Page 1
FOR CA FINAL EXAM PREPARATION
CA Final 2022
Suggested Answers ·
Paper 5 Strategic Cost
Management and
Performance
Evaluation (Old
Scheme)
EXAM YEAR TYPE
CA Final 2022 Suggested Answers
SUBJECT
Paper 5 Strategic Cost Management and Performance Evaluation (Old Scheme)
DATE
May 2022
Notes · Sample Papers · Previous Year Papers · Mock Tests
Page 2
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION
Question No.1 is compulsory.
m
.co
Candidates are also required to answer any
m
co m
four questions from the remaining five questions.
m . Working notes should form part of the respective answers.
s e
s e g l a
l a
gElectronics Limited is a well-established manufacturing company manufactures household
Question 1 a
aAB
electronic gadgets like Air Conditioners, Refrigerators, Washing Machines etc. and almost all
types of kitchen appliances. Company's main motto is to maintain the quality, for the said
purpose company follows Total Quality management (TQM). It is well known for its quality
products. In terms of quality, goodwill of the company is very high. As company never
compromises in quality, customers trust in company's product. Company is also able to charge
good prices from customers due to their quality and brand name.
The management of AB Electronics Limited has pointed out that since last two years company's
m
co
sales are decreasing continuously. Customers are not showing interest in their products and
.
company is going on at par despite of good quality products and brand name, company is not
em
able to create its products demand. Company investigated its internal departments to see
a s
whether there is an issue of quality. They spend an extra amount of 1% of its cost on testing the
l
g
products for their quality check and also make a test check on inward and outward materials.
a
As a result of all these, company found that everything is as per its standard.
To resolve this problem, company decided to decrease its selling price for various products so
that demand can be increased. In view of this company has decreased its selling price by 5%
but decrease in selling price does not affect much. As company has a good name in the market
and well known in the market increase in marketing and advertisement expenses is also no t
justified. Human resources of company are also satisfied with company's policies for them.
Company has a good relationship with the workers and also pay a handsome remuneration to
them. Internal working atmosphere of company is up to standard and workers work as team
m
members and there are no issues with unions and company employs skilled workers.
m c. o
Management of company is not able to find out the problem as to why their sales are decreasing
c. o e m
despite of good quality and at best prices, so, they decided to appoint a team of experts to point
em a s
out the problem. The experts team investigate the internal procedures as well as make surveys
s l
ag
of market and also take feedback from customers, then they observe that now a days in modern
la
era there are products with new artificial intelligence which makes life easy. They are easy to
ag use and more efficient and also energy savers and have all features to attract customers and
provide more value for money to customer. In modern urban life fully automatic electronic
devices which requires fewer human efforts & time and operates on artificial intelligence are
preferred. People are more interested in products which they can operate at remote locations
using wireless fidelity.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 1 of 35
Page 3
2 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
Observations of the expert team are as follows:
1. Products of AB Electronics Limited are not as per latest technology and company is
repeatedly manufacturing the same product since its inception.
2. AB Electronics Limited's products are not based on wireless fidelity technology and not
much user friendly.
3. To maintain the quality and durability AB Electronics Limited uses heavy materials
demanding large space and extra weight.
According to the expert's team:
The company is doing well m internal processes and also working atmosphere is good and
became a fame since last two decades and also follows TQM to some extent but as you know
"Change is the law of world" but you have not updated your products with technology and
pushing the company with outdated technology without considering the long-term sustainability.
Quality matter much but features also matters. To resume your position back in the market you
need to spend on R&D not on advertisement or test check. If company manufactures goods with
latest technology and according to modem era's need, it may beat its competitors because of
its goodwill and brand name. So, we suggest you to update your processes and manufacture
products with latest technology having easy to use and energy efficient features.
As management of AB Electronics Limited has to be spend a huge amount and efforts to get
back its position in the market, company wants to seek your opinion.
You are required:
(a) As per strategic position analysis where does the company stand. (2 Marks)
(b) DEMONSTRATE the applicability of Six C'S of TQM in AB Electronics Limited. (6 Marks)
(c) Give your RECOMMENDATION for implementation of Six Sigma techniques in AB
Electronics Limited. (6 Marks)
(d) Currently at which phase of life cycle in AB Electronics Limited product is going on and
also LIST out the uses of product life cycle. (3 Marks)
(e) "Change is the law of world." STATE these words in contrast of this situation. (3 Marks)
Answer
(a) Strategic Positioning of AB Electronics Ltd.
AB Electronics Limited is losing its high ranking, established position in the market
due to its inability to keep pace with the impact of technological advances in its
product range, now a days customers desires modern era products with artificial
intelligence which is clearly a lack of understanding the external environment.
In addition, the observations of the expert team state that the products are not up-to-date
technologically which means they are not having abilities, resources or latest skills that
enable them to adopt technology. They obviously failed to invest in resources which are
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 2 of 35
Page 4
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 3
vital for success in business. However, company is having up to standard working
atmosphere and a force of skilled workers which will make a smooth way for updation
m
of new strategy.
o m .co
Therefore, it is apparent that current strategy of AB Electronics is not a suitable fit with
c
. position” is concerned with the impact on strategy of the external environment, em
the strategic position.
m
e resourcesof theandenvironment, l a s
s
The “strategic
lacultural and political framework of the organisation provides a basis for understanding the strategic a g
internal competences, and the expectations and influence of stakeholders. Together,
g
a consideration strategic capability, the expectations and the purposes within the
a position of an organisation.
-Johnson and Scholes, 2005
Firstly, organisations need to understand the external environment in terms of PESTEL and
Porter’s 5 forces. Secondly, the company has to consider what customers value in terms of
product feature. In addition, it should consider whether it has resources and competencies to
succeed in the market. Since threshold levels may change over time so the organisations may
need to continue to invest in resources base to simply stay in business. Finally, understanding
the specific political and cultural context in which the organisation operates can have a significant
m
impact on strategy. Such analysis enables the organisation to understand the ease or difficulty
c o
. TQM in AB Electronics Ltd.
with which new strategies could be adopted.
Below are the criteria included in Six e
(b) DEMONSTRATE applicability of Six C’S of
m
la s C’s for successful implementation of Total Quality
Management (TQM):
(i) Commitment: A company
g
a has to be committed to improve quality not just at the
operational level, but all across the organization levels. It is given that AB
Electronics Ltd. does not compromise the quality due to which it has earned the trust
of its customers of many years. This is a clear indication of commitment of AB
Electronics Ltd. to quality.
(ii) Culture: A company must encourage individual contributions towards creativity and
quality improvement. AB Electronics Ltd. has been producing good quality goods, has
a policy of not compromising on quality (main motto), which indicates that it has
m
c. o
a culture that promotes quality control.
m
c. o m
(iii) Continuous Improvement: Total Quality Management is a process that needs to be
s e
em
monitored continuously. A company should always seek ways of improving the
s l a
product. Here, AB Electronics Ltd. has fallen short, in that it manufactured its
la ag
products based on outdated technology. The company did not improve its
ag product features to include the latest features like artificial intelligence,
wireless fidelity, ease of use etc.
(iv) Co-operation: Total Employee Involvement and co-operation is paramount to
develop improvement strategies and associated performance measures. It is given
that AB Electronics Ltd. enjoys good internal working atmosphere, workers work
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s ag
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 3 of 35
Page 5
4 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
as team members and that there are no issues with the unions. The employees
are skilled and hence would be in a position to contribute towards process
improvements where required. This indicates a co-operative and inclusive working
environment.
(v) Customer Focus: Customers are both internal and external customers. Internal
customers would be the employees of the company with whom mutual respect is
necessary to preserve employee morale and employee participation. As mentioned
before, AB Electronics Ltd. has a co-operative and inclusive working environment,
hence the internal customer focus is sufficient.
External customers are the consumers of goods and services. AB Electronics Ltd.
has focused on quality and has earned the goodwill and reputation of the customers
over many years. However, it has not kept itself abreast with the current needs of the
customers. “Quality matters but features also matter”. AB Electronics Ltd. has had
the shortcoming of not upgrading its product features to match the current
requirements of the customer. This has resulted in steady decline in sales despite
producing good quality products. It now has to develop a system to periodically
connect with the customers and the external environment to become aware of
the current needs and trends in the market.
(vi) Control: Documentation, procedures and awareness of current best practices are
essential for proper implementation and functioning of TQM. AB Electronics Ltd.
already has monitoring procedures to maintain quality control of its current
manufacturing methods. Similarly controls have to be created to monitor the
process and procedures following upgradation of its manufacturing process.
(c) RECOMMENDATION for implementation of Six Sigma techniques at AB Electronics Ltd.
