Page 1
FOR CA FINAL EXAM PREPARATION
CA Final 2022
Suggested Answers ·
Paper 6F
Multidisciplinary Case
Study (Old Scheme)
EXAM YEAR TYPE
CA Final 2022 Suggested Answers
SUBJECT DATE
Paper 6F Multidisciplinary Case Study (Old Scheme) November 2022
Notes · Sample Papers · Previous Year Papers · Mock Tests
Page 2
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
DISCLAIMER
This Suggested Answer hosted on the website does not constitute the basis for evaluation of
m
m c. o
co
the student’s answers in the examination. The answers are prepared by the Faculty of the Board
. e m
em
of Studies with a view to assist the students in their education. Alternate Answers have been
la s
l a s a g
aerrorg or omission is noticed, the same may be brought to the attention of the Director of Board
incorporated, wherever necessary. While due care is taken in preparation of the answers, if any
of Studies. The Council of the Institute is not in any way responsible for the correctness or
otherwise of the answers published herein.
Further, in the Elective Papers which are Case Study based, the solutions have been worked
o m
out on the basis of certain assumptions/views derived from the facts given in the question or
c
. to work out the solution to the case studies
m
e made or views taken.
language used in the question. It may be possible
la s
g
in a different manner based on the assumptions
a
m
m .co
c. o se
m
s em g la
gla a
a
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 1 of 31
Page 3
2 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
PAPER – 6F: MULTI-DISCIPLINARY CASE STUDY
The question paper comprises five case study questions. The candidates are required to
answer any four case study questions out of five.
All your workings should form part of your answer.
CASE STUDY – 1
Majestic Industries Limited is a company; they are· manufacturing ancillary products for power
sector. With opening up of power sector to private sector over the past decade, the company is
planning big to contribute its might. Due to various and far reaching changes brought in tax laws
and company law, the company is facing certain issues the facts of which are as under :
Facts of the Case:
1. The company has been claiming deduction of employees' contribution to Provident fund
irrespective of the fact that the payment was delayed in some months. In one of the
assessment year, the assessing officer has disallowed the claim of those months where
there were delays in payment. However, the tribunal in appeal filed by the company, it has
been allowed. The accountant is in dilemma for assessment year 2022-23 whether he can
still continue to claim the same. The accountant of the company provides you the following
information regarding employees' as well as employers' contribution to provident fund with
it dates of payment. The due date for filing the tax return for the company in this case is
31-10-2022.
Employees' Employers' Due date for The actual The actual date of
Contribution Contribution payment amount paid both payments to the
to PF to PF concerned authorities
1,33,000 1,33,000 20-05-2021 2,66,000 13-05-2021
1,34,000 1,34,000 20-06-2021 2,68,000 19-06-2021
1,33,500 1,33,500 20-07-2021 2,67;000 25-07-2021
1,34,000 1,34,000 20-08-2021 2,68,000 08-10-2021
1,33,500 1,33,500 20-09-2021 2,67,000 16-10-2021
1,32,500 1,32,500 20-10-2021 2,65,000 13-10-2021
1,34,500 1,34,500 20-11-2021 2,69,000 20-11-2021
1,33,000 1,33,000 20-12-2021 2,66,000 22-03-2022
1,50,000 1,50,000 20-01-2022 3,00,000 29-03-2022
1,49,000 1,49,000 20-02-2022 2,98,000 29-09-2022
1,47,000 1,47,000 20-03-2022 2,94,000 29-10-2022
1,48;000 1,48,000 20-04-2022 2,96,000 Not Paid
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 2 of 31
Page 4
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6F: MULTIDISCIPLINARY CASE STUDY 3
2. The board of the company is spending as CSR responsibility of the company on the CSR
Activities. CFO of the company provides you the following information:
m
c. o
` In Crore
m
.co m
Particulars 31-3-2022 31-03-2021 31-03-2020 31-03-2019
m s e
e a
Net profit 3.50 7.50 4.25 3.00
s
a is also making CSR contribution through BMC foundation, an independent NGOa
Sales (turnover) 600.00 850.00 700.00 710.00
g l
lCompany
ag registered under section 12A & 80G of the Income Tax Act, 1961, but the foundation has
not yet taken registration with Ministry of Company Affairs (MCA) for carrying on CSR
activities.
3. The CFO informed the board that the reporting requirement of financial statements has
increased tremendously. For many information, ageing analysis has been introduced, more
information regarding immovable property, utilization of borrowings, benami properties
etc., has been introduced and accordingly scope of CARO has also been enlarged. The
chief accountant of the company provides the following details of Trades Payable as at 31-
m
c. o
03-2022:
em ` 15,00,000
Outstanding payments:
Less than 180 days
l a s
a g
Over 180 days and less than a year ` 11,20,000
For a period between 1 to 2 years ` 5,00,000
For a period between 2 to 3 years ` 3,00,000
GST charged by suppliers is @ 12% which is included in the above outstanding payment.
The company is regularly claiming available ITC in their books but has not made any
reversal of ITC in respect of outstandings arising during the year. Trade payables in the
above is due for payment, are undisputed and payable to non MSMEs.
4. NAN Consultants (Delhi) impart accounting software training to accounts and finance
o
personnel of the company at their Delhi office which is also registered under GST. The
m
m .c
agreement to render this service was entered into with its head office at Mumbai.
. co 1.1 The Employees' contribution to provident fund will be deductible to the sextent
MCQs: Provide the correct option to the following questions.
e mof:
s em g l a
gla (A) ` 16,62,000
a
a (B) ` 11,28,000
(C) ` 5,34,000
(D) ` 15,14;000
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s ag
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 3 of 31
Page 5
4 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
1.2 The Employers' contribution to provident fund will be deductible to the extent of:
(A) ` 16,62,000
(B) ` 11,28,000
(C) ` 5,34,000
(D) ` 15,14,000
1.3 Whether in the light of the case study, is the company required to form a CSR committee
during financial year 2021-22:
(A) The company is not required to form a CSR committee as the total contribution is less
than ` 50 lakh and the board shall perform the functions of CSR Committee.
(B) The company is not required to form a CSR Committee as the company does not
meet any of the criteria of net profit, turnover, or net worth during the year 2021-22.
(C) The company is not required to form a CSR committee as the total contribution is less
than ` 50 lakh and the board can decide who shall perform the functions of CSR
committee.
(D) The company is not required to form a CSR Committee as the average net profit of
the company for the last 3 years is ` 4.92 crore only.
1.4 Whether the company is required to make reversal of Input tax credit (ITC) in the given
case study and if yes, then of what amount (ignore interest):
(A) No reversal of ITC is required to be made in the books.
(B) Yes, ` 1,34,400
(C) Yes, ` 1,12,000
(D) Yes, ` 1,20,000
1.5. With respect to the training imparted by NAN consultants, what should be the place of
supply?
(A) Mumbai
(B) Delhi
(C) Mumbai or Delhi at the discretion of the consultant.
(D) In terms of section 12(5), GST is not leviable with respect to training or performance
appraisal services. Therefore, the question of place of supply does not arise.
(5 x 2 = 10 Marks)
Descriptive Questions
1.6. In the given case study, as a Tax auditor how will you report in Form 3CD the employees'
contribution to provident fund and any disallowance which is to be made as per section
40(a) (ii) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 ? (4 Marks)
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 4 of 31
Page 6
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6F: MULTIDISCIPLINARY CASE STUDY 5
1.7 In the context of the case study, explain the provisions and requirement relating to
formation of CSR Committee by the company under the Companies Act, 2013.
m
c. o
(7 Marks)
o m
1.8 How will you disclose the information relating to trade payables provided in para no 3 of
m
.c
the case study in the financial statements?
