aglasem.com
Home Schools Admission Career Mock Test PDF Docs Playground
ClassChoose class
StateSelect state

CA Final November 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme)

Download the CA Final November 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) PDF from AglaSem. These are the official suggested answers released by ICAI. Use them to check your answers and learn how to present them in the exam.
CA Final November 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) - Page 1 of 38

About CA Final November 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme)

CA Final November 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) is available here for free download. Published by ICAI for ICAI CA, this solution can be viewed online or downloaded as a PDF (38 pages). Candidates preparing for ICAI CA can use CA Final November 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) to understand the exam pattern, the type of questions asked, and the overall difficulty level.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I download CA Final November 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme)?

Open this page and click the Download button to save CA Final November 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) as a PDF. It is completely free on AglaSem Docs.

Is CA Final November 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) free to download?

Yes. CA Final November 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) can be viewed online and downloaded as a PDF free of cost on AglaSem Docs.

How many pages does CA Final November 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) have?

CA Final November 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) contains 38 pages, which you can read online or download together as a single PDF.

Where can I find more ICAI CA study material?

You can find more ICAI CA question papers, sample papers, syllabus, and answer keys on AglaSem Docs.

CA Final November 2022 Suggested Answers Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) – Text

Read the full text of this solution below — useful to quickly search, copy and reference the content online without downloading the PDF.

📄 View text version (38 pages)

Page 1

FOR CA FINAL EXAM PREPARATION

CA Final 2022
Suggested Answers ·
Paper 6A Risk
Management (Old
Scheme)
EXAM YEAR TYPE

CA Final 2022 Suggested Answers
SUBJECT DATE

Paper 6A Risk Management (Old Scheme) November 2022

Notes · Sample Papers · Previous Year Papers · Mock Tests

Page 2

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g

DISCLAIMER
This Suggested Answer hosted on the website do not constitute the basis for evaluation of the

m
m c. o
co
student’s answers in the examination. The answers are prepared by the Faculty of the Board

. e m
em
of Studies with a view to assist the students in their education. Alternate Answers have been

la s
l a s a g
aanyg error or omission is noticed, the same may be brought to the attention of the Director of
incorporated, wherever necessary. While due care is taken in preparation of the answers, if

Board of Studies. The Council of the Institute is not in anyway responsible for the correctness

or otherwise of the answers published herein.

Further, in the Elective Papers which are Case Study based, the solutions have been worked

o m
out on the basis of certain assumptions/views derived from the facts given in the question or

c
. to work out the solution to the case studies
m
e made or views taken.
language used in the question. It may be possible

la s
g
in a different manner based on the assumptions

a

m
m .co
c. o se
m
s em g la
gla a
a

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 1 of 37

Page 3

2 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

PAPER – 6A – RISK MANAGEMENT

The Question Paper comprises five case study questions. The candidates are required
to answer any four case study questions out of five.
Answers in respect of Multiple-Choice Questions (MCQs) are to be marked on the OMR
Answer Sheet as given on the Cover Page of the answer book.
Answer to MCQs, if written inside the descriptive answer book, will not be evaluated.
Candidates should answer the Case Study Questions as selected by them in totality i.e. MCQ
as well as descriptive Question of the same Case Study Question.
Candidates are not permitted to answer MCQs of one Case Study Question and the
descriptive questions of another Case Study Question and vice-versa.
Candidates may use calculator.
CASE STUDY: 1

ABOUT THE COMPANY
XYZ Limited (herein after referred as 'the Company') is engaged in coal mining and marketing.
It sells coal & coal products to various companies which are engaged in the manufacture of
power and steel. 10% of the total coal mined is also exported to South East Asian Countries.
The Company has a risk management function headed by the Chief Risk Officer ('CRO'), who
participates in all the leadership meetings and shares his views with the Heads of the
Departments during such meetings. He has a vast experience in the mining related risks.
Monthly assessment of the operational and business risks faced by the Company is assessed
and mitigation procedures are reviewed.
On a half-yearly basis, a report is submitted to the Board, for its review and a detailed
presentation is made by the CRO.

CONCERNS NOTICED
(A) The operations of the Company, were significantly affected during the last two years, on
account of pandemic. The Company was not able to implement various proposed capex
projects and costs of the projects escalated substantially, impacting the payback periods.
(B) Further, due to pandemic, employees' health was affected in most of the mining
locations, resulting in :
(i) Reduction in attendance by 50% during pandemic period, which lasted for almost 6
months.
(ii) The efficiency of the employees reduced, due to after affects of the pandemic.

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 2 of 37

Page 4

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 3

(iii) There was a huge demand for coal and employees were regularly working overtime,
to meet targets. This impacted efficiency.

m
c. o
(iv) Multiple accidents occurred in the recent past, due to employee fatigue.

m
.co e m
(C) The operating costs have gone up and the Company was unable to increase the selling

m la s
prices, since they have entered into long term sale contracts. The payments were not

s e
being received on a timely basis, and the over dues were piling up, which affected the
g
l a
g STEPS TAKEN
working capital requirements.
a
aREMEDIAL
In order to improve operational efficiencies, the Board of Directors advised the management,
to establish a Steering Committee to evaluate the areas of cost reduction and identify
efficiency improvement projects, besides prioritizing employees' Health & Wellness. The
Steering Committee comprised of Operations Head, Chief Financial Officer, Chief Risk Officer,
Human Resources Head, Logistics Head & Marketing Head.

m
Steering Committee, has come up with various suggestions for implementation, which includes

c o
(b) Modernisation of mining equipment, which. would enhance production and improve
(a) Outsourcing the entire mining activity to external agencies at fixed rate contracts.

s em
la to the wagon loading point, to reduce delays in
efficiencies.
(c) Install a conveyor belt from thegmines
a handling of the materials.
internal movements and multiple
(d) Upgrade the existing IT systems, to ensure on-line monitoring of the coal mined, shifted
and dispatched.
(e) Increase the frequency of health checks from annual to half yearly basis and extend free
medication to all employees at the Company operated clinic.
(f) Establish "Centre of Excellence" for training the employees, with respect to "Just in time",
"Multi-tasking" and "Safety" concepts.
o m
m c
m. and
c. o The Steering Committee, also wanted to assess the risk maturity levels in theseorganization
(g) Integrate the Risk Management with strategic activity.

s em the level of integration of risk management with operational performance. a
l
g gaps compared to
a
An external firm was

l a
ag
appointed, to study the existing risk management practices, assess the
industry best practices.
The external firm carried out a risk maturity exercise and applied various techniques to identify
whether all related risks have been covered and adequately mitigated. They have submitted
their report after a detailed study. They have identified that the company has a qualitative risk

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 3 of 37

Page 5

4 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

assessment module, based on which all risks are classified in High, Medium and Low. Certain
risks which are considered medium, required to be moved to high risk category. The report
also included details of the existing risk maturity levels in the company.