DMADV and DMAIC are fundamental six sigma methodologies for improving quality of
product or process.
DMAIC
▪ DMAIC stands for Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve and Control (DMAIC).
▪ It is generally used when a product or process exists and it needs to be improved to
align with customer needs.
▪ It is generally used in scenarios when competitors’ actions are unchanging, customer
behaviour is unchanging and the technology is stable.
▪ Needs of the customers within the market in which the company operates has
changed and is changing constantly. The competitor’s response is very dynamic.
Technology is also constantly changing to suit customer’s needs.
▪ In case of AB Electronics Ltd, the products are outdated and need to be
upgraded substantially to include modern technology using artificial
intelligence. Hence DMAIC will not be suitable for implementation at AB
Electronics Ltd.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 4 of 35
Page 6
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 5
DMADV
▪ DMADV stands for Define, Measure, Analyze, Design and Verify.
m
.co
▪ It is a proactive process where the project has strategic importance.
m
co m
▪ Multiple processes need to be altered.
m .
Consumer behaviour is constantly changing, as is the competitors’ response to this
s e
a
▪
s e dynamic environment.
g l
l a a
ag ▪AB Electronics
▪ Technology is constantly growing.
Hence, products need to be constantly improved and upgraded.
Ltd. operates in such an environment where technology is constantly
changing to suit customers’ needs and hence the company can use DMADV to
implement its Six Sigma Methodologies.
The steps of DMADV include:
(i) Define the project goal.
(ii) Measure and determine the customer’s needs and specifications.
m
c. o
(iii) Analyze process options to meet the customer’s needs.
(v) Verify the design performance and m
(iv) Design the process in detail to meet the customer’s needs.
e
s Ltd. and the uses of product life cycle
a
ability to meet the customer’s needs.
l
bygAB Electronics Ltd. are outdated and hence sales have
(d) Product life cycle at AB Electronics
The products manufactured a
been declining. Customers’ tastes are constantly changing. Given this, the products are
in the Decline Stage of product life cycle. This is the last stage of product life cycle, where
the company would phase out the products or will sell them in limited quantity to a niche
group of customers who still have a demand for it.
The uses of product life cycle are as follows (LIST):
(i) As a Planning tool, it characterizes the marketing challenges in each stage and
m
poses major alternative strategies, i.e. application of kaizen.
m c. o
(ii) As a Control tool, the product life cycle concept allows the company to measure
c. o (iii) As a Forecasting tool, it is less useful because sales historiesem
product performance against similar products launched in the past.
em l a s exhibit diverse
las patterns and the stages vary in duration.
a g
ag (e) STATE- Change is the law of the world
AB Electronics Ltd. is a reputed company manufacturing quality products for which it has
earned enormous goodwill from the market. It has been focused on quality and has
delivered given the existing standards of operations within the company. It does spend on
quality checks and testing. However, the market has been dynamic with changing
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 5 of 35
Page 7
6 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
technology and customer needs. Hence while quality matters, features also matter.
Hence the company has to upgrade its products to modern era requirements for long
term sustainability. The company has to be in constant touch with these dynamics. The
latest technical features need to be incorporated into the product. The company has to
constantly keep a tab on the customers’ current needs. They need to proactively take
steps to address these needs and improve the product offering to the customers. Unless
the company remains nimble to change, the demand for its products is bound to reduce
and eventually the company would have to shut down operations. Hence, “change is the
law of the world”.
▪ Conceptually correct brief explanation is sufficient for each step.
▪ Alternate points and reasoning are also possible.
Question 2
(a) A Limited is manufacturing a part, which is used in computer. Presently the company
follows traditional system of the purchasing, quality check, storage and processing. CEO
of the company has suggested that by implementing Just in time inventory system for
material purchases, the company will benefit a lot. As per present policy of inventory, raw
material required for 2 months production and finished goods equivalent to the 2 weeks
production are kept in stock. Other information are as under:
▪ The Average inventory of raw material is held by the company throughout the year.
Purchase cost of the raw material is ` 15 Crores for the year. Now on applying Just
in time, the company decided to take its production requirement directly from the
suppliers. This will result into an increase of the 10% in the cost of raw material
purchased but will save the inventory holding cost by ` 70 Lakhs. Raw material
inventory insurance will not be required now, which is ` 1.40 Crores per annum.
Savings in other overheads will be ` 20 Lakhs per annum.
▪ Projected production for the year is 2,00,000 Units. The company plans to maintain
inventory of finished goods as per present policy only. There is a possibility of
production stoppages due to unavailability of raw material from the suppliers. This
could happen due to delay in delivery by the suppliers. The labour works in one
8-hour shift per day and will remain idle if there is no material to work on. Due to
stoppage of production for this reason, it is possible to have stockout of 4,000 units
in a year. Stockout represents lost sales opportunity due to unavailability of finished
goods i.e. the customer walks away without purchasing any product. However, if
overtime is done by labour the stockout may reduced to 2,500 units. This overtime
will cost ` 20 Lakhs.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 6 of 35
Page 8
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 7
▪ Currently, sale price is ` 6,000 per unit. Raw material procurement cost is ` 1,000
per unit, that will increase by 10% under just in time inventory system. Other variable
m
overheads are ` 3,250 per unit.
o m .co
Required
.c s em
A. ADVISE on:
(i)m Acceptability of the company regarding implementation of the Just in time
s e procurement system. (4 Marks) la
l a a g
ag B. RECOMMEND factors that the management needs to consider before implementing the
(ii) Necessity of overtime cost be incurred to reduce Stockout. (2 Marks)
just in time procurement system. (4 Marks)
(b) ORAL LTD. is engaged in marketing of wide range of electronic goods. The area is divided
in four zones - North, South, East and West. Each zone has zonal sales head. The
company fixes annual sales target for zonal heads. The cost of sales target fixed during
2021 is as under:
North ` 25,00,000
m
. co
South ` 22,00,000
em
East ` 26,50,000
West ` 20,00,000
l a s
a g
The Zonal sales managers are paid commission @ 10% on sales made by them. During
2021 the sales commission paid for each zone is as under:
North ` 3,00,000
South ` 2,90,000
East ` 3,10,000
West ` 2,40,000
The summary of the variances calculated for each zone are as under:
m
c. o
Particulars North South East West
m
c. o m
Sales Price Variance 40,000 F 60,000 A 50,000 A 20,000 A
s e
em
Sales Volume Variance 60,000 A 2,60,000 F 1,50,000 F 80,000 F
s l a
ag
Sales Margin Mix Variance 1,40,000 A 80,000 F 1,70,000 F 30,000 A
gla The Company wants to award an incentive to the best performer among all the zonal
a managers on the basis of:
1. Contribution earned to the company
2. Achievement of the sales target.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s ag
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 7 of 35
Page 9
8 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
3. Sales margin achieved against target margin.
Required
(A) CALCULATE the amount of sales target fixed and the actual amount of contribution
earned in case of each of the zonal sales manager. (5 Marks)
(B) ANALYZE the overall performance of these zonal sales managers taking three
relevant base factors and recommend the best performer. (4 + 1 = 5 Marks)
Answer
(a) (i) ADVISE
Implementing Just in time procurement system will benefit the company as
explained below:
Total Purchase Cost of raw material is `15 Crores for the year at procurement cost
of ` 1,000 per unit, therefore quantity purchased would be 1,50,000 units. For
projected production of 2,00,000 units a similar number of units of raw material
would be needed equivalent to 33.33…% increase in current levels. Therefore Raw
material procurement cost under current policy (traditional system) for the projected
production would be 20 Crores.
Changes in level of production would also have impact on inventory holding cost, raw
material insurance and may also on other overheads. But nothing has been specified.
Therefore, in the absence of information about the quantum of change in these costs
due to change in production level, same costs have been taken (alternatively
proportionate changes or say an increase of 33.33% in these costs may be taken).
Particulars Current JIT Additional Inflow/
Purchasing Procurement (Outflow) in JIT
Policy (` ) System (` ) System (` )
Projected Production Level 2,00,000 units 2,00,000 units 2,00,000 units
Raw material procurement cost 20,00,00,000 22,00,00,000 (2,00,00,000)
Inventory handling cost (No 70,00,000 --- 70,00,000
longer required in JIT)
Insurance Cost on raw material 1,40,00,000 --- 1,40,00,000
inventory (No longer required in JIT)
Other Overheads (No longer 20,00,000 --- 20,00,000
required in JIT)
Overtime charges (note 1) --- 20,00,000 (20,00,000)
Stockout Cost (note 1) --- 41,25,000 (41,25,000)
Total Relevant Cost 22,30,00,000 22,61,25,000 (31,25,000)
Note1 - JIT involves the possibility of stockout of 4,000 units in a year and thus lost sales
opportunity. However, stockout may be reduced to 2,500 units by doing overtime. As such
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 8 of 35
Page 10
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 9
while calculating the viability of implementation of the JIT procurement system, overtime work
is taken into account, since it is beneficial for the company as shown in (ii).
m
Out of the total shortfall of 4,000 units, by spending on overtime 1,500 units of demand can
.co
be met. Therefore, actual stockout units is only 2,500 units. Contribution per unit is ` 1,650
m
c. o
per unit. Therefore, stockout cost = 2,500 units × ` 1,650 per unit = ` 41,25,000.
