Page 1
FOR CA FINAL EXAM PREPARATION
CA Final 2022
Suggested Answers ·
Paper 6C International
Taxation (Old Scheme)
EXAM YEAR TYPE
CA Final 2022 Suggested Answers
SUBJECT DATE
Paper 6C International Taxation (Old Scheme) May 2022
Notes · Sample Papers · Previous Year Papers · Mock Tests
Page 2
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
DISCLAIMER
This Suggested Answers hosted on the website do not constitute the basis for evaluation of the
m
m c. o
co
student’s answers in the examination. The answers are prepared by the Faculty of the Board of
. e m
e m
Studies with a view to assist the students in their education. Alternate Answers have bee n
la s
l a s a g
aerrorg or omission is noticed, the same may be brought to the attention of the Director , Board of
incorporated, wherever necessary. While due care is taken in preparation of the answers, if any
Studies. The Council of the Institute is not in any way responsible for the correctness or
otherwise of the answers published herein.
Further, in the Elective Papers which are Case Study based, the solutions have been worked
o m
out on the basis of certain assumptions/views derived from the facts given in the question o r
c
. to work out the solution to the case studies
m
e made or views taken.
language used in the question. It may be possible
la s
g
in a different manner based on the assumptions
a
m
m .co
c. o se
m
s em g la
gla a
a
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 1 of 33
Page 3
2 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
PAPER 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION
The Question Paper comprises of five case study questions. The candidates are required to
answer any four case study questions out of five.
All questions relate to Assessment Year 2022-23, unless otherwise stated in the
questions/case studies.
Case Study 1
Socrates Ltd., Mumbai
Socrates Ltd. is engaged in redistribution of air coolers in India which are manufactured by its AE
Aristotle Inc., USA. It is also engaged in redistribution of air coolers in India manufactured by Walters
Ltd. of UK which is an unrelated party. During the financial year 2021-22, Socrates Ltd. sold 1.8 lakh
air coolers of Aristotle Inc. and 60,000 air coolers of Walters Ltd. The gross profit margin was 10%
of sales in the case of Aristotle Inc. and 20% of sales in the case of Walters Ltd.
Aristotle Inc. is an internationally recognized brand and industry estimates peg the benefit of the
brand value at 1% of sales. Walters Ltd. extended 3 months credit period and whereas Aristotle
Inc. extended a credit period of only 1 month. The cost of capital was 12% per annum. There are
no other differences between the transaction with related party and unrelated party. Total sales
made by Socrates Ltd. in the financial year 2021-22 in respect of redistribution of goods of Aristotle
Inc., was ` 90 crores and whereas it was ` 36 crores in respect of Walters Ltd.
In light of the significant increase in the volume of business and to mitigate the risks of a transfer
pricing litigation, Socrates Ltd. filed for an Advance Pricing Agreement and concluded the same
in January 2021. It was valid for financial years beginning 2020-21. The APA which was signed
also included a rollback provision.
During the course of its business, Socrates Ltd. entered into an agreement for management
consultancy services from McKolsey GmbH, Germany. As per the agreement, McKolsey GmbH,
Germany was required to send its consultant{s) for conducting a work place improvement and
productivity enhancement study at Socrates facilities. The said consultants were required to
study certain process and practices of Socrates Ltd. at different locations where it operated and
suggest areas of improvement. The consultant(s) were required to be present at the facilities
of Socrates for specified time limit to complete the ground work as agreed in the agreement.
McKolsey GmbH sent an expert in air cooler industry, Dr. Richards, to India. Dr. Richards was
an employee of McKolsey and had resigned a few months before coming to India. However, Dr.
Richards was working for McKolsey as a consultant and was sent to India for this special project.
Socrates Ltd. is required to pay ` 150 lakhs to McKolsey GmbH for the management
consultancy services including those furnished by Dr. Richards who came on their behalf and
stayed in India.
The Suggested Answers for Final Paper 6C: International Taxation, in so far as they relate to
questions involving application of the provisions of Indian tax laws, are based on the provisions
of direct tax laws as amended by the Finance Act, 2021.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 2 of 33
Page 4
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION 3
McKolsey GmbH's tax advisors have advised them to file for an advance ruling to obtain
certainty on the tax treatment of the receipts from Socrates Ltd. in its hands.
m
c. o
Additional advertising efforts including digital marketing
m
co m
Vivi Digital Services Pte Ltd. is a company registered in Singapore. Vivi Digital owns, operates
.
and manages a digital platform for online sale of air coolers. Vivi Digital operates the platform
m s e
e la
'buycoolers.com' which facilitates sale of air coolers owned by companies which are registered
l a s
as sellers on its platform. Aristotle Inc, USA, entered into an agreement with Vivi Digital to
a g
ag
register itself as a seller on the platform. Aristotle Inc wanted to sell certain high -end air coolers
which were not currently marketed by Socrates Ltd. Vivi Digital facilitated sale of goods of
Aristotle Inc to customers in India during the financial year 2021-22. During the said year,
Aristotle was able to sell additional air coolers worth ` 5.60 crores through the buycooler.com
platform to customers in India directly.
Aristotle Inc, USA
Aristotle Inc. USA besides supplying goods to Socrates Ltd. and selling its high -end air coolers
on the digital platform was also engaged in systematic and continuous solicitation of business
activities with users in India. Aristotle wanted to get a better understanding of the market and
m
co
users in India to be able to expand its operations. During the financial year 2021-22, Aristotle
.
Inc had its own website and was also using third party companies to engage in interaction with
em
users directly. As per the last count, Aristotle had 2,50,000 users in India (i.e. , who had IP
a s
address in India). Separately, Aristotle also paid $ 100,000 to Kiwi Research Limited, New
l
Brand ambassador - Mike Pluto g
Zealand for purchase of data relating to preferences of users residing in India.
a
In early 2021, Mike Pluto, a famous football player, was signed up as a brand ambassador by
Aristotle for all its products around the world. In July 2021, Socrates Ltd. was planning the
inauguration of a new retail outlet in Delhi which would also sell Aristotle air coolers.
In June 2021, Mike Pluto came to India and participated in a local football tournament organized
by RAPTO Co Ltd. in India. He was paid ` 10 lakhs as participation fee. He incurred ` 4 lakhs
towards his travel and stay expenses. Socrates Ltd. agreed to pay ` 15 lakhs to Mike Pluto if
he attended the inauguration of the new retail outlet since it would be a great advertisement
o m
c
given that he was the brand ambassador. Socrates also agreed to bear the taxes applicable on
m . fee of
c. o Mike
the said ` 15 lakhs, if any.
m
m sein a game show
Pluto extended his stay and attended the inauguration and earned the advertising
e on television and won ` 10 lakhs as prize money for winning the game. la
s
` 15 lakhs (net of tax applicable). While here in India, Mike Pluto participated
l a a g (5 x 2 = 10 Marks)
ag
Choose the correct alternative for the following MCQs:
1.1 How much is the amount of equalization levy payable for the sales facilitated by Vivi Digital
through buycoolers.com for sale of goods of Aristotle Inc, USA?
(A) @2% being ` 11.20 lakhs payable by Vivi Digital, Singapore
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 3 of 33
Page 5
4 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
(B) @2% being ` 11.20 lakhs payable by Aristotle Inc, USA
(C) NIL
(D) @6% being ` 33.60 lakhs payable by Socrates Ltd.
1.2 Assuming that the DTAA between India and Germany is as per UN Model, how many days
of stay of Dr. Richards in India would lead to existence of PE of McKolsey GmbH in India?
(A) 90 days in total
(B) 183 days in the fiscal year
(C) 183 days in total
(D) Dr. Richards' stay in India does not create a PE of McKolsey GmbH since he is not
an employee.
1.3 For which of the financial years, Socrates Ltd. can avail rollback benefit on the assumption
that it has satisfied all other conditions contained in the Income-tax Act, 1961?
(A) Financial year 2016-17 to financial year 2019-20
(B) Financial year 2015-16 to financial year 2019-20
(C) Financial year 2017-18 to financial year 2020-21
(D) Financial year 2016-17 to financial year 2020-21
1.4 Socrates Ltd. had a dispute on the covered transaction under the APA for financial year
2017-18 and the ITAT has passed an order disposing such appeal as on the date of signing
the APA. What would be the years of rollback under such a scenario?
(A) Socrates Ltd. can choose the years it wants to apply for rollback and it need not chose
all applicable years.
(B) Rollback applies to all applicable years and Socrates Ltd. cannot choose. Hence,
rollback doesn't apply for any year.
(C) Rollback applies to applicable years other than FY 2017-18.
(D) Rollback applies to all applicable years including FY 2017-18 and the ITAT order is
not to be considered.
1.5 If McKolsey GmbH obtains an advance ruling in respect of the taxability of the receipts from
the management consultancy agreement with Socrates, such ruling shall be binding on:
(A) McKolsey GmbH, in relation to the above receipt.
(B) For all similar income streams of McKolsey in India during this year.
(C) The Jurisdictional Assessing Officer of McKolsey GmbH in respect of all receipts of
McKolsey.
