in supervision and segregation of duties that may change

g
with internal control.
a (h) Expanded foreign operations: The expansion or acquisition of foreign operations
carries new and often unique risks that may affect internal control, for example,
additional or changed risks from foreign currency transactions.

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 19 of 32

Page 21

20 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022

(i) New accounting pronouncements: Adoption of new accounting principles or changing
accounting principles may affect risks in preparing financial statements.
Based on the above the CRO and CFO must have deliberated following aspects of related
to risk.
(a) Financial risk relating to exports; Currency Risk; Customer Credit Risks; Country Risk
etc.
(b) New technology adoption in the production process cost implications and payback.
(c) Imports of Chips from new vendors from different geographies and additional costs.
(d) Financial risks mitigation procedures.
3.8 The net cash flows from the expansion project:
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Total
150.00 80.00 20.00 230.00
Cash inflows:
Year 3 Year 4 Year 5
Cash Prob. Cash Prob. Cash Prob.
flows flows flows
` Crs. ` Crs. ` Crs.
60.00 0.50 30.00 75.00 0.40 30.00 105.00 0.55 57.75
70.00 0.30 21.00 85.00 0.25 21.25 120.00 0.25 30.00
80.00 0.15 12.00 95.00 0.20 19.00 130.00 0.15 19.50
90.00 0.05 4.50 105.00 0.15 15.75 145.00 0.05 7.25
Total 67.50 86.00 114.50
PV 0.7722 0.7084 0.6497
Factor
PV 52.12 60.92 74.39
PV of total Cash inflows = ` 187.43 Crs.
Maximum actual funding requirement
Outflows Inflows Net Flows Cumulative cash flow
(` Crs) (` Crs) (` Crs) (` Crs)
Year 1 150.00 ------ (150.00) (150.00)
Year 2 80.00 ------ (80.00) (230.00)
Year 3 20.00 52.12 32.12 (197.88)

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 20 of 32

Page 22

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 21

Year 4 ------- 60.92 60.92 (136.95)
Year 5 ------- 74.39 74.39 (62.56)

m
c. o
Total 250.00 187.44 (62.56)

m
.co e m
The maximum funding requirement would ` 230 crores at the end of second year, since

m s
the cash inflows started to flow from the third year, which is higher than third year cash out

s e g la
flows.

l a
g OF THE CASE
CASE STUDY 4
a
aFACTS
An Indian IT Company (hereinafter referred as 'the Company') is engaged in providing software
products and solutions to its clients. The Company specialises in digital transformation, under
different platforms, The solutions include Artificial Intelligence, Machine Leaming, Robotic
Process Automation, Chatbots, Block Chain and Cyber Security intelligence.
The software company also engages in training the employees of its clients, in the journey of
digital transformation. The approach adopted by the Company is an unique business model

m
co
which combines the engineering and industry experience to provide intelligent solutions

.
including (i) Consolidate various IT tools/software programs into a single platform, (ii) minimal

em
design changes in the front end, enabling the users to continue operating the systems in

l a s
seamless manner and (iii) In-built analytics to help the users in self-learning and exception

a g
reporting.
The Company provides software solutions to clients located in India and in foreign countries.
The Company deploys teams to various projects and provides both on-site & off-shore services
to its clients.
The Company is a listed company in India as well as in United States of America (USA) and is
required to comply with the listing agreements of both the countries. The company has a well-
established Financial Reporting and Risk Management Frameworks. The Company's operations
are exposed to large number of business and operating risks.

m
co
The Company is also having a subsidiary company in USA, from where software products are

m .
c. o m
procured from the local vendors and sold to various clients along with software solutions. The

se
subsidiary company, also sells its products to the Indian Holding Company. The arrangement

s em l a
for these sales of products is such that the changes in exchange rates are linked to the selling

la a g
price of the products, either upwards or downwards.

ag ISSUES IDENTIFED
The Risk Management team along with the business teams carries out Country Risk
Assessment and also evaluates risks associated with specific projects in each country. On a
quarterly basis, the Chief Risk Officer (CRO) makes a presentation to the Risk Management

