Page 1
FOR CA FINAL EXAM PREPARATION
CA Final 2022
Suggested Answers ·
Paper 6B Financial
Services and Capital
Markets (Old Scheme)
EXAM YEAR TYPE
CA Final 2022 Suggested Answers
SUBJECT DATE
Paper 6B Financial Services and Capital Markets (Old Scheme) November 2022
Notes · Sample Papers · Previous Year Papers · Mock Tests
Page 2
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
DISCLAIMER
This Suggested Answer hosted on the website do not constitute the basis for evaluation of the
m
m c. o
co
student’s answers in the examination. The answers are prepared by the Faculty of the Board of
. e m
em
Studies with a view to assist the students in their education. Alternate Answers have been
la s
l a s a g
aerrorg or omission is noticed, the same may be brought to the attention of the Director of Board
incorporated, wherever necessary. While due care is taken in preparation of the answers, if any
of Studies. The Council of the Institute is not in anyway responsible for the correctness or
otherwise of the answers published herein.
Further, in the Elective Papers which are Case Study based, the solutions have been worked
o m
out on the basis of certain assumptions/views derived from the facts given in the question or
c
. to work out the solution to the case studies
m
e made or views taken.
language used in the question. It may be possible
la s
g
in a different manner based on the assumptions
a
m
m .co
c. o se
m
s em g la
gla a
a
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 1 of 29
Page 3
2 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
PAPER 6B: FINANCIAL SERVICES AND CAPITAL MARKETS - ELECTIVE PAPER
The Question Paper comprises five case study questions. The candidates are required to
answer any four case study questions out of five.
While answering the multiple choice question, candidates are required to indicate the alphabet
of their choice in capital letters.
In case, any candidate answers extra question(s)/ sub-question(s) over and above the
required number, then only the requisite number of questions first answered in the answer
book shall be valued and subsequent extra question (s) answered shall be ignored.
CASE STUDY: 1
Deep inside the dense forests of the Western Ghats, there is a small hill station which is rich in
natural beauty, full of clean water streams and some breath-taking valley views. It is believed
that the place was the abode of Monkey King Vali, and since it looks like a beautiful garden
hanging in mid-air, the place has been nick-named as "The Hanging Gardens of Vali".
The tourism department of one of India's western states believes that the place can be
developed as an eco-tourism resort, and hence has invited proposals from various
organisations. The mandate is to build a luxury resort with all modern day facilities along with a
road to the hill station without tampering with the nature and environment of the place. On the
road to be built, only horses and battery operated cars shall ply from a nearby plain area to the
resort built at the top of the hill.
The developer will bear all the costs of construction of the resort as well as the road. It is
estimated that the entire project will cost INR 1,200 crores, including the cost of Electric Vehicles
(EVS), and it will take 5 years to complete the project. The State Government will grant the land
for the project on an "as is where is" basis at zero cost and would ensure all necessary approvals
are in place, but it will not spend any money on the project. The developer will be given exclusive
rights to run the battery operated cars and the luxury resort for a period of 15 years, so as to
recover investment and also earn a decent return on its investment. The project qualifies for a
tax holiday scheme of the Central Government, wherein no taxes are payable for the first 15
years after completion of the project. Finally, at the end of the period of 15 years, the developer
can either retain the right to run the resort, or hand it over to the State Government for INR
1,000 crores.
Ananth Infrastructure Limited (AIL) is one of the largest and most experienced organiz ations
with expertise in execution of such projects. AIL has tangible net assets of at least INR 50 crores
in the last five years with not more than 50% of the same held in monetary assets. It also has
an average operating profits of INR 50 crores in the last four years and net worth of at least
INR 10 crores in the last five years.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 2 of 29
Page 4
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6B: FINANCIAL SERVICES & CAPITAL MARKETS 3
AIL estimates that the cash outflows in relation to the project, including working capital
requirements but excluding interest during execution of the project, will be as under :
m
c. o
Year 1 2 3 4 5
o m m
c
Infrastructure Cost (INR crores) 200 250 400 200 150
. e
s em AIL will pump in equity of INR 300 crores into AERL, the balance will be raised glas
AIL plans to create a 100% Subsidiary called Ananth Exotic Resorts Ltd (AERL) for execution
laform oftoa loan. AERL appoints Shailesh Capital, an Investment Banker, as their Projecta
of this project.
g
acharges annual fee of 1% fee on the amount raised, which is also included in the infrastructure
in the
Consultants, do a loan syndication by tapping various potential lenders. Shailesh Capital
costs stated above. The loan amount has been syndicated by Shailesh Capital on the following
terms:
i. Interest at 14% p.a. on outstanding balance which will be added to the principal till
completion of the project.
ii. Repayment can be done either by way of bullet payment of all dues at the end of Year 6,
m
or converting into secured term loan at a 12% pa. rate of interest, the principal being
co
repayable in 15 equal instalments, starting at the end of Year 6.
.
em
It is further estimated that the Net Cash Revenue, after deducting operating and maintenance
a s
costs and related expenditure, will be as under:
g l
a 200
Year 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
INR crores 120 185 215 230 250 260 280
Year 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
INR crores 300 320 340 375 400 450 500
At the end of Year 6, when the project starts yielding revenues, Shyam Capital suggests AERL
to repay the entire loan by raising funds from the general public by issuing 10 -year bonds at
10% per annum interest payable annually, repayment being done in one shot at the end of 10
m
co
years, with an escrow account created to ensure that cash flows are first used to pay interest
m .
c. o
and repay the principal. However, AIL will have to get the Credit Rating of the bonds done, which
m
se
Shyam Capital is to organize. AERL is also considering securitization as a solution to manage
em a
its finances.
s g l
la 1.1 As per the information given in the case study, which one ofathe following is the most
Multiple Choice Questions:
ag appropriate categorization of alternative sources of funding in increasing order of risk
(lowest risk first).
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s ag
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 3 of 29
Page 5
4 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
Least Risky Medium Risky Most Risky
A Project Finance Term Loan Bonds
B Term Loan Bonds Project Finance
C Bonds Project Finance Term Loan
D Bonds Term Loan Project Finance
(2 Marks)
1.2 Assuming all funding for the year is raised on day-1 of the year, what would be the amount
of interest payable by AERL by the end of Year 6?
(A) INR 630.26 crores
(B) INR 377.66 crores
(C) INR 556.63 crores
(D) INR 900.45 crores (2 Marks)
1.3 If Debt/Equity ratio is defined as amount of long-term debt over Shareholders' Funds, what
would be the Debt/ Equity ratio of AERL at the end of Year 5?