Itm
ADVISE on implementation of JIT Procurement System
s em
s esystem. Relevant Cost in JIT procurement system is `22,61,25,000 against Cost gla
is apparent that company is incurring slightly higher cost in JIT procurement
g la of ` 22,30,00, 000 under traditional costing system. Raw material procurementa
a cost under JIT has been increased at a rate of 10% irrespective of production volume
which is the main contributor for cost under JIT system along with stockout cost.
It is important to note that, by switching over to JIT system, company can save
working capital requirement of `3.33... crore (`20 crore×2/12) on account of average
inventory of raw material held at present. However, a return above equal to 9.375%
and above would be needed on long term investment to justify the JIT procurement
policy. Since a return on 9.375% on `3.33… crore will save `31,25,000 which is the
indifference point to make the decision.
m
. co
In addition to the financial factors discussed, it has to consider non- financial
em
factors as well before taking any final call on JIT for instance reliability of supplier,
s
quality at process, workforces’ capability of performing variety of operations,
existence of EDI system etc.
l a
agprice per overtime
Stock out cost without considering
Contribution per unit = Sale unit - Raw material procurement cost per unit – Other
variable overheads per unit; Contribution per unit = `6,000 - `1,100-`3,250 = `1,650 per unit.
Contribution earned from selling these 4,000 units = 4,000 × `1,650 = `66,00,000.
In such a situation the total additional outflow in JIT system would be (` 36,00,000). In this case
a return equal to 10.8% and above would be needed to Justify the JIT procurement policy.
(ii) Necessity of overtime cost be incurred to reduce stock out
Contribution per unit = Sale price per unit – Raw material procurement cost per unit
o m
– Other variable overheads per unit; Contribution per unit = ` 6,000 - ` 1,100 -
m c
Overtime cost can reduce stockouts from 4,000 units to 2,500 units that is. customers'
` 3,250 = `1,650 per unit.
c. o s em
em Contribution earned from selling these 1,500 units = 1,500 × `la
demand of 1,500 units more can be met.
las a g 1,650 = ` 24,75,000.
ag ADVISE
The contribution earned of ` 24,75,000 is more than the related overtime cost of
` 20,00,000. Therefore, it is profitable to incur the overtime cost, and this will result
in additional savings of ` 4,75,000, hence should be done.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s ag
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 9 of 35
Page 11
10 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
(B) RECOMMENDATION
The company plans to eliminate its raw material inventory altogether. Raw material will be
delivered as per production schedule directly at the factory shop floor, from where
production will begin. The management should therefore carefully consider the following
points:
(a) The entire production process has to be detailed and integrated sequentially. This is
essential to know because it should be known in advance when in the sub-
assembly process each raw material is required and in what quantity.
(b) Since production is dependent on delivery and quality of raw material, heavy reliance
is being placed on suppliers. They should be able to guarantee timely delivery of
raw material of the appropriate quality. The company is paying a premium of 10% of
original cost, that is ` 100 per unit in order to ensure the same. Each unit gives a
contribution of ` 1,650 per unit, which is 27.5% of the sale price per unit. Lost sales
opportunities due to unavailability of raw material or non-conformance of the material
can result in substantial losses to the company. While, portion of this has been
factored while doing the cost benefit analysis of implementing Just-in-time systems,
it needs careful consideration and monitoring even after implementation. Therefore,
to hedge its loss, the management and suppliers should agree on penalties or costs
the supplier should incur should there be any delay or non-conformance in quality of
materials beyond certain thresholds.
(c) Accurate prediction of sales trends is important to determine the production
schedule and finished goods planning.
(d) Continuous monitoring of the system even after implementation is essential to ensure
smooth operations. Management commitment and leadership support is
essential for its successful implementation and working.
▪ Advice regarding implementation of JIT procurement system can also be offered based on
current production level.
(b) Statement Showing “Sales Target Fixed & Actual Margin/ Contribution
Particulars Zone (`)
North South East West
Commissioned Earned 3,00,000 2,90,000 3,10,000 2,40,000
Actual Sales (Commission 30,00,000 29,00,000 31,00,000 24,00,000
Earned/ 10%)
Sales Price Variance 40,000 (F) 60,000 (A) 50,000 (A) 20,000 (A)
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 10 of 35
Page 12
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 11
Sales Volume Variance 60,000 (A) 2,60,000 (F) 1,50,000 (F) 80,000 (F)
Sales Target (Budgeted 30,20,000 27,00,000 30,00,000 23,40,000
m
.co
Sales)
o m
Standard Cost of Sales 25,00,000 22,00,000 26,50,000 20,00,000
m
Target
c
. Margin s e
e m l a
s Margin Mix Variance 1,40,000 (A)
Budgeted 5,20,000 5,00,000 3,50,000 3,40,000
l a ag
Sales 80,000 (F) 1,70,000 (F) 30,000 (A)
ag Sales Price Variance
Actual Margin
40,000 (F)
4,20,000
60,000 (A)
5,20,000
50,000 (A) 20,000 (A)
4,70,000 2,90,000
Note: Since no information has been given about Sales Margin Quantity Variance, therefore for
calculating actual margin the same has been assumed to be zero.
Statement Showing “Evaluation of the Performance of Zonal Sales Managers”
Particulars Zone
North South East West
m 5,20,000 4,70,000 2,90,000
co
Contribution earned to the company
.
(a) Margin Earned (`) 4,20,000
em
(b) Rank III I II IV
Efficiency towards the Target Sales
l a s
(a) Whether target achieved
a g
(b) Actual Sales to Target Sales 99.34%
No Yes
107.41%
Yes
103.33%
Yes
102.56%
Ratio
(c) Rank IV I II III
Margin Vs Sales Ratio
(a) Budgeted Margin/Sales Target 17.22% 18.52% 11.67% 14.53%
Ratio
(b) Actual Margin Vs Actual Sales 14.00% 17.93% 15.16% 12.08%
m
Ratio
m c. o
(c) Achievement 81.31% 96.82% 129.91% 83.14%
c. o em
(d) Rank IV II I III
em s
a from its sales.
The margin vs. sales ratio helps to track how much margin firm islmaking
ANALYSIS
las g
a of 11.67% which is the
ag
Zone EAST is yielding a ratio of 15.16% against the target ratio
good indicator of performance. At the same time, other zones are not performing well as
they have been clearly failed to achieve this target ratio, for instance NORTH Zone is
yielding a ratio of 14% against the budgeted figure of 17.22% while SOUTH Zone is almost
near to this ratio and West zone is also falling behind by 2.45%.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 11 of 35
Page 13
12 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
On the basis of margin earned SOUTH Zone is the best zone since it is highest contributor
30.59% to the total margin of the ORAL while EAST Zone is contributing 27.65% and
NORTH Zone is contributing 24.71%. Zone WEST is contributing only 17.05% which is the
lowest among all.
NORTH Zone is clearly failed to achieve the target sales while SOUTH has obtained a
figure 7.41% over and above the targeted sales. Zone EAST and WEST have also
successfully achieved the targeted sales.
Conclusion
NORTH and WEST Zone have been ranked either III or IV in each standard criterion while
SOUTH & EAST Zone are standing at either I or II in these criteria. SOUTH Zone is having
highest sales as well as highest margin amongst all zones, but they are failed to achieve
target margin ratio, they are slightly behind the ratio. Zone EAST is having superb margin
vs. sales ratio as discussed earlier at the same time they have achieved targeted sales
ratio. They are just behind SOUTH zone in target sales ratio and margin (in absolute term).
On the basis of analysis, this can be concluded that Zone EAST is best performer.
Alternate View
SOUTH Zone is best as it is ranked 1 in terms of contribution earned to the company and
st
achievement of the sales target and 2 nd in percentage on sales margin achieved. But at
the same time having highest sales margin ratio amongst all the zones and contributing
highest total profit rupee value.