(D) McKolsey and the Jurisdictional Assessing Officer of McKolsey in respect of the
Socrates Agreement.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 4 of 33
Page 6
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION 5
You are required to answer the following issues:
1.6 Compute the arm's length price of the transaction between Socrates Ltd. and Aristotle Inc.
m
c. o
using the most appropriate method and state the amount of income liable for adjustment
m
co
in the hands of Socrates Ltd., if any. (5 Marks)
. e m
s
1.7 What is the total income and total tax liability of Mike Pluto for the A.Y.2022-23? How much
e m l
is the amount of income tax liability for Socrates Ltd. in respect of the amount paid to Mike
a
s
a whether Aristotle Inc, USA, being engaged in systematic and continuous soliciting ofa
1.8 lState
Pluto? Is Mike Pluto required to file ITR for the A.Y.2022-23?
g
(6 Marks)
g
a business with users in India and/or incurring expenditure for obtaining data from KIWI
Research Limited, New Zealand would lead to either Aristotle or KIWI Research Limited
having a business connection in India? State the tax consequence, if any arising out of
such actions for both companies. (4 Marks)
Solution to Case Study 1
Answer to Q.1.1 to 1.5
m
Q No. Correct Option
1.1 A
. co
1.2 -1
s em
1.3 A
g l a
1.4 C a
1.5 D2
Answer to Q.1.6
As per section 92B, the transactions entered into between Socrates Ltd., an Indian company,
and Aristotle Inc., USA, being associated enterprises, for redistribution of air coolers would be
international transactions. As Socrates Ltd. purchased air coolers from Aristotle Inc., being an
m
co
associated enterprise, for redistribution to independent parties and Socrates Ltd. does not add
m .
c. o
substantial value to such goods, resale price method would be the most appropriate method
m
se
to determine the ALP of the transactions between associated enterprises. Since Socrates Ltd.
em la
purchased similar air coolers from Walters Ltd., UK, an unrelated entity, and sold the same to
las g
unrelated parties, this transaction can be considered as uncontrolled transaction and the gross
g a
profit margin of 20% earned on sale of such air coolers can be considered for the purpose of
a
determining the arm’s length price of the transactions between Socrates Ltd. and Aristotle Inc.
1 None of the options are correct
2 It is assumed that the advance ruling was pronounced before 1.9.2021 by the Authority for Advance Rulings
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s ag
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 5 of 33
Page 7
6 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
However, functional adjustments need to be given effect to in arriving at the ALP.
Computation of ALP of transaction between Socrates Ltd. and Aristotle Inc.
Particulars Amount (in `)
Resale price of goods purchased from Aristotle Inc. 90,00,00,000
Less: Profit margin with reference to uncontrolled transaction between
Socrates Ltd. and Walters Ltd. (20% on sale) 18,00,00,000
72,00,00,000
Functional adjustments
Adjustment for benefit of brand value of Aristotle Inc. [Aristotle Inc. has its 90,00,000
brand value internationally. Therefore, adjustment of benefit of brand
value has to be carried out to arrive at ALP (1% of sale price)]
Adjustment for credit period [Aristotle Inc. provides credit period of 1
month whereas unrelated party, Walters Ltd. provides credit period of 3
months. Therefore, adjustment for the credit period has to be carried out
to arrive at arm’s length price (1% x 2 months x ` 72,00,00,000)]
(1,44,00,000)
Arm’s length Price 71,46,00,000
Amount of arm’s length adjustment
Particulars Amount (in `)
Resale price of goods purchased from Aristotle Inc. 90,00,00,000
Less: Profit margin (10% on sale) 9,00,00,000
Cost of goods purchased from Aristotle Inc. for redistribution 81,00,00,000
Arm’s length purchase price (computed above) 71,46,00,000
Arm’s length adjustment 9,54,00,000
Answer to Q.1.7
(i) Mike Pluto is a non-resident sportsman deriving income from participation in football
tournaments in India and advertisement. Hence the provisions of section 115BBA would
apply in this case.
Computation of total income and tax liability of Mike Pluto for A.Y.2022-23
Particulars ` `
Income taxable under section 115BBA
Income from participation in football tournament in India 10,00,000
[No deduction is allowable for travel and stay expenses of ` 4
lakh]
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 6 of 33
Page 8
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION 7
Advertisement [15,00,000 x 100/79.2] (Gross) 18,93,939
28,93,939
m
c. o
Income taxable under section 115BB
m
co
Income from game show on television 10,00,000
.
Total income 38,93,939
e m
em
Tax@ 20% under section 115BBA on ` 28,93,939 5,78,788
l a s
l a s
Tax@ 30% under section 115BB on income of ` 10,00,000
3,00,000 a g
ag Add: Health and Education cess@4%
from television game show
8,78,788
35,152
Total tax liability of Mike Pluto for the A.Y.2022-23 9,13,940
(ii) Amount of TDS borne by Socrates Ltd. in respect of amount paid to Mike Pluto
Amount payable to Mike Pluto (net of taxes) = ` 15,00,000
Applicable tax rate = 20% + HEC@4% = 20.8%
m
Therefore, if ` 15,00,000 represents 79.2% (i.e., 100% - TDS 20.8%), then, gross amount
c o
TDS borne by Socrates Ltd. = ` 18,93,939 –. ` 15,00,000 = ` 3,93,939
would be ` 15,00,000 x 100/79.2 = ` 18,93,939.
s em
latotal income of the non-resident sportsman comprises
(iii) Requirement for filing ITR for A.Y.2022-23
g
of only income referred to ina that section and tax deductible at source has been fully
Section 115BBA provides that if the
deducted, it shall not be necessary for him to file his return of income. However, in this
case, Mr. Mike Pluto has income from television game show as well. Therefore, he cannot
avail the benefit of exemption from filing of return of income as contained in section
115BBA. Hence, he would be liable to file his return of income for A.Y.2022 -23.
Answer to Q.1.8
As per section 9(1)(i), business profits of a non-resident/foreign company would be deemed to
m
accrue or arise in India, if such income accrues or arises through or from any business
m .c o
connection in India. In such a case, such income would be taxable in the hands of the non -
c. o Explanation 2A to section 9(1)(i) provides that significant economic presence m
resident/foreign company in India.
s e
em a
of a non -
as l
g users in India,
resident in India would also constitute business connection in India. In case of systematic and
l significant economic presence would be established if the number a
ag
continuous soliciting of business activities or engaging in interaction with
of users is atleast 3 lakhs.
Since Aristotle Inc., a foreign company based in USA, had only 2,50,000 users in India,
business connection is not constituted through significant economic presence in India.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 7 of 33
Page 9
8 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
Hence, no income would be deemed to accrue or arise in India in the hands of Ari stotle Inc.
for the F.Y.2021-22.
Explanation 3A to section 9(1)(i) provides that income attributable to operations in India for
establishing business connection would include income from, inter alia, sale of data collected
from a person who resides in India or from a person who uses internet protocol address
located in India.
Income arising to Kiwi Research Limited, a foreign company based in New Zealand, from sale
of data to Aristotle Inc. would be deemed to accrue or arise in India through business
connection, only if the data is collected from a person who resides in India or from a person
who uses internet protocol address located in India. Otherwise, it would not be taxable in
India.
Case Study: 2
Edison Ltd., Cochin
Edison Ltd., Cochin, is a company engaged in trading activities. It is an associate of Moon Inc.
of USA. The annual consolidated group revenue of Moon Inc. is USD 2,000 million for the
accounting year 2021-2022 (TT buying rate on the last day of the accounting year is 1 USD =
` 75). Edison Ltd. is one of the constituent entities of Moon Inc Group. (being an international
group). The annual turnover of Edison Ltd. always exceeded ` 600 crores which included
` 100 crores being the volume of transactions with associated enterprises outside India.
During the financial year 2021-2022, some of the significant transactions entered into by Edison
Ltd. are:
(1) Dividend received: Edison Ltd. has 27 percent equity shareholding in Mc Dermott LCC
of USA. It received dividend of ` 90 lakhs on 5 th February, 2022. It declared Interim
dividend of ` 40 lakhs on 5 th October, 2021. It has income only under the head 'Profits
and gains from business or profession' (computed) ` 125 lakhs for the assessment year
2022-23 and has opted for section 115BAA.
(2) Transfer Pricing adjustment: Edison Ltd. imported raw materials from its associated
enterprise located in Sri Lanka in the previous year 2019-20. The ALP determination by
applying the most appropriate method resulted in upward revision of its income by ` 140
lakhs. Edison Ltd. has not contested the variation and does not want t o do secondary
adjustment.
(3) Digital advertising: In order to attract new age customers, Edison Ltd. decided to use
digital advertisements for its products. In this connection, it entered into agreement with
Tatla Pte of Singapore on January 1, 2022. Tatla Singapore could organize digital
advertising space for Edison and Edison paid f 6 lakhs on 5 th February, 2022 towards
online advertisement of its products to Tatla Pte of Singapore. Edison was not aware of
the provisions of Equalisation Levy and accordingly had not remitted the same at the time
of payment. An Internal audit conducted in April highlighted this lapse. It remitted the
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 8 of 33
Page 10
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION 9
equalization levy amount on 30 th April, 2022 as soon as the findings of the Internal audit
were known.
m
c. o
(4) Business Trust: Edison Ltd. had certain infrastructure project. In order to monetize the
m
co
same, it contributed those into 'Edison InvIT' and listed the same in accordance with the
. e m
SEBI guidelines. Edison InvIT is eligible to be treated as a 'business trust' (registered as
em
an infrastructure trust under SEBI Regulations 2014) for the purposes of the Income-tax
la s
s g
Act. Edison InvIT paid interest of ` 15 lakhs to a non-resident investor out of the interest
l a a
a(5)g Purchase
income received by it from a SPV.
of Software: Edison Ltd. acquired a ready to use software from Clinton Inc. of
USA for ` 15 lakhs. It also solicited the services of Bimsys Co Ltd., Bengaluru to add some
features in the software so purchased to make it perfectly usable for its business. It paid
` 5 lakhs to Bimsys Co Ltd.