EXPANSION / DIVERSIFICATION PLANS
Based on the revival of the Indian economy, the Board of Directors of the Company have
envisaged to diversify into power generation & distribution activities.
The various options which were under consideration included:
Option I : To set up a green-field project for power generation, funded through debt and
internal accruals.
Option II : Enter into a Joint Venture with 50% share in equity with other power generating
companies, to set up a power generation plant.
Option III : Revive a sick power generation unit, and avail tax & other benefits extended by
the Government.
The Board members have advised the CFO and CRO to examine the three options and submit
a brief report for consideration, based on which Board can assess the project viability. The
CFO & CRO, carried out the evaluation and examined the funding requirements, future cash
flows, return on investments and risks involved in each of the options.
The CFO summarized certain financial assumptions which are given below :

(Amount in ` Crores)

Option 1 Option 2 Option 3
Timelines to commence operations 5 years 5 years 2 years
Life of the project 25 years 25 years 10 years
Capacity of the plant 500MW 500MW 500MW
Estimated Project cost 2,000.00 2,000.00 500.00
Funding options
External Loan from financial institutions 1,500.00 500.00 250.00
Internal Accruals 500.00 500.00 250.00
Total Company's exposure to the project 2,000.00 1,000.00 500.00
Exposure of the Joint Venture partner - 1,000.00
Interest rates 9% 9% 6%

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 4 of 37

Page 6

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 5

The CRO, has summarized the following specific project related risks of the three options: -
(a) Project getting delayed beyond scheduled period.
m
m c. o
(b) Changes in government regulations relating to taxes and tariffs.

c o
. partner not providing funds on a timely basis. e m
s
(c) Possibility of imposition of Environment cess after 5 years.

m
emaintenance costs and machine failures. la
s g
(d) Joint venture

g l a
(e) Higher
a
a Multiple Choice Questions:
Choose the most appropriate answer from the given options.
(1.1) A Risk identification approach used by the external team was a structured program
including team exercise, where the facilitator of the firm used a set of indicators to
stimulate participants to identify risks in their respective operational areas. The approach
adopted by them was:

m
(A) Brainstorming
(B) Bow Tie analysis
. co
(C) “What if” Technique
s em
(D) Benchmarking
g l a
a
(1.2) A risk management technique involving the estimation of future cash flow benefits
relating to the project arising from risk management actions vis-s- vis the costs of risk
consequences is :
(A) Value at Risk
(B) Capital Budgeting
(C) Risk Score Cards

m
co
(D) Risk Heat Maps

m .
c. o m
(1.3) The Steering Committee's suggestion to provide training to its employees through

em se
"Centre of Excellence" to make them understand the multi-tasking and safety concepts

s g la
would fall under :

gla (A) Efficiency alternatives
a
a (B) Safety alternatives
(C) Operational alternatives
(D) Financial alternatives

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 5 of 37

Page 7

6 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

(1.4) The external firm, during its evaluation process, identified two risk attributes which are
being used to derive the risk score. The two attributes identified are :
(A) Likelihood of risk occurrence and Risk Consequence.
(B) Risk criticality and Risk Consequence.
(C) Risk appetite & Likelihood of risk occurrence.
(D) Risk appetite & Risk criticality.
(1.5) The CRO has carried out the risk evaluation of the proposed project options and listed
down the risks in his report to the Board. What is the objective of the exercise carried out
by the CRO ?
(A) Carrying out due diligence and quantifying the risks
(B) Assessing technical capability of the project team to implement the project prior to
recommending the suitable option.
(C) Quantifying all the risks associated with the project and give adequate weightage to
the risk associated with each project.
(D) Assessing external risks which are un-controllable. (2 x 5 = 10 Marks)
Descriptive Questions
(1.6) (A) Elaborate the qualitative risk assessment process which has been adopted by the
Company and explain the rationale of plotting the risks in the risk matrix.
(3 Marks)
(B) Taking into account the five key project risks identified by the CRO, classify them
into High, Medium and Low for each of the three options under consideration.
(3 Marks)
(1.7) The external firm has evaluated the risk maturity levels in the organization and issued a
Risk Assessment Report. The report compiled the characteristics associated in each of
the risk maturity level. Name the risk maturity levels taking into account the operations of
the company with related key characteristics. (4 Marks)
(1.8) (A) Based on the financial data compiled by the CFO and additional information given
below, calculate the Return on Investment and the payback period, based on
traditional method and recommend, which option would be suitable if :
(a) Return on Investment is taken as the benchmark

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 6 of 37

Page 8

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 7

(b) Payback period, from the date of commencement of operations is taken into
account.

m
c. o
(Amount in ` Crores)

o m m
c
. Revenue e
Option 1 Option 2 Option 3

m la s
seAnnual Maintenance Costs
Estimated 500.00 500.00 375.00

la Fixed & Other Costs
50.00 50.00 150.00
a g
ag 100.00 100 00 125.00
Depreciation 80.00 80.00 50.00
Tax Rates 25% 25% 10%

(3 Marks)
(B) Would the options change if risks identified by the CRO is taken into consideration ?
(2 Marks)

m
co
Answer to Case Study 1

.
em
1.1 (C)
1.2 (B)
l a s
1.3 (A) or (C)
a g
1.4 (A)
1.5 (A) or (C)
1.6 (A) Under the Qualitative Analysis, all the identified risks are plotted on a matrix. Each
risk item is given a position on the matrix chart. The probability of the risk occurring
can be plotted on the horizontal bar, while the impact of the risk can be noted along

m
co
the vertical bar of the axis. The probability-impact value of a risk is a product of both

m .
c. o
the values assigned for the risk. Hence, it can be seen that a risk with a value of 9,
m
se
where the probability and impact rate the highest, requires immediate attention –

s em g la
Grid III. Those with a low rating of 1 or 2 require the least attention and may even

gla a
be ignored, if insignificant - Grid VII.

a

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 7 of 37

Page 9

8 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

The rationale of plotting risks in the risk matrix is decide the degree of control to be
exercised.
1.6 (B) Classification of Key risks identified by CRO under each of the 3 options is as
below:
Key Risks Identified by CRO Option 1 Option 2 Option 3
Project getting delayed beyond High High High/Medium
scheduled period
Changes in government regulations High High High
with tariffs
Imposition of Environmental Cess High / High Medium
after 5 years Medium
Joint venture partner not funding on NA High NA
timely basis
High Maintenance costs & machine Medium/Low Medium/ High
failures Low
1.7 The Risk Maturity level of the company can either be Risk Managed/ Risk Enabled
because of the following characteristics:
(a) The Company has a risk management function headed by the Chief Risk Officer
('CRO'), who participates in all the leadership meetings and shares his views with
the Heads of the Departments during such meetings.

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 8 of 37

Page 10

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 9

(b) The Steering Committee, also wanted to assess the risk maturity levels in the
organization and the level of integration of risk management with operational

m
performance.
1.8 (A)
o m
(Amount in ` Crore)
c. o
.c e m
m s
Particulars Option 1 Option 2 Option 3

seAnnual Maintenance Costs
Revenue 500.00 500.00 375.00
g la
g la Fixed & Other Costs 50.00 50.00 150.00
a
a Depreciation 100.00
80.00
100.00
80.00
125.00
50.00
Interest Costs 135.00 45.00 15.00
Total Costs 365.00 275.00 340.00
Profit before tax 135.00 225.00 35.00
Tax 33.75 56.25 3.50
Profit after tax 101.25 168.75 31.50

c om
Company share 101.25 84.38 31.50

.
em181.25
Return on Investment (a) 5.06% 8.44% 6.30%

las
Cash Inflows 248.75 81.50

period ag after
Company share 181.25 124.38 81.50
Payback 11.03 8.04 6.13
commencement (b) (in years) (2000/181.25) (1000/ 124.38) (500/ 81.50)
(a) If Return on Investment is taken as the benchmark, Option 2 is suitable.
(b) If Payback period is taken as the benchmark, Option 3 is suitable.
Alternative Solution
Working Notes Amount in ` Crore
Option 1 Option 2
o m
Option 3

m .c
c. o 50.00 m 150.00
Estimated Revenue 500.00 500.00 375.00

100 00 s
e 125.00
em
Annual Maintenance Costs 50.00

s
Fixed & Other Costs 100.00
g l a
gla Depreciation 80.00
a270.00
80.00 50.00

a EBIT
50% of EBIT for Option 2
270.00
- 135.00
50.00
-
Less: Interest 135.00 45.00 15.00