Question 3
SR Limited deals in readymade garments and its clients majorly include medium and large
outlets. There are regular complaints from clients regarding delivery issues. As SR Limited
understand the critical behaviour of clients and want to establish "Customer Profitability
Analysis" (CPA) so that critical customers who are key factors can be recognized. SR Limited
provide following information regarding its four major customers:
Particulars A B C D
No. of Units Sold 36,000 48,000 42,000 56,000
Contribution per unit 36 45 48 45
No. of purchase order 100 200 150 100
No. of deliveries (Normal) 3 4 4 5
Kilometre per delivery 100 50 250 350
Order Processing Cost - ` 12,000 Per Order
Product Handling Cost - ` 0.90 per unit
Transport Cost - ` 18 per Kilometre
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 12 of 35
Page 14
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 13
Required
(a) EVALUATE the Customer Profitability by calculating Total Profit as well as Profit Per Unit
m
.co
from each customer for SR Limited and INTERPRET each customer. (4 + 4 = 8 Marks)
o m
em
(b) DEMONSTRATE three fundamental aspects of CRM to facilitate building relationship with
c
. two benefits of Customer Profitability Analysis (CPA).
profitable customer. (6 Marks)
s
m
e the relevance of Customer Profitability Analysis in reference to Banking and gla
s
(c) ENUMERATE (2 Marks)
g a sector.
lHotel
(d) DISCUSS
(4 Marks)a
aAnswer
(a) Statement of Customer Profitability at SR Ltd. - Total and per unit profit for each
customer
Sr. Particulars Customers
No 36,000 48,000 42,000 56,000
units units units units
m 21,60,000 20,16,000 25,20,000
A B C D
co
(` ) (` ) (` ) (` )
.
em
A Contribution Margin (no. of units sold × 12,96,000
s
contribution per unit)
B
l a
Assignable Marketing, Administrative
g
a
and Distribution Costs
1 Order Taking and Processing 12,00,000 24,00,000 18,00,000 12,00,000
(#of Purchase Orders × processing cost
per order)
2 Delivery Cost 5,400 3,600 18,000 31,500
(No. of deliveries × Km per delivery ×
Cost per delivery)
3 Product Handling Cost 32,400 43,200 37,800 50,400
(No. of units sold × Product Handling
m
cost per unit)
c. o
Total assignable marketing, 12,37,800 24,46,800 18,55,800 12,81,900
m
c. o
administrative and distribution costs
(B1+B2+B3)
e m 12,38,100
em
C Total Profit per customer (A) - (B) 58,200 (2,86,800)
l a s
1,60,200
las D Profit per unit per customer C / No of 1.62
ag
(5.98) 3.81 22.11
g
units
a EVALUATION
▪ “Customer D” is the most profitable customer both in terms of absolute total profit
(` 12,38,100) as well as profit per unit ` 22.11 per unit. The 56,000 units sales volume
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 13 of 35
Page 15
14 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
generated for customer D accounts for (30.8%) of the total sales volume. With a
contribution margin of `45 per unit amounting to a total of ` 25,20,000, the customer
generates higher contribution in total as compared to others. Despite having highest
sales volume, the number of purchase orders placed by this client is the lowest
at 100 orders for the period. Hence order processing cost is at lowest level,
contributing to the overall profitability generated from sales with this customer .
The Kilometers covered per delivery is the highest for this customer at 350 Kms per
delivery with 5 deliveries for the period. Among the customers, Customer D has the
highest delivery cost. In view of rising fuel prices, if SR Ltd. would like to trim
the costs, it could negotiate lesser deliveries for the period. However, Customer
D is a very important and profitable customer for SR Ltd. and hence
negotiations must ensure that Customer D is completely satisfied with any
revision the product delivery schedule of SR Ltd.
▪ The second most profitable customer for SR Ltd. is “Customer C”. The 42,000 units
sales volume generated for customer C accounts for (23.08%) of the total sales
volume. With a contribution margin of `48 per unit total contribution generated from
these sales amounts to ` 20,16,000. This customer generates higher contribution
rate of ` 48 per unit of sales as compared to bigger customers like Customer D
and Customer B. This may be due to better negotiation for selling price with the
customer by SR Ltd. as compared to other customers. SR Ltd. can look into this
synergy and try to apply it to other customers as well where feasible. Customer C
places 50% more orders as compared to the largest customer, Customer D. Hence,
to improve profitability by trimming costs, the SR Ltd. can negotiate for Customer
C to place bulk orders that would reduce the number of orders for the period.
Similarly, the number of kilometers per delivery is higher as compared to Customer A
and B. Hence in view of rising fuel prices, SR Ltd. may negotiate for lesser
deliveries for this customer.
▪ The third most profitable customer for SR Ltd. is “Customer A”. As compared to
others, this customer generates the lowest sales volume at 36,000 units for the
period. The contribution per unit at ` 36 per unit is also the lowest among the
customers being analyzed. SR Ltd. can review the reasons for this low
contribution margin. This could either be due to disadvantageous sale price
negotiations with the customer (maybe giving higher than normal discounts to
Customer A). Profitability from sales to this customer can be substantially improved
by acting upon the problem lower contribution margin.
▪ “Customer B” is a loss-making customer for SR Ltd. Despite having a second
highest sales volume of 48,000 units for the period (26.4% of the total sales volume)
and a relatively high contribution margin of ` 45 per unit, this customer generates a
loss of `2,86,800 for the period, that is a loss of ` 5.98 per unit. The primary reason
for the loss is the high number of purchase orders placed by Customer B.
Customer B places 200 orders for the period which is double of the orders placed by
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 14 of 35
Page 16
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 15
the largest client Customer D. SR Ltd. could negotiate bulk orders to be placed,
which can reduce the order processing cost substantially. If this is not feasible,
m
SR Ltd. can then charge extra for the frequent orders placed by Customer B.
m .co
This could significantly improve the profitability of sale generated with this client.
.co e m
Product handling cost of `0.9 per unit is a non-value adding expenditure. SR Ltd.
m
edistribution function efficiently; in order to procure, produce and distribute at/i n right gl
should try to minimize this cost as much as possible in order to improve profitability.
a s
a s
ltime, quantity and place respectively. For effective distribution, CRM can be enabling tool.a
(b) Supply chain management is the technique to integrate the supplier, manufacturing, store,
g
and
a CRM is an integrated approach to manage and coordinate customer interactions to
identifying, acquiring, and retaining customers. CRM enables businesses to
understand and retain customers (through better customer experience) apart from
attracting new customer, in order to increase profitably and decrease customer
management costs. CRM system, comprises following three fundamental aspects to
facilitate building relationship with profitable customers –
▪ Operative CRM takes care of individual transactions and is used by operational team.
m
Interactions by customers are kept in the data base and are used later by the
. co
service, sales, and marketing team for operational decisions. In SR Limited, the
em
staff who is responsible to deal with customer must be given access to customer’s
s
details including all the information of activities performed earlier. This will enhance
l a
the SR Limited’ staff’s efficiency to deal with customer-facing processes in a better
g
a
way.
▪ Analytical CRM analyses the data created on the operational side of the CRM effort
for evaluation and prediction of customer behaviour. In SR Limited, analytical
CRM can highlight the patterns in customers’ behaviour which will help sale team
while pitching the product at SR Limited.
▪ Collaborative CRM ensures that information about customer must flow seamlessly
throughout the supply chain, majorly distribution channel; in form of collaborative
effort by all associated department of SR Limited to increase the quality of services
m
provided to customers. Increase in utility at customer end will result in increased
c. o
loyalty. Collaborative CRM comprises interactive technology like email, digital
m
c. o m
media to simplify the communications between customers and staff which would help
in building relationships.
s e
s em (c) Benefits of Customer Profitability Analysis
g l a
gla The benefits of customer profitability analysis are as follows:
a
a (i) It helps the supplier to identify which
which customers are contributing to it.
customers are eroding overall profitability and
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 15 of 35
Page 17
16 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
(ii) It can help to provide a basis for constructive dialogue between buyer and seller
to improve margins.
(d) DISCUSSION on relevance of ‘Customer Profitability Analysis’ in the Banking and
Hotel sector.
Banking Sector
The customers in the banking industry are a varied lot, they can be classified and further
sub-classified based on the types of loans segment categories, the length of loan period,
the type of security provided or such other criteria as found appropriate by the bank.
Customer Profitability Analysis helps banks to-
(i) retain profitable customers and enhance customer experience by providing
differentiated service or products
(ii) cross sell products to existing customers
(iii) acquire new and profitable customers
(iv) make pricing determinations. For example, waive fees for profitable segments while
ask for more collateral for customer segments where chance of default is higher.
(v) migrate customers to more profitable products and services.
The banking environment is a competitive one. Hence banks need to provide timely and
transparent customer service based on the customer’s needs. This enhances customer
experience that will differentiate the bank from its competitors.