ANSWERS m
(4 Marks)
s e
PARTa–sA
e TO CASE STUDY 1
g la
g l(C) a
a
1.1
1.2 (D)
1.3 (A)
1.4 (D)
1.5 (A)
1.6 The auditor is required to report the employee’s contribution to provident fund in Form 3CD
m
as under
c. o
Clause 20(b): Details of contributions received from employees for various funds as
m
Sume Due date for
referred to in section 36(1)(va):
s
glafrom
S. Nature of fund The actual The actual date
a
No. received payment amount paid of payment to
the concerned
employees authorities
1 Employee’s 1,33,000 20.05.2021 1,33,000 13.05.2021
Contribution to PF
2 Employee’s 1,34,000 20.06.2021 1,34,000 19.06.2021
Contribution to PF
3 Employee’s 1,33,500 20.07.2021 1,33,500 25.07.2021
Contribution to PF
o m
4 Employee’s 1,34,000 20.08.2021 1,34,000 08.10.2021
m .c
Contribution to PF
c. o m
e 13.10.2021
5 Employee’s 1,33,500 20.09.2021 1,33,500 16.10.2021
1,32,500 s
em a
Contribution to PF
s g l
la
6 Employee’s 1,32,500 20.10.2021
g a
Contribution to PF
a
7 Employee’s 1,34,500 20.11.2021 1,34,500 20.11.2021
Contribution to PF
8 Employee’s 1,33,000 20.12.2021 1,33,000 22.03.2022
Contribution to PF
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 5 of 31
Page 7
6 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
9 Employee’s 1,50,000 20.01.2021 1,50,000 29.03.2022
Contribution to PF
10 Employee’s 1,49,000 20.02.2021 1,49,000 29.09.2022
Contribution to PF
11 Employee’s 1,47,000 20.03.2021 1,47,000 29.10.2022
Contribution to PF
Further as regards disallowance under section 40 (a) (ii) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 no
reporting is to be done for the same by tax auditor in Form 3CD but only the amount needs
to be disallowed by the assessee per se at the time of filling of the tax return for the
respective assessment year.
1.7 According to section 135(1) of the Companies Act, 2013, every company having net worth
of rupees five hundred crore or more, or turnover of rupees one thousand crore or more or
a net profit of rupees five crore or more during the immediately preceding financial
year shall constitute a Corporate Social Responsibility Committee of the Board consisting
of three or more directors, out of which at least one director shall be an independent
director.
Provided that where a company is not required to appoint an independent director under
sub-section (4) of section 149, it shall have in its Corporate Social Responsibility
Committee two or more directors.
As per Rule 3(1), every company including its holding or subsidiary, and a foreign company
defined under clause (42) of section 2 of the Act having its branch office or project office
in India, which fulfills the criteria specified in sub-section (1) of section 135 of the Act shall
comply with the provisions of section 135 of the Act and these rules:
“Net worth” [As per Section 2(57)] means the aggregate value of the paid-up share capital
and all reserves created out of the profits, securities premium account and debit or credit
balance of the profit and loss account, after deducting the aggregate value o f the
accumulated losses, deferred expenditure and miscellaneous expenditure not written off,
as per the audited balance sheet, but does not include reserves created out of revaluation
of assets, write-back of depreciation and amalgamation.
Exclusion of Companies [Rule 3(2) of the Companies (CSR) Rules, 2014]
Every company which ceases to be a company covered under subsection (1) of section
135 of the Act for three consecutive financial years shall not be required to-
(a) constitute a CSR Committee; and
(b) comply with the provisions contained in sub-section (2) to (6) of the said section,
till such time it meets the criteria specified in sub-section (1) of section 135.
In the present case, though the Net profit of the Majestic Industries Limited as on 31-03-
2021 (i.e. immediately preceding financial year) was ` 7.50 crore, hence the company is
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 6 of 31
Page 8
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6F: MULTIDISCIPLINARY CASE STUDY 7
not required to constitute CSR committee since, according to section 135(9) of the
Companies Act, 2013, where the amount to be spent by a company under sub-section
m
(5) does not exceed fifty lakh rupees, the requirement under sub- section (1) for
m c. o
constitution of the Corporate Social Responsibility Committee shall not be
co m
applicable and the functions of such committee provided under this section shall, in
m .
such cases, be discharged by the Board of Directors of such company. As per the
s e
s e l a
figures of net profits given in the case study the amount to be spent works out to
g
a of Balance Sheet of Majestic Industries Limited as at 31 March, 2022 a
1.8 lExtracts
` 9.83 lakh [{(7.50+4.25+3.00)/3}*2%]
g
a Particulars
st
`
LIABILITIES
Current liabilities
(a) Financial Liabilities
(i) Trade payables 34,20,000
Total liabilities XXXX
m
c. o
Total equity and liabilities XXXX
emas at 31 March, 2022 is as follows:
Trade payables
a s
Ageing for trade payables outstanding
Less lthan
st
Particulars
g
a 1 year years years 3 years
1-2 2-3 More than Total
Undisputed – Other 26,20,000 5,00,000 3,00,000 - 34,20,000
than MSME
Note: The information regarding operating cycle is not provided in the question. It is
assumed that all the trade payables are within the scope of operating cycle and hence are
classified as current liabilities.
m
CASE STUDY: 2
m are part of a renowned firm of Chartered Accountants based in New Delhi which c o
.is engaged
c. o You
About You
m
e and Indirect),
em Information Systems Audit, Risk Based Audit, Registered Valuers etc., l a s
s
in modern fields of practice such as Forensic Audit, International Taxation (Direct
l a a g
ag
About FSL
One of your friends has recommended your name to M/s Forever Source Limited (FSL), a listed
entity engaged in the manufacturing and export of speciality chemicals used in textile industry
and having annual turnover of ` 50 crores.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s ag
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 7 of 31
Page 9
8 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
Issues
I. Management has finalized the financial results for the half year ended 30th September
2022. Revenue, net profit and cash profit of the company has increased manifold, hence,
the management has decided to buy-back the shares of the company and has gone ahead
with its decision after complying with all the requirements. Company has utilized the
balance lying in free reserves and securities premium account for the purpose of buy-back.
Following relevant information is available for your kind perusal which is before buy-back:
Particulars Amount (` In Lakh)
EQUITY AND LIABILITIES
(1) Shareholders' funds
(a) Share capital 1000.00
(b) Reserves and Surplus 2000.00
Total 3000.00
Company has bought back five percent of its share capital (three percent from open market
and balance from Mr. Raman, one of the investors in the company).
II. Since the company deals in specialty chemicals, different types of inventories are lying
with the company. For valuation purposes, the same is classified into four categories
(Category 1, Category 2, Category 3 and Category 4). Company has to comply with
inventory valuation norms prescribed by IND AS 2-INVENTORIES. Following information
(category wise) is available from the company records.
(Amount in Rupees Thousands)
Inventory Item Cost Estimated Sales Selling Cost Fair Value
Price
Category 1 10,000 9,800 700 9,500
Category 2 16,000 20,000 400 19,600
Category 3 18,000 19,000 400 18,100
Category 4 8,000 9,500 350 9,000
Staff of the Company has valued the inventory at ` 52,000 (in 000's) as by every other
means (Fair Value or the selling price) valuation is greater than ` 52,000 (in 000's)
III. Company, to increase its customer reach, keeps on advertising through various modes in
national and international market. Recently, one of the friends of Mr. Rohit suggested him
to use the online advertisement platform being operated by Worldwide Online
Advertisement Agency (WOAA). WOAA do not have any permanent establishment (PE) in
India. Mr. Rohit has used the online advertising platform for certain period of time for an
agreed consideration of ` 2,50,000. WOAA has rendered services as per the terms and
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 8 of 31
Page 10
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6F: MULTIDISCIPLINARY CASE STUDY 9
conditions and agreed payment has been made by FSL after complying with all the legal
requirements as per Income Tax Act, 1961.
m
c. o
Result of using online advertisement has started pouring in. Company has received various
m
co
enquiries and one enquiry has matured into sales contract of ` 75 Lakh (excluding GST @
. e m
18%) with M/s Agro Research Limited (ARL). ARL is a newly incorporated company (during
e m
the year 2021-22) and has started its business in the month of August 2021 and ha s a
la s
s g
turnover of ` 150.00 Lakh only till date. ARL has provided all documents including its PAN
l a a
aIV.g On 1 April 2021, FSL has invested in the equity shares of newly formed company DEF
to the seller company. The product was supplied in the month of September 2021 and the
entire contract consideration has also been received in the same month itself.
st
Limited (DEF) at a cost of ` 1 Lakh to acquire 20% share in the voting power of DEF. As
per technical terms, DEF is considered to be an associate of FSL. At the end of F.Y .