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 9 of 37

Page 11

10 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

135.00 90.00 35.00
Less: Tax 33.75 22.50 3.50
Profit After Tax 101.25 67.50 31.50
Add : Depreciation 80.00 40.00 50.00
CFAT 181.25 107.50 81.50
Evaluation of Options
(i) Based on Return on Investment
270
Option I - ×100 = 13.50%
2000
270×0.50
Option II - ×100 = 13.50%
1000
50
Option III - ×100 = 10%
500
(ii) Based on Payback Period
2000
Option I - = 11.03 years
181.25
1000
Option II - = 9.30 years
107.50
500
Option III - = 6.13 years
81.50
Conclusion: Thus, on the basis of Payback Period Basis Option 3 should be
chosen. However, based on ROI criteria either of Option 1 or 2 can be chosen
considering other factors.
1.8 (B) No there will be no change in options even if risks identified by the CRO is taken
into consideration.
CASE STUDY: 2
ABOUT THE COMPANY
ABC Agri Limited (herein after referred as 'the company') is a listed company, engaged in the
manufacture of fertilisers and pesticides and markets its products through dealer network. The
role of agriculture in the Indian economy is of utmost importance and the Government
monitors the production and distribution of fertilisers across India. The Government also

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 10 of 37

Page 12

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 11

provides subsidy to the fertiliser manufacturers based on sales made to the ultimate end users
who are the farmers. The subsidy amount is computed based on the nutrient content in the

m
c. o
fertilizers.

m
co m
The Company has a strong Research & Development (R & D) team which is equipped with

.
state of the art facilities. The R & D team is associated with multiple international crop
m s e
s e la
research agencies and agriculture universities involved in the study of climatic changes, soil

l a
health testing, changes in cropping patterns and study of molecules enriching the agriculture
a g
g NOTICED
aISSUES
yields, etc.

More than 80% of the raw material requirements are imported by the Comp any, which
includes rock phosphate & acids. Due to the war between Russia & Ukraine, there has been a
manifold increase in the raw material prices and shipping costs which the Company is unable
to pass on to the customers. In addition to steep increase in prices, the US $ conversion rates
have also contributed to the increase in raw material costs, which required close monitoring of
currency movements and focus on foreign currency hedge.

m
co
PROPOSALS BEFORE THE COMPANY
.
em
The company intends to introduce new-age fertilizers & pesticides with the help of the R & D

a s
team. R & D team assesses the performance of the new products in test environment. On

l
g
satisfactory completion of the trials, the product combinations are released to the business &

a
legal teams for necessary regulatory approvals and launching of the products.
While the R & D team is coming up with new product portfolio, the marketing team have come
up with an idea of marketing these new age products through e-commerce and direct delivery
channels to the farmers. Prior to the launch of these products the marketing team would like to
carry out a survey to understand the farmer's expectation, present gaps in meeting such
expectation, market demand, regulatory compliances, supply chain challenges, etc., and
appointed an external survey agency to carry out market research and give its
recommendations.

o m
m following survey findings were shared with the marketing team for taking c
. necessary
SURVEY FINDINGS

c. o The s em
em mitigation steps prior to the launch of new products :
a
l mobile apps. and
l as • The end customers are primarily farmers, who lack awareness ofgusing
a
ag
place direct orders on the mobile app.
• The company may have to make investments, in supply chain & logistics, by way of
setting up additional warehouses and procurement of trucks and delivery vans at remote

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 11 of 37

Page 13

12 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

locations and would require compliance with statutory requirements including licenses
etc.
• Branding of the new products via e-commerce channels is a challenging exercise.
Farmers are not aware of the new product properties & its applications.
• Company need to invest in IT infrastructure for application development/support "e-
commerce portal".
• Company to recruit additional manpower for demonstration and delivery of the
products at the door step of the farmers.
RISK MANAGEMENT BY THE COMPANY
The Company has a robust ERM framework in place, which includes complete documentation
of Risk Registers, establishing Risk Management Committee and Operational Risk
Committees, risk scores, monitoring tools etc. covering Strategic and Operational activities. All
activities of the company are systematically segregated into various functions starting from
procurement to marketing supported by strategic and back office teams.
The risks are classified into controllable and un-controllable risks. The inherent risk faced by
the company is primarily monsoon. During the average monsoon period, the company
achieves the production & sales targets. During monsoon failure scenario, the sales volumes
reduces by almost 50%. The Board and the Leadership team are aware of the inherent risks
faced by the company, against which mitigation procedures are put in place.
There is also a strong team of Internal audit, which is aligned with the ERM framework of the
Company. The internal audits are carried out based on the risk matrix to ensure key risks are
integrated with audit execution. On a regular basis, the risks identified during process are
shared by the Chief Risk Officer (CRO) with the internal audit team, who in turn considers the
same during the planning and execution of various functional audits.
SIGNIFICANT RISKS HIGHLIGHTED FOR MITIGATION
During the presentation to the Risk Management Committee, CRO highlighted the following
significant risks, against which mitigation procedures were also deliberated.
• Significant volatility in the Raw material prices
• Non-availability of ships for importing raw materials
• Foreign currency fluctuations leading to high input costs
• Storage space constraints within manufacturing locations
• Lack of adequate gear to employees handling hazardous chemicals
• High talent attrition.

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 12 of 37

Page 14

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 13

• Trade-marks/patent infringement by competitors
• Finished products were awaiting sale due to delayed monsoons.
m
m c. o
• Over dues on account of monsoon failures.
•
.co
Unauthorised access & hacking of the system
s e m
em la
s g
Multiple Choice Questions

l a a
a(2.1)g The
Choose the most appropriate answer from the given options.
gap between the inherent risk and residual risk in the above ERM Environment :
(A) Shows the strength of the controls and is known as control score.
(B) Shows the level of Risk appetite and is known as Risk score.
(C) Shows the strength of controls and is known as Risk score.
(D) Explains controllable risks and the probability of their occurrence.
(2.2) The operational risk is an overarching concept inter-related with

m
(A) Risks relating to production activities

c o
. to production
(B) Risks relating to both production and maintenance activities

e m
s
(C) Risks related to all activities and not restricted

g l a
(D) Risks related to production, maintenance, human resources which are having

(2.3) The risk monitoring tools toatrack the progress of risk management using qualitative
financial impact.

assessment of probability and impact of risk :
(A) Risk Event Map
(B) Flow Charts and Risk Maps
(C) Risk Heat Maps
(D) Risk Score Cards

m
co
(2.4) A company's decision to launch new products, through e-commerce portal, which is

m .
c. o
outside its existing core competency is BEST known as :

m
em se
(A) Uncertainty

s
(B) Ambiguity
g la
gla (C) Complexity
a
a (D) Volality

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 13 of 37

Page 15

14 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

(2.5) Every listed company normally constitutes Risk Management Committee. Among the
various responsibilities of the committee, which one is not required to be carried out by
the Risk Management Committee.
(A) Discuss the risk strategies on both aggregate basis and on individual basis.
(B) Oversee that the management has robust processes to ensure adherence to the
risk policies approved by the Board.
(C) Risk Committee to discuss the agenda matters coming up for Board Meeting.
(D) Review and approve the mitigation processes in place annually.
(2 x 5 = 10 Marks)
Descriptive Questions
(2.6) Document the responsible function in the organisation and a mitigation procedure for any
of the five significant risks presented by the CRO to the Risk Management Committee,
covered in the above case. (5 Marks)
(2.7) The Board seeks your advise, with respect to the disclosure in the Annual Report relating
to Risks and Concerns of the business, based on the Case Study. (5 Marks)
(2.8)(a) Elucidate, how the risks and its mitigation procedures are considered for carrying out
an effective internal audit, by the audit team. (3 Marks)
(b) For the first two commercial risks identified by the CRO, explain how the internal
audit team can carry out a risk based audit to address the specific risk. (2 Marks)
Answer to Case Study 2
2.1 (A)
2.2 (C)
2.3 (C)
2.4 (B)
2.5 (C)
2.6 Responsible Function and Mitigation Procedure for any five significant risk presented by
CRO to the Risk Management Committee.
Significant Risks Function Mitigation Procedures
Significant volatility Commercial / 1. Long term contracts can be
in the Raw material Procurement entered at a fixed rate with
prices. suppliers.
2. Continuous monitoring of raw
material prices and entering in to
contracts as and when required.