The information system and accounting system of a bank should be customized to
provide information for such an analysis.
Hotel Sector
Hotels operate in a dynamic, complex and competitive environment. Customer service is
of paramount importance for successful business operations. At the same time, the
industry is characterized by the intangible nature of customer service, the high capital and
labour intensive commitments, high fixed cost structure and the erratic demand for
perishable nature of product offerings like food and beverages. This is compounded by the
extremely competitive nature of business where customer loyalty is not assured.
Customers are varied and need to be segmented based on suitable criteria some of which
could be individual transient customers not travelling with any group, corporate business
customers funded by their employers, wholesale booking agents or tour operators who
make bulk bookings. Customer segmentation needs to be based on criteria suited to the
hotel’s requirements. Customers within a segment share certain traits and will
respond similarly to targeted marketing strategies. Not every customer segment
contributes towards the company’s profits, hence customer profitability analysis is
very important. It gives important insights about the behaviour and the needs of each
customer segment.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 16 of 35
Page 18
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 17
To improve financial performance, hotel companies target multiple customer segments by
different product and service offering. They can vary their pricing structure an example
m
could be offering discounts on bulk booking or charging a higher price for a suite in a luxury
m .co
hotel as compared to a similar suite in an economy or business travel hotel. Product
co m
offerings could differ, providing conference room facility in business hotel versus a spa
m .
service in a tourist hotel destination. All this can be aimed at retaining profitable customers
s e
s e
through excellent customer service offering. At the same time, it can also be used to
g l a
l a a
convert unprofitable customer segments into profitable ones by cross-selling
ag It is important that the hotel information systems and accounting systems are able to
products and services. The hotel must be able to differentiate itself from its competitors
based on its customer service and enhanced customer experience.
capture and provide information based on different customers or market segments.
▪ Conceptually correct brief explanation is sufficient for each step.
m
Question 4
. co
(a) Vasco Limited manufactures 3 products UV, DV and XV. Due to scarcity of machine hours,
em
management of Vasco Limited is planning to adopt throughput accounting in the company.
a s UV
Information relating to products are as follows:
g l
a
DV XV
Selling price per unit ` 5,000 ` 4,000 ` 3,500
Material Cost ` 2,500 ` 2,500 ` 2,000
Machine Hours required 5 6 4
Maximum annual demand 3,000 units 4,000 units 2,000 units
Total factory cost is ` 1,05,00,000 and available machine hours are 35,000 hours.
Vasco Limited has to supply 2,500 units of product DV to Alfa Limited as per a court
o m
judgement which cannot be denied.
m c
. showing
c. o
Required
m
e (5 Marks)
s
(i) Rank the products using throughput accounting and PREPARE a statement
s em a
l of the company, if
optimal mix for maximization of profit.
(ii) Whether court judgement has affected the optimum plan ofgprofit
gla a
a
yes, by which amount? (2 Marks)
(iii) BRIEFLY explain 3 operational measures of theory of constraints. (3 Marks)
(b) DISCUSS the effect of Budget difficulty on Performance Evaluation. (5 Marks)
OR
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 17 of 35
Page 19
18 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
Kingstorm & Co. manufactures industrial tools. Management is having emphasize on quality
and well-known name among customers. The following details are provided by the kingstorm:
Process Time 2 days for batch
Move time 0.5 days per batch
Wait time 3 days per batch
Inspection time 1.5 days per batch
Queue time 4.5 days per batch
Units per batch 40 Units
You are required to
(i) CALCULATE manufacturing Cycle Efficiency (MCE) and INTERPRET it. (2 Marks)
(ii) Manufacturing Cycle Time. (1 Mark)
(iii) Delivery Cycle Time. (1 Mark)
(iv) CALCULATE the New Manufacturing Cycle Time and Manufacturing Cycle Efficiency
(MCE) if queue time is eliminated to 3 days using lean production. (1 Mark)
(c) What is Oligopoly market structure? DISCUSS the various pricing strategies and non
pricing strategies in oligopoly market structure. (5 Marks)
Answer
(a) (i) Statement Showing Machine Hours
Product Maximum Demand Machine Total Machine
Hours/ Unit Hours
UV 3,000 units 5 15,000
DV 4,000 units 6 24,000
XV 2,000 units 4 8,000
Total machine hours required to meet maximum demand 47,000
Machine hours available 35,000
Shortage of machine hours 12,000
‘Machine hours’ is the bottleneck activity.
Statement of Ranking
Particulars UV DV XV
Selling Price per unit ` 5,000 ` 4,000 ` 3,500
Less: Material Costs per unit ` 2,500 ` 2,500 ` 2,000
Throughput per unit ` 2,500 ` 1,500 ` 1,500
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 18 of 35
Page 20
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 19
Machine Hour Required per unit 5 6 4
Throughput Return per hour ` 2,500/5 ` 1,500/6 ` 1,500/4
m
.co
= ` 500 = ` 250 = ` 375
m
co m
Throughput Accounting (TA) Ratio 500/300 250/300 375/300
m .
(Throughput return per hour/ cost per =1.67 =0.83 =1.25
s e
s e Ranking
factory hour)
l a
l a ag
I III II
ag Cost per factory hour =Optimum
` 1,05,00,000/ 35,000 hrs. = ` 300
Production Plan
Product No of Machine Total T/P per Total T/P
units hr. per unit Machine hrs. hr. ` `
DV (for Alfa) 2,500 6 15,000 250 37,50,000
UV 3,000 5 15,000 500 75,00,000
XV 5,000/4 4 5,000 375 18,75,000
m
co
=1,250 (b/f)
.
em
Total 1,31,25,000
las
Less: Total Factory Costs 1,05,00,000
ag
Profit 26,25,000
(ii) Had there been no court judgement product XV can be fully produced = 2,000 units
using 8,000 machine hours (2,000 × 4). Because of court judgement for 2,500 units
of product DV, unfulfilled demand of product XV = 2,000 -1,250 = 750 units.
Machine Hrs. Required for 500 units of DV (500 × 6) 3,000 hrs.
Throughput Lost for Product XV (3,000 hrs. × 375) ` 11,25,000
Throughput Return Earned for Product DV (3,000 hrs. × 250) ` 7,50,000
m
Throughput lost ` 3,75,000
m
The court judgement will reduce the profit by `3,75,000.
c. o
c. o OR
s em3,000 hrs.
s em g la
la
Machine Hrs. Required for 500 units of DV (500 × 6)
g
Throughput Lost for Product XV (750 units × `1,500)
a ` 11,25,000
a Throughput Return Earned for Product DV (500 units × `1,500) ` 7,50,000
Throughput lost ` 3,75,000
The court judgement will reduce the profit by `3,75,000.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 19 of 35
Page 21
20 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
(iii) Operational Measures
The theory of constraints focuses on revenue and cost management when faced with
bottlenecks. It advocates the use of three key measures. These are:
Throughput ▪ Throughput as a TOC measure is the rate of generating
money in an organization through Sales.
▪ Throughput = (Sales Revenue – Unit Level Variable
Expenses)/Time
▪ Direct Labour Cost is viewed as a fixed unit level
expenses and is not usually included.
Investment ▪ This is money associated with turning materials into
Throughput and do not have to be immediately
expensed.
▪ Includes assets such as facilities, equipment, fixtures
and computers.
Operating Expense ▪ Money spent in turning Investment into Throughput and
therefore, represent all other money that an
organisation spends.
▪ Includes direct labour and all operating and
maintenance expenses.
(b) DISCUSSION on effect of the Budget Difficulty on Performance
Once budgets have been set as performance targets, surely performance will be
evaluated. This can be simply a comparison of actual with budgeted performance or
alternatively can be a more detailed comparison of actual performance with flexed budget
performance, as is found in variance analysis and operating statements. The evaluation
step is often one of the most argumentative as it is here that performance is likely to be
criticised and employees will be sensitive. There are many potential difficulties:
Hofstede (1968)
▪ Budgets have no motivational effect unless they are accepted by the managers
involved as their own personal targets.
▪ Up to the point where the budget is no longer accepted, the more demanding the
target the better the results achieved.
▪ Demanding budgets are seen as more relevant than less difficult targets, but negative
attitudes result if they are seen as too difficult.
▪ Acceptance of budgets is facilitated when good upward communication exists. The
use of departmental meeting was found helpful in encouraging managers to accept
budget targets.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 20 of 35
Page 22
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 21
▪ Managers’ reactions to budget targets were found affected both by their own
personality and by more general cultural and organizational norms.
m
.co
The relationship between budget difficulty and the ensuring level of performance can be
m
c. o The Effect of Budget Difficulty on Performance
shown graphically and is illustrated as under:
e m
em l a s
l a s ag
ag
m
. co
s em
l a
gSource: Otley (1987)
a
“Budget level that motivates the best level of performance may not be achievable. In
contrast, the budget that is expected to be achieved motivates a lower level of performance
as managers no longer aspire to meet the budget target.”