(A) 4
(B) 4.26
(C) 4.85
(D) Insufficient information to calculate (2 Marks)
1.4 Which of the following activities is taken up by an Investment Banker?
(A) Underwriting
(B) Syndication
(C) Financial Structuring
(D) All the above activities (2 Marks)
1.5 For AERL, what would be the most suitable source of funding the project?
(A) Go for an IPO for INR 1200 crores
(B) Approach an Infrastructure Investment Trust (InVIT) to fund the project to the extent
of INR 900 crores, with INR 300 crores coming in the form of equity from AIL
(C) Issue Convertible Bonds of INR 1200 crores
(D) Projected Cash Flows do not justify above mentioned sources of funding [i.e. (A), (B),
(C)] (2 Marks)
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 4 of 29
Page 6
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6B: FINANCIAL SERVICES & CAPITAL MARKETS 5
1.6 Should the ABRL go for a 12% term loan repayment over 15 years or issue 10year bonds
at 10%? Evaluate two options of repaying the debt based on the incremental cash flows.
m
c. o
(6 Marks)
m
co m
1.7 Given the projected Cash flows of the Company and other information available with you,
.
in your opinion, would AERL be able to get the highest credit rating for its Bonds? Why or
m s e
s e la
why not? (4 Marks)
l a a g
a1.9g Based on SEBI (ICDR) Regulations 2018, is it possible for AERL or ALL to go for a public
1.8 Suppose you are hired by AERL to explore the case for Securitization. Can AERL use
Securitization as a solution to managing its finances? (3 Marks)
issue to raise at least a part of INR 300 crores that it plans to infuse as equity? Why or
Why Not? (2 Marks)
ANSWER TO CASE STUDY: 1
1.1 (D)
1.2 (C)
m
co
1.3 (B)
.
em
1.4 (D)
1.5 (D)
l a s
g
aInterest
1.6 Term Loan at 12% p.a., repayable in 15 equal instalments
Year O/S Debt Repayment of Principal Total Repayment
6 1455.65 174.68 97.04 271.72
7 1358.61 163.03 97.04 260.08
8 1261.56 151.39 97.04 248.43
9 1164.52 139.74 97.04 236.79
10 1067.48 128.10 97.04 225.14
11 970.43 116.45 97.04
o
213.50
m
m .c
c. o m190.20
12 873.39 104.81 97.04 201.85
e
s 178.56
em
13 776.35 93.16 97.04
s
14 679.30 81.52 97.04
g la
gla 15 582.26 69.87 97.04
a 166.91
a 16
17
485.22
388.17
58.23
46.58
97.04
97.04
155.27
143.62
18 291.13 34.94 97.04 131.98
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 5 of 29
Page 7
6 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
19 194.09 23.29 97.04 120.33
20 97.04 11.65 97.04 108.69
Year O/S Debt Interest Principal Repayment Total Payment
7 1455.65 145.56 145.56
8 1455.65 145.56 145.56
9 1455.65 145.56 145.56
10 1455.65 145.56 145.56
11 1455.65 145.56 145.56
12 1455.65 145.56 145.56
13 1455.65 145.56 145.56
14 1455.65 145.56 145.56
15 1455.65 145.56 145.56
16 1455.65 145.56 1455.65 1601.21
Incremental Cash Flow
Year Term Loan Bonds Net CF Difference
6 271.72 0 -271.72
7 260.08 145.56 -114.52
8 248.43 145.56 -102.87
9 236.79 145.56 -91.22
10 225.14 145.56 -79.58
11 213.50 145.56 -67.94
12 201.85 145.56 -56.29
13 190.20 145.56 -44.64
14 178.56 145.56 -33.00
15 166.91 145.56 -21.35
16 155.27 1601.21 1445.94
17 143.62 -143.62
18 131.98 -131.98
19 120.33 -120.33
20 108.69 -108.69
Term Loan is better.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 6 of 29
Page 8
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6B: FINANCIAL SERVICES & CAPITAL MARKETS 7
1.7 The highest rating of AAA+ indicates strong capacity to pay interest and repay the principal,
based on strong financial position of the organization.
m
c. o
The bonds are structured in such a way that interest payment obligations appear to be
m
co
modest in comparison with Net Cash Revenues. There is enough margin of safety even in
. e m
the first year. However, repayment of Principal in one shot at the end of 10 th year seems
em
risky. AERL needs to create a Sinking Fund and set aside money from its Net Cash
la s
s g
Revenues every year to be able to repay the principal.
l a a
a1.8g Securitization is the pooling of assets to repackage them into interest-bearing securities.
Thus, AERL will not be able to get Highest Credit Rating of AAA+ or equivalent from a
Credit Rating Agency.
The investors that purchase the repackaged securities receive the principal and interest
payments of the original assets.
The securitization process begins when an issuer designs a marketable financial
instrument by merging or pooling various financial assets, such as multiple mortgages, into
one group. The issuer then sells this group of repackaged assets to i nvestors.
Securitization offers opportunities for investors and frees up capital for originators, both of
m
co
which promote liquidity in the marketplace.
.
em
So, one thing is clear from the meaning and process of securitization that the company
s
going for it must have mortgaged based assets or receivables to enable it to convert such
l a
assets into securities. But, as per the facts given in the present case study, AERL has been
a g
taking loans to finance its project. It has no such assets which it can securitize. So, it seems
that AERL may not be able to take the securitization route.
Alternatively
Securitization is used by companies which have clarity of vision in terms of cash flows. In
other words, the companies can reasonably estimate the amount of cash flows that can
get generated. For example, a bank that has given loans and has a schedule of E MI
repayments, an insurance company that has sold insurance policies on which premium is
payable at defined intervals, a utility company (electricity company) that can reasonably
estimate the amount of bill payments on a monthly basis, can go for securitization.
m
m .co
In securitization, all these future cash flows that are reasonably likely to be generated are
c. o m
sold to a Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV), which pays off a lump sum to the organization
em se
that is the receiver of such cash flows and purchases the future c ash flows. However, it
s la
funds the purchase by issuing securities, usually in smaller denominations, to many
la a g
investors. Thus, securities are created out of loans, which are otherwise unlisted or non -
ag
tradable.
AERL cannot opt for securitization in the first 5 years, as there are no revenues. AERL can
estimate the cash inflows likely to be generated from Year 6. However, there is no certainty
of these cash flows. Hence, it would be very difficult for AERL to use the process of
securitization.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 7 of 29
Page 9
8 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
1.9 As per Regulation 6 (1) of the SEBI (ICDR) Regulations, 2018, an issuer shall be eligible
to make an initial public offer only if:
(a) it has net tangible assets of at least three crore rupees, calculated on a restated and
consolidated basis, in each of the preceding three full years (of twelve months each),
of which not more than fifty per cent are held in monetary assets.
(b) it has an average operating profit of at least fifteen crore rupees, calculated on a
restated and consolidated basis, during the preceding three years (of twelve months
each), with operating profit in each of these preceding three years.
(c) it has a net worth of at least one crore rupees in each of the preceding three full years
(of twelve months each), calculated on a restated and consolidated basis.
In the present case study, AIL has satisfied all the above-mentioned conditions.
Therefore, it can tap the IPO route to raise capital for the project.
On the other hand, AERL is a newly formed company. It does not satisfy the above
requirements.
The case study mentions that AIL will invest the entire ` 300 crores of equity in AERL
by way of equity infusion. AERL will be able to go for an IPO as its promoter
organization, AIL, is meeting the requirements stipulated by SEBI (ICDR)
Regulations, 2018.
CASE STUDY: 2
(1) Samar Industries Limited (SIL) is a listed company engaged in the manufacturing of fancy
digital watches. It has five subsidiaries which includes a listed subsidiary. The marketing
manager, Ms. Tanmayi, has submitted a report to the top management of SIL that the youth
are looking for watches that have lots of features, other than just showing time. She feels
that the watches can be used to play games, track health parameters such as SPO2 levels,
number of steps walked by the user, heart rate, etc. In addition, watches can be
programmed to change the base appearance with the help of an App, which she believes
is a super cool idea. In other words, the watch can have a base that can be changed just
like a person can change the display picture of his/her Whatsapp Id. Having these features
will not only increase the sales volume, but will help SIL. play with prices, as different
combination of features can be priced differently. SIL will need to use a special computer
with software to build the above features into the digital watches. The procurement
manager, Mr. Abhinav informs the Management that the price of the special computer
including taxes, freight, insurance, works out to INR 10 lakhs. The finance manager, Mr.