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 14 of 37

Page 16

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 15

Non-availability of Supply Chain/ Contract terms with suppliers to
ships for importing Commercial include the CFR or delivery at place

m
raw materials. (DAP).

m c. o
co
Foreign currency Treasury 1. Entering into Hedging contracts

. e m
fluctuations leading like Forwards/ Futures/Options.

em
to high input costs. 2. Entering into currency swap
l a s
a s g
options

l a
ag constraints
Storage space Operations / 1. Identifying external godowns/
within Commercial warehouses and entering into an
manufacturing agreement for storage.
locations. 2. Build new storage spaces after
considering the cost benefit
analysis.
Lack of adequate Operations/Safety 1. Availability of adequate safety
gear to employees gear.
handling hazardous 2. Monitoring strict compliance in

m retention policies to be in
chemicals. usage of the same.
High talent attrition. Human Resources
c. o1. Talent
e m
place.

l a s 2. Periodic feedbacks to be obtained

g
from employees and trainings to

a 3.
be provided.
Rewards & Recognitions
programs to be in place.
Trade-marks/patent Legal Monitoring of patents filed by
infringement by competitors and file legal cases in
competitors. case of any infringement of patents.
Finished products Marketing Forecasting of Demand and develop
awaiting sale due to the production plans based on the

m
delayed monsoons. same.

m .co
c. o
Over dues on Marketing To obtain adequate security and

m
se
account of monsoon monitor the credit limits.

em la
failures/natural

s g
calamities.

gla Unauthorised access Information 1.
a
Cyber Security to be in line with

a & hacking. Technology
2.
ISO standards.
Need to know & Need to Have
basis access rights at the time of
granting.

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 15 of 37

Page 17

16 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

3. Use only Licensed software.
4. Cyber security Awareness
programs to all employees.
Alternative Solution
Responsible Function and Mitigation Procedure for any five significant risk presented by
CRO to the Risk Management Committee.
Risks Responsible Mitigation Procedure
Function
Significant volatility in Purchase Should book in advance the purchased
the Raw material Department contracts by properly estimating the
prices requirements.
Non-availability of Supply Chain Should book the ships in advance
ships for importing Department considering the possibility of Geo political
raw materials Risk in view.
Foreign currency Treasury Finance Should take Hedging Contract. If possible
fluctuations leading to Department use internal hedging techniques such as
high input costs netting off invoicing in own currency etc.
Storage space Production Should take on lease adequate space or
constraints within Department if required should purchase it.
manufacturing
locations
Lack of adequate Production Should made available adequate gear
gear to employees Department and also provide them proper training of
handling hazardous handling hazardous chemicals.
chemicals
High talent attrition Human Resource Should review the working conditions and
Department pay structure on periodic basis and make
changes if required to return the high
talent.
Trade-marks / patent Legal Department Should issue legal notice timely and if
infringement by required, initiate legal proceedings.
competitors
Finished products Sales Department Estimate the sale based on Monsoon
were awaiting sale Data of previous years and if required
due to delayed refer the expected rainfall.
monsoons.
Over dues on account Finance For Finance Department it is essential to
of monsoon failures. Department do monitoring of overdues.

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 16 of 37

Page 18

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 17

Unauthorised access IT Department Ensuring access to his computer with
& hacking of the proper password and use of adequate

m
system software to ensure the hacking of the

m c. o
system could be avoided.

2.7
c. o s e m
To m
s e be shownReportin Risks and Concerns g la
g launder: a
Annual

a or Scenario or Associated Principal Description
Risks
Competitive Pressure • Significant volatility in the Due to volatility in price of
Raw material prices. raw and foreign Exchange
• Foreign currency Rates the input cost has
fluctuations leading to become quite due to which
high input costs. company is losing its

m
• High talent attrition. competitiveness in the

co
market. Further situation has

.
• Trade-marks / patent
been worsened due

em
infringement by
employing highly talented
s
competitors

l a
staff of the company by the

g
competitor.

a Some cases of infringement
of Patent by competitor has
further impacted the revenue
of the company.
Supply chain • Non-availability of ships Due to delayed monsoon the
disruption for importing raw finished stocks in lying
materials. unsold in the godowns
• Storage space resulting in sufficient storage

m
constraints within space for the raw material.

co
Hence impacting Production
m .
manufacturing locations.

c. o m
• Finished products were Schedule.

em se
awaiting sale due to

s la
delayed monsoons.

la a g
g
Reputation Risk • Lack of adequate gear to Due to lack of adequate

a
employees handling headgears for employees
hazardous chemicals. handling hazardous chemical
• Trade-marks / patent any accident can take place
infringement by any time. Which may not only
invite penal actions from the

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 17 of 37

Page 19

18 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

competitors. Government but may also
• Unauthorised access & damage the reputation of
hacking of the system. company. Further
infringement of company’s
Trade-markets/patents by
competitors can also bring
bad name for the
organization.
The unauthorized access
hacking of the company’s
system may further worsen
the situation.
Credit Risk • Over dues on account of Overdue an account of
monsoon failures. monsoon failure may lead to
default by the customers and
resulting in Bad Debts
losses.
2.8 (a) Internal audit is a management function; thus, it has the high-level objective of
serving management's needs through constructive recommendations in areas such
as, internal control, risk, utilisation of resources, compliance with laws, management
information system, etc.
Risk management enables management to effectively deal with risk, associated
uncertainty and enhancing the capacity to build value to the entity or enterprise and
its stakeholders. Internal auditor plays an important role in providing assurance to
management on the effectiveness of risk management.
The internal auditors have the following vital areas of responsibility in the field of
risk management:
• Review operations, policies, and procedures.
• Help ensure that goals and objectives are met.
• Understanding the “big picture” and diverse operations.
• Make recommendations to improve economy and efficiency.
Therefore, the internal audit report is on the management of significant risks of the
organisation and the assurance is on these risks being managed within the
acceptable limits as laid down by the Board of Directors. To give this assurance, the
internal auditor conducts a process audit on risk management processes at all
levels of the organisation, viz., corporate, divisional, business unit, business
process level, etc., put in place by line management so as to assess the adequacy
of their design and compliance.

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 18 of 37

Page 20

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 19

(b) For the commercial risks & mitigation plans, below are the audit procedures:

m
Significant Risks/ Commercial Audit procedures

c. o
Risks

m
.co e m
Significant volatility in the Raw Verify key raw material purchases during the year

m s
material prices w.r.t

a s e i. identify fluctuations in purchase prices and
g la
l a
impact due to spot purchases and reasons for

ag
the excessive spot purchases
ii. Any contracts newly entered into or renewed
with suppliers or delays contacts execution
iii. Compliance to contractual terms - agreed
Rate/Price and volume
Non- availability of ships for Identify delays in delivery of materials and quantify
importing raw materials the impact

CASE STUDY: 3

o m
c
Fintech is generally described as a sector that. leverages technology end-to- end. Fintech
EMERGENCE OF FINTECH

e mcurrent technologies used in the businesses for
s
la to customers.
companies extensively use software and other

g
a when large loans are given and at the same time enjoy
providing automated financial services solutions
Financing business faces higher risk
the reward in the form of interest receipts. The Credit Manager knows that in order to survive
in the market, there has to be a proper balance between risk and reward and an optimal
decision might maximise the return.
MNO FINTECH LIMITED (MFL) – A NEW STARTUP
MFL was commenced as a start-up company with a view to tap the potential of the financial
services industry. MFL has to subsist in the stiff competing financial world and comply with

o m
c
various regulations. It has a team of enthusiastic and resolute professionals who strive to

m . industry
c. o MFL knows that for the purpose of centralised risk monitoring, the financialsservices
m
achieve excellence.

m e real-time risk
s e a
l given scenario, the
monitoring through automatic data transfer to the regulators and in gthe
a
of the country is heading towards a risk-based supervision regime involving

l a
ag biggest risk would be cyber risk.