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 21 of 32

Page 23

22 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022

Committee with regard to the process followed, tools adopted and the results of such country
risk assessments. The issues identified are:
(1) A project team of 25 members was deputed by the Company for providing on-site solutions
to one of its client in USA. The team was on deputation for two years. Salaries and other
related expenses for providing on-site solutions were paid in US Dollars by the Company.
After a period of one year, couple of team members left the Company and taken
employment in other Company for better career prospects in Canada. The Company was
not ready to accept their resignations and these employees had challenges for getting
relieved. After multiple rounds of discussions, the Company finally relieved them, after
making certain deductions, as per the employment terms, from their full and final
settlements.
These employees after getting relieved and joining the new Company have raised certain
issues relating to the work ethics & experiences of the Indian IT Company in public forum
and social media, which affected the morale of other team members who are continuing to
work at the project site.
(2) The Company also provides on-site software services to its clients in the Middle-East,
However, due to repeated terror attacks near the office of the Company and at residential
colonies where its staff resides, the Company has decided to exit from that country and
started providing off-shore services from India.
(3) Similarly, another team was working in an African country. The United States of America
& European Union, have suddenly, imposed financial sanctions against the African country
and restricted all financial transactions in US $. This would affect the collections of dues
of the Company from the clients located in the African country. However, the Company,
due to effective risk management practices, based on triggering events has sold the
receivables to another party located in Europe at a discount.
(4) The Company has exposure to currencies of different countries. 80% of the Company's
revenues are from clients situated outside India. The company takes forward & other
hedging instruments to manage the net currency risks.
Based on the facts given above, you are requested to answer the following questions:
Multiple Choice Questions
(4.1) Adverse publicity regarding an entity's practices will lead to a loss of revenue and leads to
litigation. The ex-employees view posted on social media about the Company's work ethics
is affecting the work culture of the existing employees. Any such event which is detrimental
to the business of the entity is considered as:
(A) Reputation risk.
(B) Strategic Risk
(C) Business Continuity risk.

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 22 of 32

Page 24

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 23

(D) Governance risk.
(4.2) Exiting the activities which are giving rise to Business Risk by way of either exiting the

m
c. o
service line or exiting the countries, or declining the expansion to a new geography or

o m
selling the current operations in a specific country, is the following type of risk response:

.c e m
s
(A) Reduce.

e m la
(C)s Share. g
(B) Avoid.

g a
l(D) Accept. a
a(4.3) The purpose of Risk Evaluation by the Company at the Board Level is not to:
(A) Identify the probabilities of failures and threats.
(B) Calculate the exposure of failures and threats.
(C) Identify the hiring requirements of the Company for specific projects.
(D) Make control recommendations keeping the cost benefit analysis in mind.

m
(4.4) If the company has receivables of USD 50,000 and payables of ` 40,000, which of the
following statement is not correct?
c o
. cash flow.
e m
(A) Their settlement will affect the company's

s
la to rupee, a cash gain occurs.
(B) It is not subject to transaction exposure.

g
(D) If the dollar depreciatesarelative to rupee, a cash loss occurs.
(C) If the dollar appreciates relative

(4.5) The Company sold its accounts receivable for one of its clients from the African country,
to a third party located in a European country at a discount, to hedge the country risk and
to facilitate timely recovery of over dues. This method of financing is considered as:
(A) Bill discounting.
(B) Packing credit.

o m
(C) Factoring.

m . c
c. o
(D) Cash credit. (2 x 5 = 10 Marks)

m
e covered with
m s
Descriptive questions
(4.6) Under the integrated reporting adopted by the Company, describe thea
s e g lto create value in the
matters

l a a
ag
respect to the Company's governance structure to support its ability
short, medium and Iong term. (5 Marks)
(4.7) Explain the procedures adopted by the business teams and risk management team of the
Company, for carrying out the Country risk assessment. Also list the tools available for
carrying out such assessment. (5 Marks)