Siddhanth, says that Neeraj Bank with which SIL has a banking relationship, can fund 80%
of the cost by way of a loan. The bank will waive off all other charges, except interest at
12% p.a. SIL can pay the balance in 7 instalments of INR 1,75,295 at the end of each year.
(2) Ms. Riya, who assists Mr. Siddhanth, suggests that Mr. Arun of Saahil Leasing and Finance
Ltd. had called, and offered to lease the computer. The lease rentals are payable as under:
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 8 of 29
Page 10
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6B: FINANCIAL SERVICES & CAPITAL MARKETS 9
Beginning of Year 1 4,00,000
Beginning of Year 2 3,00,000
m
m c. o
Beginning of Year 3 2,00,000
.co e m
Beginning of Year 4 1,50,000
e m
Beginning of Year 5 75,000
la s
l a s
SIL will have the right to buy the computer at the end of 5 thyear at INR 42,000. The lease
a g
ag
would be irrevocable and costs of maintenance of the computer will have to be borne by
SIL. The computer has a life of 8 years, and can be depreciated on a straight line basis.
The residual value at the end of 8 years is likely to be negligible.
(3) Ms. Tanmayi has also suggested to the Management that the new product should be made
available on credit to all its dealers. Ms. Tanmayi expects annual sales of these new
watches to be around INR 30 lakhs over the next 12 months. She feels that dealers should
be given credit period of 60 days to encourage them to stock and sell these new innovative
products. The finance manager, Mr. Ravindra, is not comfortable blocking so much of funds
in the receivables. He feels SIL must opt for factoring services to ease its working capital
m
co
position. XYZ Factors has made the following proposal in this respect.
(ii) Bad Debts: 1.5% of credit sales m
(i) Non-Recourse Factoring
.
s e
g l a
a be 1%
(iii) The factor will pay 80% of receivables
(iv) Factoring Commission will
(v) Administration costs towards collection of receivables: INR 2,000 per month.
(vi) Interest: 12% p.a.
(4) SIL has a listed subsidiary named Ketan Industries Ltd (KIL), Association for Promotion of
Indian Arts and Culture (APIAC) is an NGO which regularly conducts events. The events
include performances by various eminent artists on every 3 weekends and felicit ation of
cultural ambassadors by eminent personalities on the 4 weekend. In July 2022, APIAC
m
co
decided to felicitate Mr. Ram Acharya, who has been a great champion of Indian culture
m .
and traditions. Mr. Chaitanya, the President of APIAC approached Mr. Sridhar, the CEO of
c. o se
m
KIL, to honour Mr. Ram on behalf of APIAC, to which, Mr. Sridhar agreed. The event was
em la
planned on 24th July 2022. During the event, Mr. Chaitanya casually asked Mr. Sridhar if
s g
KIL has been able to recover from the setback it had received on account of Covid-19
la a
related lockdowns. Not wanting to create negative publicity for KIL, Mr. Sridhar said that
ag the Company is doing really well, turnover is up by more than 60% Year on Year, and they
are likely to announce a 1:1 bonus issue and a 100% dividend to shareholders along with
declaration of quarterly results, that are due to be declared on 12th August 2022. Although
it was a casual conversation and Mr. Sridhar forgot about it, Mr. Chaitanya purchased 1000
shares of KIL at INR 72 per share on 25th July 2022 through Mr. Deepak, a stock-broker,
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 9 of 29
Page 11
10 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
hoping to sell them after announcement of results on 12th August 2022. Mr. Deepak also
bought 500 shares on his own account on 25th July 2022. On 12th August 2022, KIL
announced quarterly results, which were very disappointing. Profits had dipped by 20%
even though. there was a spike in revenues. There was no announcement of either bonus
or special dividend. Shares of KIL fell to INR 57, resulting in a huge loss to both
Mr. Chaitanya and Mr. Deepak.
(5) Mr. Sridhar felt that the markets are over-reacting. The CFO of KIL, Mr. Shastri, suggests
that KIL can buy-back the shares to the extent of 2.5% of issued capital, either by way of
a tender offer, or through the stock market route, at a price not exceeding INR 6 5 per
share. Promoters are also interested in participating in the buy-back process.
(6) Based on the direction of the Board of SIL, the CFO of SIL has made investment in number
of liquid instruments. As the investment amount has gone up substantially, the CFO wants
to implement Value-at-Risk (VaR) concept for risk management and has sought your help
in the implementation VaR.
(7) SIL has a very prominent brand called "ARTSE" that is being used by number of group
companies. The Board of SIL has asked details of last three years royalty received by SIL
from the CFO. The next agenda in the Board is to consider allowing use of "ARTSE" by a
newly created subsidiary PQ.
Multiple Choice Questions:
2.1 Assuming SIL opts for buying the computer by taking a term loan, what would be the
amount of principal outstanding (rounded off to nearest thousand) at the beginning of 4th
year (after 3rd instalment of loan has been paid)?
(A) INR 6,32,000
(B) INR 5,32,000
(C) INR 4,21,000
(D) INR 8,76,000 (2 Marks)
2.2 Given that SIL can raise debt at 12% pa., which one of the following is correct with respect
to financial advantage of leasing?
(A) INR 2,77,360
(B) INR 5,559
(C) (-)5,559
(D) INR 1,67,000 (2 Marks)
2.3 The CFO of SIL has asked you to respond whether the royalty to be received by SIL from
PQ would be considered material. Which one of the following is correct in this respect?
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 10 of 29
Page 12
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6B: FINANCIAL SERVICES & CAPITAL MARKETS 11
(A) The transaction to be taken individually or taken together with previous transactions
during a financial year exceeds 5% of the consolidated turnover of SIL as per the last
m
audited financial.
m c. o
co
(B) The transaction to be taken individually or taken together with previous transactions
. e m
during a financial year exceeds 10% of the consolidated turnover of SIL as per the
em
last audited financial.
la s
l a s
(C) The transaction to be taken individually or taken together with previous transactions
a g
ag (D) The transaction to be taken individually or taken together with previous transactions
during a financial year exceeds 20% of the consolidated turnover of SIL as per the
last audited financial.
during a financial year exceeds 15% of the consolidated turnover of SIL as per the
last audited financial. (2 Marks)
2.4 Based on the data given in the case study, which one of the following is correc t regarding
the effective cost of leasing?
(A) 12%
o m
(B) 12.5%
(C) 11.5%
c
. information.
e m
sin implementing VaR. In this respect, which one of
(D) It cannot be calculated from the available (2 Marks)
g l
2.5 The CFO of SIL has sought your helpa
(A) Z-score
a
the following is not the component needed for computation of VaR?