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 19 of 37

Page 21

20 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

NEW PRODUCTS
A Fintech Start-up company will have to face the challenges in the form of customer loyalty
and stakeholders' growing expectations. Having these in mind, MFL is launching many new
products. The Chairman of MFL wants the sales manager to evaluate : - i) the efficacy of the
new products especially in the wake of new technology deployed, ii) track whether the controls
are exercised properly by designated individuals who are vested with the power of approving
new modules and iii) highlight issues and potential gaps in the processes.
RISKS AND REWARD
The Chief Financial Officer (CFO) cautioned the management that there might be defaults in
payments by some customers, as the customers would assume that there would be laxity in
controls in the collection mechanism of a Start-up company.
The Chairman of MFL wants to know what are the inherent risks of a fintech start -up company.
Evaluating and assessing governance risks plays a vital role in any organisation. For
achieving the above purpose, a risk appetite framework is to be approved ensuring that
business strategy and financial plans are linked to the same. The Chairman of MFL Is t hinking
of entrusting the above task to appropriate persons.
The management is conscious that a well-managed risk management process helps to resolve
problems when they occur rather than following an impulsive and reactive approach. Having
realised the importance of the checklists of ISO 31000 meant for risk management, the
management requested the manager's assistance in preparing a mandatory report on risk.
They also needed explanation for the concepts : i) risk aware, ii) critical controls and iii)
control weaknesses.
The management likes to take into account the impact of adverse and external conditions
which can be a big threat to the survival of MFL. For this purpose, it would like to select the
scenarios for testing purposes.
TECHNOLOGY PLATFORM FOR ACCOUNTING
The Internal Auditor of MFL, Mr Shreyas, told the management that from an audit and
accounting perspective, the most intensive focus area is the technology platform that is used
for accounting. Operational risks of misstatements in financial reporting would arise as several
types of transactions that have a financial impact are performed in various systems and there
might be inconsistent data in the final reports.
Based on the above, you are requested to answer the following questions:
Multiple Choice Questions
Choose the most appropriate answer from the given options.
(3.1) The approval of the risk appetite framework is expected to be performed by :
(A) The Board of Directors

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 20 of 37

Page 22

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 21

(B) The Risk Committee
(C) The Board of Directors and the Risk Committee jointly

m
c. o
(D) The Chief Risk Officer in consultation with the Risk Committee

m
c. o m
(3.2) The automatic data transfer to the regulators, as discussed in the case study, would be

s e
emsupervision monitoring position
done with respect to which of the following?

s g la
l(B)a Key regulatory compliance position
(A) Key

g a
a (C) Key risk monitoring position
(D) Key risk indicator position
(3.3) The cautioning of the CFO would represent:
(A) Financial risk
(B) Control risk
(C) Technology risk

m
c. o
(D) Process risk

em
(3.4) Which one of the following is the main reason, according to Mr. Shreyas, which would

(A) Co-ordination between businesssand user groups
prevent the data from being inconsistent in final reporting ?

g la
a
(B) On-going supervisory reviews
(C) Periodic master maintenance
(D) Compliance to taxation requirements
(3.5) From the angle of credit risk, the balancing between risk and reward would foremost
entail the Credit Manager to take which of the following decision ?
(A) Measuring probability of default of customers
(B) Studying the behavior of market changes constantly

o m
m (D) Quickness in realisation of collateral c
(2 x 5 =. 10 Marks)
(C) Placing a credit cap for each customer

c. o se
m
em Descriptive questions
l a Start-up company
las a g
(3.6) What is an inherent risk ? Briefly outline the inherent risks of a Fintech

ag like MFL. (3 Marks)
(3.7) You are required to suggest solutions to the sales manager for his evaluation exercise .
(3 Marks)

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 21 of 37

Page 23

22 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

(3.8) You are requested to help the management in its scenario selection for testing purposes
and also apprise them of the drawbacks of the same. (4 Marks)
(3.9) What would be the explanation of the manager to the management on the three concepts
and the important aspects of risk reporting which the manager must include in his report
on the subject ? (5 Marks)
Answer to Case Study 3
3.1 (A)
3.2 (D)
3.3 (A)
3.4 (B)
3.5 (C)
3.6 Inherent risk means the risk as it stands assuming there is no control to mitigate it.
Inherent Risks of a Fintech Start-up company:
• Competition in industry
• Complying with regulations
• Challenges in the form of customer loyalty and stakeholders’ growing expectations.
• Cyber risks
Alternative Solution of this subpart
Inherent Risks of a Fintech Start-up like MFL can be as follows:
(a) Cyber Risk
(b) Governance Risk
(c) Model Risk
(d) Operational Risk
3.7 (i) Second line of defence: Perform risk assessment of new products, services and
processes, especially in instances where new technology is being deployed.
(ii) First line of defence: Operations department often has a detailed set of process
notes that assign control steps to designated individuals, and also a method of
measuring / tracking if the controls were exercised properly.
(iii) Third line of defence: An effective internal audit would highlight issues and
potential gaps in processes, which were missed by the first two lines of defence as
well.
Alternative Solution
Solutions to the Sales Manager for his evaluation exercise:

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 22 of 37

Page 24

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 23

(i) The efficacy of the new products Refer the Report of Operational Risk
especially in the wake of new Manager.

m
technology deployed

m c. o
co
(ii) Tracking whether the controls are Developing a formal RCSA System.

. e m
exercised properly by designated

e m
individuals who are vested with the

la s
s g
power of approving new modules.

l a a
a3.8g The identification of relevant stress events requires the opinions of all relevant experts
(iii) Highlighting issues and potential Referring Internal Audit Report.
gaps in the processes.

such as risk managers, economists, business managers, and traders.
Stress Testing should include business cycle stresses as well as event specific tail risks.
For example, markets with low historical volatility may experience large discrete
movements, the scenario in such a case should reflect the potential interaction of market
risk, trading liquidity risk, and credit risk for corporate bonds.

m
Effective scenario analysis should take into account how events unfold over time.

c. o
Scenarios should also address correlations between risk factors and distinguish between

em
static and dynamic scenarios—i.e., one-period versus multi period frameworks.

s
la part of the management culture and have a
Forward looking stress and scenario tests must specify length, speed and magnitudes of

g
events and should describe dynamics between transactions. If the scenarios are well

a decisions.
developed, they can form an integral
meaningful impact on business
Alternative Solution to this Subpart
Scenario analysis can help management in its scenario selection for testing purposes
because to look at their businesses downside movement which can either be because of
a stress event or a downturn scenario. This analysis helps firms to analyse any stressful
situation which may or may not have happened in the past. It has been used for years.
Scenarios are basically sequence or development of events which start from one set of

m
assumptions to evaluate or map various outcomes of a particular situation.

m .c o
c. o
Drawbacks of Scenario Analysis

m
e could easily
s
With a small number of risk factors, the number of alternative scenarios is manageable.

s em l a
As the number of risk factors increases, the number of alternative scenarios

la g
Another drawback of Scenario Analysis is that it assumes thatathe scenarios are equally
become unmanageable.

ag probable. This ignores the correlations between the risk factors. Although stress testing
does allow risk managers to identify major risks, it is subjective in deciding how serious
the risks are. The risk manager could generate an ever larger number of scenarios and

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 23 of 37

Page 25

24 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

uncover more extreme events. But these potential losses might not be significant.
Implausible losses might be considered and plausible losses might not be discovered.
3.9 Explanation of the manager to the management on the three concepts is as follows:
(i) Risk Aware: Scattered silo based approach to risk management. Risks identified
within functions and not across processes. Also risks not communicated across
enterprise.
(ii) Critical controls: Set of controls that are designed to prevent a significant risk from
happening.
Or
A critical control can be defined as a control which can be applied and is essential
to prevent or eliminate a hazard risk or reduce it to an acceptable level.
(iii) Control weaknesses: Deficiency or failure in the implementation or effectiveness of
an internal control.
Or
A control weakness is a failure in the implementation or effectiveness of control
measures.
Risk Reporting encompasses following aspects:
• Reporting of principal or material risk factors and responsibility for mitigating
such risk factors
• Clear categorisation of risks into company specific or general/ industry related
• Ordering or numbering the risks so that investor understand the risk priorities
• Movement of risks from previous reporting periods showing the context and
cause for such changes
• Risk linkages to financial statements, other important parts of the Annual
Report
• Impact of risks on financial and non-financial matters
• Indictive risk appetite of the company as it may be difficult to quantify
• Short term Liquidity and Long-term Business Viability reporting
• Stress and Sensitivity analysis with specific scenarios linking back to principal
risk factors
Alternative Answer to this Subpart
Further the important aspects of risk reporting which the manager must include in
his report on the Risk Management are as follows:

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 24 of 37

Page 26

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 25

• Risk appetite, tolerance and constraints
• Risk architecture and risk escalation procedures
m
m c. o
• Risk aware culture currently in place

c o m
• .Significant risks and key risk indicators e
• Risk assessment arrangements and protocols

m la s
se• Critical controls and control weaknesses
la • Sources of assurance available to the Board a g
ag
CASE STUDY 4
FACTS OF THE CASE
The whole world is battling against energy crisis. The focus now is more on effectively utilizing
non-fossil fuel as a source of energy. India, with the highest band of average annual solar
radiation, which is very much conducive in manufacturing electricity, based on solar cell
technology. The requirements of this type of industry necessitates procuring good quality
m
co
materials at a low price, reliable manufacturing quality, greater levels of automation, and

.
em
employing highly trained staff members.

a s
ABC SOLAR LIMITED (ASL)

g l
a
ASL was formed five years before and is one the leading manufacturer of solar cells which go
as input to various types of solar panel production.
The modern business environment is increasingly throwing up newer challenges. At the same
time many opportunities are presented especially with globalization. Newer challenges and the
ensuing risks are to be suitably met with a dynamic risk management. Internal auditors play a
vital role in achieving the same.
RISK MEASURES AND GOVERNANCE
The plants manager has decided to incorporate several risk-control measures in its manufacturing

o m
processes, which would eventually prevent losses from faulty/incomplete processes.

m .c
c. o m
The management had an apprehension that, in future, if ASL's strategy becomes less effective

m s econtains a larger
in the marketplace the same might result in struggling to reach its goals.

s e concept of Risk Management and Internal Control is a sub-set g
l a
a
The risk manager explained to the Board that Governance structure of ASL

l a
ag
of the same. Normally,
organisations face a wide range of internal and external uncertainties which may affect the
attainment of their objectives, viz., strategic, operational, financial etc., either positively or
negatively. While Positive Risks are opportunities, the Negative Risks are threats to the
achievement of objectives.

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 25 of 37

Page 27

26 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

EFFECTIVENESS OF INTERNAL CONTROL (IC)
He explained to the Board the need for IC and who in turn asked him to prepare a report on
how the IC would help ASL in its efficient use of resources and thereby improve its
performance.
The finance manager understands the need to have preventive, detective, and corrective
(PDC) controls in its transaction approval and processing. Apart from above, he wants to
embed specific categories of controls in it before, during and after processing of a transaction
exceeding a particular value.
The Board also instructed the risk manager to work on Risk Mitigation Plan (RMP) for ASL and
to suggest activities to enhance the role of internal audit for better risk management.
IMPORT OF GOODS AND FORWARD CONTRACT
ASL intends to import some goods from Country A. The exporter from that country is unknown
to ASL. Hence the exporter needs an assurance from ASL that it will pay the exporter the sum
of money due on such export. In order to fulfil the obligation of the exporter, ASL approached
its banker to solve the issue.
On 12th January 2022, the Banker booked a forward contract for US$ 2,10,000 for ASL's
import deliverable on 12 th March 2022 at ` 76.156. On due date, ASL requested the Banker to
cancel the contract. On this date, quotation for spot rate for US$ in the inter-bank market is
` 75.9800/7985.
ESTIMATE OF SALES
The sales manager wants to estimate the northern region sales for the next year, which he
finds to be uncertain. He knows that the same cannot be easily predicted due to the
intervention of many variables that act randomly and depends on possible different outcomes
of uncertain events.
Based on the above, you are requested to answer the following questions :
Multiple Choice Questions
Choose the most appropriate answer from the given options.
(4.1) Which of the following simulation method that you would suggest to the sales manager in
his estimation ?
(A) Discrete Event Simulation
(B) Bootstrap Simulation
(C) Continuous Simulation
(D) Monte Carlo Simulation

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 26 of 37

Page 28

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 27

(4.2) ASL is already having some risk management activities running. It wants to leverage the
same to build on the Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) blocks and activities. Which of

m
the following function can effectively be utilised for the same ?

o m
(A) Stand-alone staff function
c. o
c
. process function e m
s
(B) Internal audit function

e m la
(D)s Stakeholders risk management function g
(C) Operational

g a
lThe measure of the plants manager would fall under : a
a (A) Risk Identification
(4.3)

(B) Risk Analysis
(C) Risk Ranking
(D) Risk Treatment
(4.4) Supposing, if the apprehension of the management becomes true, then ASL most likely

m
would be facing :

. co
(A) Management risks

em
(B) Market risks
(C) Model risks
l a s
(D) Governance risks
a g
(4.5) The banker in solving the issue of ASL, would most likely recommend which of the
following facility to ASL ?
(A) Bank Guarantee
(B) Letter of Credit
(C) Pre-shipment Credit
(D) Post-shipment Credit. (2 x 5 = 10 Marks)

o m
c
Descriptive questions

m .
c. o m
(4.6) Briefly explain internal control in relation with Risk Management, to the Risk Manager,

m
which would assist him in preparing his report to the Board.
s e which could (3 Marks)

s e be embedded in the transaction processing approval processes. gl
a
(4.7) You are required to suggest and explain the controls to the finance manager

l a a
ag
(3 Marks)
(4.8) Assuming that the flat charge for the cancellation is ` 200 and exchange margin is
0.11%, then determine the cancellation charges payable by ASL to the Banker on the
forward contract booked by the Banker. (4 Marks)

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 27 of 37

Page 29

28 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

(4.9) (i) Explain the analysis which will provide valuable input to the Risk Manager for
preparation of an RMP for ASL. (2 Marks)
(ii) What vital responsibilities the internal auditor of ASL should have in the field of risk
management, and explain how he will proceed to provide his assurance in this
respect ? (3 Marks)
Answer to Case Study 4
4.1 (D)
4.2 (B)
4.3 (C)
4.4 (C)
4.5 (B)
4.6 The task of IC is to help organisations achieve compliance, reporting and operations
goals and objectives. So, IC is basically a component of risk management. And, internal
control complements ERM. The ERM is basically a top down approach to Risk
Management. It’s focus is broader and aims at reducing risks that affect the entire
enterprise. On the other hand, internal control provides a bottom-up approach and it
complements ERM by doing an in-depth assessment of agency’s business processes, its
specific risks, and how those risks are being controlled.
IC includes activities designed to help organizations achieve compliance, reporting and
operations goals and objectives. Part of doing so requires that management consider the
risk to those objectives – so it is inherently a component of risk management. But IC
complements ERM; each raises the value of the other. For example, ERM helps in
developing the objective used as a basis for developing controls, while IC makes ERM
more effective when control activities are in place over risk responses and other ERM
processes.
Alternative Solution
Risk Management is a larger concept and internal control is a sub-set of Risk
Management. Both subjects fall under the mega-concept of Governance. The pictorial
depiction of the three concepts is as under: -

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 28 of 37

Page 30

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 29

Generally, organizations face a wide range of uncertain internal and external
uncertainties that may affect achievement of their objectives which can be strategic,

m
operational, financial or otherwise and effect of these uncertainties on their objectives

m c. o
can be a Positive or a Negative Risks. While Positive Risks are opportunities the

co m
Negative Risks are threats to the achievement of objectives.