2021-2022, DEF earned profit of ` 10,000 and other comprehensive income of ` 2000. In
that year, DEF also declared dividend of ` 4,000. This transaction has been appropriately
reflected in cash flow statement of FSL prepared for the F.Y 2021-2022.
During the year ended 31 st March 2022, FSL has capitalized development costs which
m
satisfied the criteria as per Ind AS 38 'Intangible Assets'. The total amount capitalized was
. co
`16 Lakh. The development project has begun to generate economic benefits for FSL from
em
01st January 2022. The directors of FSL have estimated that the project would generate
s
economic benefits for five years from that date. The development expenditure is fully
l a
deductible against taxable profits for the year ended 31 st March 2022.
g
V.
a
FSL has an Audit Committee which regularly meets and considers the financial statements.
FSL has 6 Directors which consist of 3 independent directors. Audit Committee consists of
3 directors out of which 2 directors are independent directors. All the directors are persons
with ability to read and understand the financial statement. Statutory auditors of FSL are
invited by the Audit Committee from time to time to attend the meeting.
However, statutory auditors are reluctant to attend the meeting.
Note that the company is an Ind AS compliant and answers on Direct Tax laws should
relate to assessment year 2022-23.
m
c. o
MCQs: Provide the correct option to the following questions:
m
c. o eismapplicable for
2.1 What is the status of reporting requirement of transaction of buy-back of securities done
em s
by Forever Source Limited (FSL) under the Income-tax Act 1961?
s g la
(A) No reporting is required under the Income-tax Act as the same
gla a
companies having share capital of ` 100.00 Crores and above.
a (B) Reporting of ` 50.00 lakhs will be done in Statement of Financial Transactions.
(C) Reporting of buy back of ` 30.00 lakhs will be done in Statement of Financial
Transactions.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 9 of 31
Page 11
10 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
(D) Reporting of ` 20.00 lakhs will be done in Statement of Financial Transactions.
2.2 What is your opinion on valuation of inventories done by the company officials?
(A) Valuation done by company is correct.
(B) Valuation done by company is incorrect and the correct valuation is ` 51,100
(in 000's)
(C) Valuation done by company is incorrect and the correct valuation is ` 51,500
(in 000's)
(D) Valuation done by company is incorrect and the correct valuation is ` 51,800
(in 000's)
2.3 The deferred tax Asset/liability in relation to development cost incurred by the company
(assuming tax rate 20%) and its classification while reporting in the financial statements
will be:
(A) Deferred Tax Asset of ` 3,60,000 will be recognised as current asset.
(B) Deferred Tax liability of ` 3,04,000 will be recognised as non-current liability.
(C) Deferred Tax Asset of ` 3,04,000 will be recognised as non-current asset.
(D) Deferred Tax liability of ` 3,04,000 will be recognised as current liability.
2.4 What are the tax liabilities (deduction or collection of tax i.e. TDS/TCS) on Sale/Purchase
transaction between Forever Source Limited (FSL) and Agro Research Limited (ARL)?
(A) TCS is required to be collected by FSL amounting to ` 7,500.
(B) TDS will be deducted by ARL amounting to ` 7,500.
(C) TDS will be deducted by ARL amounting to ` 8,850.
(D) TCS is required to be collected by FSL amounting to ` 3,850.
2.5 What will be the amount of tax leviable on the payment made by First Source Limited (FSL)
to Worldwide Online Advertisement Agency (WOAA)?
(A) TDS will be deducted on payment made to non-resident amounting to ` 75,000.
(B) Equalisation levy amounting to ` 15,000 u/s 165 of Finance Act, 2016.
(C) Equalisation levy amounting to ` 5,000 u/s 165 of Finance Act, 2016.
(D) TDS will be deducted on advertisement u/s 194C amounting to ` 5000.
(5 x 2 = 10 Marks)
Descriptive Questions
2.6 In view of reluctance of statutory auditor to attend the Audit Committee meeting in the
given case study, you are required to comment on the Role of Auditor in Audit Committee.
Also comment whether the constitution of Audit Committee is valid. (5 Marks)
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 10 of 31
Page 12
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6F: MULTIDISCIPLINARY CASE STUDY 11
2.7 Give examples of temporary differences transactions that may affect taxable profit or loss
of an enterprise. (5 Marks)
m
c. o
2.8 In case investment in DEF Limited has been done in a way other than cash, do you think
m
co
that transaction would also have been reported in Cash Flow Statement? Which are non-
. e m
cash transactions relating to investing activities which are not required to be reported in
em
Cash Flow Statement? (5 Marks)
la s
a s
l –A
ANSWERS TO CASE STUDY 2
a g
g
a2.1 (D)
PART
2.2 (B)
2.3 (B)
2.4 (D)
2.5 (B)
m
PART – B
. co
2.6 Role of Auditor in to attend the Audit Committee Meeting: Regulation 18(1)(f)
em
stipulates that a representative of the statutory auditor, when required, shall be invited to
s
the meetings of the Audit Committee. Similarly, Section 177 of the Companies Act, 2013
g l a
provides the auditors of a company and the key managerial personnel the right to be heard
a
in the meetings of the Audit Committee when it considers the auditor’s report but they shall
not have the right to vote.
The auditor must ensure that he communicates frequently and openly with the Audit
Committee on key accounting or auditing issues that, in the auditor’s judgment, give ri se
to a greater risk of material misstatement of the financial statements, and also ensure that
he addresses any questions or concerns voiced by the Audit Committee.
He can contribute significantly in assisting and advising the Audit Committee on improvi ng
corporate governance, oversight of financial reporting process, implementation of
m
accounting policies and practices, compliance with accounting standards, strengthening of
m c o
. andandin
the internal control systems in regard to financial reporting and reporting proce sses.
c. o em
The auditor must devote substantial professional time in assisting the management
em a s
the Audit Committee to enable them to discharge their functions effectively
l governance directly.
s g
certification of the requirements of corporate governance.
gla a
The auditor has to keep in mind that his role is not to drive corporate
a Rather, it is the management’s responsibility to do so and, in the process, he should play
a significant role in assisting management to ensure better standards of corporate
governance.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 11 of 31
Page 13
12 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
Composition of Audit Committee: As per section 177 of the Companies Act, 2013, the
Audit Committee shall consist of a minimum of three directors with independent directors
forming a majority. It may be noted that majority of members of Audit Committee including
its Chairperson shall be persons with ability to read and understand, the financial
statement.
In the given case, Forever Source Limited, a listed entity, has audit committee which
regularly meets and consider the financial statements. The Audit committee of FSL consist
of 3 directors out of which 2 directors are independent director which is in compliance with
section 177 of the Companies Act, 2013.
It is also required that all members of Audit Committee shall be financially literate. As per
fact of the case all the directors of FSL are persons with ability to read and understand the
financial statements which is also in compliance with section 177 of the Act, it can be
concluded that composition of Audit Committee of FS Limited is valid.
ALTERNATIVE SOLUTION
Composition of Audit Committee: As per Regulation 18(1) of the SEBI (Listing
Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015, the main features of a
qualified and independent audit committee to be set up are as follows:
1. The Audit Committee shall have minimum three directors as members. At least two -
thirds of the members of audit committee shall be independent directors, however, in
case of a listed entity having outstanding SR (Superior Rights) equity shares, the
audit committee shall only comprise of independent directors.
2. All members of Audit Committee shall be financially literate and at least one member
shall have accounting or related financial management expertise.
Explanation (i): The term “financially literate” means the ability to read and
understand basic financial statements i.e. balance sheet, profit and loss account, and
statement of cash flows.
Explanation (ii): A member will be considered to have accounting or related financial
management expertise if he or she possesses experience in finance or accounting,
or requisite professional certification in accounting, or any other comparable
experience or background which results in the individual’s financial sophistication,
including being or having been a chief executive officer, chief financial officer or other
senior officer with financial oversight responsibilities.
3. The Chairperson of the Audit Committee shall be an independent director and he/she
shall be present at Annual General Meeting to answer shareholder queries.