Tripathi, General Manager, Edison Ltd.
Tripathi joined as General Manager of Edison Ltd. in December, 2021. He was in Country 'P' for 10
years and used to visit India in every financial year for a stay of 100 days. He returned to India
permanently in March, 2021. During the previous year 2021-2022, he has been in India throughout.
m
co
He has income both in India and Country P. There is no DTAA between India and Country P. The
Salary from Edison Ltd. (after standard deduction).
following are the details of the income (in INR) for the year ended 31st March, 2022:
Consultancy income in India (computed) se
m 24,00,000
Income from property in Country 'P' gl
a 5,00,000
Agricultural income in Country 'P'
a 3,00,000
2,00,000
Business loss in Country 'P' (converted in Indian currency) (4,00,000)
Dividend from companies in Country 'P' 5,00,000
Rate of tax in Country P (without any basic exemption limit) 15%
Note: Income in Country P converted in INR.
m
Ashok (P) Ltd., Mumbai
m .co
Ashok (P) Ltd., Mumbai is a related party of Edison Ltd. It is engaged in manufacture of medical
c. o se
m
diagnostic equipments. Ashok (P) Ltd. has accumulated reserves and surplus exceeding ` 100
em a
crores. Its holding company (i.e., Bimal Co Ltd.) located in State Z has working capital crunch.
s g l
The Board of Directors of Ashok (P) Ltd. have drawn a plan of action to pump money in Bimal
la a
Co Ltd. and the plan is as under:
ag Incorporate a company by name AB Co Ltd. in Country W (which is a low tax jurisdiction) with
Ashok (P) Ltd. having 10% share capital and Bimal Co Ltd. to have the balance 90% of equity.
The company AB Co Ltd. would have no business activity. It was decided that Bimal Co Ltd.
would transfer fraction of its shares in AB Co Ltd. as and when it requires money to Ashok (P)
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 9 of 33
Page 11
10 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
Ltd. at 50 times to 100 times more than its cost of acquisition. The capital gain is tax-free in
both Country Z and Country W as per domestic laws.
Choose the correct alternative for the following MCQs: (5 x 2 = 10 Marks)
2.1 How much is the amount of tax payable by Edison Ltd. on dividend income received from
Mc Dermott LLC of USA?
(A) ` 15,02,280
(B) ` 14,32,080
(C) ` 8,34,600
(D) ` 7,80,000
2.2 Compute the amount of tax payable by Edison Ltd. as a consequence of primary
adjustment in respect of its transactions with its associated enterprise in Sri Lanka to get
relief from making secondary adjustment.
(A) ` 29,35,296
(B) ` 26,20,800
(C) ` 24,46,080
(D) ` 21,84,000
2.3 How much is payable by way of penalty by Edison Ltd. for the delay in remittance of
equalization levy?
(A) ` 54,000
(B) ` 53,000
(C) ` 36,000
(D) ` 10,000
2.4 At what rate is Edison InvIT required to deduct tax at source on the interest income
distribution to non-resident?
(A) 41.6%
(B) 31.2%
(C) 10.4%
(D) 5.2%
2.5 How much is the withholding of tax to be made by Edison Ltd. for the software acquired
from Clinton Inc. and how much is deductible at source on the payment made to Bimsys
Co Ltd.?
(A) 41.6% on ` 15 lakhs and 10% on ` 5 lakhs
(B) 10% on ` 15 lakhs and Nil on ` 5 lakhs
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 10 of 33
Page 12
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION 11
(C) 20.8% on ` 15 lakhs and 20.8% on ` 5 lakhs
(D) Nil on ` 15 lakhs and 10% on ` 5 lakhs
m
c. o
You are required to answer the following issues:
m
.co m
2.6 Is Edison Ltd. required to keep and maintain information and documents as a constituent
m
entity of the international group? Also, state whether it has to furnish any report in this
s e
s e g la
regard. If yes, which report and by which due date? (5 Marks)
l a a
a2.8g Compute the tax liability of Tripathi for the assessment year 2022-23.
2.7 As the Tax Manager of Ashok (P) Ltd., you have to evaluate the proposed plan of action
in the light of its permissibility under the Income-tax Act,1961. (4 Marks)
(6 Marks)
Note: Assume he has not opted for section 115BAC.
Solution to Case Study 2
Answer to Q.2.1 to 2.5
Q No. Correct Option
m
co
2.1 -3
.
em
2.2 A
2.3 C
l a s
2.4
2.5
D
A or D ag
Note – The first part of MCQ 2.5 requires how much tax is to be withheld by Edison Ltd., an
Indian company for software acquired from Clinton Inc, a US company. The facts of the case
given in page 9 simply states that Edison Ltd. acquired a ready to use software from Clint on Inc
of USA. The rate of TDS would be 41.6% as per the provisions of the Income -tax Act, 1961,
since the question does not mention that the agreement is approved by the Central Government.
The question does not contain the terms of the agreement to decide about the applicability or
o m
c
otherwise of the Supreme Court ruling in Engineering Analysis Centre of Excellence P. Ltd. v. CIT
m .
c. o
and Another. If this ruling is applicable to the case on hand, the correct answer would be Nil for the
em
s
first part of the question.
em l a
as g
Accordingly, either A or D can be chosen as the correct answer, depending on whether or not
l a
ag
the Supreme Court ruling is applicable to the case on hand.
3 None of the options are correct
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 11 of 33
Page 13
12 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
Answer to Q.2.6
As per section 92D(1)(ii), every person, being constituent entity of an international group, has
to keep and maintain the prescribed information and document in respect of the international
group.
Rule 10DA provides that every person, being a constituent entity of an international group shall–
(i) if the consolidated group revenue of the international group, of which such person is a
constituent entity, as reflected in the consolidated financial statement of the international
group for the accounting year, exceeds ` 500 crore; and
(ii) the aggregate value of international transactions –
(A) during the accounting year, as per the books of accounts, exceeds
` 50 crore, or
(B) in respect of purchase, sale, transfer, lease or use of intangible property during the
accounting year, as per the books of accounts, exceeds ` 10 crore
keep and maintain information and documents of the international group.
The rate of exchange for the calculation of the value in rupees of the consolidated group revenue
in foreign currency would be the TTBR of such currency on the last day of the accounting year.
In the given case, Edison, being the constituent entity, is required to keep and maintain
information and documents since the consolidated group revenue for the accounting year 2021-
22 exceeds the threshold of ` 500 crores (i.e., ` 15,000 crore, in this case) and the aggregate
value of international transaction of Edison Ltd. during the accounting year exceeds ` 50 crore
(i.e., it is ` 100 crore, in this case).
Yes, it has to furnish report in Form No. 3CEAA to the Joint Director as may be designated by
PDGIT (Systems) or DGIT (Systems) and it shall be furnished on or before the due date for
furnishing the return of income specified under section 139(1) i.e., 30 th November, 2022.
Where there is more than one constituent entity of an international group require to file the
information and documents under sub-rule (2) of Rule 10DA, Form 3CEAA may be furnished by –
i) any one constituent entity which has been designated for this purpose; and
ii) the information has to be conveyed to the Joint Director as may be designated by PGIT
(Systems) or DGIT (Systems) as the case may be in Form 3CEAB atleast 30 days before
the due date of furnishing return under section 139(1), i.e., before 31st October, 2022.
Answer to Q.2.7
The arrangement of routing money through AB Co Ltd. results in a tax benefit. Since there is no
business purpose in incorporating AB Co Ltd. in Country W, which is a Low tax jurisdiction, it
can be said that the main purpose of the arrangement is to obtain a tax benefit on account of
capital gains being tax free in both Country Z and Country W as per the domestic laws of these
countries. The alternate course available in this case is direct advance given by Ashok (P) Ltd.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 12 of 33
Page 14
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION 13
to Bimal Co. Ltd. However, in that case, it would be deemed as dividend under section 2(22)(e)
and would be chargeable to tax in the hands of Bimal Co. Ltd.
m
c. o
As per section 96, impermissible avoidance arrangement means an arrangement where the
m
co
main purpose is to obtain tax benefit and it -
. e m
s
i. creates rights or obligations, which are not ordinarily created between persons dealing at
em la
s
arm’s length;
l a a g
aiii.g lacks
ii. results directly or indirectly, in the misuse or abuse, of the provisions of the Act; or
commercial substance or is deemed to lack commercial substance under section 97,
in whole or in part; or
iv. is entered into or carried out, by means of, or in aa manner, which are not ordinarily
employed for bona fide purposes.
Hence, the arrangement may be deemed to lack commercial substance, GAAR may be invoked.
However, if the tax benefit in the relevant assessment year arising, in aggregate, to all the
parties to the arrangement does not exceed ` 3 crore, then, GAAR provisions would not be
m
c. o
invoked.
Tripathi would be a resident in India for A.Y. m
Answer to Q.2.8
ofestay in India for 182 days or more during the P.Y.
the year and satisfied the basic condition s
2022-23 since he has stayed in India throughout
g la
a resident for A.Y. 2022-23 if -
2021-22.