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 23 of 32

Page 25

24 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022

(4.8) Explain briefly the various internal techniques adopted by the company to manage
exposure to the foreign currency dues, citing examples from the Case Study. (5 Marks)
Answer
4.1 (A)
4.2 (B)
4.3 (C)
4.4 (B)
4.5 (C)
4.6 The various matters to be covered with respect to the Company's governance structure to
support its ability to create value in the short, medium and long term are as follows:
❖ The organization’s leadership structure, including the skills and diversity (e.g.,
range of backgrounds, gender, competence and experience) of those charged with
governance and whether regulatory requirements influence the design of the
governance structure.
❖ Specific processes used to make strategic decisions and to establish and monitor
the culture of the organization, including its attitude to risk and mechanisms for
addressing integrity and ethical issues
❖ Particular actions those charged with governance have taken to influence and
monitor the strategic direction of the organization and its approach to risk
management
❖ How the organization’s culture, ethics and values are reflected in its use of and
effects on the capitals, including its relationships with key stakeholders
❖ Whether the organization is implementing governance practices that exceed legal
requirements
❖ The responsibility those charged with governance take for promoting and enabling
innovation
❖ How remuneration and incentives are linked to value creation in the short,
medium and long term, including how they are linked to the organization’s use of and
effects on the capitals.
4.7 The country risk is a major issue of concern in overall management of business. Broadly
speaking the country risk management process involves the following steps:
(i) Identification of Risk: First and foremost, step in country risk management is
identification of risk. The various quantitative and qualitative techniques can be used
to identify the risks.

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 24 of 32

Page 26

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 25

(ii) Analysis of Risk: Once the risk is identified the next step is analyse the same from
various angles.

m
c. o
(iii) Evaluation of Risk Management Techniques: Evaluation of various techniques to

m
co
manage the risk is carried out.

. e m
s
(iv) Selection of suitable techniques: Once various techniques have been evaluated next

em
steps comes of selection of most suitable technique to manage the risk.
la
a s g
(vi) Control: Once the selected techniques are implemented they need to be reviewed ona
l
(v) Implementation of Techniques: The techniques to manage the risk are implemented.

ag periodic and if required they are revised.
The tools include Qualitative tools and Quantitative tools:
Qualitative Tools include Numeral Coding; Colour Coding; Combination of Numeral and
Colour coding.
This is one of the simplest techniques for country risk assessment to rank the countries.
The methods employed are:

m
(i) Numeral Coding: In this method, after considering various factors, a number is

c. o
assigned to a country. While the highest number indicates lesser risk, the lowest

erisk,mGreen
number indicates higher risk.

a s
(ii) Colour Coding: Different colours can be used to indicate the level of country risk.

(iii) Combination of Numeral g
l
While Red Color indicates higher Colour indicates a risk free zone.

aand Colour: A combination of colour and numeral is also
used to indicate relative level of country risk.
In addition to above, Grade Based Rating and Event Driven are also methods of country
risk assessment. For example, the two countries engaged in war, may be considered as
event driven risk.
Quantitative Tools are primarily related to economic measures such as GDP, Forex rates
and services, FDI etc. Other numbers include Growth in Industrial Production, Population
Growth, etc. Some of the indices that can be used for Country Risk Analysis are following:

m
m c. o
1. Corruption Perception Index: Higher the number indicates the country is highly

c. o emcivil liberties,
corrupt.

em la s
2. Democracy Index: The index is based on Electoral process pluralism,

s g
functioning of Government; Political participation and culture.

gla a
3. Gini Coefficient: It is one of the most popular index to gauge the rich-n-poor income

a 4.
countries.
Human Development Index: Published by UN rates, the countries on the basis of
Education level; Literacy Rate; Income; Life Expectancy and Standard of Living
The other indices include Global Peace Index and freedom in the world.