The balanced scorecard approach of Kaplan and Norton, and the building block approach
of Fitzgerald and Norton can be a great help in ensuring that objectives (or targets), or
budgets are set for a very wide range of factors, both financial and non-financial.
m
OR
m
(i) Manufacturing Cycle Efficiency (MCE)
c. o
c. o Processing Time
s e m
em a
=
l
Inspection Time + Process Time + Queue Time + Move Time + Wait Time
las ag
g
2.0 days
a
=
1.5 days + 2.0 days + 4.5 days + 0.5 days + 3.0 days
= 17.39%
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 21 of 35
Page 23
22 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
Interpretation
In Kingstorm & Co., the MCE is 17.39%, which means that 82.61% of the time a unit
is in process is spent on the activities that do not add value to the product. Monitoring
the MCE helps companies to reduce non -value added activities and thus get products
into the hands of customers more quickly and at a lower cost.
(ii) Manufacturing Cycle Time
= 1.5 days+ 2.0 days + 4.5 days + 0.5 days + 3.0 days
= 11.5 days Or
Alternatively, Manufacturing Cycle Time = 11.5 days/40 units = 0.2875 days per unit
(iii) Delivery Cycle Time
= 1.5 days+ 2.0 days + 4.5 days + 0.5 days + 3.0 days
= 11.5 days
(iv) Revised MCE
2.0 days
=
1.5 days + 2.0 days + 3.0 days + 0.5 days + 3.0 days
= 20%
Revised Manufacturing Cycle Time
= 1.5 days+ 2.0 days + 3.0 days + 0.5 days + 3.0 days
= 10 days Or
Alternatively, Rev. Manufacturing Cycle Time = 10 days/ 40 units = 0.25 days per unit
Alternative
(i) Manufacturing Cycle Efficiency (MCE)
Value Added Time (ProcessingTime)
=
Throughput(ManufacturingCycle)Time
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 22 of 35
Page 24
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 23
2.0 days
=
1.5 days + 2.0 days + 4.5 days + 0.5 days
m
m .co
= 23.53%
.co m
Interpretation
m s e
a
In Kingstorm & Co., the MCE is 23.53%, which means that 76.47% of the time a unit is
s e l
ag
in process is spent on the activities that do not add value to the product. Monitoring the
a
l (ii) Manufacturing Cycle Time
MCE helps companies to reduce non -value added activities and thus get products into
ag
the hands of customers more quickly and at a lower cost.
= 1.5 days+ 2.0 days + 4.5 days + 0.5 days +
= 8.5 Days Or
Alternatively, Manufacturing Cycle Time = 8.5 days/ 40 units = 0.2125 days per unit
(iii) Delivery Cycle Time
= 1.5 days+ 2.0 days + 4.5 days + 0.5 days + 3.0 days
= 11.5 days
m
co
(iv) Revised MCE
2.0 days
.
em
=
s
1.5 days + 2.0 days + 3.0 days + 0.5 days
Revised Manufacturing g
= 28.57%
l a
a Cycle Time
= 1.5 days+ 2.0 days + 3.0 days + 0.5 days
= 7 days Or
Alternatively, Rev. Manufacturing Cycle Time = 7 days/ 40 units = 0.175 days per unit
(c) Oligopoly
A market structure where there are few firms producing or selling homogenous or
identical product. In this type of market structure, the firms are aware of the mutual
m
c. o
interdependence of investment, production process, advertising and sales plan of its
m
rival firm. Hence, any change in any variable by a firm is likely to have an equal reaction
c. o e m
on the part of other competing firms. It is therefore clear that the oligopolistic firm, while
em a s
determining the price for its product, consider not only the demand for the product but also
s l
ag
the reactions of the other firms in the industry to any action or decision it may take.
gla If a firm does not follow or adapt its pricing policy in consonance with its competitor, the
a shift in the sales will be sensitive. That means demand will shift towards the lower price.
Thus, each firm will study the potential reaction before increasing or decreasing the selling
price. The firms in oligopolistic market maintain the price of the product either by close
analysis of each other’s behaviour or by means of cooperation and collusion.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 23 of 35
Page 25
24 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
Pricing Strategies of Oligopolies
▪ Predatory Pricing: Keeping price artificially low, and often below the full cost of
production.
▪ They may also operate a Limit - Pricing Strategy to discourage entrants, which is
also called entry forestalling price.
▪ Oligopolists may collude with rivals and raise price together, but this may attract
new entrants.
▪ Cost-Plus Pricing: A straightforward pricing method, where a firm sets a price by
calculating average production costs and then adding a fixed mark-up to
achieve a desired profit level. There are different versions of cost-plus pricing,
including full cost pricing, where all costs - that is, fixed and variable costs - are
calculated, plus a mark-up for profits, and contribution pricing, where only variable
costs are calculated with precision and the mark-up is a contribution to both fixed
costs and profits.
Non-Price Strategies
Non-price competition is the favoured strategy for oligopolists because price competition
can lead to destructive price wars – examples include:
▪ Trying to improve Quality & After Sales Servicing, such as offering extended
guarantees.
▪ Spending on Advertising, Sponsorship, and Product Placement.
▪ Sales Promotion, such as buy-one-get-one-free, is associated with the large
supermarkets, which is a highly oligopolistic market, dominated by three or four large
chains.
▪ Loyalty Schemes, which are common in the supermarket sector, such as Reliance’s
One Card.
Question 5
(a) XYZ Company is a manufacturer of an instrument which have monopoly in the market. The
company is manufacturing this instrument since 2000. Two parts, part 'A' and part 'B' are
required to manufacture this instrument. Part 'A' is manufactured at plant situated in
Gujarat. Part B is manufactured at plant situated in Rajasthan. The instrument is being
made by assembling the parts in assembling plant situated in 'Gurgaon'. The Part 'A' and
Part 'B' cannot be sold individually in the market.
Recently, the company has decided to benchmark the performance of the each plant
individually by setting the cost targets. For this a new CEO has been appointed. The newly
appointed CEO suggested that to assess the performance of each plant, a divisional
transfer pricing policy is required to be implemented in each plant. For this Managing
director of the company is opined that the transfer price should be decided by Negotiating
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 24 of 35
Page 26
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 25
or bargaining price between each divisional manager. CEO is nut in agreement with the
opinion of the Managing Director.
m
.co
You have been appointed to ANALYZE and give ADVICE:
m
c. o em
(i) Whether opinion of the Managing Director is correct. Give reasons. (2 Marks)
While m s
(ii) Options available for deciding the method of transfer pricing. (8 Marks)
s e g l a
la
giving your advice discuss the advantages, disadvantages and behavioral
(b)g What is EMA? CATEGORIES the undermentioned costs under following dimensions
consequences of each method.
a
a Environmental Prevention Costs
Environmental Appraisal Costs
Environmental Internal Failure Costs
Environmental External Failure Costs
Different Costs:
m
(i) Evaluating and picking pollution control equipment
(ii) Performing contamination tests
. c o
(iii) Creating environmental policies m
(iv) Audit of environmental activitiess
e
g lain order to prevent fines / penalties
a
(v) Improved systems and checks
(vi) Environmentally driven R & D
(vii) Failure in disposing toxic material
(viii) Cost of restoring land to its natural state (4 Marks)
(c) (i) Implementation of the Target Costing technique requires intensive market research.
Give your COMMENTS. (3 Marks)
(ii) STATE the impact of Target Costing on profitability. (3 Marks)
m
m c. o
Answer
c. o (a) (i) ANALYSIS/ ADVISE
s e m
s em l ais based on external
A negotiation-based transfer price is arrived by giving managers of the divisions
la g
a ofcomponent.
authority to decide on a mutually agreeable transfer price. This
ag information like the market price of the component, the terms
as well as the company’s internal cost of production of the
sale within the industry
This is a go
between the market and cost based methods. The managers can independently decide
whether to buy (or sell) from its internal unit or to source from the external market.
Here, Parts A and Parts B cannot be sold individually in the market, there exists
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 25 of 35
Page 27
26 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
no external market for them. Hence there is no comparative external price,
information about terms of trade etc. to compare them with.
Therefore, negotiation-based transfer price is not possible in the case of XYZ
Company. Therefore, the Managing Director is wrong.