(B) Time period
(C) Confidence level
(D) Loss in percentage or Amount (2 Marks)
2.6 Assuming 360 days in a year, evaluate the Factoring proposal given by XYZ for SIL?
m
(6 Marks)
m .co
c. o
2.7 As both Mr. Chaitanya and Mr. Deepak suffered losses by acting on 4 information provided
m
se
by Mr. Sridhar and hence there is no violation of insider trading regulations. Similarly, Mr.
em a
Sridhar believes that there is no violation of the insider trading on his part as information
s g l
shared was without any bad intention and aforementioned persons have not made any
gla a
profits. Do you agree with the positions taken by three individuals? Give reasoned answer.
a (4 Marks)
2.8 What is your view on the suggestion made by Mr. Shastri regarding the buyback of equity
shares of KIL, and which alternative, between open market and tender offer, is more
appropriate for KIL? (5 Marks)
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 11 of 29
Page 13
12 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
ANSWER TO CASE STUDY: 2
2.1 (B)
2.2 (C)
2.3 (B)
2.4 (B)
2.5 (A)
2.6 Credit Sales: ` 30 lakhs
Credit period: 2 months
Average Receivables = 30 x 2/12 = ` 5 lakhs
Factoring Commission = 1% x 5 lakhs = ` 5000
Amount paid as advance by factoring company = 80% of average receivables = 80% of
` 5,00,000 = ` 4 lakhs
Thus, factoring reserve = ` 1,00,000
Amount payable as advance by factor = average receivables – factoring reserve –
Commission = 4,00,000 – 5,000 = 3,95,000
Interest = 12 %
Thus, interest deductible = 3,95,000 x 12% = ` 7,900
Net amount paid by Factoring Company = ` 3,95,000 – ` 7,900 = ` 3,87,100
Annual Factoring Costs to SIL
Commission for 2 months 5,000
Annual Commission 30,000
Annual Interest Charges 47,400
Total 77,400
Annual Saving for SIL due to factoring
Administration Costs 24,000
Bad debts 1.5% of Credit Sales 45,000
Total 69,000
Net effective costs per year = ` 77,400 – ` 69,000 = ` 8,400
Net effective rate = 8.400/387100 = 2.19%
Factoring proposal is not tenable.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 12 of 29
Page 14
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6B: FINANCIAL SERVICES & CAPITAL MARKETS 13
2.7 Although Mr. Chaitanya and Mr. Deepak suffered losses by acting on information provided
by Mr. Sridhar, this case comes within the purview of “Insider Trading” as per the provisions
m
of SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015.
m c. o
co
Firstly, Mr. Sridhar is guilty of sharing/declaring sensitive, material, non-public information
. e m
with an outsider. It does not matter that the information was partially true, or that what was
em
stated did not actually happen the way it was shared. It also does not matter that Mr.
la s
s g
Sridhar did not intend to provide such material, non-public information with Mr. Chaitanya,
l a a
ag
or that there was no intention to profit from such events. Even if the act is out of
negligence/carelessness, without any intention to profit directly/indirectly, it is sti ll
considered as breach of provisions.
Mr. Chaitanya and Mr. Deepak acted solely with the intention of profiteering from insider
trading. The fact that they lost instead of making a profit does not absolve them of their
wrong deed.
However, the only way Mr. Sridhar can absolve himself from Insider Trading Regulations
is by stating that he has passed on a wrong information to Mr. Chaitanya and Mr. Deepak.
However, he will, then be liable for misrepresentation of facts.
m
co
Furthermore, Mr. Chaitanya and Mr. Deepak can save themselves by presenting their case
.
before the court that the information which were unpublished at the time of conveying by
em
Mr. Sridhar such as announcement of either bonus shares or special dividend were never
a s
actually published and that they have acted on a wrong information regarding the
l
2.8 Ketan Industries can buy backgthe shares either through a tender offer or through open
profitability of the company.
a
market purchases since the shares proposed to be bought back are only 2.5% of p aid-up
capital. (Open market route cannot be taken if proposed buy back is more than 15% of
paid-up capital).
Promoters of the company participated in buy back if such buy back is being done through
the open market purchases.
A company buying buy back shares from the open market need not file a letter of offer.
The buying will happen through the order matching mechanism. The company will need to
m
co
keep updating the exchange on the number of shares bought back, daily. The company
m .
c. o
can buy back the shares for a period of 6 months from the date of opening of buyback
m
se
offer. Thus, shares are bought only from those shareholders who offer their shares for buy
em l a
back. The shares are bought from different shareholders at different prices. Buy back
las g
through open market route can also happen by way of a reverse book building issue.
a and file a letter of offer
ag
When a company opts for a tender offer, it must decide on a price
with SEBI. Shares are bought proportionately from all the shareholders who offer their
shares for buy back (subject to a reservation of 15% for (“small investors”). The price at
which the shares are bought back is the same for all shareholders.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 13 of 29
Page 15
14 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
Given that Ketan Industries intends to buyback only 2.5% of the shares issued, and there
is not much of a difference between the current market price (` 57) and the maximum price
at which the company wishes to buy back (` 65), the company can opt for buyback through
open market operations.
Alternatively,
It is clearly given in the question that KIL can buy-back the shares to the extent of 2.5% of
the issued capital at a price not exceeding INR 65 per share. The words, “at a price not
exceeding INR 65 per share” indicate that the company cannot buy- back at a price more
than INR 65 per share. In the open market buy-back offer, usually volumes are not very
high. So, the company starts buying back the shares at the price available in the market.
For instance, if shares are available at INR 62, the company will buy-back shares at that
price and so on. So, this process usually continues for two-three months. So, from the
wording of the question, it seems that Open Market Offer is more appropriate for KIL.
CASE STUDY: 3
(i) Preksha Pravek Asset Management Company (PPAMC) is one of the top Asset
Management companies in India. As on July1, 2022, the AMC was managing assets
(Assets Under Management, or AUM) to the tune of INR 150,000 crores across various
schemes. It has 3 Equity Schemes, based on market capitalisation, namely Large Cap,
Mid Cap and Small Cap. Its flagship scheme is "Shining India Focussed 50 Fund", which
invests primarily in the top 100 companies in India by market capitalization and has AUM
of INR 75,000 crores, while there are two other equity oriented Funds, namely "Emerging
India Fund" focussed on Mid-Caps and "Little Gems Small Cap Fund", managing
approximately INR 50,000 crores and INR 25,000 crores respectively.
Over the last few months, PPAMC has seen a steady decline in the AUM across all 3 funds
on account of redemptions and a continuous fall in equity markets. The NAV of the 3 funds
as on October 1, 2021 and June 30, 2022, are provided below:
MF Scheme NAV NAV
(October 1, 2021) INR (June 30,2022) INR
Shining India Focussed 50 Fund 263.9243 229.6142
Emerging India Fund 56.6797 47.0454
Little Gems Small Cap Fund 81.6221 64.4822
The figures of some of the Indices for the given period are also tabulated below:
Index Value (October 1, 2021) Value (June 30,2022)
Nifty 50 17,532 15,780
Nifty Small-Cap 100 10,904 8,445
Nifty Mid-Cap 100 30,397 26,453
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 14 of 29
Page 16
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6B: FINANCIAL SERVICES & CAPITAL MARKETS 15
PPAMC charges 2% of the AUM as an Asset Management Fee and after accounting for
expenses, including commission to distributors at 1% of the AUM, it earns roughly 0.2% of
m
the average AUM. The net profit of PPAMC has declined by 12% quarter on quarter, falling
m c. o
from INR 360 crores in quarter ended March 31, 2022 to INR 315 crores by June 30,2022.
.co e m
(2) It has been observed by the management of PPAMC that investors are redeeming their
em
units and probably investing in the schemes of other AMCs who are offering Funds that
la s
a s g
are not invested in equity. This has prompted the Management to think of launching new
l a
ag The management of PPAMC is considering the launch of the following schemes:
funds, so that the AUM can be enhanced, which can lead to higher revenues and hence
higher profits.
Scheme 1: "PP Long Term Equity Fund"- this Fund would invest in Large Cap Funds. The
main reason for launching this fund is that PPAMC has expertise and a very good track
record in equity. Investors consider Large Caps to be safer and hence, are likely to invest
in a Large Cap Fund. Moreover, equity markets are likely to rebound after a prolonged fall.