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 25 of 32

Page 27

26 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022

4.8 Internal techniques explicitly do not involve transaction costs and can be used to offset the
exposure completely or partially. These techniques can be further classified as follows:
(i) Invoicing in Domestic Currency: Sellers usually wish to sell in their own currency
or the currency in which they incur cost. This avoids foreign exchange exposure but
buyers' preferences may be for other currencies. Many markets, such as oil or
aluminum, in effect require that sales be made in the same currency as that quoted
by major competitors, which may not be the seller's own currency.
(ii) Leading and Lagging: Leading and Lagging refer to adjustments at the time of
payments in foreign currencies. Leading is the payment before due date while lagging
is delaying payment post the due date. These techniques are aimed at taking
advantage of expected devaluation and/or revaluation of relevant currencies. Lead
and lag payments are of special importance in the event that forward contracts remain
inconclusive.
(iii) Netting: Netting involves associated companies, which trade with each other. The
technique is simple. Group companies merely settle inter affiliate indebted ness for
the net amount owing. Gross intra-group trade, receivables and payables are netted
out.
Netting basically reduces the number of intercompany payments and receipts which
pass over the foreign exchanges. Fairly straightforward to operate, the main practical
problem in bilateral netting is usually the decision about which currency to use for
settlement.
Netting reduces banking costs and increases central control of inter company
settlements. The reduced number and amount of payments yield savings in terms of
buy/sell spreads in the spot and forward markets and reduced bank charges.
(iv) Matching: Matching is a mechanism whereby a company matches its foreign
currency inflows with its foreign currency outflows in respect of amount and
approximate timing. Receipts in a particular currency are used to make payments in
that currency thereby reducing the need for a group of companies to go through the
foreign exchange markets to the unmatched portion of foreign currency cash flows.
(v) Price Variation: Price variation involves increasing selling prices to counter the
adverse effects of exchange rate change. This tactic raises the question as to why
the company has not already raised prices if it is able to do so. In some countries,
price increases are the only legally available tactic of exposure management.
(vi) Asset and Liability Management: This technique can be used to manage balance
sheet, income statement or cash flow exposures. Concentration on cash flow
exposure makes economic sense but emphasis on pure translation exposure is
misplaced. Hence our focus here is on asset liability management as a cash flow
exposure management technique.

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 26 of 32

Page 28

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 27

CASE STUDY 5
FACTS OF THE CASE

m
m c. o
Robin is the managing director of Style Limited which was incorporated by his father twenty

co m
years back. The Company is in garment retail business and has a store in Pune. The store did

m .
not show expected growth in the initial years. However, when Robin took over as Managing
s e
s e g la
Director, the Company has shown consistent profit during the past ten years. Robin believes

l a
that his store is one of the best managed in the city and he is considering now opening several
g REQUIREMENTS a
aFUNDING
new stores.

When Robin's father started the store, most of the equity was financed by him and the remaining
financing was arranged from personal loans from friends and family members. In order to open
new stores Robin needs a bank loan. The bank will examine financial statements. Robin has
asked you to analyse his financials.
For this purpose he has also gathered relevant information of a close competitor who is in the

m
same business for the last twenty five years. Although Robin has tabulated some information

c o
Style.Ltd.'s Store
as given below, he needs your support in calculating other missing figures.
Particulars
m 2,000 lakhs
eINR
Competitor
Revenue
la s INR 2,500 lakhs

ag
Net Income INR 60 lakhs -----
Return on Equity (ROE) 22% -----
Net Profit Margin 3% 6%
Asset Turnover 2 2
Equity multiplier -------- 2
Debt Equity Ratio 2 -------
In addition to the above, the other key issue with which Robin is confronted with is determining

o m
appropriate level of current asset. He wants your input on the key factors that need to be

m .c
c. o Recently
considered for this purpose which he agreed to do so in the next meeting.
one of his friends has advised Robin to revise credit payment period m
m s econcerned about
and receivable

s e a
the asset-liability mismatch. In the next meeting he wants your inputsl on the asset-liability
period in a manner that would increase value of Style Limited but Robin is also
g
l a a
ag
mismatch.
MANAGEMENT ISSUES
As the level of operations is expected to significantly grow in the coming years, Robin has
planned to have a robust risk management systems and procedures. Currently it is being done