(ii) Methods of transfer pricing, their advantages, disadvantages and behavioural
consequences. Transfer Pricing Methods can be broadly divided into three categories–
(i) Market Based Transfer Price
(ii) Cost Based Transfer Price
(iii) Negotiation Based Transfer Price
However, in given case of XYZ Company, there exists no external market for Part A
and Part B. Hence Market based transfer pricing method and Negotiation Based
transfer pricing method would not apply. The company can use cost based transfer
pricing methods to determine the transfer price for internal sales.
Cost Based Transfer Pricing Methods
Based on the internal cost records of the company, managers can benchmark
performance with cost targets set within the company. This is also used when, as is the
case with XYZ Company, there is no external market price to benchmark. Cost-based
transfer price maybe based on variable cost, standard cost, full cost and full cost plus
mark-up methods and can be adopted based on suitability.
Advantages
▪ Information is more easily available as compared to market price. Cost can be
broken down further for internal analysis.
Disadvantages
▪ There are multiple ways of interpreting costs, managers may not agree on the
basis to be followed. Since cost is passed to another division there is little incentive
to lower costs, which may bring cost inefficiencies into operations.
Marginal cost-based transfer price
Transfer price is recorded at marginal cost required to produce one additional unit. The
units in Gujarat and Rajasthan manufacturing Part A and Part B should have cost
records that will help them derive the marginal cost based on variable expenses
incurred while producing the components.
Advantage
▪ If the plants in Gujarat and Rajasthan have excess capacity for production, it
ensures that it recoups at least the variable cost of production. This will partially
help meeting the cost target set for performance evaluation. The assembling
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 26 of 35
Page 28
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 27
division in Gurgaon can procure the components at a lower price as compared to
a full cost pricing. This would benefit their performance evaluation as well.
m
.co
Disadvantage
m
co m
▪ No fixed cost or mark-up can be charged to the purchasing division. Hence each
m . unit of internal sale will result in a loss of approximately fixed cost per unit for the
s e
eBehavioural Consequences l a
supplying divisions in Gujarat and Rajasthan.
l a s a g
ag
▪ Non recovery of fixed cost can demotivate the supplying divisions. They may
oppose certain decisions like further capacity expansion or further infusion of
investment that lead to higher fixed cost.
Standard cost based transfer price
Transfers are recorded at a predetermined cost, which is based on budgets and certain
assumptions regarding factors of production like capacity utilization, labour hours etc.
In the case of XYZ Company, the cost targets set for performance evaluation must
match with this standard cost used for transfer pricing. Given that XYZ Company is
m
going to evaluate performance based on cost targets, any variance between the
. co
standard cost charged and the actual cost may most likely be absorbed by the supplying
em
division.
Advantage
l a s
▪
a g
Performance evaluation can be done against budgeted cost targets. Variance
analysis will help managers improve their performance.
Disadvantage
▪ Profit performance measurement is centralized and cannot be measured for
individual divisions.
Behavioural Consequences
▪ Budgeted costs are based on historical cost records. Therefore, there is little
incentive to make costs more cost efficient. The company should ensure that
m
c. o
standard cost based transfer price is periodically adjusted for any major revision
m
c. o
in costs or assumptions.
e m
em s
Full Cost based transfer price
s l a
ag
Based on full product cost, transfer price will include the cost of production and other
la
costs incurred in the value chain like general administrative expenses, research and
ag development expenses etc. There will be no selling expenses incurred by any of the
supplying plants since the parts are exclusively sold internally and do not have an
external market.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 27 of 35
Page 29
28 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
Advantage
▪ The full cost of production of goods transferred is recovered and hence supplying
divisions in Gujarat and Rajasthan incur no loss.
Disadvantage
▪ A disincentive for the supplying division is that profit cannot be charged and hence
the supplying divisions do not record any profit.
Behaviour Consequence
The problem with using full cost as a basis for transfer pricing is that it distorts the
company’s cost structure while making decisions. The purchasing department would
view the cost as a variable one, since it varies in proportion to the units purchased
internally. In reality, this price includes a portion of fixed costs of the supplying division
that is anyway a sunk cost. Consequently, the market price that the purchasing division
may calculate based on the transfer price for the input supplied, may be slightly inflated.
Cost plus mark-up based transfer price
Transfer price is based on full product cost plus mark up. Mark up could be a percentage
of cost or of capital employed.
Advantages
▪ Supplying division can now charge full cost plus mark-up which acts as an
incentive.
Disadvantages
▪ XYZ Company may set its cost targets based on historical records. Cost targets
are going to be basis for performance evaluation. In inflationary situations the
actual cost incurred may be more than the cost target set. These costs may not
be controllable by the managers of the respective plants. This can result in higher
transfer pricing costs charged by plants in Gujarat and Rajasthan. The plant in
Gurgaon may not be able to meet its cost target and hence may be demotivated.
Behavioural Consequences
▪ If performance evaluation is based on cost targets, it must account for inflationary
and deflationary situations. Specially in inflationary situations, the managers may
not be able to control the costs. Hence the cost target may be leading to
demotivation. Hence XYZ Company should proactively keep tab of current costs
while setting cost targets for performance evaluation.
(b) EMA is the process of collection and analysis of the information relating to environmental
cost for internal decision making.
EMA identifies and estimates the costs of environment-related activities and seeks to
control these costs.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 28 of 35
Page 30
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 29
The focus of EMA is not on financial costs but it also considers the environmental cost or
benefit of any decisions made.
m
.co
EMA is an attempt to integrate best management accounting thinking with best
m
c. o
environmental management practice.
e m
s
CATEGORIES
S. m a
s e l
a ag
Different Costs Dimensions
l
ag (i) Evaluating
No.
and picking pollution control Environmental Prevention Costs
equipment
(ii) Performing contamination tests Environmental Appraisal Costs
(iii) Creating environmental policies Environmental Prevention Costs
(iv) Audit of environmental activities Environmental Appraisal Costs
(v) Improved systems and checks in order Environmental Appraisal Costs
to prevent fines/ penalties
o mEnvironmental Prevention Costs
(vii) Failure of Disposing toxic material .c
(vi) Environmentally driven R & D
m
e state Environmental External Failure
Environmental Internal Failure Costs
la s
(viii) Cost of restoring land to its natural
g
a between estimated selling price of a proposed product
(c) (i) Target cost is the difference
Costs
with specified functionality and quality and the target margin. This is a cost
management technique that aims to produce and sell products that will ensure the
target margin. It is an integral part of the product design. While designing the
product, the company needs to understand what value target customers will assign
to different attributes and different aspects of quality. This requires use of techniques
like value engineering and value analysis. Intensive marketing research is required
to understand customer preferences and the value they assign to each attribute
m
c. o
and quality parameter. This insight is required to be developed much before the
m
c. o
product is introduced. The company plays within the space between the maximum
e m
s
attributes and quality that the company can offer and the minimum acceptable to
em l a
target customers. Therefore, in absence of intensive marketing research, the target
las costing technique cannot be used effectively.
ag
ag (ii) Target costing can have a startlingly large positive impact on profitability, depending
on the commitment of management to its use, the constant involvement of
management accountants in all stages of a product’s life cycle, and the type of
strategy a company follows. Target costing improves profitability in two ways.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 29 of 35
Page 31
30 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
▪ It places continuous emphasis on product costs throughout the life cycle
of every product, and the management is completely aware of costing issues
since it receives regular reports from the management accounting members of
all design teams.
▪ It improves profitability through precise targeting of the correct prices at
which the company feels it can field a profitable product in the marketplace that
will sell in a robust manner. This is opposed to the more common cost-plus
approach under which a company builds a product, determines its cost, tacks
on a profit and then does not understand why its resoundingly high price does
not attract buyers. Thus, target costing results not only in better cost control
but also in better price control.
▪ If any organisation constantly issues a stream of new products, or if its existing
product lines are subject to severe pricing pressure, it must make target
costing a central part of its strategy.
If the shortcomings of target costing are dealt with by a management team, it will
find that target costing is one of the best management accounting methods available
for improving profitability.
Question 6
(a) SMS Hospital operates a 60-bed capacity Healthcare Unit and charges ` 4,250 per bed
per day from the patients. Following data have been provided for the year ended
March 2022.
Fees Collected during the year 5,10,00,000
Variable Cost 2,10,00,000
Fixed Cost 1,80,00,000
The requirement of nursing staff is in the ratio of 500:1 mean for every 500-patient bed day
1 nurse requires. The remuneration of the nurse is ` 2,40,000 per annum.
Management of the hospital have following projections for the upcoming year:
(i) Variable cost will go up by 10%
(ii) Fixed cost will increase by ` 68,00,000 per annum.
(iii) Salary of the nursing staff and charges from patients will remain same.
The number of patients is also not likely to increase in the next year.