Investors are therefore likely to earn better returns by investing in equities.
m
Scheme 2:"PP Gilt Fund" this Fund would invest in dated Central Goverment Securities
c. o
and Treasury Bills, so that investors looking for safety of capital can move their funds into
this fund and when they feel comfortable, invest the money back into any of the three equity
emFund will provide diversification to investors and
Scheme 3: "PP Foreign Equity Fund"-sthis
Funds.
inaglobally renowned companies. This will be in line with
help them benefit from investing l
g
a investments.
PPAMC focusing only on equity
As you are an expert in the capital markets, you have been approached by PPAMC to help
them resolve the above situation. Further, one of the investors has asked the marketing
team of PPAMC to explain the difference between the IPO of a company and the NFO of
a Mutual Fund.
Multiple Choice Questions:
3.1 Which of the following statement is not true?
o m
m . c
(A) Nifty Mid-Cap 100 is the benchmark index for Emerging India Fund
c. o m
(C) Investors have lost value during the 9-month period from October1,e2021 to June30,
(B) Shining India Focussed 50 Fund has outperformed its Benchmark
em l a s
las 2022
agof PPAMC (2 Marks)
ag (D) Shining India Focussed 50 Fund is the best performing fund
3.2 Which one of the following is correct regarding the AUM under the Little Gems Small Cap
Fund on October1, 2022?
(A) INR 25,000 crores
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 15 of 29
Page 17
16 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
(B) INR 31,645 crores
(C) INR 32,279 crores
(D) Cannot be calculated due to insufficient data (2 Marks)
3.3 Given that the number of units issued by PPAMC in respect of Shining India Focussed 50
Fund, as on October 1, 2021, were 322,05,53,250 which one of the following is correct
regarding the net investments into / redemptions out of the Scheme?
(A) Net Redemptions of INR 9998 crores
(B) Net Investments of INR 9998 crores
(C) Net Redemptions of INR 11,200 crores
(D) Net Investments of INR 11,200 crores (2 Marks)
3.4 If PPAMC decides to launch an ETF, which one of the following statement will be applicable
to PPAMC as per SEBI (LODR) Regulations 2015?
(A) Disclosure of Daily movement in unit capital of the ETF to the Exchange
(B) Disclosure of NAV to the Exchange on a daily basis
(C) Daily Disclosure of Portfolio of the scheme
(D) All of the above (2 Marks)
3.5 Which of the following statements do you agree with?
(A) A Large Cap fund must invest 100% of its funds in Large-Cap companies only.
(B) PPAMC can launch a Mid and Small Cap Fund to attract investors with high risk
appetite
(C) Only one Fund can be launched by one AMC in one category
(D) All of the above statements are true (2 Marks)
3.6 Analyse the three proposals regarding the proposed Schemes and make the appropriate
suggestions to the Management of PPAMC? (5 Marks)
3.7 Given the current market situation with inflation inching up and INR depreciating against
USD, how will a change in interest rate impact the proposed Gilt Fund? (2 Marks)
3.8 Mutual fund Investments are subject to market risks. How does this statement apply to the
proposed Foreign Equity Fund and Gilt Fund? (3 Marks)
3.9 Assuming that PPAMC decides to launch a Gilt Fund, how does it approach the public for
investing their money in that particular scheme? You have been asked to list out important
differences between the IPO of a company and the NFO of a Mutual Fund. (5 Marks)
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 16 of 29
Page 18
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6B: FINANCIAL SERVICES & CAPITAL MARKETS 17
ANSWER TO CASE STUDY: 2
3.1 (B)
m
c. o
3.2 (D)
m
.co m
3.3 (A)
m s e
e a
3.4 (B)
s
a Long Term Equity Fund cannot be launched by PPAMC as it is already having a funda g l
3.6 lPP
3.5 (C)
g
a that invests in Large Caps. As per SEBI directive, a fund can launch only one scheme in
each category.
A Gilt Fund offers protection against default risk, but it is exposed to market risk. If interest
rates move up, there is a chance that the fund may give negative returns. Going by the
objective of providing a parking space for investors, it is advisable to launch a liquid fund.
Clearly, PPAMC does not have any expertise of investing in Debt. It will need t o buy
necessary software and employ fund managers who will come at a high cost. It may not
improve profitability of PPAMC in the short term. However, having debt funds will increase
o m
reach of PPAMC and is a good strategy over the long term, unless PPAMC cho oses to
remain an equity fund player.
. c
m
eput together (combined limit) is USD 7 Billion, as
s
Investments in foreign equity is subject to limits fixed by RBI and SEBI. Currently,
a of USD 1 billion on the amount of money that can
per RBI directive. SEBI has put allimit
international investments by all AMCs
be invested by any one AMC.a If g
these limits are breached, PPAMC will have to stop inflows,
which defeat its objective of increasing AUM. These funds are also exposed to exchange
rate risk. Rupee appreciation can adversely impact returns for investors.
3.7 Increase in interest rate impact price of government securities. An increase in interest rates
will result in prices of Government Securities moving down, while a reduction in interest
rates will push up the prices of Gilts in the bond market. Given the current market situation,
with inflation inching up and INR depreciation against USD, interest rates are likely to move
up. This can result in negative returns on the Gilt Fund in the short term.
m
co
3.8 Market risks in Foreign Equity Fund
m .
c. o se
m
• Economic & Political Risk: Two important factors that affect the Indian domestic
em la
markets are economic and political factors. So, any political unrest or economic
s g
turmoil would take a toll on your domestic investments. As international funds invest
gla a
in other countries or regions, the change in the economic or political condition can
a •
negatively impact your investment in international funds.
Currency Risk: Based on the type of international fund, your investment in rupees is
converted into the currency based on the fund's investment approach. So, if a fund
follows a country-specific approach where it invests in the say, US markets, your
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 17 of 29
Page 19
18 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
investment in rupees will be converted in US dollars (USD). If the US dollar
appreciates in respect to the Indian rupee, then it's a win for you. But if it depreciates
with respect to the rupee, then it'll negatively impact your portfolio.
Market risks in Gilt Fund
(i) Gilt funds carry no credit risks as they are issued by the government who never
default on its payments. However, these funds carry the risk of changing interest
rates. If the interest rates rise sharply, the NAV of a Gilt Fund falls drastically.
(ii) Since the gains from a Gilt Fund depend on interest rate changes, they cannot be
guaranteed.
Alternatively,
Both gilt fund and the foreign equity fund will be subject to market risk. In case of Gilt Fund,
this risk results from change in interest rates. Increase in interest rates will result in gilt
prices going down. Foreign equity fund will be impacted by change in prices of the foreign
stocks or indices in which the foreign equity fund will invest. In addition, it is also exposed
to the exchange rate risk. An appreciation in the rupee will pull down returns earned on the
foreign equities in USD terms.
3.9 An IPO and an NFO are means of raising money from the public. PPAMC should approach
the public by way of NFO. IPO and NFO look identical, but there are many differences
between the two. Some of the differences are listed below:
• Pricing – The shares of a company are offered to public through an IPO at a price,
which is reflective of its prospects, existing demand and many other factors, which
investors consider before investing. An NFO is typically offered at a price which
serves the purpose of determining the number of units that need to be allocated to
the person who wishes to invest a certain amount of money into the MF scheme. It is
typically offered at INR 10 per unit.
• An IPO could be for issue of fresh funds, or it could be an offer for sale. In an Offer
for Sale, existing investors offer their shares in the company to the public. It is a
secondary market activity. An NFO is always made with the intention of raising money
from the public and investing it as per the scheme objectives. There is no Offer for
Sale.
• An IPO is typically open for a period of 3 business days. An NFO is open for 15 to 20
days, so that the desired funds can be raised.