m . s e
e la
Both Risk Management and IC works together as on one hand the Risk Management

s g
mainly focuses on identification of threats and opportunities, on the other hand IC assist

l a a
ag Proper
in countering threats and taking advantage of opportunities.
Risk Management and IC hand in hand assist organizations in to effectively
pursue their objectives by making informed decisions about the level of risk that they
want to take and implementing the necessary controls.
Accordingly, it can be said that both Risk management and IC are important pillars for
governance, management, and operations of an organization’s. Further to be a
successful organization it is essential to integrate effective governance structures and
processes along with performance-focused risk management and internal control at
every level as well as across all operations of an organization.

m
co
4.7 (a) Verification: Refers to a control where a control step necessitates the transaction is

.
verified by either the same individual or a different individual before it is completed.

em
For example, in a financial lending institution, a department may process an

a s
application along with the customer documents and carry out a verification at the

l
g
end of the process within the department, before passing the file to the other

a
department for further processing that relies on the accuracy of the earlier
department’s processing.
(b) Segregation of duties: Refers to a control where part of the transaction is executed
across two segregated departments / functions / verticals thereby eliminating the
risk of the originating department to carry out the entire transactio n on its own. For
example, in a finance lending organisation, the process of sourcing an application is
owned by Sales department, while the credit process is completely segregated into
the Risk department, and further, the entire operational process of checking the

m
accuracy and completeness of the processed application documentation may lie

c o
with Operations who would actually set up the account and make the disbursement.
m (c) Supervisory control: Refers to a control where the primary transaction ./ process i s
c. o executed at a particular level in an organisation, but before e
s
m it, the
em a this is also
finalising

s anl authority superior to
classified as Authorisation if the authorisation is given by g
la
supervisor is required to review it and accord an approval. Sometimes

g the one originating the transaction. Often, where thea primary control is MIS
a (Management Information System) such review based controls fall under
supervisory control category.

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 29 of 37

Page 31

30 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

(d) Exception triggers: Refers to a control where a system, or a responsible indiv idual,
throws up regular reports of transactions which are deviant from the accepted,
established process. These reports are expected to be actioned upon by designated
individuals. This control type is effective only when the process has achieved a
stability and scale that only deviations are reviewed by authorities. For example,
reporting of error rate in an operational process is an exception trigger. Or, reporting
of a high balance in a suspense account beyond the usual acceptable levels can be
an exceptional report item.
(e) Authorisation/ approval: Refers to a control step where, after a processing of a
transaction basis built in controls is almost complete, a final authority reviews it and
approves it. For example, there are several organisations use automated or semi-
automated credit decision tools in a financial lending process. However, as per
selected parameters, a credit officer may be designated to review the system -based
processing and approve it as well.
Alternative Solution
Following controls could be embedded in the transaction processing approval processes:
(i) Preventive Controls: These controls attempt to prevent the inherent risk from
materializing into a failure.
(ii) Detective Controls: These controls are built in to analyze the process / transactions
post-facto and throw up issues and exceptions.
(iii) Manual Controls: These controls are exercised by a designated role in a manual
fashion. For example, a verification of customer documents in a credit application,
done manually, is a manual control.
(iv) Automated Controls: These controls are dependent on a predefined system check.
4.8 Bank will sell US$ to ASL at an agreed rate of ` 76.156.
Since this is a sale contract by the bank the contract shall be cancelled at ready buying
rate on the date of cancellation as follows.
Spot Buying rate on 12 th March, 2022 ` 75.7985
Less: Exchange Margin @ 0.11% ` 0.0834
` 75.7151
Rounded off to ` 75.7150
Dollars sold to ASL at ` 76.1560
Dollars bought from ASL at ` 75.7151

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 30 of 37

Page 32

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 31

Net amount payable by customer per US$ ` 0.4409
or ` 0.4410

m
m c. o
Amount payable by the ASL

c o
. Charges (` 0.4409) × US$ 2,10,000) e m
s
Flat Charges ` 200

e m la
s
Cancellation ` 92,589

a
lOr a g
g
` 92,789

a
Flat Charges ` 200
Cancellation Charges (` 0.4410 × US$ 2,10,000) ` 92,610
` 92,810
4.9 (i) Once we have identified, analysed and evaluated the risks, the next step is to rank
them in order of priority. Effective risk management involves prioritization and
thorough analysis of the risk factors based on probabilistic models which can be

m
co
directly related to the extent of impact of the risk.

.
Likewise, prioritizing stakeholders by authority and degrees of involvement and

em
levels of risk threats are necessary. This analysis will provide valuable input to a

l a s
risk mitigation plan so that more resources and attention are paid to the

Alternative Solutions ag
stakeholders who pose or face the greatest risk to the project.

Business Impact Analysis (BIA) will provide valuable input to the Risk Manager for
preparation of an RMP for ASL.
(ii) Internal Auditors of ASL will have following vital areas of responsibility in the field of
risk management:
• Review operations, policies, and procedures.
•
m
Help ensure that goals and objectives are met.

m
• Understanding the “big picture” and diverse operations.
.c o
c. o • Make recommendations to improve economy and efficiency.
s
m
e risks of the
s em a
organisation and the assurance is on these risks being lmanaged within the
ggive this assurance, the
The internal audit report is on the management of significant

gla a
a
acceptable limits as laid down by the Board of Directors. To
internal auditor conducts a process audit on risk management processes at all
levels of the organisation, viz., corporate, divisional, business unit, business
process level, etc., put in place by line management so as to assess the adequacy
of their design and compliance.

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 31 of 37

Page 33

32 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

CASE STUDY 5
EMERGING OPPORTUNITIES IN LiB RESOURCE RECOVERY BUSINESS
The key value drivers of Lithium-ion battery (LiB) resource recovery business (i) the electric
vehicle (EV) revolution, (ii) the supply shortage of strategic battery materials, and (iii) the need
for a truly sustainable environmental, social, and governance ("ESG") -friendly LiB recycling
solution.
It is expected that the recycling process can make a valuable contribution to the worl d's
transition to renewable energy sources, by diverting end-of-life LiB materials from landfill sites,
offering environmentally-friendly alternative processing methods, and providing a steady
source of recycled content into the battery supply chain.
ABOUT XMC
XMC (hereinafter also referred as 'the company') is a leading player in LiB resource (metals
like cobalt, nickel, lithium graphite, etc.) recovery. The Company has recently developed
proprietary recycling technology, however it is yet to be commercially tested on a large scale.
The pilot project has provided very encouraging results. Using this technology the company
has been able to recover 90% of the metals in the pilot project as against the 50% traditional
industry average.
The Company has two sources of revenue namely the sale of recovered metals and e-waste
collection charges. The focus of the Company is on the sale of recovered metals as it is highly
profitable.
EXPANSION PLANS OF XMC
The market demand for LiB is very high and hence there is a big opportunity for recyclers like
XMC. Currently, China controls the supply chain of LiB. In the changed geo -political scenario
especially after the war between Russia and Ukraine the Company believes its technology can
disrupt the existing supply chain. Considering this, the Company has a plan for a global
footprint. To support its aggressive growth plan, it has already raised money in the form of
equity in the capital market and has a plan to fund the establishment of plants with a mix of
equity and debt. The Company's second plant is likely to become operational in early 2023.
CONCERNS RELATING TO EXPANSION PLANS OF XMC
Expanding globally involves political risks which were not part of the Risk Management of
XMC. There is a plan to outsource the HR function in the Company. The Management of XMC
has identified that the performance of the company in the future would depend upon many
factors including:
(i) Effectively introduce methods for higher recovery rates,
(ii) Complete the construction of its planned plants on time and within the cost budgeted
for this purpose,

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 32 of 37

Page 34

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 33

(iii) Invest and keep pace in technology, research and development efforts and ensure
compliance of IPR regulatory regime,

m
c. o
(iv) Secure and maintain required suppliers' contracts and off-take contracts and

m
c. o m
(v) Attract and retain key employees who possess specialized knowledge and technical
skills.
m BY XMC s e
s e l a
of the listing requirements and to meet the expectation of stakeholders, the Companyag
STEPS TAKEN

l a
g established Enterprise Risk Management (ERM). Recently a consultant was hired who
ahas
In terms

reviewed the Business Continuity Plan (BCP) and carried out a Business Impact Analysis
(BIA).
The CRO recognized that the Company faces heightened strategic and operational risk -
which is why comprehensive Risk and Control Self-Assessments (RCSAs) were carried out as
a first step in mitigating these risks. In addition to this, the CRO makes a presentation to the
Board about stress tests for various positions taken by the Company.
It was decided that the money raised in the capital market and raised by the promoters will be
m
co
used in the business over the next two years. A large portion of the promoter's money has