The management is considering to open an ICU instead of above mentioned Healthcare
Unit which will be at par in initial 2 years but earn profits after that. ICU will also increase
goodwill and social reputation of the Hospital.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 30 of 35
Page 32
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 31
You are required to:
(i) PREPARE statement to show profitability of existing Healthcare Unit for 2022 and
m
.co
upcoming year. (3 Marks)
m
co m
(ii) Break Even Bed Capacity on the basis of projections for upcoming year. (4 Marks)
m . s e
a
(iii) Your ADVICE on the basis of Financial as well as Non-Financial Factors to switch off
s e
from Healthcare Unit to ICU. (3 Marks)
g l
l a a
a(b)g Acompletion
(Note: Nursing staff salary will be taken as Fixed Cost.)
Consultancy firm having its branches across India is facing the problem of non-timely
of services. Client are not satisfied with their services just because of delay.
However, firm has a qualified team of professionals in different fields and the team
members are highly qualified and experts in their field.
On investigation it was found that the main reason of delay is mobile phones of staff. Staff
spent their valuable time on mobile phones however staff uses his or her mobile phones
for 2 to 3 minutes at a time but frequency is high. As a result, on an average daily every
staff member spends 1/2 hour to 1 hour on receiving personal calls and on social media.
o m
It looks just a small issue but its effect is large as it also diverts their minds from their
ongoing work also.
c
. for staff members to work without phones
m
efeedbacks.
As it is a consultancy firm, it is not possible
s
to tell their additional requirementsaand
gl has decided to provide landline phones. Now staff
because they have to converse with client's officials time to time and clients also calls them
a
To resolve this problem, management
members have to submit their mobile phones at reception and they are not allowed to take
them at their workplace. Staff members are advised to use landline phones and firm mail -
id to contact the clients. As per management opinion it will improve their efficiency up to
25% but there are some issues in which management wants your opinion
(i) Whether clients will be compatible with such type of arrangements? (2 Marks)
(ii) Will it affect the morale of staff members and will it affect long term sustainability of
m
firm? Give reasons. (3 Marks)
m c. o
(c) KRK Limited deals in spare parts of motorbike. Since last 2 years, it has shown loss even
c. o e m
though it has negotiated with the suppliers very well and was able to purchase the goods
em a s
at very competitive rates. The newly appointed CEO believed that there is a need of
s l
ag
Implementation of Balanced Scorecard. CEO met the Managing Director and stated that
la
"The Balanced Scorecard is a collection of critical performance measures that have some
ag special properties. The performance measures are derived from a company's vision,
strategy and objectives. Performance measures should be chosen so that they are
balanced between outcome and lead measures."
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 31 of 35
Page 33
32 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
Managing Director of the KRK limited was very happy with the CEO and it was decided
that from the beginning of the next financial year the Balanced Scorecard will be
implemented. For implementing, the Balanced Scorecard, following strategic objectives
were, decided to begin with
(i) Expansion of eco-friendly product line.
(ii) Improve ROI.
(iii) Customer retention
(iv) Reduction in time spent in non-value-added activities
(v) Improve on time delivery to customers
You are required to CLASSIFY the above strategic objectives by perspective and suggest
a measure for each objective. (5 Marks)
Answer
(a) (i) Statement Showing Profitability of existing Healthcare Unit
Current Year Upcoming Year
Fees Collection 5,10,00,000 5,10,00,000
(12,000 bed days @ 4,250)
Less: Variable Cost 2,10,00,000 2,31,00,000
(12,000 @1,750*) (12,000 @ 1,925)
Contribution 3,00,00,000 2,79,00,000
Less: Fixed Cost
Nurses 57,60,000 57,60,000
12,000
1 2,40,000
500
Other Fixed Cost 1,22,40,000 1,90,40,000
(1,80,00,000 – 57,60,000) (1,22,40,000 + 68,00,000)
Profit/ (Loss) 1,20,00,000 31,00,000
2,10,00,000
*
12,000
(ii) Contribution per bed day = 4,250 – 1,925 = 2,325
2,48,00,000
Break Even Bed Days = = 10,667 bed days
2,325
But for 10,667 bed days, nurses required would be 10,667/500 = 21.33 or 22 nurses
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 32 of 35
Page 34
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 33
2,48,00,000 − 2 2,40,000
Break Even Bed Days = = 10,460.22 or 10,461 bed days
2,325
m
.co
10,461
m
Break Even Bed Capacity = 100 = 87.18%
c o em
12,000
m . s
eThere is significant drop down in profitability of Healthcare Unit. This drop down gla
(iii) ADVISE
s
la inhealthcare
coming year indicates that from the financial perspective the operating ofa
g
a operating anunit is not a viable option. However, based on information given,
ICU is a lucrative project in-spite of at break even in coming two years.
More than this ICU will increase goodwill and social reputation of the hospital. A good
reputation is an important asset for healthcare providers. Along with credible
market positioning, it is vital for attracting self-reliant, quality-conscious, and
cost-aware patient segments. In long run certainly, it will be worthwhile. Therefore,
it is advisable for SMS Healthcare to switch over from Healthcare Unit to ICU.
m
ALTERNATIVE
(i)
c. o Current Year
Statement Showing Profitability of existing Healthcare Unit
s em Upcoming Year
Fees Collection
g l a 5,10,00,000 5,10,00,000
(12,000 bed days @ 4,250)
Less: Variable Cost
a 2,10,00,000 2,31,00,000
(12,000 @1,750*) (12,000 @ 1,925)
Contribution 3,00,00,000 2,79,00,000
Less: Fixed Cost
Nurses 57,60,000 57,60,000
m
12,000
co
1 2,40,000
m
c. o .
500
m
em se(26,60,000)
Fixed Cost 1,80,00,000 2,48,00,000
s g la
la
Profit/ (Loss) 62,40,000
g a
a
2,10,00,000
*
12,000
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 33 of 35
Page 35
34 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
(ii) Contribution per bed day = 4,250 – 1,925 = 2,325
3,05,60,000
Break Even Bed Days = = 13,144 bed days
2,325
But for 13,144 bed days, nurses required would be 13,144/500 = 26.29 or 27 nurses
3,05,60,000 + 3 2,40,000
Break Even Bed Days = = 13,453.76 or 13,454 bed days
2,325
13,454
Break Even Bed Capacity = 100 = 112.12%
12,000
(iii) ADVISE
There is significant drop down in profitability of Healthcare Unit. This drop down
in coming year indicates that from the financial perspective the operating of
healthcare unit is not a viable option. However, based on information given,
operating an ICU is a lucrative project in-spite of at break even in coming two years.
More than this ICU will increase goodwill and social reputation of the hospital. A good
reputation is an important asset for healthcare providers. Along with credible
market positioning, it is vital for attracting self-reliant, quality-conscious, and
cost-aware patient segments. In long run certainly, it will be worthwhile. Therefore,
it is advisable for SMS Healthcare to switch over from Healthcare Unit to ICU.
(b) OPINION
(i) Use of mobile phone devices in office for personal calls distract the work and even
result in decreased productivity. Therefore, landline phones could be the option.
Clients may be compatible with such type of arrangements but what about after office
hours or there may be a situation which need immediate resolutions even most of
the times senior officials were in meetings or outside the office. Therefore, installation
of landline phone is depending on the cadre of staff and may have restricted use.
(ii) Surely, it will affect the morale of staff since their family members or relatives won’t
be able to contact them in case of an emergency. Depending on the cadre/status
of employee the mobile phones should be deposited at reception and at break time
employees could go check for missed calls of text messages received. Firm may also
reckon about allowance for making personal calls from desk during working hours
as long as it does not become excessive and the work at hand is not jeopardized. For
long term sustainability, it’s better to accept cell phones as a part of modern-day
work life and establish policies for their use. As long as firm enforce its “cell phone
use at work” policy, firm should see usage settle at levels that are reasonable for its
business.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 34 of 35
Page 36
o m
c. o
m .c
e m
em l a s
s ag
PAPER – 5: STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION 35
(c) CLASSIFY
Strategic Objectives Perspective Measures
m
.co
Expansion of eco-friendly Learning & Innovation No. of eco-friendly products
m
c. o m
product line developed.
s e
em Retention
Improve ROI Financial % increase in ROI
s l a
la ag
Customer Customer Perspective % increase in repeat
g
customers/ number of repeat
a Reduction in time spent in Internal Perspective
customers
% increase in MCE / number of
non-value added activities hours saved due to
identification of non-value
added activities
Improve on time delivery Customer Perspective % of orders on time / number of
to customers. (if highly valued by on-time deliveries
customers)
m
Or
. co
Internal Perspective
s em
g l a
a
m
m c. o
c. o s e m
s em l a
gla ag
a
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 35 of 35