CASE STUDY: 4
(1) Pankaj Pande and Mamta Mishra are veterans in the Financial Services industry. Pankaj
Pande has worked for more than 30 years, starting as a management trainee in a private
sector bank and is now the CFO of ICUCVC, a large Non-Banking Finance Company
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 18 of 29
Page 20
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6B: FINANCIAL SERVICES & CAPITAL MARKETS 19
(NBFC) having leadership in various fund and non-fund based businesses such as vehicle
finance, home Loan, gold loan, personal loan, apart from having interests in mutual fund
m
distribution, insurance, etc. Mamta Mishra, a rank holder in one of the premier B -schools,
m c. o
started her career by joining a large brokerage firm as a research analyst and then became
c. o m
the Head of Treasury for a large corporate with an active portfolio of investments across
e
emto float as
asset classes.
s a Fintech start-up that would use Artificial Intelligence (AI) to provide gl
a to common problems faced by investors and other consumers of the Financiala
(2) Both Pankaj and Mamta shared common values and believed in being client centric. They
g lsolutions
decided
a Services industry. To start their operations they identified three areas, namely home loans,
investment advisory and peer-to-peer loans. They incorporated PPMM FinServ Ltd
(PPMMFSL) as a private limited company. The paid up capital of PPMMFSL is INR 90
crores, constituting 9 crores equity shares of INR 10 each, with Pankaj Pande and Mamta
Mishra each subscribing to 4.5 crores equity shares.
(3) PPMMFSL proposes a unique model for providing home loans. The company will not
charge any interest on the home loans advanced to various home buyers. The rev enue
m
model is based on the principle of sharing of benefits. For example, when a company gives
co
a home loan, all monthly instalments for the first 5 years are used to reduce the principal
.
em
resulting in zero interest costs for the borrower. However, at the end of 5th year,
s
appreciation in the property value is evaluated based on a Housing Price Index and 25%
l a
of the increase in value is payable by the borrower to PPMM FSL. This is paid off by the
a g
borrower in addition to instalment of that year. For the next 5 years, all monthly payments
are again deducted from outstanding principal amount. This process is repeated every 5
years till the entire loan is paid off. Applicant eligibility is assessed by the AI system,
keeping track of property prices across all geographies and pulling out credit history based
on the PAN of the applicants.
(4) Investment advisory services are provided with the help of the Al system of PPMMFSL.
The system keeps reading daily market data across the globe. The Company has tied up
with brokers who can execute orders of clients across geographies and asset classes. The
AI powered system is such that the client has to just specify the amount of investment, the
m
co
period for which he/she intends to invest, the geography of choice and the system c omes
m .
up with a specific investment recommendation. PPMMFSL charges a fee of INR10,000 per
c. o se
m
annum from any person who wishes to subscribe to their offer. A total of 12
em la
recommendations can be taken by a subscriber. Revenue from the investment advisory
s g
segment is likely to grow at a CAGR of 54% going forward.
gla a
Similarly, peer-to-peer lending is completely driven by the AI. The system has access to
a various databases that can help the Company to evaluate the ability and willingness of an
individual to borrow, and the likelihood of the person to repay the borrowed amount. The
Company has consciously chosen to restrict peer-to-peer lending for short periods of 1
year or less.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 19 of 29
Page 21
20 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
(5) As home loan is a fund-based activity, PPMMFSL is looking for funding to the tune of INR
150 crores. Home loans are granted for a period of 15, 20 or 25 years. While disbursements
will happen rather quickly, over a 1-year period since sanction, repayments will happen
over a long period of time. This will mean a lot of money getting blocked for a long period
of time. PPMMFSL anticipates that its home loan book will be INR 10 crores in the first
year, and is likely to grow at 20% over the first year loan book for the next 4 years. Growth
rates are likely to slow down and stabilize at 10% thereafter. This effectively means that
the Company will need funds for growth, even after accounting for repayments. The
Company expects property prices to grow at an average annual rate of 15% over the next
15 years and the consumer price index (CPI) to increase by 20% in the first 5 years.
(6) Both investment advisory and peer-to-peer lending are activities that are driven by the Al.
This requires a lot of investment in not just building the system, but also enhancing its
features on a regular basis. PPMMFSI estimates that it requires INR 100 crores to fully
develop the AI system, and annual expenses of about INR 20 crores for the next 5 years
except the first year for the system to be fully updated and functional. Thereafter, the
system will largely be self-sustaining, and expenses towards its maintenance and upgrade
can be part of the regular Opex of the Company.
(7) While investment advisory is fee based, peer-to-peer lending is a fund-based activity,
although the period of lending is small. The Company anticipates that it will facilitate loans
of average ticket size of INR 50,000 with an average repayment term of 6 months. The
company expects to serve 1000 borrowers in the first year, with this number growing 50%
per annum for the next 5 years. The average ticket size will also grow by 20% every year.
PPMMFSL is ensuring that its Al, built for investment advisory, will also serve the
requirements of peer-to-peer evaluation. In the initial years, the company expects to meet
50% of the fund requirement from its own funds, as lenders may not join their system.
However, by the end of 5 years, the company expects that 100% of the funding will come
from the lenders, with PPMMFSL serving as a facilitator and charging a fee of 1% on the
loan amount. For the first 5 years, the company will not charge the facilitation fee to
promote the platform, passing on all interest payable by the borrowers to the lenders.
PPMMFSL is also considering guaranteeing repayment to lenders, as the AI system is
predicting a default of only 2% by the borrowers. PPMMFSL will also earn interest to the
extent of funds provided from its capital. The average rate for borrowers across credit
categories is expected to be 11.5% p.a.
(8) Given that the nature of business is different from the traditional practice, it is looking at
all possible sources of funding such as Bank loan, Venture Capital Private Equity and even
Private placement of structured securities to meet its fund requirements. Recently,
PPMMFSL has approached Deep Dive Private Equity LLP (DDPEL) with a proposal to
participate in its equity for a 25% stake by investing INR 300 crores and the initial
discussion in this respect is encouraging.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 20 of 29
Page 22
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6B: FINANCIAL SERVICES & CAPITAL MARKETS 21
(9) At the initial stage entire INR 300 crores would not be needed in the business and hence
some portion of the same can be invested in a listed convertible bond. Details of the listed
m
convertible bond issued by BL Ltd are as under:
o
Face Value
m INR 5000
c. o
c
. Rate e m
m s
NO of Shares per bond 50
a s e price per share
Coupon 10%
g la
g l Market price of Convertible Bond
Market INR 95
a
a Straight value of Convertible bond INR 5200
INR4800
Your inputs have been sought by the promoters on the above bond before they decide to
buy the convertible bond.
(10) Pankaj also provides consulting services related to debt instruments. As he is occupied in
the operations of PPMMFSL he sought your help in doing some calculation related to zero
coupon bonds (ZCBs) for one of his clients. Relevant details are given below:
m
co
Yields on ZCBs having a face value of INR 1000 are:
.
em
Years Yield to Maturity (YTM)
1 10%
l a s
2
3
11%
g
a12%
Multiple Choice Questions
4.1 How much funding would be required (rounded off to INR in crores) by PPMMFSL for
supporting all the three businesses for the first 5 years of its operations, ignoring
repayments and revenues?
(A) INR 300 crores
(B) INR 282 crores
o m
m (D) Cannot be ascertained c
. (2 Marks)
c. o m
(C) INR 350 crores
m s e
s e g l a
a
4.2 Assuming that the Company is open to fund different businesses from different sources,
l a
ag
which of the businesses is likely to be funded by a Venture Capitalist?