4. The Company Secretary shall act as the secretary to the committee.
5. The Audit Committee at its discretion shall invite the finance director or the head of
the finance function, head of internal audit and a representative of the statutory
auditor and any other such executives to be present at the meetings of the committee,
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 12 of 31
Page 14
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6F: MULTIDISCIPLINARY CASE STUDY 13
provided that occasionally, the Audit Committee may meet without the presence of
any executives of the listed entity.
m
c. o
In the given case, Forever Source Limited, a listed entity, has audit committee which
m
co
regularly meets and consider the financial statements. The Audit committee of FSL consist
. e m
of 3 directors out of which 2 directors are independent director which is compliance with
em
Regulation 18(1) of the SEBI LODR 2015 as according to the same the Audit Committee
la s
s g
shall have minimum three directors as members. At least two-thirds of the members of
l a a
ag Further,
audit committee shall be independent directors.
it is also given in the Regulation 18(1) i.e. all members of Audit Committee shall
be financially literate and at least one member shall have accounting or related financial
management expertise. As per fact of the case all the directors of FSL ar e persons with
ability to read and understand the financial statements which is also in compliance with,
however, assuming that one of the director is having accounting or related financial
management expertise and Chairperson of the Audit Committee is independent director, it
can be concluded that composition of Audit Committee of FS Limited is vailid.
2.7 Examples of temporary differences transactions that affect taxable profit or loss of
m
an enterprise:
1.
c. o
Interest revenue is received in arrears and is included in accounting profit on a time
eismincluded in accounting profit when goods are
apportionment basis but is included in taxable profit on a cash basis.
2. Revenue from the sale of goods s
la profit when cash is collected.
a g
delivered but is included in taxable
In this case, there is also a deductible temporary difference associated with any
related inventory.
3. Depreciation of an asset is accelerated for tax purposes.
4. Development costs have been capitalized and will be amortised to the statement of
profit and loss but were deducted in determining taxable profit in the period in which
they were incurred.
o m
c
5. Prepaid expenses have already been deducted on a cash basis in determining the
m . shall be
c. o 2.8 Investing
taxable profit of the current or previous periods.
m
e elsewhere
m s
transactions that do not require the use of cash or cash equivalents
s e g l a
excluded from a statement of cash flows. Such transactions shall be disclosed
gl a aan entity. Such non -cash
in the financial statements in a way that provides all the relevant information about these
a
investing activities. Many investing activities do not have a direct impact on current cash
flows although they do affect the capital and asset structure of
items will not form part of the cash flow statement.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 13 of 31
Page 15
14 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
Accordingly, in case investment in DEF Limited has been done in a way other than cash,
then that transaction would not be reported in the Statement of Cash Flows.
Examples of non-cash transactions relating to investing activities which are not
required to be reported in the Statement of Cash Flows are:
(a) the acquisition of assets by assuming directly related liabilities;
(b) the acquisition of assets by means of a lease;
(c) the acquisition of an entity by means of an equity issue;
CASE.STUDY: 3
M/s HK & Co., based in New Delhi, is a leading firm of Chartered Accountants having clients
from all verticals of business and service industry. Firm has 20 partners having professional
experience of more than three decades.
During the month of July 2022, different engagement teams handled various assi gnments. and
CA H Kumar has been asked to review and guide the engagement teams in the following
assignment.
Assignment with the firm: JK Limited (JKL)
JK Limited is interested in acquiring the running enterprise rather than starting a new project.
The company has its interest in one of the divisions of M/s ARP Limited (a listed entity) (ARP).
M/s ARP Limited is a multi-industry company having its presence from auto components to
textile mills to food processing business. All these businesses are under the same roof i.e. ARP
Limited. Shares of ARP Limited are actively traded and current market price is ` 15 per share.
Summarized Balance sheets of ARP Limited and JK Limited are as follows:
(Amount in rupees thousands)
ARP Limited JK Limited
Non-Current Assets 1000 600
Current Assets:
Trade Receivables 500 100
Cash and Cash Equivalents 500 50
Total 2000 750
Shareholders' Funds 800 500
Long Term Debt 200 50
Current Liabilities and Provisions 1000 200
Total 2000 750
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 14 of 31
Page 16
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6F: MULTIDISCIPLINARY CASE STUDY 15
Shareholders' funds of ARP Limited represent 70,000 shares of ` 10 each and rest is retained
earnings/reserves and surplus. Data pertains to the entire company and not of a particular
m
c. o
division. Segment wise valuation will lead to higher valuation of the company. Hardware division
m
of the ARP Limited will be bought for ` 60 Crores and for this acquisition, funds will be borrowed
.c o
by the management of JK Limited.
e m
s em share capital of ` 4 lakh divided into 40 thousand equity shares of ` 10 each. glas
One of the verticals of JKL is engaged in export of gold jewellery and ornaments. JKL has a
l a for half year ended 30 September 2022 has indicated 15% growth in revenue and 20%a
paid up Equity
g
aincompany
Results th
profits as compared to results of half year ended 30th September 2021. Order book of the
is strong enough to maintain this growth for next five years. After looking at the
financial results for the half year ended 30th September 2022, the management has decided to
recommend interim dividend of ` 2 per equity share. Accordingly, the board meeting has been
called and resolution has been passed with record date set as 23 rd October 2022.
One of the executive directors of the company, Mr. Tulip is very well connected with persons
having political interests and connections. Mr. Joseph from South Africa contacted Mr. Tulip and
m
offered him to engage JKL in one transaction in which his company can earn some handsome
. co
amount in one go. The details of the transactions are that Company of Mr. Joseph will transfer
em
` 5.00 crore in bank account of JKL and then JKL will transfer ` 3 .50 crores in small amounts
a s
in different accounts to be specified by Mr. Joseph. Since bank account of JKL generally
g l
receives foreign payments, so nobody will doubt the transaction. Thus, the company will be
a
earning ` 1.50 crores simply by using its bank account.
Another vertical of JKL is engaged in the manufacturing and exports of drilling machinery. The
company has made the following cash payments during the audit period 2021-2022 to the local
transporters for carrying finished goods from factory premises to the container freight station
(CFS):
(i) Payment of 6 invoices of ` 4,000 each made in cash to Mr. X on 04th July 2021.
(ii) Payment of 2 invoices of ` 21,000 each made in cash to Mr. Y on 05th July 2021 and 06th
m
July 2021 respectively.
m . c o
c. o Further management of JKL has decided to buy a sick company, MachinesIndustries
(iii) Payment of ` 40,000 made in cash to Mr. Z on 07th July 2021 against an invoice for
expenses booked in F.Y. 2020-21.
m
e Limited
em l a
las g
ais nottheinclined
(MIL) having negative net worth. Financial consultants were hired to give their opinion on the
ag decision and all of them have recommended to JKL to merge itself with
Limited (MIL) rather than merge MIL to JKL. However, management
Machine Industries
to take this
step and still undecided on the method of merger.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 15 of 31
Page 17
16 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
Further another vertical of JKL is engaged in agricultural operations. Your audit manager
CA Ms. Shweta is doing the statutory audit of JKL. During the course of au dit, she overheard
that there has been some mis-happening in the Company and the management has got an
investigation done. There is suspicion of some fraud having taken place. She has requested
the management to provide the details of such investigation but the response of the
management has been evasive. She requested the management to provide the representation
of management in respect of fraud. However, she did not get any response.
Provide the correct option to the following questions.
3.1 By which date JKL should have recommended the dividend as per Listing Obligations and
Disclosure Requirements (LODR)? (Assume no holiday in the month of Oct. 2022)
(A) 08th October 2022
(B) 17th October 2022
(C) 12th October 2022
(D) 21st October 2022
3.2 Do you think Mr. Tulip should accept the offer of Mr. Joseph and route the transaction
through the bank accounts of the company?
(A) Yes, since the transaction is being routed through banking channel, so no risk/liability
involved.
(B) No, as the transaction will be covered under offence of Money Laundering and leg of
transaction amounting to ` 5.00 crores will be classified as Layering.
(C) No, as the transaction will be covered under offence of Money Laundering and leg of
transaction amounting to ` 5.00 crores will be classified as Placement.
(D) No, as the transaction will be covered· under offence of Money Laundering and leg
of transaction amounting to ` 5.00 crores will be classified as Integration.
3.3 Considering the balance sheet of J K Limited (JKL), what is the maximum amount that
management can further borrow as per the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013?
(A) ` 550 thousands being the consolidated amount of capital invested in the form of
shareholders' funds and Long term debt.
(B) `1,500 thousands being three times of shareholders' funds.
(C) ` 450 thousands being the shareholders' funds as reduced by existing debt.