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 27 of 32

Page 29

28 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022

in silos and also he is worried about the risk culture. There is no risk strategy in writing and also
risk appetite statement has not been prepared and hence decisions are made without
understanding the risk. The internal auditors have also pointed out number of irregularities with
respect to dealing with the suppliers, customer management, inventory management, hiring of
staff and response management. Currently, reward and consequences are not aligned and
hence there is a tendency amongst employees to be ignorant about risk. Reinforcing risk culture
is the top most agenda at this moment. Robin has approached you to take suggestions
highlighting ways to reinforce risk culture in Style Limited.
EXPLORING OVERSEAS MARKETS
Robin has extensive experience of Moscow & Russia markets and therefore, exploring the
possibilities of opening one store in Moscow. He sees a huge opportunity there especially after
recent conflict with Ukraine as most of the international brands have closed their operations.
However, this decision would depend upon the analysis of related risks in opening a stor e in
Moscow. Robin is looking your inputs on this account and also wants to know how Delphi
technique can be used for political risk analysis purpose.
ACQUISITION PROPOSAL
Robin is also evaluating an opportunity to acquire a company named Start Ltd. which is in
garment manufacturing. He has hired a registered valuer, Mr. Samal, to carry out valuation of
equity shares of Start Ltd. The value per equity share of Start Ltd. as estimated by Mr. Samal is
INR 1250. Before committing for the acquisition of Start Ltd. Robin wants to fully grasp the risk
appetite and risk aversion. He also wants your help in estimating risk of bankruptcy of Start Ltd.
He has gathered the following information for this purpose.
Equity INR Goodwill INR
1000 (Face value: INR 10 each) 10,000 20,000
Retained Earnings (RE) 86,750 Net Property Plant and 2,20,000
Deferred Tax Liability 15,250 Equipment (PPE)
Long-Term Debt 1,80,000 Current Assets 1,60,000
Total Current Liabilities (CL) 1,20,000 Other Assets 12,000
Total 4,12,000 Total 4,12,000
Last reported EBIT is INR 1,10,000 and Revenue is INR 9,00,000.
Based on the facts given above, you are requested to answer the following questions:
Multiple Choice Questions
(5.1) Which one of the following would be considered by you while deciding the appropriate level
of current assets of Style Ltd.?
(A) A trade-off between equity and debt.

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 28 of 32

Page 30

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 29

(B) A trade-off between short-term loan and long-term borrowing.
(C) A trade-off between profitability and risk.

m
c. o
(D) A trade-off between current assets and total asset.

m
.co m
(5.2) Robin wants to ensure that policy related to working capital management should not

m
expose Style Ltd to the risk of insolvency. In your opinions which of the following asset -
s e
s e g la
liability mix would lead to the greatest risk of insolvency?

l a a
ag (B)
(A) Lowering current liabilities and increasing current assets.
Increasing both current assets and current liabilities.
(C) Exchanging short-term debt with equity.
(D) Increasing current liabilities, decreasing current assets and reducing long-term debt.
(5.3) A junior in your office has prepared a draft for your reference highlighting imp ortant points
about risk appetite and risk aversion which he believes would be useful while preparing
final notes for Robin. Which one of the following statement prepared by your junior is not
correct?

m
c. o
(A) Risk appetite changes over time as it is typically subject to cyclical fluctuations.
(B) Risk aversion is relatively time-invariable degree of· defensive positioning in terms of

s eriskmaversion is equal to one.
investment.

la attitude to all types of financial risk whereas can
(C) The sum total of risk appetite and
(D) Risk aversion reflects the g
a volatility.
underlying
be subject to sharp short-term
(5.4) Which of the following combination of major risks that you would like to cover in your
analysis which would help Robin in making decision about opening a store in Moscow?
(A) Financial, Regulatory and Political.
(B) Political, Financial and Accounting.
(C) Management, Cyber and Information.

m
co
(D) Management, Ethical and Political.

m .
c. o m
(5.5) Robin has asked you to use the Delphi technique for political risk analysis for evaluation

se
of decision regarding opening a store in Moscow. In your opinion which one of the following

em la
is correct with respect to use of Delphi technique for political analysis?

las (A) Visiting Moscow and making micro analysis.
a g
ag (B) Using services of an expert from Moscow.
(C) Gaining the response of a panel of geographically dispersed independent experts.
(D) Delphi technique is a quantitative technique of risk analysis. (2 x 5 = 10 Marks)