(A) Home loan business
(B) Investment advisory business
(C) Peer-to-peer lending
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 21 of 29
Page 23
22 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
(D) VC will not fund a specific business (2 Marks)
4.3 Assuming that the CPI has gone up by 30% (as against the original estimated increase of
20%) in the first 5 years, what will be the impact on the profits of PPMMFSL?
(A) There will be no impact of the CPI on profitability of PPMMFSL as the two are not
related.
(B) PPMMFSL will suffer losses as increase in the CPI will mean increase in inflation.
(C) PPMMFSL will earn a higher nominal return on its investments.
(D) There will be an impact of change in the CPI on profits of PPMMFSL, but it cannot be
said whether it will be beneficial or adverse. (2 Marks)
4.4 The risk categorisation of the three segments of the business of PPMMFSL based on
business profile (not based on the amount of exposure) has been tabulated below. In your
opinion which categorisation is the most appropriate in order of risk (highest risk first)?
Most Risky Medium Risky Least Risky
A Home Loan Investment Advisory Peer-to Peer Lending
B Investment Advisory Peer-to -Peer Lending Home -Loan
C Peer-to -Peer Lending Home Loan Investment Advisory
D Peer-to- Peer Lending Investment Advisory Home Loan
(2 Marks)
4.5 Which of the following methods can be considered by PPMMFSL to protect itself against
the risk of default by borrowers who borrowed on the peer-to-peer platform?
(A) Full Factoring
(B) Forfaiting
(C) Credit Default Swaps
(D) Risk Premium (2 Marks)
4.6 If you are the chief analyst at DDPEL, how would you evaluate the proposal of PPMMFSL?
Your answer must include calculation of Pre-Money and Post-Money Valuation, number of
shares to be issued to DDPEL for a 25% stake, total number of shares post investment by
DDPEL, possible reasons for such valuation, and likely exit route that DDPEL would take,
if it decides to invest in PPMMFSL. (6 Marks)
4.7 Based on the inputs given in the case study, answer the following questions.
(i) Conversion value of the convertible bond (1 Marks)
(ii) The percentage of downside risk (1 Marks)
(iii) The conversion premium (1 Marks)
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 22 of 29
Page 24
m
m .co
c. o
em
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6B: FINANCIAL SERVICES & CAPITAL MARKETS 23
(iv) Conversion parity price of the stock. Also interpret the results. (2 Marks)
4.8 Based on the information given in the case study, and assuming that the term structure of
m
c. o
interest rate will remain the same, answer the following questions?
m
co m
(i) Calculate the implied one year forward rates (2 Marks)
m . s e
la
(ii) Expected YTM and prices of one year and two-year ZCBs at end of the first year.
s e g
a
(2 Marks)
g l TO CASE STUDY: 4 a
a4.1 (B)
ANSWER
4.2 (D)
4.3 (C)
4.4 (C)
4.5 (D)
4.6
m
co
PPMMFSL is asking for capital infusion of ` 300 crores
.
em
Current shareholding of PPMMFSL is as under:
s
No. of shares issued 9,00,00,000
Total Amount
g l a 90,00,00,000
Pre – Money Valuation
a 90 crores
Money to be invested by DDPEL (`) 3,00,00,00,000
Stake 25%
Thus, stake of promoters 75%
No. of Shares for 75% stake 9,00,00,000
No. of Shares for 25% stake 3,00,00,000
om
Amount to be invested for 25% stake 3,00,00,00,000
m c. 100
c. o em
Value per share
em s
Position after equity infusion:
s gla3,90,00,00,000
No. of shares issued 1,20,00,00,000
gla Total
a
a Post Money Valuation 390 crores
4.7 (i) Conversion value of convertible bonds
= Conversion Ratio x Market Price
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 23 of 29
Page 25
24 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
= 50 x ` 95 = ` 4750
(ii) The percentage of downside risk
= Premium over straight value = Bond price/ Straight value - 1
= 5200/4800 – 1 = 8.33%
(iii) The conversion premium
= Current Market Value of Bond – Current Conversion Value
= 5200 – 4750 = ` 450
(iv) Conversion parity price of the stock
= Value of Convertible Security / Conversion Ratio
= 5200/50 = `104
This indicates that if price rises from ` 95 to ` 104, investor will neither gain or lose by
buying the convertible bond and exercising it.
4.8 (i) Calculation of Forward Rates
Maturity YTM (%) PVIF Face Value Price Forward Rate
1 10 0.909 1.000 909.09
2 11 0.812 1.000 811.62 0.1201 i.e.,
12.01%
3 12 0.712 1.000 711.78 0.1403 i.e.,
14.03%
(ii) Calculation of Expected Prices and YTM
Maturity Forward Rate Face Value Price YTM
2 0.1201 1.000 1.000/ (1 + 0.1201) = 0.1201 i.e.,
892.78 12.01%
3 0.1403 1.000 1.000/(1 + 1.1201)(1 0.1302 i.e.,
+ 1.403) = 782.93 13.02%
= √ (1000/782.93) – 1 = 0.1302
CASE STUDY: 5
Mr. Steffan Jolly has recently joined Cyber Digi Tech Ltd (CDTL), as its Chief Financial Officer
(CFO). He has been given additional charge of statutory compliances, CDTL is a multi -million
dollar public limited company listed on both BSE and NSE. Headquartered at Chennai, India
CDTL is engaged in customer software development, web application development, web content
management system, design services, online marketing services, testing services etc., and is
one of the key companies closely monitored by the equity analysts and other stake holders.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 24 of 29
Page 26
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6B: FINANCIAL SERVICES & CAPITAL MARKETS 25
(1) The Board members have been regularly raising issues of compliances in every meeting.
The Managing Director (MD) of CDTL Mr. Suresh Saravanan wants that Mr. Jolly should
m
c. o
give adequate time on the statutory compliances, to ensure that the Company is free of
m
co
any non-compliance, penalties and strictures given the multiple challenges impacting the
. e m
s
organization, besides day-to-day activities of managing finances and safe guarding the
e m la
s
assets and investments of the Company. The promoters of CDTL have more than twe nty
l a
listed and unlisted companies and hence compliance is a big challenge. Mr. Jolly has been
a g
ag
assured of the best in class infra-structures and manpower to carry out his duties very
efficiently. Mr. Jolly has been asked to review the status of compliances and with a focus
on associate companies, related party transactions, governance, and unlisted subsidiaries.
The Board has raised number of issues some of which are briefly discussed below:
• Compliances pertaining to the associate companies and related party
• Signing of the compliance certificate submitted to the Board
• Compliance pertaining to the significant transactions and arrangement of a material
m
co
subsidiary
.
em
• Criterion adopted for determining material subsidiary for the purpose of Regulation
a s
30(9)
g l
a
(2) Currently CDTL does not have a system of tracking economic issues and as a result of this
in the past they have made number of errors in decision making. The management is
planning to recruit a full-time economist. You have been approached in the meantime to
answer issues related to monetary and fiscal policies, open market operation of the RBI
and impact on the economy of quantitative easing
(3) CDTL has a robust treasury department and has 15 employees. The treasury department
is led by a Chief Treasury Officer, Mr. Whitehat. Mr. Suman has recently joined as a trainee
in the treasury department and has been assigned work related to back office. Initially, his
m
co
job is restricted to support functions in the accounting area. However, he has been
m .
c. o m
promised by Mr. Whitehat that he will be hired in dealing including option trading and risk
em se
management segment of the treasury operations, if he shows proficiency in a simulated
s g la
environment. Mr. Suman within six months of joining has impressed everyone in the
la a
treasury department. The CFO has given him following tasks and he has been told that he
ag will be involved in complex segment of the treasury operations if he performs well. The
information needed for the tasks are given below.