Tripathi would be resident and ordinarily
- he has during the 7 previous years preceding the relevant previous year been in India for a
period of 730 days or more; and
- he has been resident in India at least 2 out of the 10 previous years preceding the relevant
previous year
Both the conditions have to be satisfied for being a Resident and Ordinarily Resident. Since
m
Tripathi does not satisfy the above mentioned conditions cumulatively, he would be resident but
m As per section 5(1), in case of a resident but nor ordinarily resident, c o
c. o - income which accrues or arises or which is deemed to accrue or arise tosehimmin. India or
not ordinarily resident (RNOR) in India for A.Y. 2022-23.
s em income which is received or is deemed to be received in India or la
g controlled in or
l a -
a
ag - income which accrues or
profession set up in India
arises to him outside India from a business
would be includible in his total income.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 13 of 33
Page 15
14 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
Computation of tax liability of Tripathi for A.Y. 2022-23
Particulars Amount
(`)
Salary from Edison Ltd. (computed) [accrues and arises in India] 24,00,000
Consultancy income in India (computed) [accrues and arises in India] 5,00,000
Income from Property in Country “P” [neither accrues or arises nor is -
received in India]
Agricultural income in Country “P” [neither accrues or arises nor is received in -
India]
Business loss in Country “P” [neither accrues or arises nor is received in India] -
Dividend from companies in Country “P” [neither accrues or arises nor is -
received in India]
Total Income 29,00,000
Computation of tax liability
Tax on ` 19,00,000 [` 29,00,000 – ` 10,00,000] x 30% plus ` 1,12,500 6,82,500
Add: Health and education cess@4% 27,300
Tax Liability 7,09,800
Note – In the facts (given in page 10 of the question paper) relating to Mr. Tripathi, it is not
mentioned that whether the income accrued or arisen in Country “P” is received in India or not.
Since Mr. Tripathi is a resident but not resident in India for A.Y. 2022 -23, income accrued or
arisen in Country “P” would be taxable in India only if it is received in India. In the absence of
relevant information, the main solution has been worked out assuming income of Country “P”
has not been received in India and hence, not taxable in India in the hands of Tripathi.
However, if it is assumed that income of Country “P” is received in India and hence, would be
subject to tax in India, tax liability of Tripathi would be as given below –
Computation of tax liability of Tripathi for A.Y. 2022-23
Particulars Amount (`)
Salary from Edison Ltd. (computed) [accrues and arises in India] 24,00,000
Income from property in Country “P” [Assumed to be received in India] 3,00,000
Consultancy income in India (computed) [accrues and arises 5,00,000
in India]
Less: Set off of business loss in Country “P” 4,00,000 1,00,000
Agricultural income in Country “P” [Assumed to be received in India] 2,00,000
Dividend from companies in Country “P” [Assumed to be received in India] 5,00,000
Total Income 35,00,000
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 14 of 33
Page 16
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION 15
Computation of tax liability `
Tax on ` 25,00,000 [` 35 lakhs – ` 10 lakhs] x 30% plus ` 1,12,500 8,62,500
m
c. o
Add: Health and education cess@4% 34,500
m
co
Tax Liability 8,97,000
. e m
s
Average rate of tax in India [` 8,97,000/ ` 35,00,000 x 100] = 25.628%
em
Tax rate in Country P = 15%
la
l a s
Doubly taxed income = ` 3,00,000, being income from property +
a g
ag
` 2,00,000, being agricultural income + ` 5,00,000, being dividend – ` 4,00,000,
being business loss = ` 6,00,000
Relief under section 91 [Doubly taxed income x rate of tax in Country P or 90,000
average rate of tax in India, whichever is lower (` 6,00,000 x 15%)]
Tax payable 8,07,000
Note – In the facts (given in page 10 of the question paper), income from property in Country
“P” is given as ` 3,00,000. It is not mentioned whether it is computed after giving deduction of
30% u/s 24(a) or it is the rental income. The above solution has been worked assuming it is the
m
income computed from property after providing deduction of 30%. However, if it is assumed that
co
the same is rental income, deduction of 30% has to be provided. In such a case, total income
.
em
of Tripathi would be ` 34,10,000 and tax liability (before relief) would be ` 8,68,920. Doubly
s
taxed income and relief u/s 91 would be ` 5,10,000 and ` 76,500, respectively. The tax payable
by Tripathi would be ` 7,92,420.
l a
g Case Study: 3
a
Mr. Ram is a citizen of India who has been a Non-resident for Indian tax and exchange control
purposes. Ram holds 40% of voting power in ACo Inc, a company incorporated under the law
of Country A. For the purpose of expansion of business, the said company enters into an
agreement with MinMax Ltd., a company incorporated under the Indian laws. ACo Inc does not
hold shares in MinMax Ltd. but only enters into a 'preferred distributor' agreement.
Business activities of MinMax Ltd.
m
As per one of the clauses of the above agreement, A Co Inc has the power to appoint 7 directors
m .co
out of the 12 directors on the Board of MinMax Ltd. Mr. Ram is appointed as one of the Directors
c. o m
of the Indian company, MinMax Ltd. This is to exercise control over the operations of MinMax
se
Ltd. and to ensure that interests of A Co Inc are protected and that MinMax does not enter into
s em l a` 500 Crores, out of
any agreement or business relationship with competitors of ACo Inc.
The total purchase by MinMax Ltd. for the F.Y. 2021-22 is estimated togbe
gla a is to be supplied by
a
which, purchase of ` 50 Crores would be sourced locally and the balance
ACo Inc. The price for entire purchase has been fixed in the agreement and the conditions for
supply are determined by ACo Inc.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 15 of 33
Page 17
16 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
MinMax Ltd. would need to expand its operations to cater to the demands of AC o Inc and
proposes to borrow ` 200 Crores from State Bank of India (SBI). Since the borrowing is for the
purposes of operations of ACo Inc, 100% of the guarantees required by the Bank are provided
by ACo Inc. This is the first time that ACo Inc has given guarantees to an unrelated company.
The total borrowings of MinMax Ltd. is ` 1000 Crores.
MinMax Ltd. buys mobile phones from ACo Inc. The mobile phones are branded for which royalty
of ` 100 per mobile phone sold is paid to ACo Inc. Similar mobile phones are sold to other
customers in India by ACo Inc directly. The credit period offered to MinMax Ltd. is 2 months,
whereas other customers pay immediately. During the F.Y.2021-22, 10 lakh mobile phones were
bought for an aggregate sum of ` 2600 Crores from ACo Inc. Assume the royalty is included in
` 2600 Crores. The entire purchase of MinMax Ltd. were sold in the F.Y. 2021-22. MinMax Ltd.
failed to report ACo Inc as an Associated Enterprise and transactions with them were not
reported as 'international transactions'. MinMax Ltd. has received a notice from the Income Tax
department in this regard. MinMax Ltd. is now considering the option of filing Form 3CEB and
TP study/documentation relating to determination of Arm's Length Price.
Contract with BigData Company
During the financial year 2020-2021, MinMax Ltd. entered into an agreement with BigData
Company, a company registered and incorporated in Country K (India does not have a DTAA with
Country K). The agreement was for provision of certain data analytics services which would
amount to fees for technical services under the Income-tax Act. The agreement required an
advance payment of USD 100,000. The payment being made by a resident company (i.e., MinMax
Ltd.), taxes were required to be withheld at source under section 195 of the Act and net amount
was to be remitted to BigData Company. BigData Company has drawn the attention of MinMax
to a clause in the agreement which requires MinMax to pay the agreed amounts to BigData
Company in full and that MinMax needs to bear the taxes in India, if applicable. Accordingly, the
said advance of USD 100,000 has been paid to BigData Company on March 31, 2022.
Nesla Inc owned by Ram
Nesla Inc, a company manufacturing Electric vehicles. Nesla Inc is owned by Mr. Ram and is a
company headquartered in Country A. Mr. Jeff is citizen and resident of Country A since 2005
and has been working in Nesla. Mr. Jeff is appointed as Head of South Asia - Operations in April
2021 to understand the prospects in South Asian market and preparation of a plan for selling
vehicles in the South Asian market. Presently Ram’s enterprises are not engaged in any
business in South Asia.
Jeff travels to India in April 2021 and stays in a hotel in New Delhi for ten days. Thereafter, Jeff
travels extensively in India, Sri Lanka, Singapore, etc. to meet prospective dealers, automobile
experts, etc. Jeff also gives interviews in various auto magazines and automobile shows on TV
about the plans of Nesla. Jeff's job requires him to visit his head office in Country A every 25
days for reporting purposes. When Jeff visits the headquarters in June 2021, he discusses the
possibility of importing one Model-N Electric vehicle of Nesla Inc. He feels that display of the
car in India to prospective customers would increase the interest in the company's products.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 16 of 33
Page 18
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION 17
Ram approves the plan and one Model-N car is sent to India to be placed at the Mumbai airport
for display. The car is imported in accordance with the Customs law. Mumbai Airport Limited,
m
the operator of the airport, charges of ` 5,00,000·per month rent to Nesla Inc for space for
m c. o
displaying the car. Many prospective customers reach out to Jeff wanting to place orders for
co m
the car. Jeff informs that he is not autorised to obtain orders and the orders, if any, have to be
m .
placed directly on Nesla and the cars have to be imported directly by those who are interested.
s e
s e la
Given the increased interest, Mr. Jeff also meets prospective businessmen who could be
l a
appointed as dealers. It is decided that Nesla would appoint dealers in India and start selling
a g
ag
their cars from April 2022. Jeff concludes the financial year 2021-2022 with a clear plan for
India. He ends up spending about 80 days in India in the financial year.