(D) ` 250 thousands being the shareholders' funds as reduced by total existing debt and
current liabilities and provisions.
3.4 Which approach can be used by JK Limited (JKL) to value division of ARP Limited
considering the fact that segment wise valuation of ARP Limited will lead to overall higher
valuation of the company?
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 16 of 31
Page 18
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6F: MULTIDISCIPLINARY CASE STUDY 17
(A) Valuation using Net Book Value.
(B) Valuation by multiples.
m
c. o
(C) Valuation using Chop Shop method.
m
.co m
(D) Valuation using balance sheet approach.
m s e
e la
3.5 As a tax auditor, which of the cash payments made by JKL given in case study (3) above
a s g
will be reported by tax auditor in Form 3CA-3CD?
l (i), (ii) and (iii) a
ag (B) (i) and (iii)
(A)
(C) (ii) and (iii)
(D) Only (iii) (5 x2 = 10 Marks)
Descriptive Questions
3.6 You are required to guide CA Ms. Shweta how she should approach in case of JKL when
the management has neither provided the investigation report nor any representation in
m
respect of suspected fraud. (6 Marks)
c. o
3.7 Calculate the Enterprise value of ARP Limited using entity value as the base under relative
madvise the management of JKL the benefits, if
valuation method. (4 Marks)
3.8 Explain the concept of reverse merger eand
l a s
ag in the given case study.
any, in case merger of JKL with Machine Industries Limited (MIL) is done followin g the
suggestion of financial consultants (5 Marks)
ANSWERS TO CASE STUDY 3
PART – A
3.1 None of the options given is correct.
3.2 (B)
3.3 (C)
m
3.4 (C)
m .c o
c. o PART – B
3.5 (D)
e m
m 3.6 Auditor’s Responsibilities Relating to Fraud: As per SA 240as
s e g l the auditor is
a
on “The Auditor’s
l a statements, taken as a
ag
Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Statements”,
responsible for obtaining reasonable assurance that the financial
whole, are free from material misstatement, whether caused by fraud or error.
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 17 of 31
Page 19
18 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
As per SA 580 “Written Representations”, if management modifies or does not provide the
requested written representations, it may alert the auditor to the possibility that one o r more
significant issues may exist.
In the given case, CA. Sweta came to know that management has got an investigation
done as there is suspicion of fraud taken place. She requested the management to provide
the details of such investigation and representation of management in respect of fraud,
however she did not get any response.
In the instant case, the auditor observed that there was a special audit conducted at the
instance of the management on a possible suspicion of fraud. Therefore, the auditor
requested for special audit report which was not provided by the management despite of
many reminders. The auditor also insisted for written representation in respect of fraud
on/by the company. For this request also management remained silent.
It may be noted that, if management does not provide one or more of the requested written
representations, the auditor shall discuss the matter with management; re -evaluate the
integrity of management and evaluate the effect that this may have on the reliability of
representations (oral or written) and audit evidence in general; and take appropriate
actions, including determining the possible effect on the opinion in the auditor’s report.
Further, as per section 143(12) of the Companies Act, 2013, if an auditor of a company, in
the course of the performance of his duties as auditor, has reason to believe that an offence
involving fraud is being or has been committed against the company by officers or
employees of the company, he shall immediately report the matter to the Central
Government (in case amount of fraud is ` 1 crore or above)or Audit Committee or Board
in other cases (in case the amount of fraud involved is less than ` 1 crore) within such time
and in such manner as may be prescribed.
The auditor is also required to report as per Clause (xi) of Paragraph 3 of CARO, 2020,
Whether any fraud by the company or any fraud on the company by its officers or
employees has been noticed or reported during the year; If yes, the nature and the amount
involved is to be indicated.
If, as a result of a misstatement resulting from fraud or suspected fraud, the auditor
encounters exceptional circumstances that bring into question the auditor’s ability to
continue performing the audit, the auditor shall:
(i) Determine the professional and legal responsibilities applicable in the circumstances,
including whether there is a requirement for the auditor to report to the person or
persons who made the audit appointment or, in some cases, to regulatory authorities;
(ii) Consider whether it is appropriate to withdraw from the engagement, where
withdrawal from the engagement is legally permitted; and
(iii) If the auditor withdraws:
(1) Discuss with the appropriate level of management and those charged with
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 18 of 31
Page 20
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6F: MULTIDISCIPLINARY CASE STUDY 19
governance, the auditor’s withdrawal from the engagement and the reasons for
the withdrawal; and
m
c. o
(2) Determine whether there is a professional or legal requirement to report to the
m
co
person or persons who made the audit appointment or, in some cases, to
. e m
regulatory authorities, the auditor’s withdrawal from the engagement and the
e m
reasons for the withdrawal.
la s
l a s
3.7 Enterprise Value of ARP Limited
a g
ag Market Value of Equity Shares (70,000 x ` 15)
`
10,50,000
Add: Long Term Debt 2,00,000
Less: Cash and Cash Equivalents 5,00,000
Enterprise Value 7,50,000
3.8 In ordinary case, the company taken over is the smaller company; in a ‘reverse takeover’,
a smaller company gains control of a larger one. The concept of takeover by reverse bid,
m
co
or of reverse merger, is thus not the usual case of amalgamation of a sick unit which is
.
non-viable with a healthy or prosperous unit but is a case whereby the entire undertaking
em
of the healthy and prosperous company is to be merged and vested in the sick company
s
which is non-viable. A company becomes a sick industrial company when there is erosion
l a
g benefits for acquiring company:
in its net worth. This alternative is also known as taking over by reverse bid.
a
Reverse merger leads to the following
• Easy access to capital market.
• Increase in visibility of the company in corporate world.
• Tax benefits on carry forward losses acquired (public) company.
• Cheaper and easier route to become a public company.
CASE STUDY: 4
o m
c
GSV Associates is a firm of Chartered Accountants. The firm is noticed with the following issues
m .
c. o Facts of the case m
relating to their clients.
m 1. Happy Happy Limited is listed with the Bombay Stock Exchange. a s eDirectors of the
s e g l at the forthcoming
a Annual General Meeting (AGM) to be held on September 24, a
The
l
ag
company want to appoint Mr. Shyamlesh as an independent director
2022. Mr. Sanjay, son -in-
law of Mr. Shyamlesh, is a Managing Partner of Sanjay and Associates LLP, firm of
Lawyers. Mr. Sanjay is acting as a legal advisor to Generic Laboratory Limited, an
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 19 of 31
Page 21
20 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
Associate Company of Happy Happy Limited. It is to be noted that Adv. Sanjay charged
consultation fees from Generic Laboratory Limited as given below in rupees:
Year Fees Gross turnover of Sanjay and Associates
2019-20 2,00,00,000 40,00,00,000
2020-21 10,00,00,000 50,00,00,000
2021-22 0.00 45,00,00,000
2. Mr. Shyam Lal is millionaire and is fond of travelling and has investments in various
countries. He has been in India for 300 days during last 4 years i.e. 2017 -18, 2018-19,
2019-20 and 2020-21. During previous year 2021-22, he has been in India for 75 days. He
has income from sources in India aggregating to ` 25.00 lakh. Mr. Shyam Lal is not liable
to tax in any other country or territory by reason of his domicile or residence or any other
criteria of similar nature. He thinks that since he is in India for 75 days only, he cannot be
resident in India. However, he has heard that law in India is changed and so he approached
CA. Vivek with the above information for determination of his correct residential status as
per Income-tax.
3. The firm is presently doing 200 tax audits which include 50 audits of clients who offer their
income on presumptive basis. During the year, the firm is approached by other clients for
whom the firm has been rendering consulting services to undertake their tax audits.
Partners seek your expert view how many more tax audits may be added by the firm.
4. Mr. V. Kumar has sold his residential property for a total consideration of ` 3.75 crores on
15th January 2022 (the date on which transfer got completed). He paid brokerage of
` 12.00 lakh and actual cost of acquisition in 1995 was ` 20.00 lakh and thereafter in 2009-
2010 there has been further improvement costing ` 30.00 lakh. The fair market value
determined as on 1st April 2001 comes to ` 24.40 lakh. Mr. Kumar has purchased a flat
on 30th November 2021 for his residence for ` 1.00 crore and has incurred further cost on
stamp duty, furnishing etc. ` 33.00 lakh. He also deposited ` 50.00 lakh in 54EC Capital
Gains Bond. Cost inflation index for F.Y. 2009-10 was 148 and for F.Y. 2021-22 was 317.