(i) CDTL has made investment in the following two mutual funds
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 25 of 29
Page 27
26 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
Mutual Fund Star Blue
Jensen Alpha 1.10% 1.50%
Annual Return 8.50% 9.10%
Mr. Suman has also been informed that funds are benchmarked against SENSEX for
performance measurement. The return on the SENSEX is 10% and risk-free return is
6%.
(ii) CDTL has made investment in Collateralized Debt Obligation (CDO). The CFO asked
Mr. Suman to project cash flow from the CDO based on the following information.
The CDO trust holds INR 1000 crores in bonds with a coupon rate of 9%. The CDO
has three tranches: Tranche A has 800 crores with a coupon of 9%, Tranche B has
100 crores with a coupon of 10%, and the Tranche C is equity Tranche of 100 crores
with a coupon of 12%. CDTL has made investment in Tranche C.
(iii) The treasury has taken position on call option on LAX Bank which has the delta of
0.70. The CFO wants Mr. Suman to estimate delta of an equivalent put option.
(iv) The CFO wants to understand from Mr. Suman about requirements of same
person/entity making investment though FDI and Qualified Foreign Investors (QFI)
routes.
You are a friend of Mr. Suman and has agreed to help in completing the tasks given by the
CFO.
Multiple Choice Questions:
5.1 Based on the information given in the case study, which one of the following is the closest
to the annual cash flows that CDTL can expect to receive from Tranche C of the CDO?
(A) 12 crores
(B) 8 crores
(C) Zero
(D) 10 crores (2 Marks)
5.2 What would be the delta of an equivalent put option, given the delta of the call option in
the case study?
(A) 0.70
(B) (-) 0,30
(C) 0.30
(D) (-) 0.70 (2 Marks)
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 26 of 29
Page 28
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6B: FINANCIAL SERVICES & CAPITAL MARKETS 27
5.3 Which one of the following is incorrect with respect to monetary policy?
(A) The monetary policy is least likely to include inflation target
m
c. o
(B) The monetary policy is least likely to include changing repo rate
m
.co e m
(C) The monetary policy is least likely to include changing bank rate
e m
(D) The monetary policy is least likely to include transfer payment program (2 Marks)
la s
l a s
5.4 The RBI has carried out repeatedly open market purchases of government bonds. Which
a g
ag (A) Decrease the money supply
one of the following is correct with respect to such actions of the RBI?
(B) Prohibited by the RBI Act, 1934
(C) Are inconsistent with an expansionary monetary policy
(D) Are consistent with an expansionary monetary policy (2 Marks)
5.5 Which one of the following is correct with respect to quantitative easing?
(A) Its impact is neutral on the economy
m
c. o
(B) It is an expansionary monetary policy
em
(C) It leads to contraction of the economy
5.6 Based on the issues raised in thelcase
s
a study by the Board, following questions have been
(D) It leads to contraction in short term and expansion in medium term (2 Marks)
framed by the CFO. Give your a g
reasoned answers:
(i) SEBI (LODR) defines the term "associate company". For classifying an "associate
company" is it necessary that both conditions under the Companies Act, 2013 and
applicable accounting standards have been met or either of the two is sufficient?
(2 Marks)
(ii) SEBI (LODR) defines the term "Related Party". For classifying a "Related Party" is it
necessary that both conditions under the Companies Act, 2013 and applicable
m
accounting standards have been met or either of the two is sufficient? (2 Marks)
m .co
c. o
(iii) SEBI (LODR) requires a compliance certificate to the Board of Directors by the CEO
m
se
or CFO. Can the Managing Director or Whole Time Director certify the compliance
em la
certificate knowing that CDTL has not designated a CEO? (1 Marks)
las a g
(iv) Can the Board of CDTL review all significant transactions and arrangement entered
ag
into by only material unlisted subsidiaries? (1 Marks)
(v) The Explanation to Regulation 16(1)(c) states that the listed entity shall formulate a
policy for determining material subsidiary. Can CDTL adopt a different criterion for
determining material subsidiary for the purpose of Regulation 30(9)? (2 Marks)
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 27 of 29
Page 29
28 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
5.7 Based on the information given in the case study, answer the following questions.
(i) What would be the Beta of two mutual funds? (4 Marks)
(ii) Which mutual fund has performed better based on the Treynor's Ratio? (1 Marks)
5.8 Can the same person/entity make investments though FDI and QFI routes? Give reasoned
answer. (2 Marks)
ANSWER TO CASE STUDY: 5
5.1 (B)
5.2 (B)
5.3 (D)
5.4 (D)
5.5 (B)
5.6 (i) As per Regulation 2(1)(b) of SEBI (LODR), Regulations, “associate” shall mean any
entity which is an associate under sub-section (6) of section 2 of the Companies Act,
2013 or under the applicable accounting standards. So, it can be said from the
language of the said regulations that either of the two conditions is sufficient.
(ii) As per Regulation 2(1)(zb) SEBI (LODR), Regulations, “related party” means a
related pay as defined under sub-section (76) of section 2 of the Companies Act,
2013 or under the applicable accounting standards. So, it can be said from the
language of the said regulations that either of the two conditions is sufficient.
(iii) As per Regulation 17 (8 SEBI (LODR), Regulations, the chief executive officer and
the chief financial officer shall provide the compliance certificate to the board of
directors. As per Regulation 2 (1) (e), the term CEO and Managing Director can be
used interchangeably and according to 2(1)(f), the term CFO and the whole-time
finance director can also be used interchangeably. So, the Managing Director or
Whole Time Director can certify the compliance certificate knowing that CDTL has not
designated a CEO.
(iv) As per Regulation 24(4) SEBI (LODR), Regulations, the management of the unlisted
subsidiary shall periodically bring to the notice of the board of directors of the listed
entity, a statement of all significant transactions and arrangements entered by the
unlisted subsidiary. So, Board is expected to review all significant transactions and
arrangements of every unlisted subsidiary.
(v) CDTL cannot adopt a different criterion as the criteria is specifically mentioned in
Regulation 16 (1) (c). Furthermore, as per the explanation to Regulation 16 (1) (c),
CDTL can only formulate a policy for determining material subsidiary.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 28 of 29
Page 30
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6B: FINANCIAL SERVICES & CAPITAL MARKETS 29
5.7 Calculation of Beta
Star Blue
m
c. o
CAPM Return 8.5% - 1.10% = 7.40% 9.10% - 1.50% = 7.60%
m
.co e m
Excess Return 10% - 6% =4% 10% - 6% = 4%
Beta
e m (7.40% - 6%)/ 4% = 0.35 (7.60% - 6%)/ 4% = 0.40
la s
l a s
Treynor’s Ratio (8.5% - 6%)/ 0.35 = 0.0714 (9.1% - 6%)/ 0.40 = 0.0775
a g
a5.8g Yes, all existing investments made by the FIIs/SAs/QFIs are grandfathered. However, in
Mutual Fund Blue has performed better than Star based on Treynor’s Ratio
respect of those securities, where FPIs are not allowed to invest (e.g., unlisted securitie s)
no fresh purchase shall be allowed as FPI. They can only sell their existing investments in
such securities.
Alternatively,
Yes. However, in such a situation the aggregate holding of such person in the company
shall not exceed 5% of paid-up equity capital of the company at any time. This limit shall
m
co
be applicable to each class of equity shares and shall be subject to the guidelines on FDI
.
issued by GOI and RBI.
s em
g l a
a
m
m .co
c. o se
m
s em g la
gla a
a
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 29 of 29