Choose the correct alternative from the following MCQs: (5 x 2 = 10 Marks)
3.1 As regards the requirement for Mr. Ram to obtain a Permanent Account Number (PAN) in
India, which of the below statements are true?
(A) Ram is required to obtain a PAN if he has taxable income in India
(B) Ram is required to obtain a PAN since he is a director of an Indian company
m
(C) Ram is required to obtain a PAN since he is a director and has taxable Income
c o
. of the following statement is NOT true?
(D) Ram is not required to obtain a PAN in India
m
eto determine arm’s length price if information and
3.2 In respect of transfer pricing provisions, which
s
la transaction has not been maintained by the
(A) The Assessing Officer has powers
a g
documents relating to an international
taxpayer.
(B) Where any other International Transaction, other than those reported by the
assessee, come to the notice of the TPO, he cannot apply the transfer pricing
provisions on such transactions.
(C) Where in respect of any international transaction, the assessee has not furnished the
report u/s 92E, the TPO can apply the transfer pricing provisions on the same.
(D) The Assessing Officer will proceed for the assessment in conformity with the ALP as
m
determined by the TPO.
m c o
.transaction
c. o
3.3 Which of the below statement is False?
e m
s
(A) 2% penalty is to be levied if the persons fail to report the international
s em a
lto file the report of an
which is required to be reported.
la a
(B) The penalty of ` 2 lakhs shall be payable if the persons failg
ag accountant.
(C) The penalty u/s 271AA shall be in addition and not in substitution of penalty u/s
271BA.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 17 of 33
Page 19
18 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
(D) Failure to report any international transaction would be considered as misreporting of
income and 200% of the tax payable on underreported Income.
3.4 In respect of taxability of Mr. Jeff’s salary (resident of Country A - India has a DTAA
following UN Model), which statement is true?
(A) Salary is taxable for 80 days because he has rendered services in India.
(B) Salary is taxable, but he can claim short stay exemption because his stay is less than
90 days in India.
(C) Salary is not taxable, because the foreign enterprise is not engaged in any business
or trade in India.
(D) Salary is not taxable because the remuneration is not liable to be deducted from the
income of the employer chargeable under Income Tax Act, 1961.
3.5 Which is the most appropriate method for determining the arm's length price of the
transaction of purchase of mobile phones by MinMax Ltd. from ACo Inc:
(A) Comparable Uncontrolled Price Method
(B) Resale Price Method
(C) Profit Split Method
(D) Cost Plus Method
You are required to answer the following issues:
3.6 Are ACo Inc and MinMax Ltd. 'associated enterprises'? If they are, list all the circumstances
which lead to the conclusion that they are associated enterprises. (4 Marks)
3.7 You are a practising Chartered Accountant specializing in International taxation and Nesla
Inc approaches you to advise them on India tax implications of their presence in India.
What would your advice be on presence of a Permanent Establishment, filing of returns or
compliances, if any, for the F.Y. 2021-22. (5 Marks)
3.8 In respect of the payment of USD 100,000 made to BigData Company on March 31, 2022,
you are required to advise on the following:
(a) MinMax Ltd. has not complied with the TDS provisions until date. What is the
amount to be remitted if taxes are to be grossed up assuming a TDS rate of 10%?
And what amount needs to be deposited today with applicable interest? (Assume
applicable exchange rate to be 1 USD = 75.60 INR) (3 Marks)
(b) No work has commenced on the project as on date. MinMax Ltd. is contemplating
cancelation of the contract. If the contract is cancelled after the TDS is remitted, would
the amount remitted be refundable?If yes, who can claim that refund and what is the
process? (3 Marks)
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 18 of 33
Page 20
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION 19
Solution to Case Study 3
m
Answer to Q.3.1 to 3.5
m c. o
c. o B
Q No. Correct Option
e m
s
3.1
3.2 m
s e g la
l3.3a
B
g a
a 3.4
B
- 4
3.5 A
Answer to Q.3.6
Yes, Minimax Ltd., an Indian company, and A Co. Inc., a Country A company, are deemed to
be associated enterprises, if they fall under any one or more of the situations contained in
m
section 92A(2). In this case, they fulfill the following three conditions in section 92A(2) –
Condition for Deemed
c. o Fulfilment of condition in this case
emhas the power to If this power is
Associated Enterprise (AE)
(i) One enterprise appoints A sCo
a 7 directors out of the exercised by A Co,
more than half of the Board of lappoint
g
Directors of the other a 12 directors on the Board of then, MinMax Ltd. and
enterprise MinMax Ltd, which is more A Co. would be
than half. deemed AEs.
(ii) 90% or more of raw materials/ 90% of purchases of MinMax Due to fulfillment of
consumables required for Ltd. are from A Co. Inc. (i.e., this condition, MinMax
manufacturing by one ` 450 crores out of total Ltd. and A Co. would
enterprise are supplied by the ` 500 crores). The price for be deemed AEs
m
other enterprise, and the prices purchases is fixed in the
m
and other conditions relating to
.c o
agreement and conditions for
c. o e m
the supply are influenced by supply are determined by A
m a s
such other enterprise Inc.
s e l
10% or more of the total total borrowings of MinMax gcondition, MinMax Ltd.
a a
(iii) One enterprise guarantees A Co. guarantees 20% of the Due to fulfillment of this
l
ag borrowings of the other Ltd. (i.e., ` 200 crores out of and A Co. would be
enterprise. ` 1,000 crores). deemed AEs
4 None of the options are correct
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 19 of 33
Page 21
20 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
Answer to Q.3.7
Nesla Inc is incorporated in Country A, which has a DTAA with India in line with UN Model
Convention. Accordingly, the relevant clauses of Article 5 of UN Model Convention have to
be examined to determine whether a PE is constituted in India.
Relevant Clause of Article 5 Satisfaction or otherwise of
condition for A.Y.2022-23
Article 5(3) Furnishing of services through an employee PE is not constituted, since
engaged by the enterprise would constitute a Jeff spends only 80 days in
PE, if activities of that nature continue in the India in the P.Y.2021-22.
other Contracting State for a period of more
than 183 days in a fiscal year.
Article 5(4) PE shall be deemed not to include use of PE is not constituted since
facilities solely for the purpose of storage or facilities of airport space is
display of goods or merchandise belonging to used solely for display of
the enterprise. Model N car.
Article 5(5) PE shall be constituted by an enterprise, PE is not constituted, since
where a person is acting in a Contracting Jeff neither concludes
State on behalf of an enterprise, and that contracts nor plays the
person habitually concludes contracts or principal role in conclusion of
plays the principal role in conclusion of contracts on behalf of Nesla
contracts that are routinely concluded without Inc.
material modification by the enterprise.
Nesla Inc need not file return of income for A.Y.2022-23
Though no PE is constituted for Nesla Inc for A.Y.2022-23, TDS provisions under section
194-I would be attracted on airport charges payable by Nesla Inc to Mumbai Airport Ltd.,
since the same exceeds ` 2,40,000 p.a. Accordingly, it has to apply for Tax deduction
account number (TAN) and file quarterly TDS statements before the prescribed due dates
(31st July, 31st October, 31 st January and 31st May, respectively, for the different quarters). It
has to remit the tax deducted in the month of March on or before 30 th April and in case of
other months, on or before 7 days from the end of the month of deduction.
Answer to Q.3.8
`
(a) Tax to be deducted u/s 195 = 10% + cess@4% = 10.4%
Fee for technical services (net) = USD 1,00,000 x ` 75.60 = ` 75,60,000
Fee for technical services (gross) = ` 75,60,000 x 100/89.6 = ` 84,37,500
TDS = 10.4% of ` 84,37,500 8,77,500
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 20 of 33
Page 22
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION 21
[email protected]% per month on ` 8,77,500 (for delay in deposit of TDS) for
2 months (from 31 st March, 2022 to 25 th May, 2022) 26,325
m
c. o
Total amount to be deposited (including interest) 9,03,825
o m m
c
(b) Yes, the amount of TDS remitted is refundable, if contract is cancelled. Since MiniMax
. e
emu/s 195 to the person deducting tax at source from the payment to a non - glas
Ltd. has borne the TDS, it can claim refund
s
CBDT Circular No.7/2007 dated 23.10.2007 lays down the procedure for refund of
la resident. a
TDS
ag The said Circular allows refund to the person making payment under section 195,
after deposit of TDS u/s 195 to the Government account.
The amount can be refunded subject to prior approval of the Chief Commissioner of
Income-tax or the Director General of Income-tax concerned, to the person who
deducted it from the payment to the non-resident, under section 195.
In a case where remittance is made to the non-resident, but contract is cancelled, the
remitted amount would be returned to the person responsible for deducting tax at
source.
m
co
A refund in terms of this Circular should be granted only after obtaining an
.
em
undertaking that no certificate under section 203 has been issued to the non-resident.
s
The amount deducted as tax and paid to the credit of the Government, therefore,
l a
belongs to the deductor. In this case, the deductor, MiniMax Ltd. has itself borne the
a g
TDS u/s 195, therefore, refund can be claimed by MiniMax Ltd.
Case Study 4
Business International Ltd. (Bl) is a multinational Group with interests in multiple businesses.
The consolidated group revenue of BI Group is more than ` 1000 Crores 5. A-XI Ltd., an Indian
company successfully bid for Indian Cricket League (ICL). A-XI Ltd. is a part of the BI Group.