Mr. Kumar approached CA. Vivek for computation of his Capital Gain from sale of his
residential property.
5. Mr. Manish, an article of the firm approached CA Sushil with the following complex web of
relationship with different entities to understand whether they are related parties as per Ind
AS.
Company 'A' is the subsidiary of company 'B'. Company 'B' is the subsidiary of company
'C'. Company 'D' is the subsidiary of company 'A'. Company 'X' is the associate of company
'D' and company 'Y' is the Joint Venture (JV) of Company 'X'.
6. Z Limited has removed its Managing Director Mr. Keshav Prasad and is required to
compensate him for loss of office. Mr. Keshav Prasad vacated the office of Managing
Director on 31.05.2021 though his original tenure of appointment with Z Limited was to
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 20 of 31
Page 22
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6F: MULTIDISCIPLINARY CASE STUDY 21
continue up to 31.12.2023. He had joined on 1st April 2019. He has drawn remuneration
during the last three years per month as under:
m
c. o
2019-20 ` 20 lakh
m
c. o m
2020-21 ` 25 lakh
s e
em the correct option to the following questions.
2021-22 (upto 31st May 2021) ` 30 lakh
s g l a
a
MCQs: Provide
l a
ag (A) Happy
4.1 You are required to identify the correct statement from those given below:
Happy Limited can appoint Mr. Shyamlesh as an Independent Director
irrespective of the fact that Mr. Sanjay, his relative, is Legal Advisor to Generic
Laboratory Ltd. which is its Associate Company.
(B) Happy Happy Limited cannot appoint Mr. Shyamlesh as an Independent Director as
he is relative of Mr. Sanjay, who is Managing Partner of the firm which is legal advisor
to Generic Laboratory Ltd., its Associate Company, irrespective of the amount of fees
charged by Mr. Sanjay from its Associate Company.
m
(C) Happy Happy Limited cannot appoint Mr. Shyamlesh as an Independent Director as
. co
he is relative of Mr. Sanjay, Managing Partner of the firm which is Legal Advisor to
em
Generic Laboratory Ltd., its Associate Company, and the fees charged by Mr. Sanjay
s
exceeds the percentage as specified in the Companies Act, 2013, during one year
l a
out of the three immediately preceding financial years.
g
a
(D) Happy Happy Limited can appoint Mr. Shyamlesh as an Independent Director even
though his son in law Mr. Sanjay is the Managing Partner of the firm which is Legal
Advisor to Generic Laboratory Ltd., its Associate Company, as Mr. Sanjay did not
charge any fee during the immediately preceding financial year.
4.2 The residential status of Mr. Shyamlal will be _________
(A) Resident
(B) Non-resident
m
(C) Not-ordinarily resident as he is not a resident of any other country based on domicile
m .c o
and his income excluding, income from foreign sources exceeds ` 15 lakh.
. co 4.3 GSV Associates can accept further audit under section 44AB of ___________
em
(D) Not-ordinarily resident as he is having income above ` 15 lakh.
em l a s
las (A) 90 audits
a g
ag (B) 40 audits
(C) Nil
(D) 60 audits
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 21 of 31
Page 23
22 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
4.4 For reporting purposes as per Ind AS, which are the related parties of company 'C' ?
(A) A, B, D
(B) A, B, D, X
(C) A, B, D, Y
(D) A, B, D, X, Y
4.5 The maximum amount of compensation to which Mr. Keshav Prasad is entitled for
premature termination of his office as Managing Director shall be -
(A) ` 715.48 lakh
(B) ` 930 lakh
(C) Nil
(D) ` 697.50 lakh (5 x 2 = 10 Marks)
Descriptive Questions
4.6 Explain 'not-ordinarily resident' status of an Individual. (5 Marks)
4.7 Compute the capital gain in respect of property sold in point (4) of the case study
(5 Marks)
4.8 Explain the reasons for which a Managing Director or the whole time director may be
denied the compensation for loss of office. (5 Marks)
ANSWERS TO CASE STUDY 4
PART – A
4.1 (C)
4.2 (B) or (C)
4.3 None of the options is correct.
4.4 (B)
4.5 (A)
PART – B
4.6 As per section 6(6), an individual is said to be not-ordinarily resident in India in any previous
year, if such individual satisfies any one of the following conditions:
(i) He has been a non-resident in India in any 9 out of the 10 previous years preceding
the relevant previous year, or
(ii) He has been in India for a period of 729 days or less during the 7 previous years
preceding the relevant previous year, or
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 22 of 31
Page 24
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6F: MULTIDISCIPLINARY CASE STUDY 23
(ii) He is an Indian citizen or person of Indian origin (who, being outside India, comes on
a visit to India in any previous year) having total income, other than the income from
m
foreign sources [i.e., income which accrues or arises outside India (other than income
m c. o
derived from a business controlled in or profession set up in India) and which is not
co m
deemed to accrue or arise in India], exceeding ` 15 lakhs during the previous year,
m .
who has been in India for 120 days or more but less than 182 days during that
s e
s e la
previous year, or
l a a g
a4.7g Computation of capitalParticulars
(iv) He is an Indian citizen who is deemed to be resident in India under section 6(1A).
gains of Mr. V. Kumar for A.Y. 2022-23
` `
Sale Consideration 3,75,00,000
Less: Brokerage 12,00,000
Net sale consideration 3,63,00,000
Less: Indexed cost of acquisition [` 24,40,000, being 77,34,800
higher of Fair market value on April 1, 2001 and
m
co
` 20,00,000, being actual cost of acquisition x 317/100]
.
Less: Indexed cost of improvement [`30,00,000 x 64,25,676 1,41,60,476
em
317/148]
s
la54 [`1 crore + ` 33 1,33,00,000
2,21,39,524
a g
Less: Exemption under section
lakhs]
Purchase of residential house within the stipulated time
(within one year before or two years after the date of
sale)
Less: Exemption under section 54EC, assuming 50,00,000 1,83,00,000
invested within six months from the date of transfer
Long term capital gains [Since the property is held 38,39,524
m
for more than 24 months]
m .co
c. o
4.8 Prohibition on payment of compensation for loss of office of Managing Director or
m
se
Whole-time director or Manager [Section 202 of the Companies Act, 2013]: No
em la
payment of compensation shall be made in the following cases-
las (i)
a g
where the director resigns from his office as a result of the reconstruction of the
ag
company, or of its amalgamation and is appointed as the managing or whole-time
director, manager or other officer of the reconstructed company or of the body
corporate resulting from the amalgamation;
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 23 of 31
Page 25
24 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
(ii) where the director resigns from his office otherwise than on the reconstruction of the
company or its amalgamation i.e. resigns on his own;
(iii) where the office of the director is vacated under section 167(1);
(iv) where the company is being wound up, (by an order of the Tribunal or voluntarily),
due to the negligence or default of the director;
(v) where the director has been guilty of fraud / breach of trust / of gross negligence/gross
mismanagement in relation to the conduct of the affairs of the company or any
subsidiary company or holding company thereof; and where the director has
instigated/ has taken part directly or indirectly in bringing about, the termination of his
office.
CASE STUDY: 5
Brightstar Limited is currently engaged in different business segments and is also looking to
expand its operations. The Company is also exploring investment from an overseas investor to
carry out the expansion plan. During the month of April 2022, an overseas investor showed
interest to acquire 51% stake in Brightstar Limited and has appointed an independent consultant
to carry out the due diligence of Brightstar Limited. As per one of the conditions of Memorandum
of Understanding (MoU), the Company is required to submit its financial statements for the year
ended 31st March, 2022 as per IFRS.
Brightstar Limited is in the process of computation of the deferred taxes as per applicable IFRS
and wants guidance on the tax treatment for the following:
The Company had acquired 40% stake in SUN Limited for an aggregate amount of ` 90 crore.
The shareholding gives Brightstar Limited significant influence over SUN Limited but not control
and therefore the said interest in SUN Limited is accounted using the equity method. Under the
equity method, the carrying value of investment in SUN Limited was ` 140 crore on 31st March,
2021 and ` 150 crore as on 31 st March, 2022. As per the applicable tax laws, profits recognized
under the equity method are taxed if and when they are distributed as dividend or the relevant
investment is disposed of. The tax rate is 20%.