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 29 of 32

Page 31

30 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022

Descriptive Questions
(5.6) Using the data tabulated by Robin you are required to calculate the missing figures. Show
your working. (5 Marks)
(5.7) Based on the data given about Start Ltd., what would be your prediction about the
bankruptcy in a short-term? (5 Marks)
(5.8) As desired by Robin what would be your suggestions for reinforcing risk culture in Style
Ltd. Robin also wants you to prepare a note on the role of the board and senior
management in promoting sound risk culture. (5 Marks)
Answer
5.1 (C)
5.2 (D)
5.3 (C)
5.4 (A)
5.5 (C)
5.6 Style Ltd.’s Store
(1) Equity Multiplier = 1 + Debt Equity Ratio = 3
Alternatively, it can also be computed as follows:
ROE = Asset Turnover x Equity Multiplier x Net Profit Margin
22% = 2 x Equity Multiplier x 3%
Equity Multiplier = 11/3
Competitor
(1) Net Income = 6% x INR 2,500 lakhs = INR 150 lakhs
(2) ROE = Asset Turnover x Equity Multiplier x Net Profit Margin
= 2 x 2 x 6% = 24%
(3) Debt Equity Ratio = 625/625 = 1
Equity = 150/24% = 625
Assets = 2500/ 2 = 1250
Debt = 1250 – 625 = 625
5.7 Prediction about the bankruptcy in a short-time can be predicted using Altman Z score as
follows:
Z = 1.2 x X1 + 1.4 x X2 + 3.3 x X3 + 0.6 x X4 + 1.0 x X5

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 30 of 32

Page 32

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 31

X1 = working capital / total assets. Measures liquid assets in relation to the size of the
company.

m
c. o
X2 = retained earnings / total assets. Measures profitability that reflects the company's age

m
co m
and earning power.

m . s e
la
X3 = earnings before interest and taxes / total assets. Measures operating efficiency apart

s e
from tax and leveraging factors. It recognizes operating earnings as being important
g
l a a
ag X = market
to long-term viability.
4 value of equity / book value of total liabilities. Adds market dimension that can
show up security price fluctuation as a possible red flag.
X5 = sales / total assets. Standard measure for total asset turnover (varies greatly from
industry to industry).
40000 86750 110000 1250000 900000
Z = 1.2 x + 1.4 x +3.3 x +0.6 x +1.0 x
412000 412000 412000 315250 412000

m
Z = 0.117 + 0.295 + 0.881 + 2.379 + 2.184
Z = 5.856
c o
. be concluded that there is low risk of going
e m
s
Since Z score exceeds 4.48. It can therefore

lado not consider the Deferred Tax Liability as a part of
bankrupt in short run.

a g
Alternative Solution - If students
Total Liabilities.
40000 86750 110000 1250000 900000
Z = 1.2 x + 1.4 x +3.3 x +0.6 x +1.0 x
412000 412000 412000 300000 412000
Z = 0.117 + 0.295 + 0.881 + 2.50 + 2.184
Z = 5.977

m
Since Z score exceeds 4.48. It can therefore be concluded that there is low risk of going

m .co
bankrupt in short run.

c. o 5.8 Step I – Develop risk strategy
se
m
em l a characteristics
s g
Step II – Prepare Risk Appetite Statement

gla Step III – Adopt a rigorous recruiting process so that desired
a
risk culture

a into hiring requirements
Step IV – Use reward and consequences to demonstrate that risk management is
everyone’s responsibility covering all critical areas of operations

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 31 of 32

Page 33

32 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022

Step V – Establish mechanisms to encourage escalation, rapid response, investigation,
and attention by all employees and ensure that decisions are made within the risk strategy
and risk appetite framework.
Board and senior management role in promoting sound culture:
1. Lead role in establishing the tone at the top by promoting risk awareness within a
sound risk culture. It should be communicated that excessing risk taking is not
supported and everyone has to work within the established risk appetite and limits.
2. The responsibility of implementation and reinforcement of sound risk culture and
provide reward to employees who work within the risk appetite and limits and at the
same time penalize those whose behavior is inappropriate.
3. Ensure that all material risks exceeding appetite are recognized, escalated and
addressed in a timely manner.

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 32 of 32

Document Details

Board / OrgICAI
ExamICAI CA
TypeSolution
Pages33
Languageenglish
Updated23 Oct 2026

More from ICAI

ICAI CA