The company selected 15 players cricket team. As per ICL mandate, the team composition
would be mixed Indian and Foreign players. A-XI Ltd. selected foreign players from South
Africa, Australia, Kenya and Bangladesh. A-XI Ltd. has to pay franchisee fees $ 10 MN to
m
co
International Cricket Control Board (ICCB). As per the agreement, A-XI Ltd. will get share
m .
c. o
of 5% in revenue generated through selling of match telecast right and 5% revenue for the
m
se
sale of tickets. The worldwide telecast rights for the event have been awarded to Sumito
em la
Satellite, Japan. For the promotion of the team, A-XI Ltd. hired David Bothom, Ex-Australian
las a g
Cricketer. A-XI Ltd. also entered into an agreement with Albert Advertising, a Singapore
ag
company for online advertisement of match promos. All the foreign players will get $1MN as
match fees.
5 To be read as ` 10,000 Crores
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 21 of 33
Page 23
22 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
More details about each of the parties with whom A-XI Ltd. transacts and details of the
transactions are as under:
1. Peter, Player from South Africa.
In the financial year 2021-22, Peter was in India for a test series for 60 days and after 20
days rest period in India, he played ICL for another 60 days.
His income from India is as below:
Particulars Amount Remarks
Test match fee $ 0.5 MN
ICL Match Fees $ 1.0 MN
Advertisement for an automobile $ 0.25 MN The shooting was held in India.
company headquartered in US The payer company is from US.
Article writing fee (Articles on $ 0.10 MN The article was published in
ICL) newspaper widely circulated in
India.
Participation fees charged in live $ 0.25 MN
TV show in India.
Article writing fee for an online $ 0.25 MN Published in leading sports portal
platform. (Articles on Motivation accessible worldwide.
etc. of Sportsmen)
Auction of his Cricket bat $1.00 MN Which is donated to a, charitable
Institution in India (approved
under section 80G).
2. Shiv Paul, Player from Kenya.
He was in India in FY 2021-22 for 90 days only. His father was citizen of India, settled in
Kenya. His father has a residential house in Jaipur (Rajasthan) which is rented to an
Individual and the monthly rental income ` 2 lakhs. Rent is paid by the tenant to a Private
Trust created by his father where Shiv Paul is the sole beneficiary, and the trust is
registered in Cayman Island. The private trust is non-discretionary, specific, irrevocable
trust. The bank account of the trust is in Kenya and rent is remitted to Kenya Bank Account.
Apart from ICL match fees, he also participated in advertisement of fashion wear and
income from such advertisement shoot is ` 10 lakhs.
3. Albert Advertising, Singapore.
Albert Advertising is a company based in Singapore and Sumio Satelite, a company based
in Japan, is one of the largest shareholders with 40% of the shares being held by them. A-
XI Ltd. also holds 65% equity in Sumito Satellite. Mr. Raghvendra is CEO of Albert
Advertising, and he is also Director (Marketing) of A-XI Ltd. The total contract value of
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 22 of 33
Page 24
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION 23
A-XI Ltd. and Albert Advertising is for $ 50 MN and the entire amount has been paid in
advance by A-XI Ltd. Albert Advertising has entered into similar type of agreement with
m
other companies. The contract values are an average of about $ 45 MN. In those later
m c. o
agreements, the terms are different and importantly, the companies are permitted to pay
co m
the fees over a 3 month period. Mr. Raghvendra does not hold any equity in A-XI Ltd. A-
m .
XI Ltd. has given the corporate guarantee to Singapore Bank for a loan of $ 2 Million
s e
s e la
obtained by Albert Advertising. Albert Advertising's total borrowings are about $ 30 million.
l a a g
ag Raghavendra
4. Raghavendra, CEO of Albert Advertising
is the CEO of Albert Advertising since January 2019. He has been a part of
the senior management of the BI Group for many decades. Raghavendra was with Sumito
Satellite Japan as Manager marketing from January 2008 to December 2014. He relocated
to India in January 2015 accepting the role of Director Marketing at A-XI Ltd. He was in
India from January 2015 to December 2018 and relocated to Singapore from 2019. He
has been a non-resident since P.Y. 2019-2020. In March 2022, the income tax department
came to know of a residential property acquired by Raghavendra in Japan in 2016. A
notice under section 10 of the Black Money Act, 2015 has been issued.
m
Raghavendra says he bought the house for $ 5,00,000 in 2016. The fair value of the house
. co
as determined valuer recognised by the Govt of Japan as on 31st March, 2022 is $ 1.5
em
million.
5. Sumito Satellite, Japan
l a s
a g
The company got the live telecast right of ICL matches and the contract value is $ 200 Mn.
The said amount is payable to ICCB. Sumito Satellite expects to earn about $ 400 Mn by
selling timeslot for advertisement during the tournament. To carry on the activities in India,
the company has set up a project office in Delhi. The Company has deputed two
technicians, who would be staying in India for a total period of 100 days to manage
uninterrupted relay of live telecast of ICL matches. The salary of technician A and
Technician B would be $ 5000 per month. Since Sumito Satellite needs more staff; they
propose to hire some staff from A-XI Ltd. who will work under the supervision of technician
A and B. For hiring of staff from A-XI Ltd., Sumito Satellite would pay $ 1 Lakh.
m
co
6. David Bothom, Ex Australian Cricketer.
m .
c. o
He is resident of Australia, stayed in India in the P.Y.2021-22 for 65 days, he will get ` 25
m
se
lakhs for promotion of matches. Apart from this, he wrote some article in newspaper and
em l a
his fees for writing articles is ` 5 lakh and he has also become the visiting faculty for
las g
coaching in Indian Cricket Academy and his fees for the same is ` 10 lakh.
a (5 x 2 = 10 Marks)
ag
Choose the correct alternative from the following MCQs:
4.1 What is the due date for filing Country by country reporting by A-XI Ltd.?
(A) On or before the due date of furnishing the return of income.
(B) One month before the specified date of filing of Income tax return.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 23 of 33
Page 25
24 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
(C) Within the end of twelve months from the end of the accounting period of the reporting
entity.
(D) On or before the end 30th November of the Assessment year.
4.2 Is the tenant of the Jaipur house required to deduct tax at source while remitting the rent,
if the rent is taxable in India?
(A) No, because individual assessee is not required to deduct TDS unless the Turnover
in the preceding years from business exceeds ` 1 Crore.
(B) No, because the house is being used for residential purpose and not for business
purpose.
(C) Yes, because TDS is applicable while making payment to Non-resident and the sum
is chargeable to tax in India.
(D) Yes, because the rent payment is more than ` 2.40 lakhs.
4.3 Raghavendra wants to argue that the notice issued to him under section 10 of the Black
Money Act, 2015 is invalid since he is a non-resident in 2021-2022 and that he had
acquired the property out of his tax paid income in Japan while he was a non -resident.
What would you advise?
(A) The notice is invalid since he is a non-resident in the year of issue of notice.
(B) The notice is invalid since the assets have been acquired out of income earned while
he was a non-resident.
(C) The notice is valid since the property was acquired in the year when he was a
resident.
(D) The notice is valid even if he was a non-resident in all the years in question.
4.4 As a Transfer Pricing consultant, please advise whether A-XI Ltd. and Albert Advertising
is Associated Enterprise or not?
(A) Yes, because one enterprise participates directly in the shares carrying not less than
twenty six percent of the voting power in the other enterprise.
(B) Yes, because one enterprise participates indirectly in the shares carrying not less
than twenty six percent of the voting power in the other enterprise.
(C) Yes, because Mr. Raghvendra is the common director in both the companies.
(D) Yes, because one enterprise guarantees loan exceeding the prescribed percent of
the total borrowings of the other enterprise.
4.5 Whether employees of Sumito Satellite will create Permanent Establishment in India?
(A) Yes, because employees stay in India is more than ninety days.
(B) No, because project does not last more than six months.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 24 of 33
Page 26
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION 25
(C) No, because PE cannot be created because of the stay of employees in India.
(D) Yes, because the foreign company has a project office in India.
m
c. o
You are required to answer the following issues:
m
.co e m
4.6 Give a brief note on the taxability of each source of income of Peter, the South African
m la s
player. (Assume exchange rate for computing income to be 1 USD = 75 INR) (7 Marks)
s e g
a
4.7 If the house property in Japan is held to be an undisclosed foreign asset under the Black
l a
ag
Money Act, what is the maximum tax and interest liability that Raghavendra could have?
You need not comment on other penal implications. (Assume exchange rate for computing
income to be 1 USD = 75 INR) (3 Marks)
4.8 Give a brief note on the total income and tax liability of Shiv Paul, Kenya Player. Whether
your answer would be different if there is no trust, and the payment of rent is made directly
to the account of Shiv Paul outside India? (5 Marks)
Solution to Case Study 4
Answer to Q.4.1 to 4.5
m
co
Q No. Correct Option
.
em
4.1 C
4.2 C
l a s
4.3
4.4
C
B a g
4.5 B or C
Note - MCQ 4.5 requires candidates to examine whether the employees of Sumito Satellite,
Japan will create PE in India. Since it is not mentioned whether India’s DTAA with Japan is
based on OECD Model Convention or UN Model Convention, the question can be answered on
m
the basis that India’s DTAA with Japan is based on OECD Model Convention or the UN Model
co
Convention. Option (B) would be the correct option as per UN Model Tax Convention and Option
m .
c. o Answer to Q.4.6
(C) would be correct option as per OECD Model Convention, since there is no concept of service
m
se
PE in OECD Model Convention.
s em l a 2022-23 since his
Peter, being a foreign national, would be non-resident in India for thegA.Y.
gla a stay in India is less than
a
stay in India is for only 140 days during the previous year 2021-22. His
182 days in the P.Y.2021-22. Also, he does not satisfy the condition of minimum 60 days in the
P.Y.2021-22 and 365 days in the four immediately preceding previous years, since the question
does not mention about his stay in India in the earlier previous years.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 25 of 33
Page 27
26 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
In case of non-resident, income which accrues or arises in India, income which is received in
India and income which is deemed to accrue or arise in India would alone be taxable in India.