The Company measures its head office property using the revaluation model. The property is
revalued every year as on 31 st March. On 31 st March 2021, the carrying value of the property
(after revaluation) was ` 80 crore whereas its tax base was ` 44 crore. Carrying amount of
property in the books of the company on 31st March 2021 was equal to the carrying amount of
the property as per tax records. During the year ended 31 st March 2022, the Company charged
depreciation. in its Statement of Profit or Loss of 4 crore and claimed a tax deduction for tax
depreciation of ` 2.50 crore. On 31 st March, 2022, the property was revalued to ` 90 crore. As
per the tax laws, the revaluation of Property, Plant & Equipment does not affect taxable income
at the time of revaluation. The tax rate is 20%.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 24 of 31
Page 26
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6F: MULTIDISCIPLINARY CASE STUDY 25
During the year, Brightstar Limited delivered manufactured products to customer K. The
products were faulty and on 1st October 2021 customer K commenced legal action against the
m
c. o
Company claiming damages in respect of losses due to the supply of faulty product. Upon
m
investigating the matter, Brightstar Limited discovered that the products were faulty due to
.co e m
defective raw material procured from supplier F. Therefore, on 1st December 2021, the Company
e m
commenced legal action against F claiming damages in respect of the supply of defective raw
l a s
s
a Limited has estimated that its probability of success of both legal actions, the actiona g
materials.
g l
aof K against Brightstar Limited and action of Brightstar Limited against F, is very high.
Brightstar
On 1st October 2021, Brightstar Limited has estimated that the damages it would have to pay
K would be ` 10 crore. This estimate was revised to ` 10.40 crore as on 31st March 2022 and
` 10.50 crore as at 15 th May 2022. This case was eventually settled on 1st June 2022, when the
Company paid damages of ` 10.60 crore to K.
On 1st December 2021, Brightstar Limited had estimated that it would recei ve damages of
` 7.00 crore from F. This estimate was revised to ` 7.20 crore as at 31st March 2022 and ` 7.40
m
co
crore as on 15 th May 2022. This case was eventually settled on 1st June 2022 when F paid
.
` 7.50 crore to Brightstar Limited. Brightstar Limited in its financial statements for the year ended
em
31st March 2022, provided ` 7 .20 crore. The financial statements were authorised by the Board
of Directors on 26th April 2022.
l a s
a g
On 1st April 2021, Brightstar Limited purchased ` 20 lakh* options to acquire shares in CASA
Ltd., a listed entity. The Company paid ` 0.50 per option which allows the Company to purchase
shares in CASA Ltd. for a price of ` 4 per share. The exercise date for the option was
31st December 2021. On 31 st December 2021, when the market value of a share in CASA Ltd.
was ` 5.20 per share, the Company exercised all its options to acquire shares in CASA Ltd.
In addition to the purchase price, the Company has also incurred directly attributable cost of
` 2 lakh for purchase of ` 20 lakh shares in CASA Ltd. The Company has classified these
shares as trading portfolio. However, the Company has not disposed of any of the shares in
o m
CASA Ltd. between 31 st December 2021 to 31 st March 2022. The market value of the shares of
m .c
c. o Brightstar
CASA Ltd. as on 31st March 2022 is ` 5.80 per share.
Limited acquired 100% of Methane Private Limited, on 1 January m
m s e of 200 each
2021. The fair
st
s e a
l At the time of the
value of the purchase consideration was ` 20 crore consisting of ordinary shares
g
gl a a net assets of Methane
of Brightstar Limited. The fair value of the net assets acquired was ` 15 crore.
a
acquisition, the value of the ordinary shares of Brightstar Limited and the
* PS: Read ‘` 20 lakh options’ as ‘20 lakh options’
PS: Read ‘` 20 lakh shares’ as ‘20 lakh options’
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 25 of 31
Page 27
26 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
Private Limited were only provisionally determined. On 30 th November 2021 it was finally
determined that the fair value of Brightstar Limited's shares was ` 22 crore and the fair value of
net assets of Methane Private Limited was ` 16 crore. However, the directors of Brightstar
Limited have seen the fair value of the company's shares decline since 1st January 2021 and
wanted to adopt the fair value of the shares as of 1st February 2022, which will result in the fair
value of consideration being valued at ` 18 crore.
One of the subsidiaries of Brightstar Limited started its business in India with Indian Rupee as
its functional currency. After several years, the entity expanded and started exporting its
products to Europe. During the year ended 31 st March 2021 only 30% of the business was
conducted in Euro. By the end of 31 st March 2022, 90% of the business was conducted with
Europe and the transactions were denominated in Euro. The raw materials required (for the
products to be exported to Europe) are all imported materials and the purchase transactions are
denominated in Euro.
Brightstar Limited has constructed a shopping mall earlier. A portion of a mall is renovated by
constructing a food court, spa and gaming zone so as to increase the footfalls in the mall. The
food court and gaming zone are expected to result in a significant increase in sales for the shops
and outlets of the mall.
Brightstar Limited previously had a defined pension plan (a defined benefit plan) under which
the employees who joined before 1 st April 2020 were enrolled. With respect to employees who
joined on or after 1st April 2020 were all enrolled in the industrial pension plan. The Company
found that the industrial pension plan was more beneficial to the employees than the defined
pension plan. Hence, during 2021-2022, it decided to shift all the employees from defined
pension plan to the industrial pension plan. The entity paid ` 10 crore to the employees who in
turn agreed to forfeit the pension entitlement from the defined pensio n plan. The liability
recognized in the financials, for the year ended 31 st March 2021, with respect to the pension
liability was ` 14 crore.
MCQs: Provide the correct option to the following questions.
5.1 What is the value of purchase consideration and fair value of net assets of Methane Private
Limited as at the date of acquisition?
(A) Purchase consideration ` 22 crore, net asset value ` 16 crore.
(B) Purchase consideration ` 20 crore, net asset value ` 15 crore,
(C) Purchase consideration ` 18 crore, net asset value ` 16 crore.
(D) Purchase consideration ` 22 crore, net asset value ` 15 crore.
5.2 What will be the functional currency of the subsidiary of Brightstar Limited for the year
2021-2022?
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 26 of 31
Page 28
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6F: MULTIDISCIPLINARY CASE STUDY 27
(A) Changed to Euro at the end of financial year 2021-2022, if it is considered that the
underlying transactions, events and conditions of business have changed.
m
c. o
(B) Changed to Euro at the beginning of financial year 2021-2022, if it is considered that
m
co
the underlying transactions, events and conditions of business have changed.
. e m
s
(C) Changed to Euro at the end of financial year 2021-2022, if it is considered that the
em
underlying transactions, events and conditions of business have changed.
la
l a s
(D) The functional currency remains to be Indian Rupee.
a g
a5.3g What should be the accounting treatment for the cost incurred for the renovation?
(A) Expenses incurred for food court and gaming zone should be charged to statement
of profit or loss;
(B) Expenses incurred for food court, spa and gaming zone should be charged t o
statement of profit or loss;
(C) Expenses incurred for food court, spa and gaming should be capitalised;
(D) Expenses incurred for food court and gaming should be capitalised.
o m
5.4 What is the entry to be passed in the books of CASA Ltd. of account as on 31st March 2022
c
. Dr.
with respect to legal action commenced by customer K on the company?
To Current Liability A/cse
A Statement of Profit or Loss A/c
m ` 10.40 crore
g lA/ca
` 10.40 crore
a
B Statement of Profit or Loss Dr.