.
been invested in short-term liquid investments which are exposed to market risks. Further,

em
battery metal prices are volatile and hence they too are prone to hedging using derivatives.

l a s
The treasurer has used many derivatives instruments to hedge market risk.
FURTHER ACTION POINTS
a g
The Board has expressed its desire to have a fresh review from the external consultant
regarding the roles and responsibilities of the CRO considering the rising complexities in the
business. Currently, the company also has a corporate- level risk steering committee.
Multiple Choice Questions
Choose the most appropriate answer from the given options.
(5.1) Which one of the following is incorrect with respect to essential actions to be taken to

m
write a BCP ?

m
(A) Conducting a hazard identification of surface area threats.
c o
. the
c. o m
e lost. a loss
(B) Assessing those risks to determine their frequency and history and prioritizing
s
em l a
ones most likely to have at least a moderate impact, and conducting

las g
estimation to see what the business can withstand and what could be
(C) Thinking through a business impact analysis based ona the first three essential
ag actions.
(D) Deciding what losses will be acceptable but not identifying a means to reduce those
losses.

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 33 of 37

Page 35

34 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

(5.2) Which one of the following is not correct with respect to Business Impact Analysis (BIA) ?
(A) BIA is an analysis is used to quantify the financial value of each function to the
business and to identify the risks to the most valuable functions.
(B) BIA does not suggest mitigation actions to reduce the likelihood of risks.
(C) In the event of a disaster, the BIA indicates how much is lost per hour or per day for
the length of the outage. Many of these functions are linked to an IT system that
supports them.
(D) BIA provides many benefits to an organization, many of which are valuable beyond
the scope of a BCP.
(5.3) Which one of the following is not correct regarding the primary objectives of RCSA ?
(A) The reliability and integrity of information.
(B) Compliance with policies, plans, procedures, laws, regulations, and contracts.
(C) The safeguarding of assets.
(D) The economic and efficient use of resources is not the primary objective of RSCA.
(5.4) Which of the following is incorrect regarding political risk ?
(A) It concerns those political and social developments that can have an impact upon
the value or repatriation of foreign investment or on the repayment of cross -border
lending.
(B) It includes arbitrary or discriminatory actions taken by governments, political groups,
or individuals that hurt trade or investment transactions.
(C) It is more related to trade and investment risk.
(D) It is more related to country risk.
(5.5) Which one of the following is incorrect regarding ERM ?
(A) It includes strategic risks.
(B) It includes operational risks.
(C) It includes hazard/ compliance risks.
(D) It does not include financial reporting risk. (2 x 5 = 10 Marks)
Descriptive Questions
(5.6) What is the goal of stress testing? Should the stress test consider the interplay of market
and credit risk? Give a reasoned answer. (4 Marks)

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 34 of 37

Page 36

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 35

(5.7) The purpose of using derivatives is the management of market risk. However, while
addressing market risk the use of derivatives exposes XMC to other risks. Identify the

m
c. o
four risks which arise as a result of the use of derivatives for managing market risks.

m
c. o
(2 Marks)

e m
em as
(5.8) What are the examples of strategic risks in the Case Study ? (2 Marks)

s (7 Marks) gl
la to Case Study 5
(5.9) Assuming you are hired by the Board for defining key responsibilities of the CRO and its

g
office, what would be your suggestions ?
a
a
Answer
5.1 (D)
5.2 (B)
5.3 (D)
5.4 (C) or (D)
5.5 (D)

m
5.6 Goals of Stress Testing:
•
. co
Binding Constraint – Stress test results have become the binding constraint for

em
evaluating capital adequacy and the key driver of dividend policy for many
institutions.
l a s
•
a g
Management attention – Given its linkage to dividend payments, as well as the
governance requirements demanded by regulators, stress testing has the attention
of senior management and the board of directors.
• Intuition – Many users find stress results to be more intuitive than other risk metrics
because they are presented in an accounting framework, similar to other external
communications regarding the institution’s financial condition.
• Transparency – As outcomes are linked to casual factors in stress testing, such
results are also more transparent and easier to understand than other risk metrics

m
co
(such as economic capital).

m .
c. o
• Consistency – The enterprise wide stress testing usually piggybacks the budgeting
m
se
and planning process, which gives a degree of consistency with the inputs and

em la
approaches accepted already in a well established process.

las g
Stress in market situations can usually cause counterparty riska(credit risk). It may have
Yes, Stress tests should consider the interplay of market and credit risk.

ag more negative impacts than pure market impacts. For example, in a market neutral swap
portfolio, a significant movement in interest rate will have more impact along with default
of the counterparty on their contractual obligations. While small market moves will not

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 35 of 37

Page 37

36 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022

have much impact on market rates and credit worthiness but large market movements
can cause worse credit events and vice-versa.
5.7 (a) Valuation Risk: Derivative prices valuation may change due to changes in interest
rates, foreign exchange rates and other factors which have relation to the volatility
of the rates.
(b) Liquidity risk: Counterparties may have liquidity crunch which may make it difficult
to close the derivative contract or offset the contract.
(c) Counterparty risk: The counterparty may refuse or not settle the obligations for full
value either on due date or any future time.
(d) Settlement risk: It is a risk that the transaction gets settled without receiving the
value of the contract from the counterparty.
5.8 • Risks in connection with decisions about outsourcing.
• Risks concerning innovation and R&D and infringement of IPR regulations.
• Risks concerning new sources of finance.
• Risks concerning the likelihood of achieving organisational objectives or destroying
shareholder value.
Alternative Solution
In the changed geo-political scenario especially after the war between Russia and
Ukraine the Company believes its technology can disrupt the existing supply chain.
5.9 Key responsibilities of the CRO and CRO Office are:
(a) has the organisational stature, skill set, authority, and character needed to oversee
and monitor the firm’s risk management and related processes and to ensure that
key management and board constituents are apprised of the firm’s risk profile and
relevant risk issues on a timely and regular basis; the CRO should have a direct
reporting line to the CEO and a distinct role from other executive functions and
business line responsibilities as well as a direct reporting line to the board and/or
risk committee;
(b) meets periodically with the board and risk committee without executive directors or
management present;
(c) is appointed and dismissed with input or approval from the risk committee or the
board and such appointments and dismissals are disclosed publicly;
(d) is independent of business lines and has the appropriate stature in the firm as
his/her performance, compensation and budget is reviewed and approved by the
risk committee;

© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 36 of 37

Page 38

m
m .co
c. o

e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6A: RISK MANAGEMENT 37

(e) is responsible for ensuring that the risk management function is adequately
resourced, taking into account the complexity and risks of the firm as well as its

m
Risk Assessment Framework (RAF) and strategic business plans;

m c. o
co
(f) is actively involved in key decision-making processes from a risk perspective (e.g.,

. e m
the review of the business strategy/strategic planning, new product approvals,

e m
stress testing, recovery and resolution planning, mergers and acquisitions, funding

la s
s g
and liquidity management planning) and can challenge management’s decisions

l a a
ag (g)(h) ismeets,
and recommendations;
involved in the setting of risk-related performance indicators for business units;
at a minimum quarterly, with the firm’s supervisor to discuss the scope and
coverage of the work of the risk management function.

m
. co
s em
g l a
a

m
m .co
c. o se
m
s em g la
gla a
a

m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 37 of 37

Document Details

Board / OrgICAI
ExamICAI CA
TypeSolution
Pages38
Languageenglish
Updated23 Oct 2026

More from ICAI

ICAI CA