As per section 115BBA, income received or receivable by a non-resident sportsman (including an
athlete) by way of inter alia participation in any game or sport in India; or advertisement; or
contribution of articles relating to any game or sport in India in newspapers, magazines or
journals would be chargeable to tax @20% plus surcharge, where applicable, plus health and
education cess@4%. Accordingly, his income from India would be taxable in the following
manner:
Test match fee [$ 0.5 MN x ` 75] x 10/100 = ` 3.75 crores – taxable @20% under section
115BBA, since it is for participation in a sport in India.
ICL Match fees [($ 1.0 MN x ` 75) x10/100 = ` 7.50 crores - taxable @20% under section
115BBA, since it is for participation in a sport in India.
Advertisement for an automobile company headquartered in US [$ 0.25 MN x ` 75] x 10/100 =
` 1.875 crores - is deemed to accrue or arise in India since the shooting is in India Thus, such
income would be taxable in India @20% u/s 115BBA, though the payer company is from US.
Article writing fees (Articles on ICL) [$ 0.10 MN x ` 75] x10/100 = 0.75 crores (or ` 75 lakhs),
taxable @20% under section 115BBA, since it for an article in respect of sports and published
in newspaper.
Participation fees charged in live TV show in India, [($ 0.25 MN x ` 75) x10/100] = ` 1.875
crores would be taxable in India as per the normal rates of tax and not as per section 115BBA,
since participation fee is not in respect of any game or sport in India.
Article writing fee for an online platform [($ 0.25 MN x ` 75) x10/100] = ` 1.875 crores would be
taxable in India as per the normal rates, since these articles are not written in newspapers,
magazines or journals.
Auction of his cricket bat [($ 1.0 MN x 75) x10/100] = ` 7.5 crores would be taxable in India as
per the normal rates of tax not as per section 115BBA, since it is not in respect of participation
in matches, or advertisement or article writing in newspapers, magazines or journals. Deduction
u/s 80G would be allowable for amount donated to an approved charitable institution to the
extent of 50% of (lower of amount donated or 10% of adjusted total income).
Answer to Q. 4.7
As per section 3(1) of Black Money (Undisclosed Foreign Income and Assets) and Imposition of
Tax Act, 2015, every assessee would be liable to tax@30% in respect of his undisclosed foreign
income and asset of the previous year.
Accordingly, Raghvendra is liable to pay tax @30% in respect of value of undisclosed foreign
asset during the previous year 2021-22, the year in which such assets came to the notice of the
Assessing Officer.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 26 of 33
Page 28
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION 27
The relevant date for determination of the value of undisclosed assets would be the first day of
April of the previous year (1 st April, 2021, in this case) in which the undisclosed asset located
m
outside India comes to the notice of the Assessing Officer. The value of residential apartment
m c. o
would be the higher of -
(i)
.c o
its cost of acquisition (5 lakh USD x ` 75 = ` 3.75 crore); and
e m
m value as on 1.4.2021)
date e(Fair
(ii) the price that the property shall ordinarily fetch if sold in the open market on the valuation
l a s
l a s
section 40 of the Black Money Law, he is also liable to pay interest under section 234Aa
g
gthe Income-tax Act, 1961 for failure to disclose income from a source outside India in the
aofreturn
As per
filed under section 139(1) and interest under sections 234B and 234C of the Income -tax
Act, 1961 for failure to pay advance tax on undisclosed income from a source outside India.
Note - Computation of tax on undisclosed foreign asset has not been given in the above solution
since the fair value of the house as on 1.4.2021 is required, whereas the question mentions the
fair value on 31.3.2022. If it is assumed that the fair value of the house as on 1.4.2021 is the
same as on 31.3.2022, then, the tax liability would be 30% of 15 lakh USD (fair value, since the
same is higher than the cost of 5 lakh USD) x ` 75 = ` 3,37,50,000.
m
co
Answer to Q.4.8
.
em
Mr. Shiv Paul, player from Kenya, would be non-resident in India, since his stay in India during
s
the previous year 2021-22 is only for 90 days 6. Accordingly, income which accrues or arises in
g l a
India, income which is received in India and income which is deemed to accrue or arise in India
a
would be taxable in his hands in India for the P.Y.2021-22.
As per section 115BBA, income received or receivable by a non-resident sportsman (including
an athlete) by way of inter alia participation in any game or sport in India would be chargeable
to tax@20% plus surcharge, if applicable plus health and education cess@4%.
(i) As per section 60 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 rental income in respect of Jaipur house
which is transferred to the Private trust would be taxable in the hands of father of Mr. Shiv
Paul though Mr. Shiv Paul is the sole beneficiary of the trust, since such income is
transferred to the Private trust without actual transfer of the asset.
m
co
Accordingly, Mr. Shiv Paul’s total income would comprise of match fees of ` 7.50 crores
m .
c. o
(1 million USD x ` 75 x 10/100) and income from advertisement of ` 10 lakhs, totalling
m
se
` 7.60 crores
[email protected]% (i.e., 20% plus surcharge@37% and cess@4%) as per
em a
section 115BBA. The tax liability would be 28.496% of ` 7.60 crores = ` 2.1657 crores or
as
` 216.57 lakhs.
g l
l a
ag
(ii) The total income and tax liability of Shiv Paul would not change even if there is no trust
and the payment of rent is made directly to the account of Shiv Paul, since such income is
transferred without actual transfer of the asset.
6 and there is no information regarding his stay in India in the four immediately preceding previous years
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 27 of 33
Page 29
28 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
Case Study: 5
Megastar Ltd., Delhi
Megastar Ltd. is a company with businesses across multiple sectors both in India and abroad.
It wanted to expand its manufacturing capacity by importing machinery from its associated
enterprise located outside India with offshore supply of spares and contract for installation in its
premises. It apprehends some dispute because of some complexities in the terms of contract.
It proposes to obtain an advance ruling in this regard.
Megastar Ltd. recruited one mechanical engineer and one software specialist. The details are
given below:
Mechanical Software
Engg. Specialist
Name Robert Vishnu
Place of residence before joining for employment UK India
Period of stay in India in preceding 4 years 90 days Since birth
Nationality Indian Origin Indian citizen
Date of joining (assume for counting period of stay) 29.10.2021 01.11.2021
Place of posting New Delhi Country Z
Salary income (computed) 25,00,000 25,00,000
Other income by way of rent outside India 6,00,000 Nil
Tax payable in the place of posting As per IT Act No Income-tax
Transfer Pricing disputes
Megastar Ltd. has a subsidiary, Ministar SA, in Country J and there has been supply of finished
goods by Megastar Ltd. to Ministar SA. Ministar SA has onward sold those goods as a sole
distributor for certain countries including Country J. There is a DTAA between India and Country
J. For the assessment year 2019-20, there are some disputes with regard to arm’s length price
of the supply of finished goods and the TPO had proposed an upward adjustment to the revenue
earned from Ministar SA. The company has contested the order and currently an appeal against
the order is pending before the ITAT.
For the immediately preceding assessment year (i.e., A.Y.2018-19), the Income-tax officer
passing an order in conformity with the order of the TPO had made an upward adjustment to
the price of the goods sold to Ministar SA by adopting a different method of determining arm's
length price. Megastar had challenged the order before the ITAT (subseq uent to being
unsuccessful before the DRP). The ITAT heard the matter and disposed off the appeal by setting
aside the order of the TPO directing them to consider afresh with full discretion. The remand
proceedings are currently being undertaken by the TPO.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 28 of 33
Page 30
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION 29
Megastar Ltd. proposes to enter into an agreement with its associated enterprise Mike SPA of
Belgium for supply of goods for ` 150 crores in the financial year 2022-23. The agreement is
m
in the proposal stage and not yet finalized. It is contemplating to go in for Advance Pricing
m c. o
Agreement.
c o
Megastar has a. subsidiary in Country J. The DTAA between India and Country J provides for
Other transactions
e m
m @ 20% in respect of dividends received by shareholders of a company in las
taxation ofedividend
l a s
J. The DTAA between India and Country K provides for concessional rate of tax@10% g
a
in g
Country
aMegastar Ltd. entered into a contract with Mano Pte, Singapore for ` 5 crore in the financial
respect of dividend.
year 2021-22. Mano Pte Ltd. designed and developed an online platform to facilitate online sale
of goods worldwide by Megastar Ltd. The said payment was for the design and development
services and also include fees for maintenance and support for one year after the in stallation of
such a platform. There is no PE of Mano Pte Ltd. in India. The payment does not amount to
Royalty under India-Singapore DTAA.
Proceedings against Robert
m
co
While conducting the background check for the employment of Robert, it was found that Rob ert
.
em
was resident in India till the assessment year 2014-15, when he left for employment in June,
s
2015. He acquired a property in July 2017 out of unaccounted money kept in a bank account
l a
outside India. These amounts were accumulated when he was resident in India and were not
a g
disclosed for income-tax in India. Notice under section 10 of the Black Money Act, 2015 was
issued in December, 2020.