To Non-Current Liability A/c
` 10.60 crore
` 10.60 crore
C Statement of Profit or Loss A/c Dr. ` 10.50 crore
To Current Liability A/c ` 10.50 crore
D Other Comprehensive Income A/c Dr. ` 10.40 crore
To Current Liability A/c ` 10.40 crore
5.5 What will the accounting treatment of the action of Brightstar Limited against supplier F as
m
co
per applicable IFRS?
m .
c. o m
(A) Asset receivable shall be recognised for ` 7.50 crore
em a se
(B) Asset receivable shall be recognised for ` 7.40 crore
s g l
la (D) It will be considered as contingent asset which will not be a
(C) Asset receivable shall be recognised for ` 7 .20 crore
ag CASA Ltd.
recognized in the books of
(5 x 2 = 10 Marks)
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 27 of 31
Page 29
28 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
Descriptive Questions
5.6 How should the discontinuation of old defined pension plan be accounted in the financials
of Brightstar Limited for the year ended 31 st March 2022 as per Ind AS? (2 Marks)
5.7 With respect to SUN Limited, what will be the deferred tax and where will it be impacted?
(2 Marks)
5.8 Compute the deferred tax liability as on 31st March, 2022 and the charge/credit to the
Statement of Profit or Loss and/ or Other Comprehensive Income on head office property.
(6 Marks)
5.9 The Company has requested you to suggest the accounting treatment of the abov e
arrangement and transaction of acquisition of shares in CASA Ltd. (5 Marks)
ANSWERS TO CASE STUDY 5
PART – A
5.1 (A)
5.2 (A) or (C)
5.3 (D)
5.4 (A)
5.5 (D)
PART – B
5.6 The discontinuation of old defined pension plan is a curtailment event. Brightstar Limited
is supposed to recognise gain or loss on settlement when the legally bind agreement has
been reached, that eliminates all further legal or constructive obligations for the benefits
provided under the pension plan in exchange for lump sum payment.
As per para 109 of IAS 19 ‘Employee Benefits’, the gain or loss on a settlement is the
difference between:
(a) the present value of the defined benefit obligation being settled, as determined on the
date of settlement
(b) the settlement price, including any plan assets transferred and any payments made
directly by the entity in connection with the settlement.
Accordingly, Brightstar Limited recognises a settlement gain of ` 4 crore (ie ` 14 crore –
` 10 crore) in its financial statements for the year ended 31 March 2022.
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 28 of 31
Page 30
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6F: MULTIDISCIPLINARY CASE STUDY 29
5.7 DTL created on accumulation of undistributed profits as on 31.3.2022
m
Carrying Value as Tax base Taxable Total Deferred Charged to P&L
c. o
value per tax temporary tax liability @ during the year
m c
c. o b
records differences 20%
e m
em 140 crore 90 crore 90 crore 50 crore 10 crore s
a d e= b-d f = e x 20% g
s g l a
a
31 March 10 crore
l a
ag 312022March 150 crore 90 crore 90 crore 60 crore 12 crore (12 crore – 102crore)
2021
crore
5.8 (a) In case deferred tax is created only on account of depreciation
Carrying Value as Tax base Taxable / Total Credit to
value per tax (deductible) Deferred tax P&L during
without records temporary liability/ the year
revaluation difference (asset) @
20%
m
co
a b c d e= b-d f = e x 20% g
.
31 March 2021 44 crore 44 crore 44 crore nil nil nil
em
Less: Depreciation (4 crore) (2.50
for the year crore)
l a s
g
2021-2022
Carrying value as
on 31 March 2022
40 crore
a41.50
crore
41.50 (1.50 crore)
crore
DTA (0.30 DTA (0.30
crore) crore)
(b) Computation of tax effect taking into account the revalued figures and adjusting
impact of tax effect on account of difference in depreciation
Carrying Value as Tax Taxable / Total Credit to Charged to
value after per tax base (deductible) Deferred tax P&L OCI during
revaluation records temporary liability/ during the year
difference (asset) @ the year
20%
m
co
a b c d e= b-d f = e x 20% g h
m .
c. o m
31 March 2021 80 crore 44 crore 44 36 crore DTL 7.2 - DTL 7.2
se
crore crore crore
em la
Revalued again 90 crore 41.50 41.50 48.50 crore DTL 9.7 DTA (0.30 DTL 10
las g
on 31.3.2022 (It crore (44- crore crore crore) crore
g a
is assumed that 2.50) (Refer (Refer Note
a
revaluation has table (a) below) [10
been done after above) DTL (B/F) –
taking into 0.30 DTA =
consideration 9.70 DTL]
the impact of
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 29 of 31
Page 31
30 FINAL EXAMINATION: NOVEMBER, 2022
depreciation for
the current year)
Additional DTL 2.50 DTA (0.30 DTL (2.80
DTL/DTA crore crore) crore) (Refer
required during (Refer Note below)
the year (IV-I) table (a))
Note:
As per para 65 of IAS 12 ‘Income Taxes’, when an asset is revalued for tax purposes and
that revaluation is related to an accounting revaluation of an earlier period, or to one that
is expected to be carried out in a future period, the tax effects on account of revaluation of
asset and the adjustment of the tax base are recognised in other comprehensive income
in the periods in which they occur.
Here, it is important to understand that only the tax effects on account of revaluation of
asset and the adjustment of the tax base are recognised in other comprehensive income.
However, tax effects on account of depreciation of asset and the adjustment of the tax
base are recognized in profit and loss.
Accordingly, first of all the tax effect has been calculated assuming that there is no
revaluation (Refer Table (a) above). Later the DTA arrived due to difference in depreciation
is adjusted with the DTL created due to revaluation. DTA of ` 0.30 crore on account of
depreciation will be charged to Profit and Loss and DTL of ` 2.80 crore will be charged to
OCI. Net effect in the year 31.3.2022 will be DTL 2.50 crore (DTL 2.80 crore – DTA 0.30
crore) [Refer Table (b) above].
5.9 The option to acquire shares in CASA Ltd. Would be regarded as a derivative financial
instrument. This is because the value of the option depends on the value of an underlying
variable (CASA Ltd.’s share price). As per paragraph 4.1.4 and 4.2.1 of IFRS 9 ‘Financial
Instruments’, all derivatives are measured at fair value. On 1 st April 2021, when Brightstar
Limited purchased 20 lakh options to acquire shares in CASA Ltd. At ` 0.50 per option,
Brightstar Limited will recognise Option Asset for ` 10 lakh by passing the following journal
entry:
Option on CASA Ltd. Shares Dr. ` 10 lakh
To Bank ` 10 lakh
Brightstar Limited shall measure the option at fair value at the end of every reporting period
and also before exercise. The increase in share price on exercise date represents fair
value of the option as the time value is zero on exercise date. Therefore, Brightstar Limited
will measure the option at ` 24 lakh [20 lakh option x (5.2 – 4)] and recognise fair value
gain of ` 14 lakh ( 24-10) in profit or loss.
The following journal entry will be passed:
© The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 30 of 31
Page 32
m
m .co
c. o
e m
em l a s
s a g
PAPER – 6F: MULTIDISCIPLINARY CASE STUDY 31
Option on CASA Ltd. Shares Dr. ` 14 lakh
m
To Fair value gain ` 14 lakh
m
On exercise of the option on 31 st December 2021, Brightstar Limited will pay ` 80 lakh for
c. o
.co e m
20 lakh shares of CASA Ltd and the option derivative will be converted to shares of CASA
m la s
Ltd. Therefore, Brightstar Limited will pass the following entry:
s e g
l a ` 80 lakh a
Investment in CASA Ltd. Equity shares Dr. ` 104 lakh
ag
To Bank
To Option on CASA Ltd. Shares ` 24 lakh
Paragraph 5.1.1 of IFRS 9 ‘Financial Instruments’ requires that the transaction costs shall
be added to fair value if the financial asset is measured at other than fair value through
profit or loss.
In the given case, ` 2 lakh incurred by Brightstar Limited for acquiring equity shares of
CASA Ltd. Will not be added to the fair value of the equity shares of CASA Ltd. This is
because equity shares of CASA Ltd. Are classified at fair value through profi t or loss in
m
accordance with paragraph 4.1.4 of IFRS 9 Financial Instruments. Therefore, Brightstar
c. o
Limited shall recognise ` 2 lakh incurred on acquisition of equity shares of CASA Ltd. In
m of financial position at 31st March 2022 as a
profit or loss as on 31st March 2022.
s e
la lakh. The increase in fair value of ` 12 lakh is taken
The investment is included in the statement
g
current asset at its fair value of ` 116
to the profit and loss.
a
m
m .co
c. o se
m
s em g la
gla a
a
m .
.co s e m
m
e Accountants of India l a
l a s a g
g
© The Institute of Chartered
a For more Question Papers, Sample Papers, Notes & Syllabus visit Page 31 of 31