Choose the correct alternative for the following MCQs: (5 x 2 = 10 Marks)
5.1 How much is the fee payable for the APA by Megastar Ltd. in respect of the agreement for
supply of goods to its associated enterprise Mike SPA of Belgium?
(A) ` 5 lakhs
(B) ` 10 lakhs
m
(C) ` 15 lakhs
m c o
is the time limit for completion of assessment of Robert under the Black.Money Act,
(D) ` 20 lakhs
c. o 5.2 What s em
em a
2015?
s g l
la a
(A) 31.03.2021
ag (B) 31.03.2022
(C) 31.03.2023
(D) 31.12.2022
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 29 of 33
Page 31
30 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
5.3 What is the monetary limit applicable for Megastar Ltd. who is a resident when it wants to
get a ruling about its tax liability from the Board for Advance Rulings for the transaction it
is proposing to undertake for import of machinery with offshore supply of spares and
contract for installation in its premises?
(A) ` 100 crores in aggregate
(B) ` 300 crores in aggregate
(C) ` 100 crores per annum
(D) No monetary limit
5.4 Which of the following action of Megastar Ltd. in respect of payment made to Mano Pte
would be a proper compliance of law?
(A) Deduct tax at source @10% on the payment of ` 5 crores.
(B) It is neither royalty nor Equalization levy. Hence, no need to withhold tax on the
payment made to Mano Pte.
(C) Deduct @6% as Equalization Levy
(D) Deduct @2% as equalization Levy
5.5 Insertion of which clause in the DTAA between India and Country J would enable taxation
of dividend@10% instead of 20%?
(A) Non-discrimination clause
(B) Most Favoured Nation Clause
(C) Limitation of benefit clause
(D) Tax Parity Clause
You are required to answer the following issues:
5.6 You are the tax consultant for Megastar Ltd. The Board of directors want you to give a
brief outline about the option of preferring MAP in respect of dispute relating to arm’s length
price of the supply of goods. Please comment on the issues eligible for MAP, pr ocedure
for resolution by Competent Authorities, time limit for its resolution and time limit for
acceptance/non-acceptance of the resolution. (5 Marks)
5.7 If Megastar were to file a request for APA beginning financial year 2022-2023 covering the
transactions relating to Ministar, SA,
(a) Can the current outstanding disputes of A.Y. 2018-19 and A.Y. 2019-20 be addressed
and resolved using the roll back clause? (3 Marks)
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 30 of 33
Page 32
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION 31
(b) What would be the significant differences for Megstar (in timing, certainty etc)
between selecting MAP remedy against the roll back clause for resolving the dispute
m
c. o
of the earlier years? (3 Marks)
m
co m
5.8 Based on the facts given above Robert and Vishnu, you are required to determine their
.
residential status and their total income for the assessment year 2022-23. Ignore DTAA.
m s e
a s e (4 Marks)
g la
l
g to Q.5.1 to 5.5 a
aAnswer
Solution to Case Study 5
Q No. Correct Option
5.1 C
5.2 C
5.3 A
m
5.4 -7
c. o
5.5 B or D8
emalternate dispute resolution mechanism available
Answer to Q.5.6
l s
a disputes giving rise to double taxation or taxation
The Mutual Agreement Procedure (MAP) is an
a g
to taxpayers under the DTAAs for resolving
not in accordance with DTAAs.
Brief Outline: Megastar may prefer MAP, in respect of dispute for the A.Y. 2019-20 for which
appeal is pending before the ITAT, since MAP and domestic remedy proceedings can be availed
by the taxpayers simultaneously, there could be instances where the ITAT in India passes an
order in respect of the same disputes that are also being examined under MAP. However, the
Competent Authority in India shall not deviate from the orders of the ITAT for the relevant year
where the dispute is decided on merits.
In respect of A.Y. 2018-19, since order of the ITAT does not resolve the disputes but only sets
o m
c
them aside to be adjudicated afresh, then, access to MAP would be provided again after the
m .
c. o Issues
fresh adjudication by tax authorities, if requested for by the relevant taxpayers.
m
e DTAAs:
types of cases/situations, if they result in taxation not in accordance with thesrelevant
m
eligible for MAP: India provides access to MAP in respect of, inter-alia, the following
s e g l a
l a a
ag
a) Transfer Pricing adjustments;
b) Determination of existence of a Permanent Establishment;
7 None of the options are correct
8 It is assumed that both Country J and K are OECD members.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 31 of 33
Page 33
32 FINAL EXAMINATION: MAY, 2022
c) Attribution of profits to Permanent Establishments, whether admitted or not by the
taxpayer;
d) Characterisation or re-characterisation of an item of expense or payment as a taxable
expense or payment (like Royalty or Fee for Technical Services (FTS) or Interest); and
e) Characterisation or re-characterisation of an item of receipt as a taxable income (like
Royalty or Fee for Technical Services (FTS) or Interest).
A taxpayer can request for assistance under MAP regardless of the remedies provided under
the Indian domestic law.
Procedure for resolution: A taxpayer resident in India can make an application to the
Competent Authority of India having jurisdiction over the case (depending on th e location of
treaty partner) if it considers that the actions of the tax authorities of the treaty partner resulted
or will result in taxation not in accordance with the relevant tax treaty.
The MAP application in Form No. 34F or the copy of the MAP application filed before the
Competent Authorities of other countries or specified territories (treaty partners) must be
submitted to the Competent Authority of India having jurisdiction over the case.
Once a MAP application is accepted by the Competent Authority of India having jurisdiction over
the case, the said Authority shall intimate the Competent Authority of the relevant treaty partner
about such acceptance through a written communication.
If both the Competent Authorities successfully resolve a MAP case, they would formalise a
mutual agreement amongst themselves at the earliest possible. The Competent Authority of
India having jurisdiction over the case would intimate the Indian taxpayer who had applied for
MAP about the terms and conditions of the resolution.
Acceptance or rejection of the MAP resolution is the prerogative of the Indian taxpayer but in
either situation, the MAP case would be closed by both the Competent Authorities as resolved.
Time limit for resolution: The Competent Authority in India should endeavour to resolve MAP
cases within an average time period of 24 months.
Time limit for acceptance or otherwise of MAP: The assessee has to communicate his
acceptance or non-acceptance of the resolution in writing to the Competent Authority in India
within 30 days of receipt of the communication. In case of communication of acceptance, it has
to submit withdrawal of domestic appeals.
Answer to Q.5.7
(a) (i) In respect of A.Y. 2018-19, since ITAT has not decided the matter and has only set
aside the order for fresh consideration of the matter by the lower authorities with full
discretion at their disposal, the matter shall not be treated as one having reached
finality and hence, benefit of rollback can still be given.
(ii) In respect of A.Y. 2019-20, since an appeal has been filed by Megastar which is
pending before the Appellate Tribunal for a rollback year, on the issue which is the
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 32 of 33
Page 34
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6C: INTERNATIONAL TAXATION 33
subject matter of the rollback provision for that year, the dispute can be resolved
using the roll back clause only if the said appeal is withdrawn by the applicant (to the
m
extent of the subject covered under the agreement) before furnishing the modified
m c. o
return for the said year.
c o
• Roll .Back: Megastar can take the benefit of rollback, since ITAT has not decided the
(b) A.Y. 2018-19
e m
m and has only set aside the order for fresh consideration.
ematter l a s
a s g
l• MAP: Access to MAP would be provided again after the fresh adjudication by taxa
ag authorities, if requested for by the relevant taxpayers.
A.Y. 2019-20
• Roll Back: Megastar has to withdraw the appeal pending before the ITAT to the
extent of the subject covered under the roll back agreement.
• MAP: MAP and domestic remedy proceedings can, however, be availed by the
taxpayers simultaneously. If the MAP resolution is communicated to the company,
o m
when the appeal is still pending, the company has to withdraw the appeal while
. c
communicating its acceptance of MAP resolution.
m
eIncome
s
Answer to Q.5.8
g a in the P.Y.2021-22 and for 90 days in the four
ldays
Residential Status of Robert and his Total
a Therefore, he neither the fulfills the condition of stay in
Mr. Robert’s stay in India is for 154
immediately preceding previous years.
India for 182 days in the P.Y.2021-22; nor the condition of stay in India for 60 days in the
P.Y.2021-22 and for 365 days in the 4 immediately preceding previous years. Hence, he would
be non-resident in India for the A.Y. 2022-23.
In case of non-residents, income which accrues or arises in India, income which is received in
India and income which is deemed to accrue or arise in India would alone be taxable. As per
section 9(1)(ii), salary income for rendering services in India would be deemed to accrue or
m
arise in India. Accordingly, his total income would comprise of only salary income and other
m .co
income by way of rent outside India would not be taxable in his hands in India, since he is a
c. o Residential Status of Vishnu and his Total Income m
non-resident. Hence, his total income would be ` 25,00,000.
em l se
a in India for 182
l as a
Mr. Vishnu left India during the P.Y. 2021-22 for employment and he stayed
g
ag
days or more i.e., 215 days in the P.Y.2021-22, he would be resident in India for the A.Y.
2022-23. Further, since he is in India since birth, he would be resident and ordinarily resident in
India. In case of resident and ordinarily resident in India, global income would be taxable.
Accordingly, salary income which accrues or arises outside India would also be taxable in his
hands. Hence, his total income would be ` 25,00,000.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 33 of 33